772 Comments
User's avatar
Sue's avatar

I wish more people were more afraid of the Empire than Trump. Why is Trump on his way out? Because he messed up the corporate empire. He cut off their slave labor, he messed up their cushy trade deals, he exposed their phony Russiagate nonsense, and he messed up their income stream by bringing boys home from endless wars and created peace in the middle east. Biden is a puppet of the corporate empire, so be afraid of the future.

Koshmarov's avatar

The funny thing is that Trump did this stuff more or less by accident. I'm sure the analogy has been made already, but he was like Peter Sellers as Chauncey Gardener in "Being There."

It really illustrates how fragile the whole system is and how inept the "Boys at the Top" are. Promoting fear is their last-ditch effort to cow the public and distract us from their greed and ineptitude. Out of quarters, guys.

Sue's avatar

The scary part is how the media, big tech, the Roberts court all colluded to oust Trump. That is empire.

RAH's avatar

Yup. They ran the Russia hoax, Ukraine hoax / impeachment, social media bans / censorship, 90% negative media coverage and, last but not least, a ham-fisted ballot stuffing scheme. And even after all that, he expanded his base. This isn't over - not by a long shot.

Thom Prentice's avatar

Evidence please for Jan-fisted ness in ballot stuffing? Source? Evidence?

Gary Hemminger's avatar

Um, whether they colluded or not, he lost the election (fair or fraud). Whomever was stupid enough to believe the MSM or big tech was the reason he lost. You can't collude to convince intelligent people who seek the truth. You can collude with idiots that only believe one part of the story anyway. If they want to hear bullshit, they will hear and see bullshit. You don't have to be a master colluder to convince people of what they want to hear and see. You just have to give it to them.

I can tell you one thing for sure, if the US was rid of all people who believe Trump was their savior AND all people who thought Trump was Hitler, we would have a much happier and more reasonable country.

Sue's avatar

I am in neither of those groups.

William Taylor's avatar

I just came across a video clip of Dan Bongiorno (on Hannity) cautioning Dems about the censorship issue, and referencing "Coming for you next." The comments section was filled with people vowing to cancel FB and Twitter accounts. I suggest you do the same and spread the word. It's a hopeful idea during these difficult times. F 'em. Btw, I quit FB five years ago and have never joined Twitter.

Sue's avatar

Conservatives should organize a “Dump Twitter Day”.

Sue's avatar

This morning I can’t believe I live in a country where people can be silenced and ruined for their political views. Hawley and Cruz are being destroyed for asking for a ten day audit. We live in a tyranny of giant corporations. It was a sad day yesterday when America got scolded about freedom of speech by Angela Merkel from a foreign country. Today I am blocked by FaceBook for discussing election problems. These are very dark days.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

So let me get this straight. You are more afraid of the Roberts court and the rest of the empire than you are of Donald Trump in his present mentally ill condition? I wonder if you realize how much Trump is compromising national security every day he remains in office. And did you see the pictures from the Capitol? Are you in favor of what that mob did? Trump explicitly sent the crowd there, and even lied and said he would be marching with them. Of course he then went immediately back to the WH.

Sue's avatar

Yes, I am more afraid of the Empire. Trump is not crazy and he said nothing to incite violence. He said the marchers would walk to the capitol and “greet the Congressmen as they came out”. His security team probably nixed the walk with them idea.

Do not call those protesters a mob. They were there all day peacefully protesting. Time will tell who actually incited or committed the breakin. The FBI said there was a busload of Antifa people there.

P&KA's avatar

Yes. I'm also way more afraid of a hidden Tech oligarchy with increasing carte blanche to spy on, censor, and imprison citizens than I am of a dork with bad hair and makeup that may or may not have encouraged a mob that did 1/1000th the total damage and violence than a year of BLM/Antifa did supported by mainstream media blessings and corporate sponsorship.

I hope that you got that straight.

Gary Hemminger's avatar

I can tell you one thing for sure, if the US was rid of all people who believe Trump was their savior AND all people who thought Trump was Hitler, we would have a much happier and more reasonable country.

William Taylor's avatar

You mean the mostly "Peaceful protesters?"

Eponymous Anonymous's avatar

The big takeaway from the last two presidential elections is that democracy is broken under our one party of two factions. Ive taken for granted the democrats rigged the primaries twice and I fully expected the 2016 election to be rigged as well. Was this general election rigged? Maybe, but it doesnt really matter, since its already an established practice and the time for outrage was 4 years ago, but we got anally forcefed russiagate instead. Seems as though there was a long game at play and suffering through the last four years, whipping polarization up to the point of last wednesdays unauthorized tour of the Capitol was all according to plan. Now were prepped to lose the 2nd amendment which is what this is probably all about. And that probably means a lot of people will have their weapons pried from their burnt dead hands once you realize a well armed militia with black rifles has no chance against drone warfare. I watched a couple videos from nagorno karbakh and that was my takeaway from that. If the 20th century is any measure we are overdue for another engineered population reduction event. The bar for survival is the level of ones addiction to rage inducing clickbait agitprop

Thom Prentice's avatar

I AM more afraid of the Robert’s court and you would be too if you had any sense.

Daren Sweeney's avatar

Great comment. ) Wall Street, Big Tech, and the military industrial complex jumped off his bandwagon after 2016 because he was a less reliable ally than Bush The Simple, the Clintons, and Obama.

P&KA's avatar

hmm, Biden seems like way more of a Chauncey to me. At least the senile dumbass he is today.

Being fed speeches to just barely recite successfully after days of practice? Also, Trump might joke about grabbing a pussy or three, but Joe is definitely the one with the blank look in his eyes that would cluelessly say to a bunch of women "I... I like to watch!" Doesn't seem far from all of his idiotic hair sniffinz.

Trump at least had some media savvy (and an underrated talent for Improv that would put most Second City alumn to shame), for what he completely lacked in personal and professional wisdom. Trump's just a tantrum and a semi-erect penis, looking for action. It was his vain stubbornness that made him (likely) less manipulateable than Joe, not his stupidity.

I didn't think it could get genuinely worse than Trump but I'm pretty sure we're about to cross the Rubicon on that. God... what a hopeless mess this Republic is, lol.

Koshmarov's avatar

Props for calling out Trump's improv talent; it's an (if i may pirate the adjective) underrated element of charisma, that deeply-difficult-to-define but all-too-necessary quality for successful politicians.

Speaking rigidly from a script tends to put most people off. Not making a moral judgement; just a thing I've observed.

P&KA's avatar

Bingo. Great improv is a very rare talent, but if you can find it, it's great for making the audience feel engaged and every performance feel novel or even authentic. Obama made fun of disabled people as well, but Trump owning it and refusing to apologize arguably made people feel like anything was possible with him.

Your perspective is valid for Trump as Chauncey, maybe I just find imagining Joe in the place of Sellers more amusing in my head.

I started imagining 2022 when Kamala whispers to a mentally failing Joe that he might be able to walk on water "like in that movie." Then, umbrella in hand, Biden walks out into a lake and quickly falls in and drowns, as the Veep tries to contain her smirk.

That has to be considered at least a plausible end to his life at this point.

It's going to be another completely buffoonish 4 year slog.

