1639 Comments
User's avatar
HeftyMatty's avatar

Woke worship!

I am in my mid-50s and over the last year, my late-20s daughter has moved back into our house after 4 years at an East Coast private university working on a Doctoral Degree, because of Covid.

This is her daily woke worship ritual:

1. Read, remember or discover something that someone said, did or thought (usually from some subreddit or another or some memory of how her mother or me treated her or one of her siblings).

2. Come upstairs from her basement bedroom, fuming.

3. Find her mother or me, or both.

4. Angrily describe the injustice to us.

5. Call the perpetrator (usually us or some other family member) some name: bigot, homophobe, racist, etc.

6. Be outraged until she discovers some other thing that upsets her.

Repeat for infinity.

There is no joy or humor in her life. But she has worshiped this way in our house for months. It is her ritual. Of course, nothing ever changes because that's not the point. The point is to be OUTRAGED.

I think this is what DeAngelo is doing. And everyone of her ilk. Don't resolve anything. Don't make progress. BE OUTRAGED!

Hank Stillwell's avatar

Tell her she should move out of your basement because she lives on what used to be indigenous land.

Matt Taibbi's avatar

DiAngelo notes she lives on indigenous land in her book

Certex's avatar

I would say more that she lives - and writes - on disingenuous land.

Bazz's avatar

Give it all back to the dinosaurs

Spartacus's avatar

Indeed. But did she give her property back to the natives along with all of her money?

publius_x's avatar

If she does live on "indigenous land," can she point to the excavation site near her house where prehistoric fossils were found, akin to the Lucy site in Ethiopia?

The Bearded One's avatar

Helpful note for her: All land is indigenous land - be it in Europe, Asia or the Americas. I guess she could move to Antarctica -maybe?

Certex's avatar

You damned...Polar bearist...you! White bear fragility!

Polly Frost's avatar

Maybe DiAngelo should build a casino and then write about how the indigenous people are being oppressed by lending their tribal names to casinos.

Sevender's avatar

Genius. Every time you win, a BIPOC person lectures you on white privilege and keeps your winnings.

When you get tired of gambling without reward, you can buy tickets to the entertainment shows. You can't actually see anything, you just buy the tickets.

For dinner, you can go to the all-they-can-eat buffet.

Of course, the whole complex is completely nonsmoking, for whites.

publius_x's avatar

Heads, she wins; Tails, you lose.

Gutterdandy's avatar

She might move to Canada and write about Native Canadians next....

Bob Robertini's avatar

Of course she does. I wonder if she is this much of a cartoon in her actual personal life. Yikes.

Nanthew Shandridan's avatar

She has skillfully made herself unparody-able because there is no room left to exaggerate.

Vida Galore's avatar

She is. Have you watched the Evergreen College fiasco documentary on Brett Weinstein's dismissal? She has a cameo and it's quite something.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Does corporate media try to distract Americans with manufactured outrage while their lobbyists tell congress how to vote and the economic issues that are destroying Americans lives to profit only the rich?

Where does DiAngelo and those in the media that talk about her fit into that equation?

Peter Schaeffer's avatar

As Apple (and many other companies) has shown, if you wave a rainbow flag you can get away with anything. Biggest corporate tax evader on the planet? Check. Labor abuses including suicide nets? Check. Firing problematic employees (AGM) for crimethink? Check. Massively supporting Dr. Dre ('Bitches ain't shit, but hoes and tricks')? Check. Exploiting slave labor (Uighurs) while valiantly defending personal privacy? Check. Complete immunity from criticism by the likes of Robin DiAngelo? Check.

The obvious villain here is 'wokeness' that put identity politics ahead of all other issues.

Futuristic Bow Wow's avatar

Somebody’s obsessing on corporate media this fine morning. Have a beer, Piketty. Life’s too short...

Peter Schaeffer's avatar

Historically, the traditional left has been hostile towards large (and small) corporations. However, the rise of 'wokeness' has put an end to all that. Just profess to believe in 'wokeness' and all is forgiven. At least the Catholic Church charged real money for indulgences. Now just saluting the rainbow flag (or hiring Robin DiAngelo) will suffice.

Bob Robertini's avatar

The corporate media does whatever it takes to make money. Period. The media is not our friends. Journalists are not our friends. The media would throw their own grandmothers under a bus to make a buck. But that's it. All that other stuff is just posturing. If the corporate media would make more money by supporting really nice things, they would. But the money is made on the right and left sides of the media promoting conflict and tribalism. They don't give a crap about "profiting only the rich", they only care about making money for themselves.

Thom's avatar

Well Matt, at least she is pitching her screed to her Indigenous patronage.(;-})

As Usual,

EA

shieldmaidenpdx's avatar

THAT is fucking hilarious! Well put.

Polly Frost's avatar

Don't laugh! As we type my local Chumash casino is stealing our ideas. “White Fragility” the musical. “White Fragility: An Evening of Pop Song Hits by Old White Men Who Hopelessly Tried to Sound Non-White.”

KLS's avatar

Start with “Jive Talkin”…

Jason Matte's avatar

The biggest favour you could do for her is to set her free. That will reorder her priorities. You know, paying for shelter, food, transportation etc. Allowing this simply enables it.

Ann S.'s avatar

I'd agree. Facing adult responsibilities and hardships has a wonderful tendency to bring perspective and clarity.

elaine's avatar

It can also bring decent manners. That young scholar sounds like a tyrant.

publius_x's avatar

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LSGl3d4KOMk

(completely unrelated on the social justice frontier... one of the first examples of the singular "them")

Koshmarov's avatar

The wild thing about this video is that it's green-screened in front of a drum set and amps in somebody's library. MTV had money to burn in the '80s. Where is rtj when we need her?

Another from this subgenre: https://youtu.be/ejorQVy3m8E

rtj's avatar

You rang? Oh, i have to dig up some social justice videos? Ok then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXAlfh6QKQs

mkp's avatar

They bands were producing those videos. Only a few were realy good.

sasinsea's avatar

The production values on this puppy are SKY HIGH.

Jason Matte's avatar

It's exactly how I look on my Teams/Zoom meetings when the fake background is enabled. Nice to see how far technology has come.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Jason - Setting her free because you are angry that she does not believe a set of lies you happen to believe is not assured of enabling her to "reorder her priorities". What is is assured of doing is creating a deeper rift between father and daughter.

Maybe she should be on her own and maybe she should not. Economic conditions have forced increasing numbers of 20 something educated children home with their parents. That is neither of their faults. But He does not give the evidence to answer that one way or the other. All he gives us evidence of is that BOTH and and his daughter are delusional because of the media they consume.

I don't think anyone can give him good advice based on his version of things. How about you?

Jayhawk's avatar

Maybe we should all stop sending these indoctrination machines that pose as Colleges and Universities $50K per year to ruin our kids.

Skeptic's avatar

Easier said than done. It's a huge issue.

I've got a young teen and tween who are both smart and academically oriented. Not everybody can go to Hillsdale, and they don't offer engineering. I would certainly be as proud of them if they wanted to go into the trades instead of going to university, but I don't think that's going to be a fit for either of them.

I'm hoping we'll see some entrepreneurship and creative destruction in the university sector. There are many parents who want better alternatives.

MountainCarp's avatar

Trade school is the best route to competence and entrepreneurship at the moment.

Rob Roy's avatar

Move to Finland...best education in the world and it's free.

Commentorinchief's avatar

No it’s not, LOL. You simply pay for it in significantly higher taxes. Nothing in life is free. At least nothing worth buying.

Lightwing's avatar

Yes. I have been hoping this as well.

Jonathan's avatar

$200k or more to get a credential, to get a shot at a top flight career. What a racket.

I've been holding out hope the system would break down before my kids graduate high school, but I'm running out of time.

