542 Comments
User's avatar
Tom Worster's avatar

Matt, since I don't use Twitter and probably others don't, maybe you can allow people here to vote too. Make four comments yourself, one for each title, and subscribers use the hearts to vote.

Daniel Bailey's avatar

Well said. I want nothing to do with an openly censorious company like Twitter.

My vote is for "The Deficit Myth"

Time Out with Tori's avatar

TY. I'm protecting my mental health like a newborn baby and closed all my social media accounts. Would love to be able to see the 4 books, please. And thank you.

Trevor Deke Bajus's avatar

+1 My life is much improved after I quit Twitter.

Kobe Yank-Jacobs's avatar

I recommend OpaVote so we can rank our choices and get a majority winner using ranked-choice voting: https://www.opavote.com

DC Reade's avatar

I don't Twitter either, but I'm okay with any of the choices.

Mike's avatar

I am not on twitter so I will vote here: The Culture of Narcissism

K.M.'s avatar

I’m listening to that right now on Audible. We should also add in Revolt of the Elites. How about we read all of Christopher Lashe and be done with it. The guy is timeless.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

I second this. Lasch is a must. I keep going back to "The Revolt of the Elites" for my #1 book, "The True and Only Heaven" and "The Culture of Narcissim" of his are earlier ideas on the same theme. Conservatives have taken over as the guardians of American democracy since the Elites became global citizens and have abandoned their civic obligations.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

And by "conservatives", I mean the regular citizens in your community who keep the small towns running. They are not necessarily political. They are family first people. I revere our town's water and sewer people and our snow removal is the envy of the Mid Hudson region. Lasch gave me the big picture of who in the town is window dressing which is important for the town to look prosperous, but who in the town is really essential. They can be full of themselves as they are also often the car dealers and lumberyard owners. But, by and large they keep things human.

Ieneke van Houten's avatar

Yes! The longer I live in my small rural town, the more I appreciate the core of blue collar families that has been here for generations. They may not use the proper pronouns but they know how to handle a chainsaw or a bulldozer and generally Get Things Done. My inner redneck has been growing at the expense of the inner semi hippie.

Erin Drake's avatar

Started Revolt a week ago, its excellent, the author is dead, and I believe it was his last work published in 1994-5.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

Here's Lasch's intro to "Revolt of the Elites" which was published before the book came out. Lasch actually died after he wrote the intro and before his book was published. This is the book in a nutshell. http://archive.harpers.org/1994/11/pdf/HarpersMagazine-1994-11-0001862.pdf

Chaco Cortes's avatar

Sounds awful. And it's dated, as in pre-Net, ergo no longer relevant. I prefer facts to opinions anyway. That's why I read a lot of history books. Lasch is allegedly a historian but this book looks to be more philosophical and heavily theoretical. Maybe he was a wannabe social engineer? You have to be an oligarch to play that role.

memento mori's avatar

Also not on twitter, but if I were, I would also vote for The Culture of Narcissism.

Roger's avatar

I don't know if there's an irony here, but I clicked my like button to see who gave me the previous like and it seems I inadvertently "liked" my remarks. That and the fact I chose "The Culture of Narcissism", seems rather appropriate.

L.A. Sanchez's avatar

That seems like good enough reason for me! I’ll switch my vote to this. Not that I think my vote is that important but then again maybe by writing this it will make people feel sorry for me and then tell me how important my vote is and 😂😂😂 Yaaay ME!

Montana1680's avatar

Amusing Ourselves to Death. Neil Postman

Michael F's avatar

May be the book I’ve referenced most over the last year. Eye-opening.

Kris Kaul's avatar

The People, No: A Brief History of Anti-populism, by Thomas Frank. Or his earlier book, 'Listen, Liberal'.

Ieneke van Houten's avatar

Yes! I just listened to that. We need our words back.

John Halle's avatar

The Limousine Liberal, Steve Fraser. Shows how the Democrats' new coalition between educated suburban professionals and inner city minorities recapitulates the old liberal Republican coalitions of the 1960s, e.g. John Lindsay in NYC, Lowell Weiker, Ella Grasso in CT, etc. The common theme in both: hatred for the working class and, more substantively, unions. And, of course, the hatred was/is mutual. Archie Bunker, we should remember, was a Democrat from Queens. And we can be certain he would vote Trump. Meathead, of course, is a Warrenite. (Maybe Edith would go for Bernie, though she'd would dare tell Archie).

