742 Comments

So disappointed in Twitter. I thought Elon was a big supporter of Substack. Terrible news, but so grateful for the work you and others did on the Twitter files.

Expand full comment

MATT, YOU DON'T NEED TO LEAVE TWITTER. There is a work-around for the Substack block.

Karlyn Borysenko (someone I follow on Substack) posted this: "For people writing on Substack who still want to share their work on Twitter, there is a workaround... You need to use a URL SHORTENER. I took the URL from my trans martyr article that Twitter was blocking and used URL shortener to make a new URL: http://unwoke.info/trans That URL redirects to the Substack article." She also noted that "Twitter will still remove the embed to the article generated by the URL, so consider LOADING THE PICTURE you used in the header image of your article instead."

Expand full comment

Wholeheartedly agree. Leaving would be a mistake. The discourse on Twitter too often rolls around in the gutter, but it remains a powerful medium. Your comments on Twitter are engaging. Example: your follow up statements to M. Hasan were prompt, readily accessible and excellent. You have a good following there and you should keep it. Have a good vacation.

Expand full comment

How would Matt leaving Twitter be a “mistake”? Dude’s a best-selling author who’s written many excellent books, I think he’ll be fine.

Nobody “needs” fucking Twitter, particularly not Matt. In fact, we’d all be better off without it.

Expand full comment

If it’s either/or, thanks for staying on Substack.

Expand full comment

Only losers use twitter. He should definitely leave - Matt has been a massive hypocrite for continuing to use it all these years, given that it is the source of much of the corruption he writes about.

Expand full comment

Sleazy, Sleazy, Sleazy... Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Or in your case, don't let fantasies of purity piss all over the practicalities. Matt has used Twitter to his advantage, by persuasively responding to critics and defending his position. Thomas Neuburger has some constructive thoughts about it.

https://neuburger.substack.com/p/democrats-vs-democrats-one-of-them

If Matt's had enough of Twitter, so be it. I commend him for stepping into the electronic public square, however flawed, and sharing his views.

Expand full comment

I never used twitter and I've still gotten the news I need.

Expand full comment

Twitter is far more than a place to read the news.

Expand full comment

Correct, it might be the best propaganda distribution system since the TV. Well, more of an evolution.

Expand full comment

Have you finished mopping the bathrooms yet?

Expand full comment

Nah. The last thing I did at work today was explain to a breathless hypochondriac that I will never be instituting vaccine mandates at my company.

Expand full comment

Spoken like the commie you clearly are. Poor thing upset that your commie daddy’s lost their exclusive access to ban viewpoints that hurt your little feelings?

Expand full comment

Try again. Twitter was shit from the beginning - it doesn't matter who owns it. Any form of social media based on ad revenue can't avoid being pathetic.

Expand full comment

OUCH!!! 🥴 🥴 😄

Remind me to never tangle with you Mr. Minor.

Expand full comment

Listen to Archie Bunker intoning to Meathead...

Expand full comment

The 50s are over buddy.

Expand full comment

I do the same with bitly - https://app.bitly.com/ -- seems to be working great as of today: https://twitter.com/BlakeBelt

Expand full comment

Yes, but the problem of censorship remains. That aside they will just ban bitly links.

Expand full comment

Twitter is what it is, but like you say, it's a "happening" place still.

Be careful what ghetto you move too.

Expand full comment
Apr 7, 2023·edited Apr 7, 2023

Counterpoint - Twitter sucks, and fuck Twitter.

Expand full comment
Apr 8, 2023·edited Apr 8, 2023

I'm grateful to Musk for blowing up the govt censorship. Will not abandon Musk while righting the ship for the benefit of all. The man may have saved our country.

Expand full comment

Musk accidentally did something that was good in a fit of pique.

Let's not go crazy stanning the guy. Abandon him? He's a symptom of corruption, not the cure to it.

Expand full comment

The wealthiest person in the world “saved our country” by purchasing Twitter? What country do you live in?