Postimpressionist's avatar

He knew all right and so did a bunch of US. That's why he stopped the US from signing on to the TPP and said "Make America Great Again".

P&KA's avatar

Hey Grisha, I was thinking of another fictional/IRL comparison a week ago and wanted to hear your thoughts:

Jimmy Dore is the current "Lonesome" Rhodes from "Face in the Crowd." Rhodes has always been and was written to be an evergreen character, these fake-populist demagogues constantly pop up, but...

That clip last week of Jimmy going off on how the DSA or whoever "I shouldn't go to them, they should come to ME!" or something like that vibe just made Rhodes pop into my head.

Koshmarov's avatar

I'd like to be able to give you a better answer, but in truth I've never seen "A Face in the Crowd," a deficit I should probably correct.

I recall Dore having some good insights when he appeared on Useful Idiots and otherwise don't know much about him. I'm not a podcast/YouTube kind of guy (mainly because I'm a monotasker and am trying, although largely failing, to reduce my online time). Me doing my Fukuyama bit; at the end of history, there's too much media to consume.

Sorry, but thanks for asking! Others may have some more useful thoughts.

P&KA's avatar

I'd recommend it if you're looking for a good classic to watch. You'll never look at Andy Griffith shows - especially when he smiles - the same way ever again.

Well, just my thoughts: I'm sorta mixed on Dore. He can be funny and I like that he can get passionate about genuinely fucked up things but he almost always goes too far with his negativity. ex. He's the type that completely shits on Bernie because he didn't meet Jimmy's expectations after nearly a lifetime of public advocacy and service. Meanwhile all Jimmy does is scream in front of a green screen. So it's cheap.

Dore also has an especially bad fan community in my experience. I know that's a tricky criticism, but I think it follows his energy in this case.

Jeff Weskamp's avatar

Sam Harris made the comparison between Trump and Chauncey Gardener on one of his podcasts.

Montana Shadow's avatar

Harris has completely lost his mind with TDS!

Postimpressionist's avatar

He knew what was happening. The breaking up of the US and parceling it out to failing nations which has been happening since Daddy Bush. That's why the first thing Trump did was SQUASH the TPP. That would have been the death knell. And Biden will JOIN because he can be President for ever as there is no longer a need to vote.

Gary Hemminger's avatar

Well, I think we need to vote. Even if it is fraud, there will still be 270 electoral votes to stay in office. Republicans need to learn how to cheat better next time if fraud is what you believe happened.

I believe there is no proof of fraud and I believe there is no proof that there wasn't fraud. Both sides saying otherwise are simply idiots with no ability to think logically.

Nobody's avatar

So you're for a banana republic and may the most corrupt win?

I think there probably was fraud and there has been for decades. I find it hard to believe there were so many near 50 50 splits, and how come Joe couldn't pull in a crowd no matter where he went. Even those who voted for him didn't like him. Why so much relaxation on rules? No ID checks, no signature checks, keep changing the deadlines, etc. All this stuff was probably done to facilitate ballot harvesting. Why should driving, flying or operating a drone take more ID than voting.

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

My personal tin foil hat feeling is that Donald Trump was allowed to win in the same way we know Hillary cheated Bernie out. We flat out know the the DNC cheated to make Hillary the nominee. That fact can't be disputed.

Think about it in big picture form though. Most people aren't able to think about things that way. Donald Trump being elected president did more for the Progressive movement in 4 years than they've been able to achieve in 4 decades. Most of this is actually very good, but you have to look at the next steps of such a situation.

The next 4 years are going to be very interesting, and I hope for all of our sakes, my thoughts are serious tin foil, and not reality. Our Tehnocracy however is taking over in big ways.

Thom Prentice's avatar

Although I voted, “needing to vote” is the Apostles Creed ofAmerianity ...

Gary Hemminger's avatar

I am pretty sure he is on his way out because he lost the election. Whether fair or fraud, he lost the election. That is why he is on his way out. They are all puppets of money.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

Ok, but Trump would have stayed in power permanently if he had been reelected. I am afraid of the Dems too (Lyndon Johnson was my first political "enemy" in the 1960s), but Trump is worse. And by the way Noam Chomsky says vote for the opponent of the worst candidate if you think that one is dangerous. I think concentrating on hating the Dems under current circumstances is a case of the best becoming an enemy of the good.

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

Living with that much fear is unhealthy.

Sue's avatar

True, but living with no fear probably makes us naive and gullible.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

I can't seem to trace your reply back to my prior comment. Which fear are you referring to?

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

It could be many. This delusion that so many have about Trump wanting to be emperor. I scoffed at Republicans when they said Obama was going to do it, it's only fair I scoff at delusional folks that think Trump would have. That is ultimately the issue. We are a totally delusional society now. We seem to be afraid of so many things that aren't real. Thanks to our intelligence agency owned media.

Sue's avatar

US Presidents can only stay for eight years.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

Don't you see that with another four years in power Trump would have arranged to amend the Constitution so he could rule indefinitely?

And in fact he already said that's what he wants.

Pat's avatar

Can you back up that with facts? He was the least oppressive President in modern history. Sure, he tried to stop undocumented immigration. But as far as citizens of the US, he was sort of hands off unless there was explicit ressurections like Portland and the DC riots over the summer.

Give one factual thing he did, other than tweeting, that proves he was an authoritarian dictator.

As far as I see it, the media says he was authoritarian and people just go along with that without examining the facts. It's like, right now, they are saying that the capitol riots on the 6th killed five people. That's garbage. One person was shot by LE. The Capitol policeman died, but the three medical emergency people that died passed away because of medical emergencies, not the protest. The only reason those three are included is because five deaths sounds more serious than two, although two deaths is a stain on the day and makes me want to bow my head and cry. But that's not good enough for the media. No. They have to pump up the hatred, by inflating the damage. It's a pure propagandists’ play. Manipulate the emotions. Get people emotional enough and they won't be able to use logic. Makes them all easy to lead around by their noses.

And bringing it full circle. I read some of the documents dumped by Wikileaks. Specifically the ones about keeping Europe engaged in Afghanistan and the war on terror. The bureaucrats planned and printed PR media articles specifically about children and women because they knew their citizens are more easily swayed if one or both of those groups are involved. It was deliberate propaganda used on citizens to manipulate them into approving the continuation of the war. Every time the allied nations began to flag in their support, the women and children articles would flood the media.

Gary Hemminger's avatar

Sure buddy. And I have a bridge to sell you so please call me. As I said above:

...if the US was rid of all people who believe Trump was their savior AND all people who thought Trump was Hitler, we would have a much happier and more reasonable country.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Sure, Ralph... this goes right along with him being a Russian plant, a dictator, a despot and an authoritarian. Unfortunately for you, and aside from making Twitter rants a daily news item, he's done none of these things. I don't believe him CAPABLE of these things, and believe me when I say that if he had tried it... he'd have been yanked out by his hair.

It's nice to see you here defending your own news programming though, it really shows your devotion to your sad old religion.

Nobody's avatar

If he was going to do that why wait until the second term? The premise is ridiculous: if I lose the election I will concede but if I get reelected I'm going to change the constitution (how exactly?) And appointment myself dictator for life? Lay off Maddow for a bit, man.