Alien On Earth's avatar

Deep truth! Let them Woke on their own dime...

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Most WOKE people are living on their own dime. Most Anti Woke people are living on their own dime.

What you are saying is that if your child does not agree with the set of LIES you beleive in then you should not support then right in the middle of a pandemic when more 20 somethings than ever are being forced to live at home.

Got it.

FNR's avatar

I figured out late, maybe less than 10 years ago, that no one hates progress more than progressives.

Russel's avatar

Pre-enlightenment feudalists

Sevender's avatar

Well, the whole book Matt is reviewing is pretty explicitly that.

Chris Long's avatar

I'm in my mid to late 50's and have children ranging in age from 30 to 18. Only 2 at home at this stage. I commend you patience. I have been known to suggest to my own children that if living with their parents is a hardship, they should move out quickly to lessen their own pain!!

Charles Clemens's avatar

It was 1972. I was 21 and just out of the Army. My father discovered my pipe and my weed and reminded me that it was his home and I was no longer a welcome guest. It was the best thing that ever happened to both of us.

Nobody's avatar

I've noticed the same thing about people addicted to watching the news. I don't know if it's an adrenaline rush or something else, but there seems to be a psychological response to outrage that some people find intoxicating.

I'm curious, what degree is she studying for down in that basement?

Jonathan's avatar

"The Righteous Mind" by Jonathan Haidt offers an excellent explanation of moral outrage.

Jennifer's avatar

And "Hate Inc." by Matt Taibbi details the media's exploitation thereof. ;D

Chuck Pezeshki's avatar

That book is a VERY mixed bag, though it is basically universally praised. If you're interested in a more evolved analysis (I talk directly about Haidt) you can read this: https://empathy.guru/2019/02/21/creating-a-we-for-an-evolving-world-empathetic-leadership-book-refactor-and-the-first-of-two-introductory-posts/

Rick Abrams's avatar

When people hear something which triggers their emotions, they what more of it.

Ann S.'s avatar

Anger and fear make people more malleable, and therefore more easily controlled. It's most effective when both are induced, but in a pinch, either one will do.

Phil's avatar

I assume you paid for her entire 4-year ride at the East Coast private university where she failed to attain her Ph.D.? Wow, you're in hell.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Phil - So using your way of thinking you pay for your child's education they are then required to hold your same view of the world regarless of how moronic your view may be. Got it!

Another reason College should be funded by the government,

Phil's avatar

"So using your way of thinking you pay for your child's education they are then required to hold your same view of the world regarless (sic) of how moronic your view may be."

You could not be more wrong even if you tired twice as hard to fail as you already are.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Phil - Last time i checked paying for your kids COLLEGE does not make your political ideas CORRECT.... No more than getting your PHD makes your political ideas correct.

They BOTH sound like fools who have let corporate media misinform them both so much they are not divided. And that is the goal of corporate media. TO divide. Matt's book HATE INC.... is all about this.

This guy is a victim himself as is his daughter. Maybe he should clean up his own act and start being an ADULT before blasting his kid.

FNR's avatar

LMAO!!! do you use a pole vault to jump to these cockamamie conclusions?

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

FNR - It is called being an adult not a child parent. Being just as MISINFORMED as his daughter and then angry at her is childish parenting.

It is called being an ADULT... He needs to let it go and soon she will to. If he is going put and lash out because she has not fallen for the bullshit right wing lies he has all he is doing is showing he is still a child in my view. Grow the F up and get over it.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Sadly, she is connected to the Social Umbilicus and being fed pure poison by algorithms which detect, predict and even direct her emotions for max-level advertising. It's evil, I tell you... but what can anyone do?

You can't MAKE an addict quit -they have to want to do it first and foremost.

We have an entire world full of people staring at screens and being manipulated 24/7.

What's the worst that could happen?

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Scott - "we have an entire world full of people staring at screens and being manipulated..."

Sadly you are one of them, not?

Thom's avatar

Re: Hefty Matty

Your fatherly anecdote "Woke Worship" is quite probably the most definitive, and insightful, description of this current "Woke" phenomenon that has infected the reasoning of so many in our society of most all ages. The form of intellectual impatience this behavior reflects has been evident for most of my life {79 years and counting}, most often by those who simply do not think before they speak or, in modern parlance, "tweet"/write. A common behavioral manifestation of this absence of forethought is, of course, too often being adamantly incorrect; while 'believing' their feigned "outrage" to be enlightened and reasonable.

Many years ago there was a wise saying that, I believe(?) described this modern behavior:

"MINDS IN NEUTRAL, FULL SPEED AHEAD!"

Here is another one, if you can't get them to stop it.

"If you don't leave me alone, I'll have to find someone who will!"

As Usual,

EA

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Ethan - "woke worship" is a line literally being fed to sheep that consume right wing propaganda... Matt is cashing in on people that consume propaganda and clearly you are one fo them.

He and his daughter are two sides of the same coin. Both equally misinformed. The fact that he is annoyed that his daughter does not share his idiotic ideas is more evidence parents should NOT be funding their kids education if in so doing they think their kids need to beleive their parents idiocy... Right?

Koshmarov's avatar

"Matt is cashing in on people that consume propaganda"

Nah.

Matt is "cashing in" on people who are sick of propaganda.

Good for him.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Kosh - Woke is literally a made up corporate narrative to distract and divide voters so they don't come together and elect leaders that will change economic policy to help ordinary Americans if it will hurt corporate profits. They don't care what side of the debate Americans are on, only that Americans HATE elected leaders that are not on their side on this issue.

Matt flaming the fires of this because it ropes in people like you who know their economic policy ideas are moronic so you invest your passion in identity political ideas. Matt ropes you in and rings the cash register while holding on to his liberal creds... Right?

Thom's avatar

Piketty doo doo - You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about! This may not be the ideal venue to test your language skills, at least until you actually learn the language du jour.

Heh Jeb...JEB...dammit Jeb awaken, I think thars a snake in yer britches.

As Usual,

EA

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Ethan - Got it your writing skills are better than mine. But your parenting skills are not...

Jayhawk's avatar

I love that last line and plan to use it against the aggressively WOKE, much appreciated.

Thom's avatar

Thank you, I appreciate both your appreciation and the "like" of my comment. (:-})

As Usual,

EA

Sevender's avatar

Nothing ever changes because there’s never a consequence to her actions. You’re terrible parents.

Hank Stillwell's avatar

Thats a nasty thing to say. It's not parents' fault if their kid is going through a difficult time and processing it with some bizarre woke bullshit. Screw you.

Phil's avatar

"...their kid is going through a difficult time and processing it with some bizarre woke bullshit."

The parents are still to blame, but less and less so as the "kid" gets older. The only reason the "kid" (an adult, by virtually every standard, in her late 20's and apparently "educated" at an East Coast private university and working on a Doctoral Degree) is having a difficult time is because she has no critical thinking skills; e.g. a Bizarre Woke Bullshit Detection Meter.©

Sevender's avatar

LOL. Of course it's your fault. An entire generation loves their self-delusions more than they love their children.

Latouche's avatar

We got a tough guy on the thread. Curious as to the self-delusions that turn on sevender. Share with us, sevender, your deepest, dark delusions.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 1, 2021
Comment deleted
Rick Abrams's avatar

I treat adolescence which ends around age 35, as a form of mental illness. LOL

elaine's avatar

"Terrible parents" is too harsh, but their current strategy isn't helping her. She's really too old--late twenties--to be acting like this. Can't she process her difficult time without tracking down her parents in the house and yelling at them? How is she going to handle the workplace?