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

Anything by David Graeber, but if I had to pick one it would be "Debt: The First 5000 Years." The 2nd of his would be "Bullshit Jobs". Free online stuff of his is "Revolutions in Reverse." 2nd: Sheldon Wolin's "Democracy Inc" Managed Democracy and the Specter of Inverted Totalitarianism". (Dense, but important). "Solidarity for Sale" by Fitch. Christopher Lasch's "The Revolt of the Elite"; Ray Oldenberg's "The Great Good Place".

Wally's avatar

Boo and mega boo on using Twitter! Down with tyranny!

Growling Puppy's avatar

I'm not going to make a book suggestion, but a discussion suggestion - Instead of feeding the disgusting monstrosity that is Twitter (so many comments state that they do not have an account there), why not utilize a forum specifically designed for book discussions like GoodReads or LibraryThing?

Psuke's avatar

Alas, GoodReads is owned by Amazon and those of us that avoid Amazon as we avoid Twitter (and apparently its not a small contingent) will be left out. LibraryThing I am less familiar with.

Growling Puppy's avatar

I mostly agree with you about GoodReads. The data provided to GoodReads is sold over and over. I use the site but there are many books that I do not add because it would draw unwanted attention to my account. I use it for book discussions on mainstream reading. I do not discuss politics there unless I am able to land safely in the middle.

OTOH, Amazon is putting zero work into the site (no more API) and no longer seems to care about it in general. In addition, the books that Matt lists are hardly controversial. They're not something that's going to get you blacklisted from anywhere. They're not even out of the mainstream groupthink.

LibraryThing is ... different. Go there and look for the post "What Makes LibraryThing LibraryThing?" It's a mess, but it's an endearing mess. It's the users that make it so. I have no fear of posting my thoughts about anything I read out of the mainstream.

Michael Feldman's avatar

How about about "War With Russisa"? Stephen F. Cohen

Rob Roy's avatar

Mike Feldman,

Excellent suggestion!

Rob Roy's avatar

Mike Feldman,

Excellent suggestion!

Liz M's avatar

I second The Revolt of the Elites by Lasch.

Kresge's avatar

What are the four suggestions? I am not on Twitter. Thanks.

Carol Scherer's avatar

Yes. Would like the four suggestions shared in email.

Wally's avatar

And to all of you with reading-deficit disorder, the time for proposing new titles has passed and Matt is asking you to vote on the four books he has selected.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

I'm not going to re-activate a Twitter account just to vote on this.

They can suck it.

Wally's avatar

I’ve been joking around on this comment section but in all seriousness, why are so people running to Twitter to vote? Doesn’t this crowd mostly decry the social media giants? Why not abstain from voting on Twitter and instead pressure Matt to use some other way of counting the vote? We have met the enemy and it is us.

Koshmarov's avatar

Three of those four titles are "The [Something] of [Something]." It's like a Middlebrow Concerned Citizen Title Generator.

Aidawedo's avatar

"reading-deficit disorder?" you sound like an a$$.

Last One's avatar

No, he/she is not. Matt’s twitter post is followed by a stream of replies suggesting other books to review. I guess it’s the nature of twitter, but still is hilarious.

Wally's avatar

Click on his Twitter link in the square box after his paragraph.

Jim Gottstein's avatar

The Zyprexa Papers, by me. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0578627264/lawprojectfor-20

The description is:

"On December 17, 2006, The New York Times began a series of front-page stories about documents obtained from Alaska lawyer Jim Gottstein, showing Eli Lilly had concealed that its top-selling drug caused diabetes and other life-shortening metabolic problems. The "Zyprexa Papers," as they came to be known, also showed Eli Lilly was illegally promoting the use of Zyprexa on children and the elderly, with particularly lethal effects. Although Mr. Gottstein believes he obtained the Zyprexa Papers legally, the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York in Brooklyn decided he had conspired to steal the documents, and Eli Lilly threatened Mr. Gottstein with criminal contempt charges. In The Zyprexa Papers, Mr. Gottstein gives a riveting first-hand account of what really happened, including new details about how a small group of psychiatric survivors spread the Zyprexa Papers on the Internet untraceably. All of this within a gripping, plain-language explanation of complex legal maneuvering and his battles on behalf of Bill Bigley, the psychiatric patient whose ordeal made possible the exposure of the Zyprexa Papers."