Montana Shadow's avatar

Are you THAT dense to actually believe that?!?!

I expect far more fro Taibbi readers, c’mon!

Shame on you!

Sue's avatar

That could not happen. The Congress would not stand for it, especially since Republicans lost the majority.

Tom Worster's avatar

Do you really believe that Ralph? I mean _really_ believe? Not just a hyperbolic response to someone you disagree with.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 9, 2021
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 9, 2021
Comment deleted
Sue's avatar

LBJ got the Civil Rights passed, he cut poverty in half, and created the two best social programs ever. Not a bad record.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 9, 2021
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 9, 2021
Comment deleted
Ralph Dratman's avatar

I should not have implied that Trump is worse than LBJ in everything. Johnson ran a horrific war; Trump has done no such thing. I meant to say that Trump is worse than contemporary Democrats, and I think that is the case.

Thom Prentice's avatar

Sorry to have said what I did and thank you for the additional information, Dir.

AllObamasfault's avatar

He "messed" up the "corporate empire"???!!! Seems they messed him up. And who knew slave labor was cut off...someone should tell the kids.

Kurt's avatar

Yes, be very afraid. Maintain maximum fearfulness. Paralyze yourself with panic and fear. Imagine the worst that can happen and worry about it incessantly. Zzzzzz..... 😴

I’m usually impressed with the general level of Taibbi Substack Comments Section commentary, but it seems like the furies are released this morning.

William Taylor's avatar

Have you all looked into the rumors coming out of Italy?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 21, 2021
Comment deleted
Sue's avatar

It is hard to expose something when most media censors it.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 21, 2021
Comment deleted
Sue's avatar

Assange and Snowden are American heroes and should receive protection under whistle blower laws. It will never happen. The NSA andCIA are excellent at covering their own asses.

John's avatar

Exactly, Trump is gone now and unlikely to come back so what now? The same jackwads who gave us the Iraq war and the Drone war and slavery in Libya are back in charge (and arguably never lost power)! Sweet. Now we get them with the added power of full blown mainstream media and tech censorship/cancel culture to back them up. Awesome. I can't wait to upload my social credit score and medical history on my global passport. The future is going to suck.

K.M.'s avatar

You forgot to add Hollywood & Academia to the wings of the DNC. They’ve infiltrated everywhere. Anywhere in the U.S. where bureaucracy reigns, you will find the DNC lurking nearby.

Koshmarov's avatar

I think this is due less to DNC operatives being hyper-competent masterminds and due more to Hollywood, academia, and local bureaucracies wanting to hitch their wagons to the perceivedly ascendant star.

I wonder what happens when the magical star doesn't deliver on its promises.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

None of their fans will notice. They'll be too busy sniffing their own farts.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

How far did you get in school?

Stxbuck's avatar

Hollywood will always be in thrall to the DNC for the foreseeable b/c they provide them moral cover for collaborating w/ the ChiComs to market their CGI schlockfests in China. Good movies don’t play well and n China b/c you have to speak English to get them. Marvel Milan vs. Uighur Thanatos-just get the explosions and shiny things right and it will sell tix in Wuhan and Harbin w/out subtitles.

Koshmarov's avatar

Remember when Martin Scorsese got canceled for expressing his opinion that Marvel CGI schlockfests "weren't cinema?" Good times.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

We will find out. Normally the Democrats don't do much of anything. Obamacare was one big exception.

K.M.'s avatar

My insurance premiums and deductibles went up 300% after that was passed. Not sure if I would celebrate that. Unless it evolves into universal healthcare then it might be worth it but it’s pretty sucky right now.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
K.M.'s avatar

This reminds me of the meme going around w/ 2 bombers, the one above is the “republican” which is plain w/ bombs dropping. The one under it is “democrat” which has a rainbow, blm sticker ect... but it’s still dropping bombs. That meme explain so much w/ so little.

Stxbuck's avatar

Great, The Hunger Games minus teenagers with flamethrowers on reality TV. We’ll probably start seeing them in Queens and Baltimore tho.....

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
K.M.'s avatar

This basically sounds correct. Heterosexuality will be frowned on basically. Straight white guys will either fake being gay or trans to fit in. They will start having to keep their straightness in the closet. White women will become the new white straight males as they become the new punching bag for minority men and women and aren’t allowed to defend themselves. (this has already begun, aka Karen, white women tears, ect...). Of course white and some poc lesbians won’t fare much better because trans-women are encroaching on spaces they see as their own. Nothing anyone can do either as the new intersectionality world order says the most “oppressed” wins.

David's avatar

Yep. We (and I mean everyone) just lost one of the few willing to stand in the way of inspiring headlines like this. https://twitter.com/ChineseEmbinUS/status/1347247602094534658?s=20

Koshmarov's avatar

Read the ending of Fahrenheit 451 again if you want to recover some small, shriveled hope.

"You'll stink like a bobcat for a few days, but it'll be all right."

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

...and control of the house, senate and white house.

What's the worst that could happen?

AMWL's avatar

Does anyone really think that the incoming Biden administration is going to magically restore civil liberties and usher in a new golden era of real journalism? The military industrial complex/deep state/Uniparty monster that grew exponentially after 9/11, right through the Obama/Biden administration, is firmly entrenched and overflowing with power and money. The last feeble possible check on this swamp, the fatally flawed Donald Trump, has finally been neutered. You may not want to admit that. You are about to see the State, at the behest of its true masters, unleash a final devastating attack on what remains of our civil liberties and an independent press, all in the name of our safety and security, against what they label to be insurrectionists and seditionists. Why they will even come after you Matt; Glenn, and any other remaining actual journalists. Watch your back.

Wally's avatar

I am old enough to remember a time when broadcast TV news and a stodgy newspaper syndicate controlled what the public heard. If you didn't like what they were saying, you had to run down to a street corner in the center of town and hand out flyers to random pedestrians. If you were lucky, a few deep-thinkers plus the local crackpots and lonely-souls stopped to talk. Today, substack is the street corner and we're the crackpots, lonely souls, and one-in-a-million deep-thinkers.

Since the rise of the internet and a massive influx of user commentary (and other reasons), the establishment has lost control of their narrative. They are busily trying to re-assert it. As I said on other threads, watch out for an attempt to repeal section 230 which will remove liability protection from internet sites like this one. Without any further protection for public forums, the removal of 230 will leave the little platforms with an enormous, and perhaps impossible, task of allowing this kind of discussion forum. I think there lies a real threat to Matt and Glenn, etc. The can vet their own writing for liability but the costs of the current format might be too high to maintain.

Stxbuck's avatar

A buddy of mine saw the future of our internet in China a couple years ago-“Lots and lots of My Pretty Kitty vid”.....

Wally's avatar

Yes, we are seeing the beginning of the of the internet good old days. Once credit card and other services that make the internet go round start restricting access, we will be back on the actual street corner.

Wally's avatar

Sorry . . . beginning of the end of the . . .

Pat's avatar

I think you misunderstand 230.

“No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider."

Substack is a publisher. It isn't using section 230 to avoid being liable for it's content.

Wally's avatar

I’m referring to substack’s liability for content that is posted here, including Matt’s. Such content is understood legally as not being content that is created or developed by the internet publisher - substack in this case - and is covered by 230.