Claudia Reilly's avatar

Oh my gosh. Our own parents accepted us and what we said. We accept our children. These are not terrible parents. These are parents who realize life is more complicated than their daughter understands. And ALL parents who are kind and good reflect and are aware our children look at life in ways that our different from us and we understand and sort of smile and remember our youth. We all need to empathize and be amused and discuss without hatred or anger.

Sevender's avatar

Lmao. We have two entire generations now of fat, depressed, socially anxious young people whose IQs are lower than their elders' for the first time since WWII. But you're all Perfect Parents!! LOL.

John W Burns's avatar

No, life is really pretty simple. Simple courtesy towards your parents and siblings for starters. These parents are doormats. If a sister of mine operated this way, I'd quickly cut her out of my life and my family's life. Zero tolerance for that kind of horseshit.

Jim M's avatar

I gotta say something to support your statement. Princess is acting like a spoiled princess b/c Daddy & Mommy are (and have been) more interested in being her friend that being good parents. This bs from this kid didn't just magically appear; it's the culmination of years of habits and 'keeping the peace' instead of establishing boundaries. I have zero sympathy.

Snowflake is the mirror image of Archie Bunker. Daddy needs to be the mirror image of The Meathead. Oh, and my credentials are that I raised three daughters, okay?

And like other commenters, I'm curious as to her field of grad work. I'll put a plugged nickel on it ain't STEM! Obviously her behaviour reeks of Grievance studies, but that's too obvious. What is it? Hmmm???

Algator's avatar

Fair enough; but in this particular war, to take refuge behind a STEM major is the last refuge of a scoundrel.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Spoken like someone who has never had a 20 year old spawn live in their house.

Why be so nasty and rude, ya cunt?

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Scott - I have had 3 20+yr old spawn living in the house. None of them agreed with me on politics. Did not bother me any more than my views bothered them. The older the get the more they end up thinking like me, but that is because they are out in the workforce crushing it. We are lucky few in this country moving forward and not one of us thinks it is because we are more brilliant or work harder than anyone. We just live in the right place at the right time and being swept forward by trends we did nothing to create. Just like the majority of Americans who are being swept down word (despite being smarter and working harder than us) by the trends they did noting to create.

We may not agree on politics but we agree that some places are economically better than others and people living in those places should appreciate their great fortune.

M. Gage's avatar

Man, my kid was spazzing out from the internet during Covid too. I went on walks with her to the park with our Dachshund until the gibberish stopped spewing forth from her mouth. It usually ended when she saw a duck or something.

Exercise is the best cure for all the bad feels, bro.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

Gaga - I fear you have missed the central them from most of the "parents" on this board. What you have articulated is what any normal parent would do.

These "parents" think that if the dad is paying the bills his daughter is required to tell her dad his moronic ideas (mostly lies and fabrications) are absolutely brilliant and how much she adores the close attention he pays to every syllable uttered by Sean Hannity or Tucker Carlson.

That seems to be the consensus on parenting on Matt's board. Right Matt?

KDB's avatar

What an awful way to live.

Bill Heath's avatar

For the adults? Absolutely.

For the infant they're enabling? It's a wonderful life. Every day is Christmas, her birthday and Juneteenth combined.

Recommendation: Tell her to believe whatever she wants. Tell her to behave like an adult or get out. Now she has something genuine about which to be enraged.

KDB's avatar

I don’t know. Being angry all the time is an awful way to live. You are right they need to cut off the financial support immediately. These adults need to live in the real world

Abbybwood's avatar

Maybe move her out of the basement and into the attic? Make sure there is no WiFi up there. If she wants to stay make her go through every box and organize all the Christmas decorations and photos and Granny’s old chest of clothes and recipes. Let her rock in Granny’s rocker and peruse all the old books and Bibles and letters. When she has finished all that and written a 200 page paper about her experience then take her to the lake for a few weeks of camping with no WiFi.

Then help her move out. That oughta set her head on straight.

Fortun8 Son's avatar

No wifi. No A/C. And finish the sheetrock project up there while you’re at it.

Michael D (Piketty)'s avatar

He and his daughter are two side of the same coin.... Both are being manipulated to insure the rich and powerful keep their power by dividing us. Father and daughter, conservative and liberal. Just keep voters divided and the rich keep getting richer at the expense of everyone else.

Ollo Gorog's avatar

Sad to say, but many of her generation are clueless...and also helpless. Putting her out on her own wouldn't have the desired affect. She would more than likely end up in the arms of some nutcase like DiAngelo.

Charles Clemens's avatar

It is time to stop being an enabler. Set the beast free and see if she can live in the wild.

Koshmarov's avatar

It's tough to be an AWFL. Life is a challenge every day.

MDM 2.0's avatar

I read these comments and start understanding more and more the old man that shakes his fist and tells me to stay off his grass

Koshmarov's avatar

I would like to speak with your manager.

Nanthew Shandridan's avatar

I am surprised at how significant that is ... and yet in reflecting it all seems so unsurprisingly obvious.

About a Goy's avatar

“I was excited and felt an immediate need to let them know I was not racist,” she explains, adding: “I proceeded to spend the evening telling them how racist my family was. I shared every racist joke, story, and comment I could remember my family ever making…”

When someone tells you they're incapable of self-awareness, believe them.

Jeff's avatar

That quote struck me as well. There must be something wrong me. When I, a white guy, meet black people, I interact with them just as I do with other INDIVIDUALS.

About a Goy's avatar

My parents and grandparents were hardly on the front lines of the Civil Rights Movement either, in terms of race relations, but being a normal, well-adjusted individual, I’ve managed to mature and raise a young man far superior to me without feeling the need to walk around self-flagellating for clicks and profit.

Simon's avatar

Ah but if you had been slow roasting your mind in collectivist doctrine and learning to view every micro-action and thought exclusively through the filter of racial dynamics whilst hardly ever meeting an actual living breathing black person....you might find it a lot harder to do that.

Waiting for Homo Superior's avatar

Gawd, ain’t it the truth! She sounds insufferable.

Sue's avatar

If she truly is non-racist, she would simply go to dinner with people of color and enjoy the evening with them talking about sports, family stuff, business, or anything else. Her selfinvolved need to talk about race shows her disregard for anything about the people except their color. That is the definition of racism. She needs to forget about “other white people” and focus on working on her own sad personality.

RedFire's avatar

She needs to “do the work”! Lol

Doctor Mist's avatar

Yeah, well, according to St Kendi, there’s no such thing as a non-racist, just racist and anti-racist. “Self-involved” is exactly the right word.

“Live and let live” is I guess a ship that sailed long ago.

Tracey's avatar

It seems like the people with her sort of mindset think by spouting off how woke they are they're good people and don't actually need to work to improve their personality, temperament, integrity, etc. I'd bet in her mind she considers herself fully evolved.

Gutterdandy's avatar

All DiAngelo sees is race. She is the one with a major problem.

Jeff H's avatar

The excerpted anecdote was an attempt by DiAngelo to admit to her own problematic behavior. By criticizing her in an attempt to join this bandwagon here you accidentally agreed with her.

norstadt's avatar

Criticize = agree. Don't criticize = agree. What are the other options?

Always Adblock's avatar

Notice race: racist. Say "I don't see race": racist.

Agree with DiAngelo: racist who needs to "do the work". Don't agree with DiAngelo: racist who's too "fragile" to "do the work."

Say you have black friends: racist, reducing friends to colors. Don't say you have black friends: neo-segregationist.

The only way to win is not to play. Smile, nod, and walk away.

Simon's avatar

Erm..Her behaviour in the anecdote isnt 'problematic' its flat out loony toons absurd. It's like a cartoon skit of the most absurdly try-hard woke person who is so desperate to show a black person how non racist and right-on they are that they somehow end up spending the whole evening actually subjecting them to racist jokes and being incapable of talking to them as human beings.

I mean... what the actual Fuck????