There is some relevance to today as it is a cautionary tale about believing drug company statements about their drugs or relying on the FDA's determination of safety and efficacy of drugs.

JoLeigh Bowden's avatar

Thank you Jim. My elderly mother was a victim of the Zyprexa scam when she was in hospital and it was killing her. This was around 2007 in Texas. My brother and I had to go to extreme measures to get the doctors to stop giving it to her, and she very nearly died before they took her off. She recovered rapidly thereafter. They teated us as interlopers with real disgust that we were trying to interfere in their prescriptions. The doctor-pharma brainwashing and payoffs were obvious. It was horrifying to be so powerless in the face of this wall of terror, at least that is what it felt like.

Jim Gottstein's avatar

I am glad you managed to get your mother off Zyprexa. A number of people have told me their elderly parent improved greatly after being taken off Zyprexa. Others have told me they saw the deterioration and when their parent died, the doctor said, "your parent was old." There is now a black box warning on Zyprexa's label that it doubles mortality in the elderly. I think that was at least partially as a result of the documents I released which my book, The Zyprexa Papers, is about.

Jim Gottstein's avatar

Hi Joyceleigh,

I hope you read the book and let me (& Matt) what you think.

Chui's avatar

The Science of Storytelling: Why Stories Make Us Human and How to Tell Them Better; Will Storr; ISBN: 9781683358183

My take on this is that persistent notion that until we understand how narratives work, the control they exert both on us and those we interact with, we will forever be screaming at the sky wondering why things keep getting worse.

Synopsis:

The compelling, groundbreaking guide to creative writing that reveals how the brain responds to storytelling

Stories shape who we are. They drive us to act out our dreams and ambitions and mold our beliefs. Storytelling is an essential part of what makes us human. So, how do master storytellers compel us? In The Science of Storytelling, award-winning writer and acclaimed teacher of creative writing Will Storr applies dazzling psychological research and cutting-edge neuroscience to our myths and archetypes to show how we can write better stories, revealing, among other things, how storytellers—and also our brains—create worlds by being attuned to moments of unexpected change.

SH's avatar

I got a message that you replied to my "dunno" reply, but I can't find it here in this thread, sorry - if it shows up, I'll respond :)

Chui's avatar

It posted twice and when I deleted one, it deleted both.

SH's avatar

I dunno, seems to me the best way to get out the importance of stories is to tell one that resonates - Crow and Weasel by Barry Lopez, who just died :(

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 28, 2020
Comment deleted
Catherine's avatar

Well, I was just concerned that the site could be used to promote books for sale in a dishonest way. It occurred to me. Just generally.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 28, 2020
Comment deleted
Chui's avatar

Thanks. A relatively new discovery for me. Still working my way through the Storr ecosystem.

mcelroyj's avatar

Is there a way to see this without social media (twitter)? Will never in a million years join Twitter, but I would read a book and discuss it with a group online.

Phil C's avatar

Well, there's always Mastodon...

mcelroyj's avatar

I like Dr. Kelton's work, having read some pieces on MMT --- so I'd vote for the Tyranny of Merit

mcelroyj's avatar

I mean --- more interested in Sandel's work here

Open House's avatar

I cannot stress enough how Christopher Lasch is a timely read for our times, despite the fact that he died 25 years ago. Also, Matthew Crawford's' Why We Drive, Toward a Philosophy of the Open Road, Fabian Scheidler, The End of the Megamachine, A Brief History of a Failing Civilization (a great re-actualization on Lewis Mumford's The Myth of the Machine ) and Thomas Frank's The Road to Oblivion.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

Yes! An aristocrat imprisoned in a grand hotel during the early Soviet days has working class people pretty much his only friends. I'm part way through. Have had trouble reading during the pandemic. My attention span is shot.

Gordon Freeman's avatar

WTF?? All four of those books cover the same general material (huge social problems traceable to the elite classes). That stuff has been covered to death. Why not pick one title that covers that issue, and three others that are on completely separate subjects?

tom mitchell's avatar

Why are any of these more relevant than "The Hunchback of Notre Dame" or "The Sound and the Fury" ? The human condition and human nature are still the same

Trollificus's avatar

I would agree, and yet, in this very thread, a fellow of apparently high self-regard dismissed Lasch (and presumably, contemporaries) as "irrelevant" because he wrote in that pointless "pre-Net" era. What to do about such engrained presentism?

tom mitchell's avatar

Intriguing question. Live in the moment, maybe? Reach into our zen zones ? If the kingdom can be lost because of the lack of a nail in a horseshoe, where does the present and its future possibilities intersect with the past and its legacies? I think of Sherlock Holmes writing koans in beautiful calligraphy.