Content that is created by a platform itself is not covered under 230 and is not protected from the usual liability exposure. Many of the lawsuits that involve 230 turn on the question of whether content is user generated or not.

Substack is now protected from liability arising from us commenters who both pay Matt and in some measure provide a value to him with our comments. That’s why I said the current format might not be sustainable without 230. See, for example, Pornhub’s removal of user generated content to protect itself from liability. Without 230, internet platforms like substack or YouTube or whatever will have to screen all user generated content for liability issues.

The larger platforms probably are already developing algorithms to do so, while the smaller, less well funded ones are going to struggle with this task and probably will be forced to eliminate user generated content like this forum. Whether the elimination of a forum results in a platform no longer being a viable business and therefore shutting down altogether will depend upon how critical user generated content is to that platform.

Thank you for the opportunity to clarify.

Koshmarov's avatar

"Substack is now protected from liability arising from us commenters who both pay Matt and in some measure provide a value to him with our comments."

My comments probably provide a detriment to Matt, but otherwise, good post.

Pat's avatar

No. I still think you are wrong. FB, Google, Twitter...they don't create their own content. Their whole premise is that they only provide a space for people to comment. They provide a service to those independent people. The users aren't in a contractual economic relationship with the service providers.

Substack is a for-profit company that subcontracts with writers to provide original created content. They are like any other media company. The content here is not a service. It is a product. Since the company was created to provide a product, if doesn't qualify for section 530. Since they provide a product, they can be sued just the same as CNN and any other media company.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
Thom Prentice's avatar

You were an international terrorist lol

Koshmarov's avatar

"Does anyone really think that the incoming Biden administration is going to magically restore civil liberties and usher in a new golden era of real journalism?"

I'm gonna do an ageism here, but a bunch of dumb kids who spend all day on Twitter?

Galleta's avatar

No. The kids think they can more easily manipulate Biden. They have no idea yet that they are riding currents and not steering them

Galleta's avatar

Watch Kulinski, Nina Turner, Jimmy Dore’s crew, Gabbard...

Seder is on MSDNC payroll now so...

TYT is on DNC payroll now....

Tom Worster's avatar

Biden is Obama's surrogate/proxy (albeit unwanted and disdained) so why would anyone expect any interest in civil liberties from him?

Galleta's avatar

Obama is every bit as much the frontman as Biden

Koshmarov's avatar

This is the thing that gets to me in terms of visible power moves. It must have been deeply humiliating for Biden to play second fiddle to Obama after he put more time in, and for career bureaucrats, it's all about putting in the time.

How was Biden the best thing the DNC had to put forward this time around? The cracks are showing.

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

It really is no longer the Military/Industrial complex. We don't have industry anymore. It's the Democrats super heroes. Banking and Big Tech. Bill Clinton gave up on being the party of the people when he ran, and embraced banking. Now they've embraced Big Tech. This is how you dominate a people. The world is now hooked on Technology like no heroin addict has ever been hooked on that drug. The end is already here. We have been submitted. Just figure out how you can follow along with the herd and still feel somewhat like your own person.

UrbanCommonSense's avatar

It's not over yet. Individuals can still choose to be moral actors. Your don't have to work for Google, Twitter, Facebook, Amazon if you don't want to. You can take your talents somewhere else. Or collect unemployment. It's a moral choice.

I'm not judging anyone. I'm just saying that we do have choices. Computer programmers have choices for sure. When the full AI is in place many programmers won't be necessary, so no one should be fantasizing that they will be exempt.

We are building our own endgame, and we can stop anytime.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

This "AMWL" message is talking about "Deep State" theories that are right wing in nature.

"You are about to see the State, at the behest of its true masters, unleash a final devastating attack on what remains of our civil liberties and an independent press"

We will see what happens. If Biden does not do any of that stuff, will you admit you made a mistake?

Rebecca Tagett's avatar

Ralph, The Deep State is simply the set of unelected power brokers and their institutions, which obviously exists. The concept is independent of left or right wing. However, the concept is uncomfortable for the Deep State itself, which is why "belief in a Deep State" is the first accusation you will see being tied to Q-anon in the Mainstream Media.

I went to highschool with a girl who is now a Q-anon member, and I spoke a lot to her at the last reunion. The Deep State thing is only a small part of their world view. And believe it or not, she had some good points, but overall quite insane.

Koshmarov's avatar

"The Deep State is simply the set of unelected power brokers and their institutions, which obviously exists."

I say again, like a stuck record, "Who elected James Clapper and John Brennan to anything, and why do they have a platform to tell me what to think on national TV?"

Tom Worster's avatar

And if you think the CIA (for example) doesn't know how to whip the White House, Congress or Supreme Court into line when necessary, well...

Ralph Dratman's avatar

I agree with you on that point. Fortunately, we now have YouTube, so no one has to watch an anchor or a news channel they dislike. You can read and watch other commentators... such as Matt Taibbi. Noam Chomsky. And even grisha koshmarov, if he creates his own youtube channel.

Tom Worster's avatar

"Deep state" is to stable federal bureaucracy as "conspiracy theory" is to analysis of available facts.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

Obviously in a sense there is a "deep state" that confronts every politician in the form of personal cooperation and institutional inertia/strength. However, that phenomenon is, by its nature, not controlled by any one person or group. I certainly believe your friend had some good points. I would be very interested to learn what they were, in your view.

Tom Worster's avatar

The "controlled by any one person or group" is very misleading and I urge you to try thinking about institutional power instead. Maybe start with Jerry Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy. (I remember reading his column in Byte.)

Another way of thinking about this is that an organization can exhibit consistent and specific intentional behaviors even if nobody working in the organization seeks or even understands them. And these characteristics (ultimately disposition to behave in power-preserving/expanding ways) are often stable even in the face of turmoil within the organization.

Another way of thinking about it: it's sufficient for every individual to be motivated by career, budgets, org charts, money while the organization appears (and by all epistemological reason does) seek other goals.

Rebecca Tagett's avatar

Obviously the Deep State is not controlled by any one person or group - I don't think anyone ever implied that it was. But the wealthy and powerful are highly networked with each other, which gives it a collective consciousness.

As for my high school friend's "good points", I just meant that I agreed with her on a lot of things. When she was not talking about a "drop" or a "Q-drop" (some secret message to the followers), we talked about Jeffrey Epstein and how his crimes were covered up by powerful people (deep state). The government-pedophile lore in Q is partly true, the problem is that they are taking it to the nth degree. We also talked about "the swamp" and the corrupt Democratic party and how we both would like to see them out. We talked about how our politicians don't represent us, and spend our tax money on war.

See, they have some of the same gripes that we do about our government. They unfortunately act insane, thinking Trump is some kind of messiah, and all the mystical "drops" and other B.S. that are cult-like. One of their favorite things to say is that Trump kicked Epstein out of Mar-a-Lago for hitting on girls, so that proves that he was the good guy, while Clinton et. al. were guilty. I think the whole Epstein scandal fueled the Q movement a lot.

Bill Heath's avatar

I do not believe there is a "Deep State." Rather, I see a confluence of interests. Democrats are the party of government, wanting ever-increasing size, spending and power. Government employees behave rationally, i.e. in their own interests, which includes ever-increasing size, spending and power. Requires no overt nor covert collusion.