That should litetally be an episode of South Park

But apparently DeAngelo is serious....?

Sasha Stone's avatar

What is a whole class of well-meaning people to do when they have everything and it's still not enough? Well, they join a cult - anything that will explain both their misery and their abundance. There is a reason why cults - from Charles Manson to EST to Nxium target the richest among us. And why people who struggle to put food on the table are less likely to fall for a charlton who promises them enlightenment.

FNR's avatar

it's a movement of millions of chronological adults with the maturity level of a sheltered, spoiled pre-teen.

"here's 99% of what you want, 99% of best anyone has ever had, anywhere, ever."

to which they respond:

"everything is all bad. I am living in Hell."

Sasha Stone's avatar

Exactly. What do you give people who have everything? Anxiety.

publius_x's avatar

I've heard the punchline as Xanax. Same difference.

Abbybwood's avatar

I am 71 and all this CRT and wokeness and talk of being cis-gendered or whatever does have a feeling of cultness. Like the Emperor with no clothes and everyone in the crowd admiring how beautiful his clothes were, save one child who had the innocence of brutal truth to blurt out, “The Emperor has no clothes!”

The spell was broken as even the Emperor looked down and could see he was wearing no clothes.

I can understand how in the corporate world people who have spent decades of their lives trying to get to the top would “go along to get along” with this WF bullshit, but I think a cult is a cult and a bad fad is a bad fad.

Eventually (sooner rather than later I hope), the clear thinkers with eyes to see will come to the same conclusion as Rodney King did: “Can’t we all just get along?!”

Ollo Gorog's avatar

I was a non-traditional college student (code for old-guy) that graduated in 2015. Many of the kids I went to class with had never skinned a knee, never bled, some had never experienced pain, and most had had a silver platter life. The anxiety level of these kids was palpable.

Skeptic's avatar

Great comment, but you may be a little generous with "well meaning." White, privileged DiAngelo fans live in safe, comfortable cocoons, but spout ideas that hurt poor people who pay the consequences. Insane ideas like "defund the police" don't come from poor minorities who have to put their kids in the bathtub when the bullets are spraying across the neighborhood. They come from the Robin DiAngelos and Lisa Benders (from Minneapolis City Council). Is that well meaning?

“They were careless people, Tom and Daisy- they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made.”

Jonathan's avatar

Ideals that cut against one's own [apparent] interests are a luxury, and therefore a marker of status.

https://quillette.com/2019/11/16/thorstein-veblens-theory-of-the-leisure-class-a-status-update/

Tom Worster's avatar

That and fleecing rich people is attractive, well, because they have the money you want. Can't help thing of Jeffrey Epstein.

Mickey Mouse's avatar

It’s that or drugs. I prefer my drug addicted rich friends to the rage addicted work ones. At least the drug addicts can be fun sometimes

Stxbuck's avatar

The American working class have never had a revolution because they are too busy working-Eric Hoffer

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

OoOoh... maybe they'll all drink poison and go away then!

Polly Frost's avatar

Robin DiAngelo is a variant of Mad Cow Disease. I live in a small city with a lot of wealthy white liberals who love this Robin DiAngelo crap. It's just guilty white liberal masturbatory masochism. Back before the lockdown if I went to a dinner party I could be certain that one or more of the people at the table would gas on about how much they hated living in a place with so little diversity. I'd sit there thinking it wasn't like anyone forced them to live here. Much cheaper to live in Baltimore or Detroit or the South Side of Chicago. The head of our sweet little botanic garden got his board to read DiAngelo. Then they sent out an email about how racism would not be tolerated anymore at the garden. I asked them for a specific example of racism and they couldn't come up with any. But nonetheless they insisted white supremacy and white fragility are a serious threat. These people are sick in the head. White supremacy and fragility is not a problem. Mentally ill white liberals are the problem.

OldMillennialGuy's avatar

In my weaker moments, people like that make me wish the mob comes for the suburbs one day.

Koshmarov's avatar

I am willing to Venmo a donation to the Vengabus for this mob.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

No nonononononono... The Vengabus is coming? We're going to Ibiza??? I'll go pick up some E.

Tom Worster's avatar

I don't think being totally out of touch is a mental illness. But yes, this cohort of totally out of touch people (not all of whom are white, btw) is a huge problem.

Mike Lofton's avatar

Thank you Matt. DiAngelo is an awful, self-loathing, condescending, race-baiting Marxist huckster. A good friend of mine, an educated man of color, asked me to read WF. I agreed. When it arrived, I took it on vacation to read on the beach. (white privilege alert!) After finishing the second chapter, I called him to verify that there wasn't some demented child abuse edition of the book that I may have ordered. He assured me that, that thought, was simply more evidence of my natural and incurable white racist behavior. I asked, "And that doesn't even feel, much less sound, racist to you?" The damage this woman has done on adults should be embarrassing to adults.

Tedder130's avatar

How is she in any way "Marxist"? I think you misuse that adjective.

Mike Lofton's avatar

Hi Tedder130, I understand that one of the awful (and deadly) tenants of Marxism is to separate the classes. In DiAngelo's case, she specifically uses race as class. Another Marxist tenant is the elimination of the individual in favor of the "class". That's why I use the term Marxist. If you have a different or interesting perspective, I have an open mind.

Frances Taylor's avatar

You get a lot of Marx apologists in this audience. There are even outright communists in the comments sometimes that will deny the Uygher Muslim camps and that the Russians persecuted the Jews.

I agree with you completely. This is race communism, not unlike the Nazis. But people will make excuses for whatever reason.

Tedder130's avatar

There are a lot of smart people who are Marxist, communists, Buddhists, and so on. They point out that the so-called genocide of Uyghur Muslims is a propaganda ploy by the usual actors to manufacture consent for war on China. How is this even controversial?

Russians under the Czar persecuted Jews for many reasons. The USSR attempted to alter that practice, especially since many Party members were Jews. Nevertheless, there is a large Russian Jewish diaspora who will never forgive Russia for its past depredations.

And what in the world is "race communism"? The term itself is contradictory. It seems that due to over 100 years of elite propaganda, anything that is 'bad' is just called 'communist'.

Patricia Kane's avatar

For symmetry, shall we discuss the children being held in cages while waiting for families who are ready to take them? Or how about the hideous statistics as to poverty, violence, maternal health and other indices of well being for our indigenous peoples? Something about "people who live in glass houses...." or "Let he who is without sin...." comes to mind.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Heh, the Nazis had LOADS of good excuses, too.

That's nice cunts... I'm glad their bullshit was ended.

Nanthew Shandridan's avatar

"You get a lot of Marx apologists in this audience." First, there numbers are less then the haters, so its really not that disproportionate, and Second many of us aren't really apologists in that we think he is right, we just think his ideas are being hugely exaggerated and misrepresented.

"There are even outright communists in the comments sometimes that will deny the Uygher Muslim camps and that the Russians persecuted the Jews." First, the Russian Programs before Communism killed more Jews then the ones following communism, so those terrible pogroms seems to be less the fault of communism and more the fault of pre-21st century Russian governments in general regardless of system. Second, while the suffering of Uygher Muslims is terrible I am not seeing anyone deny it nor do I really see how that is strictly communism's fault -- the big transnational companies that profit most from it like Apple could make it stop any time if they insisted their products not be made with slave labor, and instead they are the ones spending their capitalist resources to help this slavery continue: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2021/may/11/apple-continues-use-china-slave-labor-report-shows/

I abhor what is happening to the Uyghers, but just like the suffering of the Russian Jews I see no reason to believe it is strictly communisms fault and wouldn't be happening otherwise. This is especially as it is the most capitalist of the transnational companies propping this situation up and encouraging it meanwhile "communist" China is really mostly just communist in name only -- its really is just a party-aristocracy that regulates over what is otherwise just a free-enterprise society where and when it isn't actively regulating which is more than you seem to intimate. You can can call an A-bomb a banana but that doesn't make it true. China calls itself a communist country because it helps keep the uprisings down by claiming "yes this is a government and system designed for the people" then it is to admit "yah we hijacked and replaced what was intended to be that system with a vastly extra-cruel hybrid of aristocracy and the worst of free-market ideals" <- the optics on admitting that truth just wouldn't be very good or useful to the aristocratic rulers like Xi.