Roger's avatar

I'm not on Twitter as well, my vote goes to The Culture of Narcissism.

Pluto's avatar

"Through a Glass Darkly: The U.S. Holocaust in Central America" - written by Thomas R. Melville, As recounted by Ronald William Hennessy of events from the 1960s.

On the back cover, (FR) Daniel Berrigan, S.J. -

"'Through a Glass Darkly' is a meticulous, passionate, at times humorous, at all times insightful chronicle of mass murder in Guatemala and El Salvador. At long last, the truth is out. And this extraordinary document is completed, even as the imperial bones of Ronald Reagan are provided with insufferably banal splendor, through Washington avenues, on to the National Cathedral (sic). There, ironies collide as G.W. Bush mounts the same pulpit whence more than a year ago, he initiated the criminal war against Afghanistan and Iraq. Now the mad logic continues, a criminal president eulogizes the architect of mass murder in Central America. Still, in this book, something else, something infinitely precious and rare: the truth."

... and from Stephen Kinzer -

"Too few Americans know about the tragedy that has enveloped Guatemala for decades and about America's role in that tragedy. 'Through a Glass Darkly' tells the story in a way that is passionate and deeply moving but also detailed, factual, and informative. Readers will never again think of Guatemala --or the United States--in the same way".

Chaco Cortes's avatar

BTW, Kinzer is a prolific author who writes well. A few faves for a better understanding of 20th century history and how we got here are "Poisoner in Chief" (Sidney Gottlieb), "The Brothers" (as in Dulles) and "All the Shah's Men."

You can go deeper with books by Tim Weiner. For instance "Legacy of Ashes" and "Enemies: A History of the FBI" are essential.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

“Overthrow” for an overview. Kinzer is a great great writer! a former NY Times international. correspondent. And I second “Legacy of Ashes”.

Koshmarov's avatar

Mark Riebling's "Wedge: The Secret War Between the FBI and CIA" is good too

Genevieve Charbin Cerf's avatar

I spend a lot of time in Germany. To this day, they find it too painful to talk of WWII and the holocaust. We will find it just as hard to talk about this book, in particular, since the last administration has been so cruel to the survivors of this mass murder, fighting to come to the US as a last desperate measure to find a life for their families.

Pluto's avatar

Thank you for your thoughtful comment. Unfortunately, this book is not widely read and the conditions it records are little known and unlikely to be disseminated among the US public in a meaningful way--

Nigel Dessau's avatar

Hate the last part of the title because it derails people but Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960-2010 by Charles Murry

Trollificus's avatar

The last bit, "by Charles Murray" gets some people's cancellin' glands workin' too.

KeKe's avatar

I agree with this suggestion.

tom mitchell's avatar

None of the above ! We need books that light up the "little grey cells." These are intellectually extremely weak choices, based on one-trick-pony solutions to complex processes that developed malignancies over time. Lasch is the only one of the four authors who attempts some more comprehensive understanding. These choices advocate emotional lunges to replace common sense. Narcissism is at least a factor in evolution, a core malignancy. Without merit, we get Tammany tyranny or Athenian-style mob rule. Inequality is always present in every system of education or government. And deficits occur when a very few can extract excess social wealth and fob the cost onto everybody else -- everybody else owes the interest payments, which can become huge as a % of national production. We don't need a "book club" for these thoughts. Aristotle addressed most of them pretty adequately in his "Politics." The closest this list comes to a serious thought process is trying to answer the question: "How can we have a good society for all citizens and also have Picasso, Mozart, and Pasteur ? "

Phil C's avatar

Appreciate the Poirot reference but, given that you made it, I posit that your little grey cells *will* light up if/when you read "The Deficit Myth," the table of contents alone of which debunks the baseless charge that its ideas constitute a simplistic solution to "complex processes that developed malignancies over time." In the first place, said malignancies did not merely "develop" - they have been cultivated. This book introduces the reader to those issues and proposed solutions to them in layperson's language, with remarkable aplomb and preternatural tact.