UrbanCommonSense's avatar

Ralph, the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012 is not a "right wing conspiracy." Nor is that fact that several major Intelligence officials are on the payroll at CNN and other news sources.

AMWL is right on point. The impending state of permanent lockdown with "privileges" granted to those with "social credit" and the proper ideology is being imposed on the US RIGHT NOW, brick by brick.

We can stop this. Businesses like Twitter, Google, and Facebook require employees. All moral actors should resign from these companies and go work somewhere else. Talented programmers from MIT and CalTech can always find a high-paying job.

Galleta's avatar

I don’t know if you’re aware of this, but India of 6 billion or so people has state sponsored coding degree holders like America has fat people. Not even to mention the rest of Asia.

They already don’t need or want American workers in big tech. They Dems are happy to align with the Koch bros to accommodate supply for the demand

Koshmarov's avatar

b-b-but Hillary told me to "learn how to code"

Rebecca Tagett's avatar

I agree with you overall but their employees consist of a lot of high tech immigrants who won't care.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

You visualize permanent lockdown continuing even after the pandemic has subsided; why? Also, can you recommend any site or article that might help me understand your concerns about the the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, or tell me more about it?

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

It won't be a lockdown. That idea is about as unhinged as you thinking Trump would declare himself emperor. There will be a new Social Credit Score system implemented however. It will be tied to Covid at first. If you want to travel outside the US, or fly? You'll need your health Passport to prove you've had all your vaccinations. It won't be quite as rigorous as the Chinese system, but it may get close in time.

All of this will take year, maybe a decade or more, but it's coming. Gasoline vehicles, and likely personal ownership of transportation will be phased out as well. In fact, I hypothesize that ownership of anything will be gone maybe in my lifetime (I am very middle aged). Subscription based enjoyment of "things" will just be the new way.

Turd_Ferguson's avatar

In answer to your last question? Probably not. I mean, Trump was some diabolical Fascist dictator who rounded opposition forces up and publicly executed them, and did all sort of dastardly deeds that sold all of America off to the Russians... None of that actually happened, but most purveyors of Main Stream news media will believe it forever.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

No, Trump has not rounded anyone up or had people killed. It is something a bit more indirect that is worrying many of us.

In the 20th center there were a number of historical studies written that followed the steps and changes toward autocratic government in several different countries (it happens all around the world at various times and places).

In those studies, several authors found that they could see a clear historical pattern in how each leader develops his power, and what happens at each step of the process.

What is alarming people is that Trump is following those steps very closely. Not that he is necessarily imitating anyone else's ascent to power (there is no way to know if he is unless he tells someone). But if a leader wants to start an autocratic government, logically a number of things must be done to get the people ready for that drastic change in their society. (That is happening right now in Hong Kong). The ruler ideally wants to find a way to make a substantial portion of the population actually want an autocratic government.

How can a leader accomplish that, when the effects of an autocracy are likely to be bad for most people? The leader has to lie to them and say, in effect, when I am the sole ruler, everything will be beautiful and you will all be rich and very happy. It is quite a trick, and Trump has done that part very skillfully. Remember when he said we would have so much winning, we would be tired of winning?

Did that happen? Did we win a lot? No, that was a lie.

Trump's problem is that persuasion is the only part of autocracy he is good at. Actually running a government is way beyond his education and training. Interestingly, though, even though he has done a terrible job of being the leader, his followers still love him! They are even ready to risk their lives to advance his cause. (And that young woman at the Capitol actually did die.)

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 10, 2021
Comment deleted
Ralph Dratman's avatar

I have not been able to figure out which of my comments you are responding to. Could you please write a little more so I will know what you are discussing?

Tom Worster's avatar

This is a straw man. Biden doesn't need to "final devastating attack on what remains of our civil liberties and an independent press" to be a routinely authoritarian head of the world's most potent military empire ever. And the "deep state" would never have allowed Trump or anyone else to do something so dramatic anyway because -- it's bad for business to do it like that.

Koshmarov's avatar

I question the potency of our military empire. What's the last unqualified US military success? Grenada? Panama? Iraq v.1? Track record for the last 75 years ain't stunningly great.

I'm sure MT could make a cutting analogy to some bad sports team that is overfunded and underperforms here; I don't follow sports.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

I'm genuinely sorry that I don't understand your comment enough to reply. It is getting late. Maybe tomorrow I'll understand it right away.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
AMWL's avatar

Yes I did. Agree with Matt, and was amplifying as a means of therapeutic venting...

Andy's avatar

Why feed into the ongoing character assassination of a person by saying things like “you don’t have to like him”? Assange is the contemporary Gramsci. Jailed in order to “stop that brain from working for 20 years” as the fascist prosecutor Ingrò said. And that’s precisely what they’re doing to Julian.

Mona Holland's avatar

>>Why feed into the ongoing character assassination of a person by saying things like “you don’t have to like him”?<<

That's appropriate; Julian Assange, by many reports, is a major asshole on an personal level. He's left behind a long, long trail of embittered former employees and friends. The issue is, however, he doesn't have to be the sweetest thing since sugar to merit free speech protections.

Not being "nice" isn't the issue.

Jane's avatar

Most people who have achieved the level of success and notoriety he has, leave a trail of « embittered former employees & friends ». Jealousy, competitiveness, etc. Ask any successful business owner. The point is, every story about him does not need to start with a disclaimer on his character.

Mona Holland's avatar

"Most people who have achieved the level of success and notoriety he has, leave a trail of « embittered former employees & friends »"

They do?!

Well, Assange has an unusually large and embittered crowd of them.

At any rate, given his widely acknowledged reputation of assholishness, I think it's right and proper tor Taibbi and others to stress that even assholes merit free speech protections.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
Sotos K. Yannopoulos's avatar

One may like or dislike a person and even if crazy that doesn’t mean they are stupid. Face it. Whatever his story he did nothing that the press hasn’t been doing for years. One can argue that a sworn member of the military or government or even a citizen could be liable ( I would question the latter), but he is none of these things. His beliefs are not the point. He is liable because he is not part of the club-MSM- and what he has done has ruffled everyone’s feathers.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Postimpressionist's avatar

He only had a bail hearing. No one even talks about the defense at a Bail hearing.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Postimpressionist's avatar

I can't find that anywhere. I thought has not come before a court yet anywhere. Where did he appear in court?

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Daren Sweeney's avatar

Many at the time saw Daniel Ellsberg as a traitor for getting the NYT and WaPo to print the Pentagon Papers. (Could you imagine these rags doing this today?) Now, he's considered a hero.

Morty Shallman's avatar

He was considered a hero then, too. History did not need to vindicate him. The rightness of his cause of informing the public about the crimes and lies of their government are -- and were -- plainly evident. So, too, with Assange. He's a hero, but unlike Ellsberg, he's being crucified for it. It is a disgrace.

Geoff's avatar

Of course they could. If there's a Republican president (as there was), they publish. If there's a Democrat president, they quash it and write an editorial warning that anyone else who publishes it should have their twitter and facebook yanked and, if possible, have Mastercard, Paypal and Patreon stop processing payments for them.