Boris Petrov's avatar

Nice to meet again our demented Frances: "...comments sometimes that will deny the Uygher Muslim camps and that the Russians persecuted the Jews..."

The "genocide" of Uyghur people in China is as fake War party/CIA propaganda as not that long ago a coming "genocide of Jews in USSR" - see below:

Elie Wiesel's Israeli propaganda and the myth of Soviet genocide against the Jews

His book "The Jews of Silence" was created as part of Israel’s covert propaganda and influence program targeting American Jews.

Elie Wiesel's Israeli propaganda and the myth of Soviet genocide against the Jews - Immigrants as a Weapon (substack.com)

https://yasha.substack.com/p/elie-wiesels-israeli-propaganda-and

Yasha Levine -- Apr 28

Frances knows not how to spell "good Uyghurs Moslems", mixes terms Russia and USSR, didn't notice that Russia stopped being Communist 30++ years ago, and has no feeling for the modern Warshaw Gheto -- the horror of open concentration camp, Gaza

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E1XaJs3XsAYIC3B?format=jpg&name=small

Tedder130's avatar

I have not read Ms DiAngelo and I will not, so I don't know how she is using 'race' instead of 'class'. All I know is that her analysis, as shown by Matt, is in no way Marxist. First, Marx does not 'separate' the classes, he simply analyzes them for what they are. In this day, his thought about class is taken for granted. Second, I don't know what you mean by "elimination of the individual", except how neoliberalism exalts the individual in our modern days. None of this seems to have anything to do with DiAngelo's work.

Alistair Penbroke's avatar

What Mike means by "separate" the classes is to strictly divide the population into them, assume nobody can move between them and assume that their thoughts, wishes and behaviours can be trivially derived from which class they're in.

Marxism was never widely accepted, even in Marx's day, because it's patently nonsense. Capitalists work, but even if you consider their work to somehow not be labour, many capitalists are themselves former (e.g. factory floor) workers. Capitalists can also go back to being workers if their business goes under, so Marx's assumption that there's a bright line between these largely arbitrary classes is false. And people knew it was false back when he was promoting this idea.

Marxism is fundamentally a collectivist ideology that "eliminates the individual" insomuch as it assigns people beliefs and desires based on their "class" (which is itself assigned to them), and any objections by people who don't in fact think that way are not listened to but ignored or written off as "false consciousness".

Mike Lofton's avatar

I'm sorry but I don't understand your comment. Your first sentence states that you haven't and will not read DiAngelo, and your last sentence (assertion) seems to contradict that. Thanks for the civil exchange.

Snarcalita Eikidjunotte's avatar

Sorry, only class is class, and Marx had Tenets, landlords have Tenants. You really haven't read much have you?

Blue Thing's avatar

I really hate comments like this. They take away from the conversation. You come off as a jerk, too.

Mike Lofton's avatar

My typing inadequacies are duly noted. And, yes, I do read often. Why such an obnoxious comment? Is civil discourse that difficult for you? This thread is interesting with your contribution being an exception.

Salusa Secundus Snape II's avatar

You really need to acquaint yourself with Marxism before you start reciting what you may have overheard at a party as the definitive analysis. In the first place, Marxism doesn't propose "separating the classes." Classes, by definition, are already separate. Marxism requests that members of the working class (the proletariat) become conscious of their existence within the class to which they already belong, and organize for their own liberation.

And as far as "elimination" goes, eliminating class *distinction* is the ultimate goal of communism, not melting into a state-worshipping mass. (That has much more in common with Nazism.)

Do your homework, son!

Alistair Penbroke's avatar

That's circular logic: merely playing with words. It has no intellectual merit.

"Classes, by definition, are already separate". The critique of Marx is not that classes don't exist at all - that's a strawman argument you just invented - but that his assumption that there are bright dividing lines between them and that people are born into those classes. That belief is wrong. Because it's wrong, Marxism has to try and explain people's rejection of these wrong beliefs without admitting to their wrongness, hence the concept that the working classes are somehow "not conscious" of the fact that they're working class. Such drivel.

Also! There seems to be a common idea in some of these comments that Marx was correctly analyzing life in Victorian England. He was not, and had to rely constantly on fraudulent in practices in his written works to disguise that fact.

One of his favorite tricks was to rail against situations described in factory inspectorate reports, many of which were written decades before he cited them, whilst ignoring that those mill owners had already been prosecuted, or that factory safety laws had already been reformed by Parliament many years earlier. He had to ignore these facts, because his whole thesis was that capitalism could not reform itself and was going to self-destruct. He also liked to point almost exclusively at archaic nearly feudal "industries" as examples of what all of capitalism was like, whilst ignoring much better capitalised firms that had better conditions. This often proved the opposite of his case, because e.g. his criticism of small family baking firms boiled down to: conditions are bad because they lack sufficient capital to invest in machinery. In more advanced industries he struggled even harder to make his arguments work, like railways, where he was trying to argue that they were very dangerous and capitalist railways were killing more and more people, whereas in reality railways were rapidly becoming the safest mode of transport that existed.

In one notorious case, some other researchers who checked a quote attributed to a British prime minister by Marx discovered it was wholly fabricated and the PM had in fact said the opposite.

All of Marx is like this. His work isn't an intellectual nor cutting analysis of anything, it's just lots of academic jargon and deceptive claims, many of which fall apart when his citations are checked. The man contributed nothing of any intellectual merit to the world, and it betrays a deep malaise in society that so many people think he did.

David Otness's avatar

Um, you'd be wanting 'tenet' here, Mike. (I know, I know.... But SOMEBODY'S got to do it.) You're welcome.

Patricia Kane's avatar

Suggest you read "Caste" by Isabel Wilkerson and re-consider your perspective. Or not.

Tedder130's avatar

Too much here to fully elaborate, but some:

Pertinently, 'caste' is not the same as 'class'; the former is fixed, the latter is fluid. Caste seems much more to describe segregation while we know that there are many black capitalists. My 'perspective' is that it is just nonsense to portray any thought you don't like as 'Marxist'.

Mary Williams's avatar

Good suggestion, I read "Caste", it's an honest look at the economic divide which is where our real problems lie, nothing like money or lack thereof to separate the people.

RedFire's avatar

Suggest you extricate yourself from this lunatic cult.

Martin Blank's avatar

That book is pretty silly. Nothing much interesting in it a thinking person wouldn't know, and where it does go off the beaten path it is wrong.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Hmm, good point but maybe it's more accurately "Marxite".

Still, she does equate race with class... and thinks all YPIPO are rich or privileged. Guess she's never been to Appalachia.

Athena1's avatar

So, the KKK is Marxist, too?

lol

sasinsea's avatar

"Marxist" is just a synonym for "bad" or "makes me uncomfortable" for a lot of conservatives. DiAngelo's stuff is bad for enough reasons that nobody should need to invent new ones.

FNR's avatar

"Racist" is just a synonym for "bad" or "makes me uncomfortable" for a lot of lefties. DiAngelo's stuff is bad for enough reasons that nobody should need to invent new ones.

Skeptic's avatar

Lenin summarized the Marxist view of the world by saying that all of human history can be reduced to one question: "Who whom?" (Kto kogo.) Who is doing it to whom?