tom mitchell's avatar

You are right that Kelton makes a fair effort to sift the relevant from the misguided notions. Neither our recent-past policy-makers mor Kelton, however, appreciates

tom mitchell's avatar

some of the nuances ignored in the measures to which they pay such close attention. No one has clearly explained why $4 Trillion added to US bank reserves in 2009-11 resulted in almost zero monetary stimulus. To me, the answer is obvious -- the actual money supply is not be found in reserves supplied by the Fed, but in loans outstanding to domestic borrowers. Loan growth in 2009-12 barely increased at all -- especially when commercial paper and other traditional sources of credit are taken in to account. The quarterly Survey of Senior Bank Loan Officers showed showed 19 -- 19! -- consecutive tightenings in loan standards from 3Q 2007 to 2Q 2012. That means the same borrowers were squeezed consecutively at least 4 times - on an annual basis -- in that period. Talk about pushing on a string! The Propensity to Lend fell off a high, steep cliff -- the Fed was powerless to create loan supply -- which is what increases money used in the real economy. Similarly, Kelton talks about the poor track record of the unemployment - inflation trade-off model. But just as with loan supply, loan demand is driven by a Propensity to Borrow. Anecdotal evidence indicates the Great Recession dramatically reduced the small-business and consumer appetites for money to put to use. Even now, we hear people wondering why the $1,200 or $600 checks are not being spent, helping to grow the economy. How can they wonder? Do they not know at all what our lives are like? After you've had your lines of credit cut four times in three years by the same lender, do they think suddenly you are optimistic about drawing down the skimpy stub of your former spending power still available ? Kelton is the only other person I've read who uses the right number for 2007-09, that homeowners lost $8 Trillion, but even she misses that it was a 2005-12 phenomenon, not 2007-09. But to rely on any model predicting inflation or unemployment without recognizing the huge swings in Propensity to Lend and Propensity to Borrow that are the canaries in the money mines, are still far too crude and inattentive, in my opinion.

tom mitchell's avatar

Possibly the simplest point is: economists believe numbers tell a story. Certainly the population of dogs in Germany reported for 1921 - 25 paints a

grim picture. But Sentiment -- as economists use the term -- drives both business and consumer behavior in ways the economists cannot measure and rarely imagine. If your home's value is increasing 5% per year, maybe you will put in a deck or replace a shower much quicker than if you just saw its value drop (50%). Maybe if you hadn't been raked over the coals about the loans you made to people solidly employed in good jobs in 2003-07, you would be optimistic about lending to them today. There's nothing trivial about certain decision forces that cannot be measured accurately from one decade to another, And all that was true before the Pandemic. I admire Stephanie Kelton for her correct belief that a lot more can be done. But we are dealing with a Science that is not just Dismal. It;s also murderous.

memento mori's avatar

Not on Twitter, now or ever, so I guess I am not registered to vote.

Certex's avatar

The four poll choices are racist against books whose titles do not start with the word 'The.' Disgusting.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S9WWz95ripA&ab_channel=NapalmRecords

Aidawedo's avatar

this is great how Matt's readers take real issues like racism so seriously

L.A. Sanchez's avatar

I won’t speak for others but I take ACTUAL racism seriously. “I don’t like that,” or “that wasn’t funny to me,” does not = racism. If it did no one would ever speak to anyone unless it was to tell them how racist they are

DC Reade's avatar

you have to understand the nature of the confusion we're mired in; that retort has been used sarcastically for so long that it's now trite.

Also, even obvious Internet sarcasm is liable to being misunderstood.

But the main problem is that you kicked things off with a non sequitur, just as an excuse to employ the word "racist" sarcastically. And while I don't usually autopsy jokes because it takes the funny out of them, in this case there was nothing to lose. That wasn't humor; it was bait. Well, you caught someone. Now what?

Certex's avatar

I take racism seriously, obviously. But, like everydamnedbody else, I have had so much pain and horror and stress with this year and its madness (ever worked at a covid testing centre? I have. Talk aboot going into the absolute eye of a pandemic storm) I just have to react with humour after a certain point. Only thing that keeps me sane. Well, that and Pornhub, and bath salts, and scratch cards, and chocolate, and beer, and...eh...well, that thing is still illegal, so...no comment. And stuff like the video linked to below helps too, I suppose. Have a laugh on me. Well, on the band, but, well, you know what I mean. Slainte! Happy Hogmanay (look it up) from Scotland! Worship Odin! :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S9WWz95ripA&ab_channel=NapalmRecords

Chaco Cortes's avatar

OMG! Master of IKEA?! Thanks, I needed that.