K.M.'s avatar

I can as long as it’s a Republican administration.... like it was in Nixon’s time.

Jane's avatar

Yes, it’s a form of virtue signalling disclaimer employed by anyone who writes about him. Alan Rusbridger, in his much belated piece on the extradition, did the same thing.

Egill's avatar

Would you still feel the same way if he were guilty of raping a sleeping woman without protection, which was the allegation he fled investigation of?

Boris Petrov's avatar

Assange was NEVER accused of rape - he was accused of using "leaky condoms". Accuser withdrew this ludicrous and previously unheard charge and Swedish court dropped the case.

Under US pressure, the strange charge was re-introduced (without accuser !?) and CIA propagandists ever since use the term -- charged for sexual crime...

Note that in Sweden like in all Western countries editors of main newspapers are always paid by CIA. Former chief editor of Germany's "Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung" wrote a book about this and his own role....

Sotos K. Yannopoulos's avatar

Even if he had sex in public with a porcupine, what has this to do with Wikileaks? Why are we discussing ad hominem attacks? I don’t think he ever posed as a moral leader. Face it; most people only like the truth when it fits their ideological narrative.

Rebecca Tagett's avatar

I agree, but it is surprising how many women would like to hang him for that,

without even reading a bit to learn that it was a bogus charge.

Koshmarov's avatar

I personally love it when the CIA inspects my used condoms to make sure everything was on the up-and-up. We need a trusted authority to ensure the safety of the world.

Sotos K. Yannopoulos's avatar

The CIA is capable of a lot of stupidity, but this reeks of some political E or GG employees sucking up.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Gary Hemminger's avatar

I don't think you actually needed to write this...it was pretty clear to anyone with a brain.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

All you know how to write is insults.

Daren Sweeney's avatar

I wonder what Tara Reade or the other women/girls Biden felt up would think about that. I'd love to know how the women at that D.C. rally in January 2017 rationalize supporting a guy as the "Resistance" who also has a serious problem with strange behavior with women and a VP who started her political career by giving the mayor of SF a bj. (Whether Trump "does it more" than Biden is debatable and not relevant in that both exhibit behavior with women that pass the floor of acceptable behavior.)

Morty Shallman's avatar

That charge has been debunked.

Egill's avatar

I disagree, unless by debunked you mean swept under the rug because it was ideologically inconvenient

Zar's avatar

Here's an impressively detailed debunking effort by Caitlin Johnstone. She's "fringe" as political commentators go, but she's difficult to disagree with.

https://caityjohnstone.medium.com/assange-smear-2-hes-a-rapist-df9effd8b49d

Postimpressionist's avatar

You mean like this being swept under the rug:

Ukraine wants the $13,000,000,000 that Biden and the US government embezzled from the People of the Ukraine.

US Tariff Scam & Embezzlement of International Technical Assistance Funds.

This is what Victor Shokin was Investigating when he was fired, by Biden. (Soloman is redeem)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0PkAuND3S4

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Mostly disagreeable's avatar

Sweden dropped the charges. The whole "case" was stupid beyond belief.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

He did not rape her. They were sleeping together overnight. She only accused him of omitting the condom. And the charges have now been dropped by the Swedish government.

Gary Hemminger's avatar

Were you in the room or something? No one knows what really happened. If the Swedish government dropped the charges, then maybe nothing illegal happened, but who the hell knows...

Zar's avatar

Texts she sent to a friend say:

• She “did not want to put any charges against JA but the police wanted to get a grip on him”

• She was “shocked when they arrested JA"

• That “it was the police who fabricated the charges”

That's according to Assange and his Swedish lawyers, so maybe take with a grain of salt.

https://wikileaks.org/IMG/html/Affidavit_of_Julian_Assange.html#sdfootnote110anc

Ralph Dratman's avatar

The accusation was not of rape, only of intercourse without a condom without consent. If it had been rape, they would have charged him with rape, I think.

Bill Astore's avatar

Of course, it's not just about punishing Assange (or Manning or Snowden or Winner). It's about intimidating all potential whistleblowers and anyone who seeks to practice true confrontational and critical journalism. The US and UK governments are sending a message: air our dirty laundry and we promise to put you in prison and keep you there, no matter how trumped up the charges may be.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
Morty Shallman's avatar

If the conflict is illegitimate like Iraq War 2, then absolutely.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
Morty Shallman's avatar

As is yours. I know I shouldn't feed trolls like you, but you're an especially pernicious little fucker. Must come from typing with one hand up your ass. Now, kindly fuck off and let the grown-ups have a serious debate.

Geoff's avatar

Do I want to? Not necessarily. Do I think a free society can both stay free and eliminate that risk? Definitely not.

VanishingTribe's avatar

"Now Trump is on his way out, but the lockdown era is just beginning. You’ll forgive me if I’m more scared of that than the other thing."

Exactly. While the left (I'm not referring to "traditional" liberals, but the socialism-infatuated wackjobs of the present) have been running around in circles with their hair on fire screaming and pointing "Russia! Racist! Orange Man bad!" for the last four years, their handlers in the deep state have quietly been setting the stage for an authoritarian medical-industrial-tech dystopian nightmare far worse than anything Trump could imagine. For all of his failings, and they are many, at least Trump didn't give in to the authoritarian impulse that seduced so many former Presidents, including Clinton and Obama -- starting a new war. Wars abroad lead to civil liberties being curtailed at home, for the sake of "safety" and "the homeland." Any sane person (right, left, or in the middle) who looks at Biden's proposed cabinet members should be quite nervous.

Blissex's avatar

«While the left (I'm not referring to "traditional" liberals, but the socialism-infatuated wackjobs of the present) have been running around in circles with their hair on fire screaming and pointing "Russia! Racist! Orange Man bad!"»

That's not the socialists, it is identity-politics market libertarians, who support globalism and financialization. Trump mostly in the beginning was, while being no socialist, for nationalism and productive industry.

Koshmarov's avatar

The word "socialism" is The Bloody Shirt. You're never going to get anywhere using it in American politics. "Social Security" ... maaaaaaaybe.

Postimpressionist's avatar

Social Security is paid for by the people who use it. It is an INSUANCE PROGRAM paid BEFORE they use it. An Insurance program is NOT socialism. MEDICAID is Socialism. Not Medicare.

Blissex's avatar

«Social Security is paid for by the people who use it. It is an INSUANCE PROGRAM paid BEFORE they use it. An Insurance program is NOT socialism. MEDICAID is Socialism. Not Medicare.»

Well, MEDICAID is also insurance: it effectively insures *everybody* against the risk of becoming too poor to pay healthcare premiums. Same as MEDICARE really.

Also Social Security (OASDI) does the same: it gives rather smaller pensions than those earned by contributions to high earners and rather larger pensions than those earned by contributions to low earners.

Therefore it effectively insures *everybody* against the risk of being too poor to get a decent pension.

So if you look at the disproportion between contributions and "returns" all three programs are "socialist", but if you consider that disproportion as insurance against poverty, all three are contributory insurance programs.