In other words, everything and everyone must be viewed through the lens of oppression.

In that sense, she is certainly Marxist, although a particularly low and vulgar kind.

Brian's avatar

This comment is why I like the comment sections of Matt's articles. I had never heard of this before and was able to verify it and learn something. Thanks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who%2C_whom%3F

Patricia Kane's avatar

Check your Russian. Your phonetics are off.

Skeptic's avatar

I'm fluent and studied in Moscow. What's your objection, that it's pronounced kto kovo, but spelled kto kogo? How is that possibly worth noting here?

RedFire's avatar

It’s obvious she’s substituted class with race. If you don’t see the Marxism running thru this garbage I don’t know how to help. And yes, I’ve read.

Tedder130's avatar

If she has substituted 'class' with 'race' then she fails to understand either. There is nothing redeemable about her work, except perhaps in the minds of certain commenters to indulge in their obvious hatred of Marx.

FNR's avatar

it's always personal. it can't be his ideas are garbage, it's just that people hate HIM!

so silly.

Graeme Rodaughan's avatar

The key architecture of Marxism is to divide the community up into distinct categories where membership is immutable, the groups are in perpetual conflict, and one of the groups is oppressing the others. The end game always results in the elimination of the 'oppressor,' group. CRT and DiAngelo adopt the Marxian architecture and simply swap race for economic position. While I don't know if DiAngelo is a Marxist, she is an absolute adherent of their basic ideological architecture.

DNY's avatar

All of "wokeness" is a derivative of Marxism by way of the Frankfurt School and other similar thinkers like Gramsci and Derrida and the various anti- and post-colonialist thinkers whose ideas depend on Lenin's (probably wrong) imperialism theory. That's how.

FNR's avatar

cultural marxism groups people, which can be neutral, but it is also strongly anti-individual. she is enthusiastically anti-individual.

IMO, it is one of the worst things about the left.

they consolidate in order to dominate.

publius_x's avatar

She makes too much to be a Marxist.

Skeptic's avatar

"In the United States, the working class are Democrats. The middle class are Republicans. The upper class are Communists." Whittaker Chamber

Atom's avatar

Except this is no longer true. The working class aren’t Democrats any longer, and communism for all the discussion here about it, is a dead philosophy.

Tedder130's avatar

Many of the 19th century communists came from bourgeois backgrounds. They were called 'class traitors'.

FNR's avatar

today I like to call them "financially comfortable, guilt-ridden, gullible white people (who want absolution on the cheap)"

Patricia Kane's avatar

Funny but not accurate. I know Marxists who are quite well off.

FNR's avatar

it's easy to call yourself a communist when you're rich.

Mike Lofton's avatar

Ironic and very funny! :)

Pat Fahy's avatar

She is in no way a Marxist. Since she is anti universalism, she is most likely a postmodernism and a neoliberal.

craazyman's avatar

I'm an educated man of color when I get a tan. If I were a "man of color" due to heredity I think I'd believe white people have gone completely insane. And I'd be right!

But I'd awkwardly smile and try not to say anything about it in public.

Seriously, to be a fly on a wall at an African-American barber shop these days . . . can you imagine?? What you would hear?? It would be hilarious and devastating at the same time.

White people were partly insane to begin with, but so are most people everywhere they form into groups.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

I recommend that anyone who reads this post (from Mike) not continue down the rabbit hole he’s started.

Mike Lofton's avatar

So, is thoughtful dialogue and exchange now considered a rabbit hole? Let's at least call it the briar patch. :)

Jonathan's avatar

Sounds like you need better friends.

chguy's avatar

A white woman who is by her own admission uncomfortable interacting with people from other races assumes all other white people share this trait (we don't), then constructs elaborates rules that she demands we all use in interactions with people who aren't white. Then she makes a ton of money at it.

A story: my partner is Latino and I am white. A few years ago, we went through a period where we were having focused weekly conversations about various issues in our relationship. One week, the issue we chose was "one of us is brown and one of us is white."

Afterwards, I told a progressive white friend about this, and her first reaction was: "Oh, that must have been so uncomfortable!" No, I told her, it was a Tuesday at our house. That was an easy conversation; sex, money and housework are the tough ones.

Fast forward a couple of years, and she's terminating my contract with an agency she works for because I'm not aligned enough with their woke agenda.

The problem isn't that progressives have taken over the conversation about race. The problem is that people who are uncomfortable talking about race have taken over the conversation about race.

Skeptic's avatar

One of the things that brings me here is that so many of the commenters sound like people I'd like to drink beer with. And a few of them sound like the people we'd complain about/ make fun of as we tippled.

Sevender's avatar

In all honest, I'd tweet about her to her boss and others complaining she's firing you after you discussed dating a Latino and call her a racist.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

hahah someone should do this.

"She fired me after she found out I'm gay and in an interracial relationship. She made a face when she found out and then she treated me badly for two years before getting my canned from a project."

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

For real.

Sorry the cunt fired you. What an ignorant shit.

Koshmarov's avatar

"No, I told her, it was a Tuesday at our house."

The great Raúl Juliá on this topic: https://youtu.be/oDRnVPlRzag

Jon Schreifels's avatar

You should get paid simply for the pain of reading through that. You read it so that we don't have to. You have my deepest gratitude.

Lillia Gajewski's avatar

I admit I have never read White Fragility. (Life is too short.) But this woman sounds like a horrible human being who, rather than simply admit she is a horrible human being, generalizes her horribleness to all those who look like her and now makes money on it. And she gets away with it because white liberals separate the chosen from the damned by level of guilt.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 30, 2021
Comment deleted
Simon's avatar

I'm honestly not sure about that. I think she may very well believe all of it in a 1984 double-thhink kind of way.

James russo's avatar

Another great article, Matt. Keep up the great work! Between you, Glenn and Bari I don't understand how more people aren't frightened by the direction the far left is taking the Democratic Party and how pseudo academic work is being socialized and taught like its peer reviewed scientific theory

Kathleen McCook's avatar

Now add Snowden. continuing ED.

mkp's avatar

Yes he has the street cred.

James russo's avatar

I'll have to check him out. Thank you for the recommendation

David Ross's avatar

Those are my favorite three authors as well. Each piece is a treat!

James russo's avatar

They're all excellent. I find myself going back and reading their pieces several times

Daren Sweeney's avatar

They aren't far left. They come from establishment, affluent backgrounds who are certain all their thoughts, however inane, represent truth.

Omaha NYer's avatar

Dumb question on my part, who is Bari?

David Ross's avatar

Bari Weiss. She's excellent, check her out.

Nobody's avatar

She's a neocon hack. Hardly what I would call excellent.

David Ross's avatar

Bari Weiss? Lol, have you gotten into the Tide pods again?

Peko67's avatar

Read her nytimes exit article. Made me a fan.

David Ross's avatar

I did as well, and that's when I subscribed!

Certex's avatar

Every time I read the name Bari Weiss, I instantly think of this song. Sorry. :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZui5pteOoM

Yawny's Digest's avatar

Every time I read the name Bari Weiss, I think of the words "toady" and "Assad."

Nobody's avatar

Everyone who knows nothing about Bari should watch this before they decide to take this sockpuppet seriously. I don't particularly like or agree with Jimmy, but his comments on this interview are great:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jS-sxJFn6O0

Certex's avatar

Not as entertaining as Fun Lovin' Criminals. :)

Liz M's avatar

Last summer, the CEO of my large corporate company sent out a newsletter praising White Fragility and suggesting we all read it. Tells you something.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

I'm sure the burgeoning upper class Nazis went around handing out Mein Kampf, or its lesser-known sequel Mein Krampf: the story of Hitler's short but exuberant career in track and field.

Lucas Corso's avatar

I’m waiting for the movie.