Certex's avatar

Welcome. My brother introduced me to the band a couple of days ago. I just listened to an album of theirs for the first time. One of the funniest and weirdest bands I have ever heard in my life. Magic! Was going to say "Racist against non-funny bands," but some folk round here have no sense of humour. :)

Ph8drus's avatar

If you read only to affirm your take on "real issues" you are missing out and missing the point. Further, your insistence on serious has badly damaged your sense of humor.

Certex's avatar

Whimper whine whinge. T'was but a bit of folly verbiage to do with the fact that all four books start with the word 'The.' In other words, it was a...

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/joke

And, more pertinently...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=th4Czv1j3F8&list=RDth4Czv1j3F8&start_radio=1&ab_channel=NapalmRecords

L.A. Sanchez's avatar

Mascot just can’t leave it. He/she loves to create conflict. Thanks for your original post. And thanks for calling me a racist and for letting me bait you

Certex's avatar

Not touching any low-hanging 'bait' joke fruit. :)

DC Reade's avatar

and the labeling of "racist" was necessary to the jest, because...

Certex's avatar

Cos I felt like it. You being racist to me? Laughing. How can you be racist against a book title? It was absurdist humour, meaningless, abstract. Now go away.

Wally's avatar

Ahem, click on his Twitter link above. But down with using Twitter!

SH's avatar

Well, if one doesn't do Twitter - why can't the list be posted here?

Wally's avatar

I dunno. Matt’s post is not the model of clarity. Probably asked an assistant to post this.

SH's avatar

The more I think about it, it occurs to me that this particular thread itself might be a good springboard for a discussion that encompasses many of the ideas expressed in various books that are proposed - given that apparently a goodly number of Matt's readers eschew Twitter, FB, etc. as a means of "communicating", why are the books to be chosen listed on Twitter? If indeed "the medium is the message", what "message" does using a medium like Twitter, which privileges sound bites and #hash tags over any nuanced discussion of ideas, convey?

Just a thought, there's more, but, it seems to me, it's a start ....

Ieneke van Houten's avatar

Neither do I. Please repeat somewhere.

Rob Roy's avatar

Yes. Will someone just list them? I would also add any book by Max Blumenthal.

Wally's avatar

I did above, or is it below? Anyway, an hour ago.

T.'s avatar

The Revolt of the Elites by Christopher Lasch.

Roger's avatar

"CIA as Organized Crime" by Valentine

Roger's avatar

Valentine was given complete access to CIA agents by Wm. Colby who thought he was on their side. Valentine's father was an agent. His previous book was about the Phoenix program in Vietnam. Basically the Phoenix program was rolled out worldwide by the CIA. The USA Fusion centers which bring all the police and National Security State actors to work together, as well as the militarization of the police is fruit of that program.

Athena1's avatar

Well that's not terrifying at all.

Roger's avatar

For those who dont know, the Phoenix program was an extra-judicial program of surveillance, assassination and torture directed against anyone not actively supporting the USA's regime in Vietnam.

Harrie's avatar

Agreed: Culture of Narcissism by Christopher Lasch. It’s foundational and sets up many of the other suggestions. A great ‘same page’ from which to begin this project — not to mention, dare I say? — this year?

Susan Russell's avatar

What would be nice is if, whatever it is, it wasn't written by someone with an a agenda.

Susan Russell's avatar

I suppose everything is to a certain extent and especially now, but some of these titles made me want to wrap a warm towel around my head.

Marvinmots's avatar

I recommend a book called "Take Back The Power! : Sustainable Energy and Freedom are Within Your Grasp" at Amazon.com

NancyD's avatar

ThriftBooks AbeBooks GoodWillBooks for used books!

Thorsten Debs's avatar

Powell's in Portland is a union shop.

LH Fry's avatar

Also Better World Books. They also have depository bins all over the country in which you can leave books you don’t want. They ship them to places in the world that need books - even textbooks.

Damian's avatar

And their postage is free. Even to Australia.