Expand full comment

A man who stumbles upon the right thing while otherwise acting like an overgrown toddler does not deserve your allegiance.

People who have principles and conduct themselves with integrity are worthy of loyalty. Musk doesn't fit the bill.

Expand full comment

"We've got one that can see!" - They Live

#OBEY

Expand full comment

Hallucinations run deep, into your life they will creep...

Expand full comment

This is quite the dick flute solo.

Expand full comment
Apr 7, 2023·edited Apr 7, 2023

As if Twitter won''t block URL shorteners that point to sites they don't like? It's the principle.

Expand full comment

But does the workaround work? That's the main question. Is Twitter actually weeding out shortened URLs that point to Substack? Seems that the OP believes they aren't.

Expand full comment

Mice shouldn't play at cat and mouse games.

Expand full comment

Mice gotta get their cheese too, so you at least have to try.

Expand full comment

Apparently Matt has enough cheese to go on family vacations, hopefully somewhere nice.

Expand full comment

The OP said it works... so far.

Expand full comment

Until they "fix" it, which they will.

Expand full comment

The OP said she tried it, and it works. .. so far.

Expand full comment

Principle? Modi should have been the principle. And I love your work.

Expand full comment

Nah, he should leave. Twitter makes every user dumber, without exception.

Expand full comment

You, M. Sleazy, must have used Twitter extensively at one time.

Expand full comment

I learned a LOT on twitter. Life, and twitter, are what you make them.

Expand full comment

Why should anybody need to “workaround” twitter’s new (are they new?) policies? I thought Elon Musk was bringing free speech back. Anybody can post anything, right? Unless they’re a direct competitor to Twitter? Is that what the deal is?

Is substack even actually a “direct competitor” to Twitter? I don’t think so, but if you know how it is and what the rationale for people needing to “workaround” posting substack links (or any other links, for that matter) is, please enlighten me.

Expand full comment

Musk lied. He does that a lot. It's who he is. He's a bullshitter too.

Expand full comment

Gosh, I’m starting to get the impression that most billionaires are total fucking assholes… Who’da thunk it??? Haha…

Expand full comment

Lord Musko as the "USSR" and hidden links as modern day samizdat.

Works for me.

Expand full comment

Ditto!!!!

Expand full comment

There is something to consider. Elon has A Lot of irons in the fire. It is possible (even likely) he doesn't know.

Expand full comment

I'm sure Matt asked him directly...

Expand full comment

Possibly, but this is a huge week for SpaceX a lot is riding on a safe launch out of Boca Chica for the starship program. If Elon has ever focused on a single aspect of his many endeavors this would be it.

Expand full comment

Maybe Elon's focus should be on his mini Starlinks that are rapidly turning into space trash.

Expand full comment

Uncle Elon is spending the weekend sitting on his front porch whittling whole pineapples. That's about it.

Expand full comment
Apr 8, 2023·edited Apr 8, 2023

You’re seriously making excuses for Elon-fucking-Musk? Really? “Uhhh, I dunno, maybe Elon just doesn’t know what’s going on…” I can guaran-fucking-TEE you that Elon Musk knows exactly what’s happening at Twitter right now.

Pathetic. Are you a fellow Billionaire Traveler or something? Like, you’re just here to stick up for the billionaires? I’d maybe buy that excuse if Elon didn’t tweet a thousand times a day…

Expand full comment

"Are you a fellow Billionaire Traveler"

Why yes I am! I only come to places like this because it keeps me In Touch with The Little People.

Expand full comment

Yeah, good one. But you still didn’t explain why you would make excuses for Elon Musk. I’m genuinely curious.

Expand full comment

I could put it another way. I could ask why you think 1. Elon knows anything about this, 2. wants it to happen?

Expand full comment

Russia peasants used to same thing about the Tsar, "If only the Tsar knew, he would do something."

Expand full comment

You seem to know a lot about Russian peasants. Are you the one? 🤔

Expand full comment

Or maybe it’s temporary.

Expand full comment
founding

I get Substack alerts in e-mail so it doesn't change much. But it would change non-subscribers getting alerts.