Jeff's avatar

I have to wonder whether your CEO read it first, or if the suggestion was just made to virtue signal.

Waiting for Homo Superior's avatar

I’m not surprised. This sounds like the stuff my former workplace would require.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 30, 2021
Comment deleted
RedFire's avatar

Exactly. This is their playbook-recognize it next time you hear a CEO rambling on about “equity” which no one can define..and is gibberish

publius_x's avatar

Pro tip" until the CEOs second homes are gifted to homeless people, they don't mean it.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 30, 2021
Comment deleted
Jonathan's avatar

Large institutional investors--Vanguard, Fidelity, Blackrock--are pressuring corporations to hire Diversity & Inclusion officers. Woke ideology is a control mechanism, and it's not going away.

Domenick Doran's avatar

What is the reason that an investor would want companies they invest in to do this? I can think of lawsuit avoidance, or possibly boycott avoidance, but honestly, both of those seem like smaller risks than the amount of resources that DEI implies in additional staff and then just lost time for all of the existing staff when they're invited to mandatory meetings for DEI training. Am I missing the real reason?

Jonathan's avatar

My guess is it's not about mitigating risk or generating value; it's about political control. Last summer, we saw a whole lot of corporations line up very quickly in lockstep with the BLM movement. It was quite unprecedented--and a bit creepy, wasn't it? It was *not* just a marketing exercise either as many people argued. It's one thing to put a BLM logo on your advertisements, quite another to instruct employees to "be less white" in internal HR videos.

Here's what they have to say about it:

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-12-10/blackrock-plans-to-push-companies-on-racial-diversity-in-2021

Basically, it is no longer okay for corporations to focus solely on maximizing profits. They must follow the edicts of their masters in Davos, and this is the mechanism for making that happen.

Skeptic's avatar

This is, and will be, the best comment.

Trevor Friberg's avatar

There are lots of overpaid CEOs out there but if you think that they are making 500x more than they deserve then you do not have a proper understanding of economics, or maybe just math.

norstadt's avatar

1000x ? I'm thinking of James McNerney.

"As Boeing's first CEO without a background in aviation, he made the decision to upgrade the 737 series to 737 MAX instead of developing a new model."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_McNerney

BAILEY BUILDING AND LOAN's avatar

McNerney:

(Pulls booger out of nose)

"Hey what if we just put bigger engines on it?"

Sycophant Chorus: "Good idea boss!"

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 30, 2021
Comment deleted
Sevender's avatar

Does anyone here read German?

After World War II, scholars interviewed average Germans to see why they were attracted to Nazism in the first place. For some reason the men’s interviews have been translated into English and are available online but the women’s never were. I wonder why.

Margaret Winter's avatar

Oh please please Matt Taibbi, make this one generally available, it is just too rich & hilarious not to share on Twitter

Rob de Riche's avatar

Share the link and people can get a teaser and then if they subscribe Matt can afford to live and write another day. I found this article via Twitter and subscribed. Not sure if you're implying it should be free in entirety, but I don't think artists and writers should give everything away.

mkp's avatar

I think the more he shares the more he makes somehow with new people finding him

Margaret Winter's avatar

As always, I already did that first thing - share the link on Twitter. No I am not implying Matt shouldn't have paid subscriptions. Occasionally Matt shares a whole column for free, by popular request.

Rob de Riche's avatar

Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Matt writes, "No: DiAngelo’s brand of bourgeois Spencerism is ascendant, tipsy with itself and encouraged now by a Republican backlash. At this point there’s nothing we can do but hang on and wait for the dinner to be over, and God knows how long that will take."

Jesus Christ no, Matt! Nihilistic passivity is not the answer. Standing up to these racist bullies and demanding an instantiation of Martin Luther King, Jr.’s dream is the answer. "I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character." Let’s aggressively defend that ideal, not unproductively sneer from behind our computer screens.

Yawny's Digest's avatar

Well, to be fair, Matt has written extensively and aggressively about this subject, to the point where many of his readers have been responding with "can we just ignore her and move on?" He's one of the more widely-read writers who's been consistently standing up to, and yes, "calling out," these bullies.

The Dandy Highwayman's avatar

Turns out we can do both.

Join me in sneering.

*unh!

Nice!

For real though, I have always believed in that dream for all of my fellow humans.

Just because people are becoming a Nazi mob that won't change. All of my dealings are above the board and fair to all, always.

There. I'm living proof that DiAngelo's premise is wrong. If I hadn't maintained my own individual integrity, I might have lost myself and not been able to be here to share this ideal with friends, strangers, my offspring, co-workers, the guy delivering sodas who did CPR while we raced to the convenience store on the "person not breathing call" -everyone. Even the person who wasn't breathing.

It's more simple than anyone makes it out to be, and the secret lies in being present in the moment. Really present. Entirely so.

Then, you're real.

Julie Maizels's avatar

Yes, much damage has already been done and much more will continue to be done if we do not actively stand up to these nonsensical racist ideologues.

Starry Gordon's avatar

Popcult has to work itself out in its own way. We who are smart have not solved the problem. Now another kind of people are going to have their shot. It won't be nice, it won't be intelligent, it may lead to all kinds of grief, but by God, when the Lawd gets ready, you got to move. In this case the Lawd being the _vox_populi_.

radrave's avatar

Do-nothing is Matt's position, take it or leave it. Personally, I'm going for the latter option.

Snarcalita Eikidjunotte's avatar

I am reminded to the sort of evangelist preacher who rails relentlessly on in detail about the struggle against the temptations of homosexuality. I think at this point, people recognize that they are describing their own inner demons as if everyone had those urges, thereby revealing themselves. DiAngelo does the same thing with racism, but with even less self-awareness.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Pointing out that DiAngelo is racist and dumb isn’t going to cut it. We need to be educating people about the origins of critical race theory, which is a fusion of the ideas of the neo-Marxist Frankfurt School and the French postmodernists like Foucault. Only when we have a macrocosmic view of all these ideologies, which have destroyed the American humanities and most of American culture and art, can we repair the damage.

Certex's avatar

You won't get most of the public to care in the slightest about the origins of this hacky huckster crap. Much easier just to say, when people start going on about "white people this, white people that," that they're being RACIST and to SHUT THE FUCK UP. That would cure this whole raging brain fluke viral contagion a lot quicker than trying to explain to people why Foucault was a raving sadomasochistic lunatic.

Ian Jameson's avatar

You couldn’t be more wrong. That’s what the PC left is doing right now — telling people not to ask questions and have conversations, but rather to just shut the fuck up. People need to be convinced through reason. The solution to a witch hunt is not another witch hunt.

RedFire's avatar

Last thing we need is a epistemological study of Foucault and others. Maybe shut the fuck up is a bit harsh but not that far off. People need to be extricated from this cult with common sense and reason.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Foucault is being taught in American universities across the country. He needs to be widely unmasked as the paltry scholar and intellectual fraud he was.

If we don’t attack the intellectual arguments, the true believers will say, "You just haven’t read Foucault and Robin Diangelo. You need to read the smart people and get smart like me." If we aren’t able to explain why those so-called smart people weren’t smart at all, we’re screwed, ‘cause their explanation will always be that these postmodernist and neo-Marxist "geniuses" are simply over our heads.

If you want to appeal to homespun common sense, go for it. That may work on some people. I am for deploying every weapon we have against these pseudo-intellectual bigots.

Certex's avatar

There is no witch to hunt. I am just beyond sick of hearing white people being put down morning, noon and night. See, all this 'explain the roots of Foucault discourse' crap works on the educated middle classes, if they even care - and a good section of them won't anyway - but the working classes rightly don't give a damn about this polysyllabic crap. Allowing that there is some sort of 'debate' on this shit, like the nutters like DiAngelo have anything to say of any use to humanity whatsoever, just gives it oxygen.