They key is that *everybody* gets insured: someone earning $1m/year with children who loses everything gets MEDICAID, when he retires she gets MEDICARE, and she gets OASDI when she retires or becomes disabled. The higher-than-proportional taxes and contributions she made when earning $1m/year insure her against the risk of not being able to contribute later when becomes too poor to do so.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 9, 2021
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 8, 2021
Comment deleted
RAH's avatar

Say what you will but Donald Trump has clearly delineated how the seemingly disparate views of the progressives and deplorables are not that different.

Geoff's avatar

Actually, Trump lunatics will be surer allies for this than respectable Republicans. Do you seriously think Ross Douthat, David Frum and Lindsey Graham are going to interfere with the expansion of government control? Ben Sasse? Our only hope is people like Cruz limiting the damage, and that's not out of principle as much as spite.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 8, 2021
Comment deleted
Koshmarov's avatar

Cruz might be the next Trump. He's a complete sociopath and asshole, but he understands that brazenly attacking the shit that sucks is more immediately gratifying for the public than actually fixing anything.

He should keep workin' on the Al Gore beard. It's a good look.

mcelroyj's avatar

The screws are tightening second by second, but the grand distraction of American political theatre means that heads are turned the other way, as the networks of power splay their adversaries through the grinder - memo to all those who were espousing MBAs and business/computer technical educations as far back as the 80s --- this is what happens we an entire generation fails to read history. It starts with a lack of imagination, and constipated leadership but then quickly evolves into a vacuum of bloviation not seen since the universe was created ---- distraction, hyper-capitalistic paternalism and in the end YOYO (you're on your own) neoliberal dogma erodes the fibers of community/family so much so that anger/fear take over our collective brain stem.

Special thanks to those like Matt, Julian for not bending the knee to American power networks.

Daren Sweeney's avatar

Maybe the Romans were nearly as good as providing Bread and Circuses to the people.

Blissex's avatar

It is quite amazing that an australian journalist publishing in Sweden can be accused of breaking an american law on american government secrecy, and regarded as a traitor and a terrorist.

But there are plenty of scared oldies who got theirs and are terrified of any potential disturbance to their tranquility, and don't much care about brown people in far away places or foreign journalists either, and who write with their votes blank cheques to the government as long as their real estate and share prices go up. "Better safer than sorry", "absolute safety at any cost to someone else", "Security is well worth sacrificing somebody else's life", etc.

Koshmarov's avatar

Looking at the media for the past two days has been an amazing display of ingroup/outgroup thinking.

To the "OMG 5 DEAD AT THE CAPITOL" crowd; how many Iraqis, Afghans, Syrians, Somalis, etc. ad in., as well as the American soldiers sent to kill them, have died in the last 19 years? You got a count? Is the specific number important? It seems to be important as long as it's a single-digit number.

David's avatar

Thanks for that! Also of the 5 who died at the Capitol, 4 died of natural causes. The only violent death was by the gov't on a Trump supporter. Blaming that on Trump is disingenuous at best.

Stxbuck's avatar

A Capitol police officer died after getting conked w/ a fire extinguisher. Prosecutors are seeing how many federal murder charges they can justify.

David's avatar

Yes he passed some hours before I made my post, I was unaware. RIP Brian Sicknick.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Everything you post is benign, including your multiple plugs for this substack article.

P&KA's avatar

The United States has always been very good at promoting a special form of sociopathy with its citizens in terms of getting many of us to believe that foreign lives are less valuable than their own... The one exception being when they "need our help" to "free" them from their own leaders, thus justifying deploying our Forever War machine followed by our poisonous consumer products and industry.

Our dog shit leadership - sadly - does reflect what many of us have chosen to become.

Now we're finally closing our long journey toward finally deciding that we're too dangerous to be trusted with our own freedom, liberty, privacy, and power of choice.

Koshmarov's avatar

Dead accurate.

You have your Brzezinskis and your Kissingers, who tacitly or openly declare that non-American lives don't matter, and your Albrights and Powers and Rices, who argue for a "responsibility to protect," the soft sell. Two sides of the same bloody coin.

We the people get the leadership we deserve.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
P&KA's avatar

I don't see how that could be the whole of it. Much of Greek Mythology is clearly a metaphor for the inevitable corruption of leadership or anyone with power over the populace. So many of them clearly had to have seen that aspect of it. Am I wrong?

Koshmarov's avatar

"Am I wrong?"

No.

The Greeks had their foibles, but ancient Greece was still a hell of a society. I have always loved that the Pantheon of Olympus was openly corrupt, self-interested, horny, and petty. Hellenics seem to generally have had a more realistic idea about the moral character of their leadership than Abrahamites do.

I know hero worship is dumb, but I still want Yanis Varoufakis to save the world from itself -- when he couldn't even save Greece. The problem with hero worship is that it puts all the burden on the hero and none on the worshiper. The old myths have a thing or two to say about this.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
P&KA's avatar

I don't quite agree with that interpretation of "God is dead..." especially with the context of the rest of the statement. I read it as Nietzsche arguing that by not having a mythical being to blame our failures on, humanity was left with a sort of morality vacuum and had to logically accept that we're responsible for our choices and failings also and their consequences.

It has the character of cautioning about something similar to the converse of a power vacuum, to me. We lost the power of blaming God(s) for what we do (scary) but we gain the realization that we are the gods of our own fate (scarier).

To the point about the lack of values as an ideology, I don't see Nietzsche believing that this problem would have been anything new. He may have been against the concept of collectives of any kind, but religious/spiritual is obviously an evergreen collective.

Regarding the Actions for Assange, tbh I and many others (the few REAL socialists left) have been pleading with POTUS (not DNC hacks) for a Pardon, even appealing to him to do the right thing for the wrong reasons. I can't travel but some have. Since I already knew that the few Dem's that actually want to help him are unable to do any more, I went to the only miniscule (but most plausible) shot I could take, the President's vanity.

Bill Heath's avatar

Please consider viewing people as individuals. I am an "oldie" who has preached about the dangers of COVID19 to brown people whose lives will be lost in second- and third-order effects of the illness, such as famine. The toughest sell has been progressive millenials, who never tire of lecturing others about systemic racism, but refuse to believe the risks created by lockdowns. After all, everybody is like me and my acquaintances, just work from home, and if you run out of bread, eat cake.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
Postimpressionist's avatar

DNC computers were not authorized have National Defense Information on them. They have election information and private personal e-mails.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 9, 2021
Comment removed
mcelroyj's avatar

Your analysis is stunningly poor. There is a way to make your points without this kind of 7 year old tantrum.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
Geoff's avatar

But the actual act was working a source. Charging Assange with espionage is like saying that if the reporters talking to Ellsberg had asked him to try to get them an actual copy of the Pentagon Papers then they were no longer journalists, but participants in the release of classified documents.

Koshmarov's avatar

All of this shit is intended to blur the line between "journalist" and "spy," which I take as MT's main point. It's intended to establish a legal precedent that a journalist who publishes information the regime doesn't want disclosed can be defined as a spy.

The distinction with Assange is actually much less ambiguous, in my opinion, than the Ellsberg and Manning cases. Both Ellsberg and Manning were ultimately Pentagon functionaries, which is how they got access to the information they got access to. They signed off on the paperwork.