Expand full comment

If the changes to their API and third party apps are an indicator, then no, its not temporary.

Expand full comment

It was an automated reply! See Matt’s T feed

Expand full comment

Not with this kind of ultimatum - only Elon could make this level of decision:

“a decision that apparently will come with a price as far as any future Twitter Files reports are concerned.“

Expand full comment

This appears to be true.

Expand full comment

Check twitter. That's all you have to do, Steve. It's really quite simple. I know it's scary stepping outside the friendly confines of the Racket News threads, but som-a-times you gotta do it...

Expand full comment

Agreed. I had thought it would make sense for Twitter to invest in or simply acquire Substack. Obviously a different trajectory right now, but that could change quickly. Matt leaving twitter is massive development -- and very much will reviewed and assessed by Elon.

Expand full comment

God no. Keep twit away from substack.

Expand full comment

No no no no. We need more distributed networks (and power), not more consolidated.

Expand full comment

Why would you even WANT Twitter-cum-Elon to “acquire” substack? The entire point of substack is to publish journalism free of corporate influence.

The day substack is “acquired” by anybody is the day I cancel my subscription.

Expand full comment

Me too. I was sure that Musk supported Substack. Odd

Expand full comment

I think the cleanest solution would be for Twitter and Substack to negotiate a kickback/royalty system, so that Substack pays Twitter some small fee for every Substack post shared on Twitter.

That way, Substack can leverage Twitter to drive engagement, and Twitter doesn't have to subsidize their competitor.

Expand full comment

Or... or, hear me out, human beings should be able to freely share links as the creators of the world wide web intended.

Expand full comment

Realistically, Musk didn't drop $44 billion to run a charity.

Expand full comment

No, Musk dropped $44 billion to run a tightly controlled propaganda machine. First he came for the algorithms, then he came for substack and all other competitors, then he came for...

Expand full comment

then he came for. . . the pigs.

I feel sorry for his pigs.

Expand full comment

The messaging is too erratic to be propaganda

Expand full comment

Charging for links (which is full on nuts) is a great way to turn a business into a charity.

Preventing or charging for links is so absurd from a business perspective--especially for a social media site that is 99.99% marketing--that it must be some philosophical stand devoid of any business logic.

One thing I noticed about Musk is that he does his deliberation post decision making (releases early and release often)--which is unusual outside of geek circles--but it really seems to work for him. I'm not predicting what Musk's final decision will be, but Musk deliberates post decision. The arguments for or against happen now.

Now not the time to submit.

Expand full comment

Charging for links isn't that different from selling ad space- they pay a price to market their content on the platform.

Expand full comment

Okay. Not a charity. That’s fine. What do you think he dropped 44 billion dollars on, then?

Expand full comment

A business that sells user data and ad space. When the website is free, you're the product.

Expand full comment

A megaphone? Loud and unstoppable.

That said for sure Lord Musk got the "national security" speech and of course the warning about his kids.

That's just how they roll.

Opinion control is central in a managed democracy.

Expand full comment

Create your own site and share links with anyone you deem worthy., that's the beauty of the internet.

Expand full comment

The World Socialist website has seen an astonishing drop in traffic, like 100s of 1000s of visits.

That's down to "Google" doing the work of the deep state and of course the ultragarchs.

If you build they will NOT come.

Field of. . . something.

Expand full comment

That's an actually great idea. It could work, as the great Robert Heinlein once said, "Never appeal to a man's higher nature. He may not have one. Invoking his self-interest will give you more leverage."

Expand full comment

Musk supports Musk. Period.

Expand full comment

Yes. I lose hope for humanity when I see the worship.

His souped up V2s are nice and shiny though!

He's never going to Mars either. Why? To live in a cave and then die there?

Expand full comment

I'm grateful to Elon Musk for so much, but too much is riding on the mood swings of one eccentric billionaire.

Expand full comment

You think that Tesla, SpaceX, Neuralink and The Boring Company are results of Musk's mood swing?