I understand implicitly what the censorious ostensible 'left' have been doing recently to shut people up under the guise of 'extremism' after the Capitol debacle. But anybody who cares enough to research the subject knows where the roots of this psychotic discourse lie in universities, French nihilism, blah blah blah. Make the masses care about that. Or tell some racist fuck to shut up when they start spewing race hate. Know which way I would go.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Working-class people have brains and intellectual curiosity like anyone else. It’s clear you think the solution is shouting at and shaming people, and it’s clear I’m not going to change your mind. Have an amazing day.

Jayhawk's avatar

Yeah, but it would sure be fun to tell them to shut the fuck up. Or, they could all just spend 10 minutes with me in a small locked room and I could provide some old fashioned therapy.

Certex's avatar

They would certainly learn something about 'white fragility' then. Laughing.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 30, 2021
Comment deleted
Ian Jameson's avatar

That’s self-pitying nihilism and I have no time for it. If your local school board announces plans to start teaching white kids they have been born with original sin and black kids that they can’t succeed in this country, flood the meeting with sensible parents disclaiming this neo-racism with reason and evidence. If your Congressperson starts talking about their intersectional privilege, attend one of their community meetings and tell them on a livestream how that kind of thinking deprives people of their individual identity and entrenches, rather than diminishes, racism.

Take action. Don’t feel sorry for yourself.

Leland E Hutchinson's avatar

One could walk away and say, "Sorry. I'll have to get back to you on that." That is harder to do, however, in an employer mandated training session. I doubt many people believe this stuff, particularly the way it is packaged by obvious poltroons like DiAngelo. You would have to be deep into a rather dim Human Resources cult to think this is valuable. Contempt is a difficult attitude to channel. Back in high school we used to mock nonsense by going over the top in our participation.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Most people don’t believe it, but are cowed into silence by the cancel mob.

Poltroon means coward. Diangelo is no coward — she’s a brazen grifter. A more apt noun for her is charlatan.

Leland E Hutchinson's avatar

eek! You are right. I used the wrong descriptive term of abuse. I meant "nincompoop". Thanks for straightening me out. It is always important for invective to be on the proper vector.

Anon's avatar

Don't blame Foucault for any of this! Foucault wrote over and over again about the folly of categorizing people into rigid groups and how doing so allows authoritarians to institute control over more and more of our personal lives. He was dead set against biological essentialism, even in its apparently benign forms. I would argue that reading Foucault's writings on the histories of our concepts of mental illness and sexual orientation, and doing a similar deconstruction of our concept of race, would go a long way toward countering diAngeloism. As a matter of fact several books exist doing just that: "The History of White People" by Nell Irvin Painter and "The Invention of the White Race" by Theodore W Allen both come to mind.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Foucault was an anti-science, lunatic subjectivist who insisted the Holocaust was caused by the Enlightenment. He insisted that objective reality was unknowable, and reduced all of science to his concept of "biopower" in which things like special relativity are in fact just means of oppressing some and benefitting others with no relation to external, empirically discernible reality. Critical race theory, queer theory and postcolonial theory are saturated in references to Foucault.

He also went to his grave in 1984 insisting that AIDS, the virus that killed him, was a social construct. How identifying a virus which mowed down gay men like flies as a social construct, and how demeaning the scientific method which was responsible for the development of anti-retroviral drugs which saved countless gay men’s lives, you’ll have to explain to me.

You should listen to Noam Chomsky’s views on the effect Foucault and postmodernism have had on people in the developing world seeking to cast off the yoke of colonial oppression. It’s difficult to achieve liberation when you’re told liberation is like everything else an illusion and nothing means anything.

https://www.openculture.com/2018/02/noam-chomsky-explains-whats-wrong-with-postmodern-philosophy-french-intellectuals.html

Gloria Steinem has also called out the disastrous effect Foucault and the postmodernists have had on the fight for women’s equality and women’s studies, which under his influence has busied itself with pretentious, nonsensical word games rather than rigorous scholarship concerned with bettering the lot of women.

If you read Jose Guilherme Merquior’s magisterial 1985 review of Foucault’s entire corpus, “Foucault,” you’ll see he had absolutely no competence as a historiographer and that not one word in his books can be trusted.

To quite Camille Paglia, "He knew nothing."

Anon's avatar

I have found Foucault's concept of biopolitics to be very helpful in explaining to lefty college graduates why the very real abuses done in the name of covid19, as well as the very real abuses done to those labeled "lunatics", are actually bad. He was very sensitive to the ways in which blind worship of "science" (which is constantly evolving--"race science" was quite mainstream in the 1920s-1930s) can lead to mass violations of human rights.

Ian Jameson's avatar

Foucault’s antidote to bad science was epistemological, nihilistic anti-science couched in deliberately inchoate prose. "Nothing means anything and nothing is knowable" is a bland, unsustainable conclusion.

The correct antidote to bad science is good science.

Not every concept in postmodernism isn’t without some truth; it’s just that the handful of concepts that are valid have been lifted from infinitely more insightful writers like Emile Durkheim, Erving Goffman, and Friedrich Nietzshe. They offer an enriching read; Foucault’s writing is 90% bullshit and thereby does not.

Certex's avatar

Was just using the French philosopher as illustrating a wider point. :)

Certex's avatar

I find the modern self-loathing, self-flagellating white liberal guilt in America to be deeply, deeply troubling. It's coming from people who increasingly seem to be unhinged. Their whole 'born with the Original Sin of being white and thus worthless' schtick seems to me to be nothing more than a contemporary manifestation of the whole post-slavery notion that there will be a revenge race war in America, and the white folks are going to get murdered when it comes. Charles Manson preyed on the same crap in his own wee cult world.

Reading a grovelling, pandering, pathetic book by some mentally unbalanced snake oil saleswoman (she comes from a fucked-up background) won't save you from a never-coming race hate bullet, penitent and fearful whitey, trust me. Ironically, the anti-white racism that filth like this worthless book is perpetuating is starting to have real-world ramifications in race relations, allowing anti-white sentiment to be spoken much more freely, and this, in turn, ratchets up the race-revenge-based paranoia of the people who read this shit to 'absolve' themselves in the first place. What a finger-licking-good Kentucky Fried cluster fuck.

Unfortunately, this race hate contagion has infected the UK. A top-selling book on this increasingly race-fractured, fractious island (we always take our lead from across the Atlantic) recently was Why I’m No Longer Talking to White People About Race by a middle class black English writer named Reni Eddo-Lodge. I read as much of this race-hate-cum-anti-white-apologist book as I could. Ms. Eddo-Lodge posited in the text that the reason that Asian grooming gangs in the UK had picked on mostly white girls was because they had absorbed Western beauty standards, were brainwashed into finding white girls more attractive than brown-skinned girls, and thus raped vulnerable teens accordingly! At that point I roared and threw the fucking book across the room, for obvious reasons. I have no desire to read the twisted-mind ravings of a racist lunatic, no matter how critically feted she may be by fawning Guardian-reading, self-loathing sniffy liberal types.

All this racism, more and more pointed towards white people these days, is just divide-and-conquer swill, to give people a bogeyman (black or white) at different-coloured eye level to rail against, instead of looking up at the elites slowly and joyously strangling us all and fighting back against them. Idiots like Eddo-Lodge and DiAngelo make a bad sociological situation much, much worse, whether by accident or by design. And I don't know or care which one of these it is anymore. There's money in them thar race hate peddling. Sick of it all, top to toe, dick to dorsal.

Certex's avatar

Look at this woman's Wiki page photo. Note the cracks in the white paint in the background. It's like a naked representation of her psyche. She just looks plain nuts. Would you buy a used race hate ideology from this woman?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robin_DiAngelo