Guy W Meyer Jr.'s avatar

Abe Books sadly is a division of Amazon designed to make you think you have found an independent bookseller.

L.A. Sanchez's avatar

Thriftbooks and my local book bargain bin also sometimes have a lucky find at library sales.

Trollificus's avatar

A LOT of lucky finds at library sales! They sell over-donated (popular) and under-accessed (often very good) books at the sales at our central library, for next to nothing. $20 will get me more than I can carry out, and more than I can read before the next sale.

Alan Morse's avatar

Is Wordery.com clean? (I know Book Depository is Amazon.) There's indiebound too.

M Biz's avatar

Abe books is owned by Amazon.

Jim Trageser's avatar

AbeBooks now owned by Amazon - sorry!

Aidawedo's avatar

Never. How elite of you. Amazon saved our asses over here during Covid.

Rob Roy's avatar

Jeff Bezos made 13bn in ONE day. He could give every American $3000 and still have as many riches he had before the pandemic. No one has to use Amazon for anything! And shouldn't!

Nine's avatar

Jeff Bezos ex-wife MacKenzie Scott gave more than $4 billion to charity. She donated to 384 organizations across the U.S. and Puerto Rico and some of that money came here to Vermont. Our Foodbank got $9 million. That's pretty amazing.

James W Dunlap's avatar

13bn in one day would be 4,745bn in a year, which is about 23% of the US's GDP. And Bezo's net worth is estimated at 185bn.

$3000 for every American is $1,000,000,000,000 ($1 trillion), about 6 times his net worth. Try $200 per American.

So 13bn is a reasonable figure for his annual earnings, but 2-3 orders of magnitude too high for daily.

Mind you I'm not saying he's not rich. But no need to add gratuitous zeros. And he did something to earn it by creating a valuable, useful infrastructure.

Roman's avatar

These are fake money. They cannot be converted to anything useful. If he sold all his shares he’d get a small fraction of the current nominal value.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 28, 2020
Comment deleted
Rob Roy's avatar

Jeff Bezos made 13bn in ONE day. He could give every American $3000 and still have as many riches he had before the pandemic. No one has to use Amazon for anything! And shouldn't!

stealthmouse's avatar

I hate to break it to you, but that's $900 billion dollars. It's not good to accept sound bites, especially those that come from journalists (most journalists are completely inept at math).

Stxbuck's avatar

He also lost 7bn in a week this year. Talk about foundations made of sand if you think the federal government can go full candyman in seizing Bezos wealth for leftist edification.

Kateinhi's avatar

Learn how to shop local. THAT’s what’s going to save your ass.

SH's avatar

And fried a lot of others ...

E.T.'s avatar

The fact is it's a capitalist system; Jeff Bezos knows how to compete in this system. I cannot blame him for operating his business better than his competition. I prefer Amazon not be an Oligopoly as it is - but unless America forms a new system of commerce, here we are.

Jeff DeLisle's avatar

Linda, charity begins at home. This is America! Be generous and share your wealth with those less fortunate. Spend your money wherever you like but please let me spend my money including where to direct my charity, as I choose.

Gail Jonas's avatar

See https://popularresistance.org/amazon-posted-job-to-monitor-employees-efforts-to-unionize/; https://edition.cnn.com/2020/09/10/business/amazonbasics-electronics-fire-safety-invs/index.html;https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/oct/02/almost-20000-amazon-workers-in-us-test-positive-for-covid-19;https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/08/opinion/amazon-antitrust.html?campaign_id=39&emc=edit_ty_20201009&instance_id=22979&nl=opinion-today&regi_id=17409781&segment_id=40414&te=1&user_id=789f1698844dc1d874e6d8c07b0c93b5;https://popularresistance.org/amazon-expects-employees-to-operate-like-fast-moving-machines/;https://www.seattletimes.com/business/because-of-injury-claims-state-wants-amazons-automated-warehouses-to-pay-higher-workers-comp-premiums-than-meatpacking-or-logging-operations/?utm_source=marketingcloud&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=TSA_102120175703+Because+of+injury+claims%2c+Washington+wants+Amazon+warehouses+to+pay+higher+workers%e2%80%99_10_21_2020&utm_term=Former%20Subscriber;https://www.seattletimes.com/business/because-of-injury-claims-state-wants-amazons-automated-warehouses-to-pay-higher-workers-comp-premiums-than-meatpacking-or-logging-operations/?utm_source=marketingcloud&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=TSA_102120175703+Because+of+injury+claims%2c+Washington+wants+Amazon+warehouses+to+pay+higher+workers%e2%80%99_10_21_2020&utm_term=Former%20Subscriber;https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/nov/26/amazon-and-apple-not-playing-their-part-in-tackling-electronic-waste;https://calmatters.org/california-divide/2020/12/becerra-amazon-california-covid-19-investigation/?campaign_id=49&emc=edit_ca_20201216&instance_id=25099&nl=california-today&regi_id=17409781&segment_id=47096&te=1&user_id=789f1698844dc1d874e6d8c07b0c93b5.