Expand full comment

If they are, bring on mood swings!!! 😁

Expand full comment

I think we should be very careful what we are asking for; Neuralink, AI and then there is ... POSTHUMANISM, right?

Expand full comment

Humans are just a transitional form.

He needs to stop torturing pigs though.

Expand full comment

Are you JUST HUMAN? In which transitional phase are you?

Expand full comment

I think you are upto something and we are not far, if that, apart

Expand full comment

I'm not up to, but against; I like humanity and post- means AIity

Expand full comment

No, he stole all those ideas, some of them horrendously bad, like this tunnel trains, from Popular Science articles written many decades ago. Mush has never invented or even originated one single thing. Not even paypal.

Expand full comment

China's tunnel bores are astounding, huge and can bore thru anything. In Seattle a tunnel was delayed for over a year because the pathetic bore got stuck. Musk is a leech.

Expand full comment

"Popular Science articles written many decades ago." -- Is this a... reference that supports your claims?

Expand full comment
founding

Elon is first and foremost a businessman. Sub Notes is a direct competitor to Twitter. So it shouldn't be all that surprising he would have a vested interest in trying to marginalize it. He does have $40B invested ...

Expand full comment

Musk is first and foremost a chaos agent. As a "businessman" he is mostly a useful idiot for various government enterprises, foreign and domestic.

Expand full comment
founding

A very rich and successful chaos agent, so he must be doing something right.

Expand full comment

Oh, a sycophant. Beg your pardon.

Expand full comment

IMHO Elon Musk is first and foremost an engineer looking to make the world a better place.

Expand full comment

Going to Mars won't do a thing for Terra.

If he goes to Mars, which he won't.

Expand full comment

No, it’s not understandable. I was puzzled when he made an offer for Twitter instead of waiting for 3-6 months. I am surprised now. Makes little to no sense.

Expand full comment

Add to his investment to buy Twitter, the 20 million he has spent on it since.

Expand full comment

One can NEVER stop attacking millionaires. They have their own agenda. Elon too.

Expand full comment

Elon is no millionaire. How offensive. ;)

Expand full comment

Elon is probably playing “WAC-A-Mole” over at twitter

Expand full comment

Elon is a big supporter of Elon. It starts and stops there.

Expand full comment

Musk supports himself, for himself.

That's the list.

Twitter is just as bad as it ever was, only now he's the one pulling all the greasy strings. I am still waiting for my account to be restored, but only so I can get banned again as quickly as possible.

Expand full comment

It was an automated reply. See Matt’s Twitter feed

Expand full comment

I am banned from Twitter and so rarely go. I have asked to be reinstated, but nothing happened. I guess that LORD Musk is too busy reading all the adoring comments here to bother.

Expand full comment
Apr 7, 2023·edited Apr 7, 2023

but but but all the blue check set said that you were a puppet of The World's Richest Man?

Expand full comment

I don't get why "world's richest man" is supposed to be an insult off the bat, especially if you made your fortune. What's wrong with that?

Expand full comment
founding

Wealth doesn't matter if you're Soros. If you're Musk then you're a "powerful oligarch".

Expand full comment

Repubs did the same thing with Kochs vs Soros back in the day. Each side has its billionaires that it sees as heroes and villains.

Expand full comment
founding

True, though there are some significant distinctions between the two.

First off, the Kochs funded mostly pro-business PACs with a goal of strengthening the American economy, business landscape, and energy independence. Nothing they supported ever gravely impacted individuals, at least so far as I know.

Soros in contrast directly funds all sorts of far-Left radical candidates, especially local and state district attorneys who are openly pro-crime -- at least so long as those crimes are committed by non-white perpetrators. These fringe candidates could never have been elected without Soros dumping mountains of cash on small (and small funded) local elections. Look at the numbers. The result has been a major uptick in violent crimes in every major city he has had a hand in. And the majority of the perps are career criminals, many of whom are free on cashless bail from another recent offence. There is no deterrent.