Assange isn't a US citizen, he never worked for DOD, and he never signed off on shit. Manning's in jail, and that's not nothing, but there seems to be an eagerness to burn Assange at the stake to redefine what the Western concept of "law" is -- i.e. it is whatever the biggest dog says it is.

Sue's avatar

Trump should pardon Assange and Snowden before he leaves. We need whistle blowers. If not for those two we would not have known that all Americans are constantly surveilled, and we would not have known about the misasventures of Hillary and Democrats.

SW's avatar

They want to close that loophole and keep it closed forever. And make it clear to any journalist who wants to expose another Gitmo or MiLai massacre that their days as a citizen with Constitutional rights is over. Intimidation by example.

K.M.'s avatar

What’s really amazing is the treatment our government is giving an autistic hacker vs. Jonathan Pollard who actually SPIED for Israel AGAINST THE USA and is now being greeted in Israel by Netanyahu himself as a national hero..... We are dupes guys! Where’s the national outrage?

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/12/30/middleeast/jonathan-pollard-israel-arrival-intl/index.html

Koshmarov's avatar

Pollard and the USS Liberty are straight yuks all the way down. If you're going to be a spy, spy for the right country. It pays dividends.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 8, 2021
Comment removed
K.M.'s avatar

Well, Israel doesn’t bother me and I’m neutral on Zionism but what does bother me is this guy was an American citizen and literally gave our secrets away to a foreign country, he gets released EARLY and gets to fly to the country he sold us out to and is greeted by their leader! The media are crickets!

K.M.'s avatar

At least Julian wasn’t a citizen, he owes no loyalty to our country.

Koshmarov's avatar

Matt, thanks for this piece.

"This was a death penalty offense, the Brookings Institution noted, not worrying at the oddness of charging a foreigner with such a crime."

This continues to drive me bananas. How does the US government assert the legal right to charge an Australian national under US law? Where is the Australian government here? Does it care about its citizens and their rights or is it out to brunch?

I need a smart lawyer, preferably Australian, to explain it to me.

Olaf's avatar

The Australian government is pretty much in lockstep with the US on all things. It is a bipartisan approach. Hence why we eagerly signed up to invading Iraq based on Cheney-inspired dishonesty all those years ago.

Our government has completely vacated the field with regards Julian Assange just as they did with David Hicks who was incarcerated in Guantanamo and convicted by a US Military Commission under a law that was subsequently found to be invalid as it didn’t exist at the time of the alleged offence.

My local representative at the time Hicks was incarcerated went on to become the recent Australian ambassador to the US. I am not a lawyer but at the time Hicks was incarcerated I wrote to him asking how it was reasonable Hicks could be held in Guantanamo when he had not seemingly actually committed an offence under any law. I received a response which threw Hicks and any notion of the rule of law under a bus. The vibe was Hicks was a bad guy in a bad place thus it was open slather. Due process and legal principle seemed incidental or even unnecessary as applied to Hicks.

I mention this case as it illustrates is the caliber of our politicians and their approach to Assange. They are demagogic, power hungry and opportunistic. Principles and laws are malleable and only applied where expedient.

The power structures have decided the transparency bought by Wikileaks is extremely inconvenient. An example will be made such that the next potential Assange will think twice about such acts unless they want to be hounded to their grave.

The politicians in Australia lean towards secrecy and corruption just like those in the US. We are even prosecuting a whistleblower who revealed our government was electronically eavesdropping on the impoverished, newly independent East Timor when we were bullying/negotiating with them over gas deposits in the waters between our two countries.

You don’t need a lawyer to explain the Australian government’s approach to Assange. Just an understanding of the worst aspects of human nature and the corrupting influence of power.

Koshmarov's avatar

Thanks for the detailed response.

Remember when the CIA pushed Gough Whitlam out in 1975? A complete gas.

David's avatar

Maybe the Deep State has Five Eyes. Maybe.

Koshmarov's avatar

There's only One Eye to rule them all. The post-WWII USA intelligence consortium was set up with much assistance from the English along English (i.e. class-based) lines.

K.M.'s avatar

See... “The Anglo American Establishment” by Carroll Quigley. They’re really was a post WW2 English/American goal to rule the world.(ok, a bit of hyperbole).

Galleta's avatar

Why did the Australian govt donate big $$$$ to the Clinton foundation? Does Australia not have any charitable orgs or do you all believe the Clinton Initiative was the best vehicle for tangible results?

Koshmarov's avatar

Good point, but the Aussies probably don't have much more control over their government's actions than we do. I think that's what Olaf's getting at.

randall grass's avatar

another great piece Matt...very balanced and your point re: focusing on institutions and broad policy rather than personalities/individuals is very apt. I have mixed feelings about Assange and do not feel all of his actions even regarding Wikileaks dumps are defensible...but your points about the implications of the legal actions against him and the underpinning laws and regulations are crucial. As always people need to look beyond their desired outcome in specific cases to broader implications of policy actions. A great example of that is when Harry Reid got rid of the Senate rule that required a super-majority for judicial confirmations.... for the expedient reason that he wanted Obama nominees to be confirmed over Republican obstruction... a few years later that lowered confirmation threshold resulted in the confirmation of, for instance, Brett Kavanagh ..similarly those who cheer FB and Twitter suspended Trump's account are not thinking of the implications of tech corp algorithms or functionaries making decisions on what is false or true and there can be available in the public square....

Morty Shallman's avatar

Julian Assange is a hero, and his persecution by the US, UK, et al, is a disgrace.

Stephen Youhanaie's avatar

I'm not a fan of the current or next President. However, I think the "State" will be more punitive under Biden, by a long shot.

Koshmarov's avatar

He has this weird thing called a legislative record.

Ralph Dratman's avatar

What kind of punitive actions are you thinking Biden will take?

Stephen Youhanaie's avatar

He'll go back to the stuff that Snowden narc's on. Also,ci see free speech and assembly tensions

Mostly disagreeable's avatar

The empire's mask has already dropped. Patriot Act, round 2, is going to be dazzling in its aggression against citizens, who are now openly recruited to spy on neighbors for infractions of pandemic "policy" and just over the past two days openly recruited to help the corporate press hunt down protesters--not because LE needs help but so people become further accustomed to snitching on each other and to taking pleasure in fellow citizens' social death. It's a short path from gleeful doxxing to Stasi-level surveillance.

The "something" in the War on Terror's "see something, say something"slogan has been greatly expanded and one is tacitly expected to view fellow citizens as sacks of pathogens and terrorists. Citizens number well over 300M, why is this tolerated?

Koshmarov's avatar

"one is tacitly expected to view fellow citizens as sacks of pathogens and terrorists. Citizens number well over 300M, why is this tolerated?"

I might be an incurable optimist, but I think if they push it too hard it won't be tolerated for very long.

P&KA's avatar

But if all but four lucratively-lobbied politicians are in the pocket of the Elite, who's left to change it?

...and then just as someone points that out, The Distraction:

CNN/MSNBC "A BOMBSHELL! TONIGHT!!!! Former President Donald Trump has just revealed that he wouldn't date a trans woman because QUOTE 'They're kinda icky.' Is this the worstest most horriblest and bigotiest behavior from him yet? We go now live to our trans correspondent Cuntrapoints who is sobbing at this very moment..."