Why in the world would I support a business like this because it's

convenient for me but bad for so many others?

Gail Jonas's avatar

Thanks. I knew about TinyURL but didn't think to use it. Here's another Amazon article, TinyURLed: https://tinyurl.com/ybfqnq7c.

MaryMargaret Flynn's avatar

I choose "The Deficit Myth". thank you mary margaret flynn

Ryan Lee's avatar

Sounds like some high quality entertainment

User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 29, 2020
Comment removed
User's avatar
Comment removed
Dec 29, 2020
Comment removed
L.A. Sanchez's avatar

A while ago I heard a speaker say that “race” is a political idea. Obviously there are different skin colors which pols would like to take credit for creating but I’m interested in your opinion of race as a “category” for political purposes? Surely it’s useful when pandering for votes and power but in the larger sense when? was post Civil War when this became the standard political fare? I thought citizens of all races seemed to be moving closer to a social equivalence until the 90s(?). At what point did the regression begin? Were we making progress or was my perception more fairy tale than reality?

Lucas Corso's avatar

Cool. I suggested only two books, and both made the final 4. “The Deficit Myth” and “The Tyranny of Merit.” Somehow I feel validated.

Tim Schooley's avatar

Is the winning selection going to have future editions published with a "Matt Taibbi Book Club Selection!" medallion on the cover? No reason for Oprah to have all the fun.

Ed Weinberg's avatar

I get a lot of value out of your read on things Matt, and this sounds like a great way to further the scope of TK. One suggestion - instead of just criticism of the parts of the eventual book that you disagree with, can you use the problems it brings up as a jumping off point for your own musings? I’ve noticed how a few of the authors seem to point toward a socialist panacea for the big and real problems they bring up, and your experience in what collectivism can turn into seems helpful here for expanding that conversation in pragmatic terms.

VoteGreenOrDontComplain2Me's avatar

Bullshit Jobs or Debt by David Graeber. We need to rethink and reimagine the purpose of work, who does it and how it gets done.

D Burlin's avatar

I vote for 1) Culture of Narcissism and 2) Tyranny of Merit. Not in the same vein as the suggested for, but on your own, highly recommend Last Stands: Why Men Fight When All is Lost by Michael Walsh. I'm reading it now and it is fascinating.

Ph8drus's avatar

Maybe for future reviews, something a little more contrarian could be fun. Rather than approaching a collection of reviews as "books someone loves or was told to love," more of a "books someone despises or was told to despise." Something like a, "Why Burn This Book?" review. Take a look at books which have triggered a "burn that!" response. Books landing on a list for cultural/political reasons and billed as bad for you. Candide, Frankenstein, The Color Purple, To Kill a Mocking Bird, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, A Clockwork Orange, Of Mice and Men, One Flew Over the Cuckoo Nest, The Jungle, and on and on.

Wally's avatar

I like this post. Let’s add to it and make it a Top post.

My suggestions are Das Kapital, the Koran, and Eat, Pray, Love.

Cowgirlcontrarian's avatar

Anything on the NY Times Non-Fiction Best Seller list

Captain Dicky's avatar

Where to vote on these books? And what are the four book to choose from?

Peter Milovanovic's avatar

I'm reading Vijay Prashad's Washington Bullets which is a history of US imperialism. You can hear him talk with Paul Jay on the Analysis News from earlier this month.

Tom Worster's avatar

I'm not on Twitter. My vote:

The Cult of Smart

Dunno anything about it but I like the title. Makes me think of Rick Perlstein's superb article in The Baffler a few years ago "Outsmarted".

https://thebaffler.com/salvos/outsmarted-perlstein