Remember the Left's battle cry, "Citizen's United!!!!" and their constant whinging about money in politics? Now that the donkeys have become the party of the mega donors (and the control which they wield), suddenly money is no issue. Yet they still try and pretend they are the party of the working man/woman/non-binary. What they have become is the party of the super rich and the perpetually dependent. Screw the middle classes who build this country keep it going.

So yes, both the Kochs and Soros have funneled money into political causes. But the impact each has had is vastly different.

Expand full comment

I believe our resident feline is being snarky-castic. You know how cats are.

Expand full comment

That has been said about Matt, verbatim — 'he's a puppet of The World's Richest Man.' Feral Finster is mocking them.

Expand full comment

Maybe I should have added the trademark symbol to "World’s Richest Man(R)"?

Expand full comment

Purrrrrrrr

Expand full comment

Another feline?

Expand full comment

Duh I'm so stupid. Thank you. :)

Expand full comment

I inherited a bit of gullibility, m'self. Comes natural, as they say. I hate it when that happens (-;

Expand full comment

At what rate is gullibility taxed these days when passed as inheritance? I do hope at a fair rate. 🤔

Expand full comment

If only they'd known, Freedom Lover. They'd have happily dinged me for that, and the only other thing I inherited from my family — a doormat from the '80's that reads "Go Away." My godmother had a great sense of humor.

Expand full comment

Ask them, I'm not part of the blue check set.

Expand full comment

The only way it would be more ironic is if these things were being said by a bunch of so-called journalists at a place owned by Jeff Bezos.

Expand full comment

Because, if you've noticed, Elon has made Twitter a complete advertisement so that he can make money off his failed Doge crypto. When I saw that I was just like, FUCK NO!

Expand full comment

You'll believe whatever a billionaire says, eh? Sure, sure, his daddy's billions from blood emeralds didn't help whiny Elon at all.

Expand full comment

... actually, he used taxpayer funds and/or "incentives" like environmental protection, ESG, THE GREEN NEW DEAL, Space Exploration or whatever the scheme is to assist in the rise to the world's richest man. Along with the sale of PayPal. Like most bigillionairs, didn't use their own money to get filthy rich.👍 Another sell out(ter) of the American Dreamers.🍻

Expand full comment

No one does it single handed.

He is the head of the spear and deserves credit and wealth.

Expand full comment

Well that's debatable lol. I'm just answering the question they had. I'm kind of a fan of how the Tesla manufacturering and distribution is run, but not much of the rest of the story.

I haven't read your work yet, sir. Looks interesting and looking forward to.

.

Expand full comment

The creation of the manufacturing process for things like cars and rockets is what he himself claims is his specialty. Part of it is knowing the product intimately, which most CEOs lack. He knows his business top to bottom. He does know how those rocket engines work, despite claims to the contrary from his short sellers.

Expand full comment

You should do it too then.

Expand full comment

... I'm actually one of these types: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanist_Manifesto

Expand full comment

Thought so.

Expand full comment

Strawmen gonna straw, yo...

Expand full comment

So not helpful but thanks for coming out.

Expand full comment

... and now he's a *real boy*

Expand full comment

The world has gone off the fucking rails. That said, have a great week, dude.

Expand full comment
founding

Still waiting for the good in Good Friday.

Expand full comment

You probably won't find the Good in Good Friday on the internet.

Expand full comment

How about a seasonal joke?

What’s the difference between Jesus and a picture?

Takes one nail to hang a picture.

Expand full comment
founding

You're going to hell for that one. Or worse, Oakland.

Expand full comment

I don’t have an opinion on Heaven or Hell, as I know people in both places.

But Oakland? Fuck that. 😂

Expand full comment

You guys are missing the mark. Oakland's actually kind of cool in a sketchy sort of way. It's Stanford that contains the real locus of Hell.

Expand full comment

Yes, Stanford has definitely revealed themselves to be up the ass of the CIA, haven't they?

Expand full comment

Sketchy?

Sign me the fuck up.

Expand full comment

Bad “Joke”.

Expand full comment

What! It’s a classic.

Expand full comment

Super edgy brah.

Expand full comment

Sorry, I’m all out of circumcision jokes.

Expand full comment

Cringe. And people pay to read whatever it is you write? Do I have that right?

Expand full comment

How about the “pass” in Passover? The “ram” or “mad” in Ramadan?

I’ll get my coat…

Expand full comment

Well, as the movie says, its a long good Friday.

Expand full comment

“We are all individuals” bruh.

Expand full comment

😂😅🤣😆

Expand full comment

Enjoy vacation, but for what it is worth, I am a paid subscriber of Racket (and other Substack feeds) and treat Substack as an informative place for thoughtful, long-form content, and Twitter as a way to see a quick witty banter-type debate (I know, that’s a kind characterization of many Twitter threads). Don’t leave Twitter. Even if you can’t link to Substack, your more personal content and commentary are valuable there. Plus, maybe Elon will change his mind.

Expand full comment

I mostly use Twitter for links to stories I might otherwise not see.. and people as well. I can still link to my Wordpress blog and have great discussion unimpedef by character limits. But of course I don't make money from it.. so there's that.

Expand full comment

You are a great journalist and I never followed you or anybody else on Twitter. I’m with you right here on Substack and am a dedicated supporter.

Expand full comment

Seems foolish and short-sighted by Twitter

Expand full comment

This is all beyond stunning.

Expand full comment

Happy spring break, you earned it!! Glad you are staying on Substack.

Expand full comment

Strange bedfellows now estranged. So many connected interests. Tangled webs everywhere. Appreciate you Taibbi!

Expand full comment

Thanks for all your work. Standing up for what you believe in even when it comes at a cost is something we should all strive to do.

Expand full comment

Suits me. I found reading Twitter files on Twitter beyond inconvenient.

Expand full comment

Musk insisted that Matt post them there. It was his only condition.

Expand full comment

I know.

Its a dismal way of publishing that kind of information. If the rupture between Twitter and Substack that Matt reports here would lead to a new publishing arrangement between he and Musk, that would suit me, and some others by the look of it.

Expand full comment

It was, I agree. I can still read 10,000, even 20,000 words in one go. A twithead or a tiktocker though? "Impossible"

Expand full comment

Don’t have a twitter account and don’t plan to. Substack for me!

Expand full comment

Matt, enjoy the vacation. You, and your family, earned it.

Expand full comment

The Craziest Friday Ever...until Next Friday.

Expand full comment

Have an awesome vacation, man. 🤘🏻

Expand full comment

MEGA KUDOS for standing up for Substack against this inexplicably petulant sh*tf*ckery that I could only hope is a belated April Fools' joke, Matt 👏👏👏

If it isn't a joke, Elon just Streisand-Effected Substack Notes from oblivion into the stratosphere. That was dumb.

"posting my articles on Twitter instead of Substack"

How the eff am I supposed to post 10K-word-plus pieces on freaking Twitter like my Dissident Dialogue with CJ Hopkins (https://margaretannaalice.substack.com/p/dissident-dialogues-cj-hopkins) and the nearly book-length one currently underway with Meredith Miller?

Matt, I hope your stand will help bring Elon to his senses as he has just dealt a blow to free speech and independent journalism infinitely more lethal than anything exposed in the Twitter files.

Your move, Elon.

Expand full comment

I heard a rumour today that substack is being sold and when googling who's buying it- Elon is not opposed to Twitter buying it (from Dec 2022).

I was only recently allowed back on Twitter (permanently suspended in April 2022 for questioning the evidence for a pandemic caused by a virus) shared a few substacks for a week or two but came off it again because I was getting more posts from people I am not following than from people that I am, I know I am being led down a propaganda pathway.

Now not even allowed to share evidence written in full on here.

Crazy world indeed.

🐒

Expand full comment

He says it will give him, "control of the narrative layer".

But hey, he's just a genius billionaire who is trying to save humanity by moving us to Mars. Him and Dr. Doom.

People believe that.

Expand full comment