When contacted by press, YouTube admirably reversed bans and content removals involving a Canadian broadcaster. But the episode reveals the limits of algorithmic censorship
The video of that late night host calling Ivanka Trump "cunt" is still allowed. Or Stephen Colbert calling Trump Putin's Cock Holster. Or the thousands of videos of the russian collusion nonsense. Or the russian bounty nonsense.
Some of the brightest minds and smartest people go to work for companies like Facebook, YouTube, Google etc which spend every minute of their existence to figure out how to place an ad in front of our eyes for 1 more second.
That's how you know that some of the dumbest smart people end up controlling your speech too.
Same thing on Wall St. Did you read Antonio García Martínez book? There were times I got angry at his descriptions of FB and then I calmed myself with the fact that it is a confession. Very interesting book, especially the afterword to the 2nd edition.
I remember when someone programmed a bot to observe internet comments and respond like a “human” based on what it read/absorbed and with 36 hours it turned into a racist troll! It makes sense that an algorithm programmed by Alphabet/YouTube types would reflect their political nitwittery in it’s decisions.
STX... You realize Dennis Prager is as much a grifter as the Evangelicals pushing Trump down the throat of their followers. RIght? Prager U = Trum U aka Grifter U
That's irrelevant. Everyone's a grifter on both sides. What we are talking about here is that Prager U routinely gets censored for milquetoast stuff while corporate media gets to lie about everything.
None sense. The platform with his name on it funded by a billionaire pushing one thing and one thing only, lower taxes to the rich. The way they do it is to focus conservative voters on identity politics rather than economic policy.
The people on his platform are Grifters. They get paid by the click to push none sense meant to distract conservative voters away from the policy that Lobbyists are getting passed that has for 40yrs shifted GDP from the middle class and poor to the WEALTHY. (Trumps tax cut is the perfect example. Bailing out Banks is another one and the recent stimulus sending mostly going to large companies is another one, min wage, health care etc...)
His platform is to focus you on Woke Professors at Ivy League schools and Tranny's so you ignore how you are getting screwed by the Rich.
Censorship, blacklisting and persecution of dissenters is the biggest issue we face right now. It literally strikes at the foundations of our Democracy. It's shocking that the LEFT is willing to turn a blind eye to this out of disdain for Trump Supporters and any journalist capable of nuance. I think this extended to people like Alex Jones, who should not have been deplatformed for political beliefs, despite being fairly annoying.
My friend the LEFT - allowing for the modification of the definition of LEFT that Scott called out - is not just willing to turn a blind eye. They're the ones who are demanding that censorship, blacklisting, and persecution.
Indeed. Just one recent example: the entire DP leadership - as well as "thoughtful" hangers on like the Atlantic etc - all cheered on the complete, thorough & total elimination of Parler from the internet. There is no doubt that these last few years the Left, led by the DP, as Mr Taibbi has pointed out, is the greatest threat to freedom of speech.
ART- Matt has done an outstanding job of pointing out how the left is reducing freedom of speech. And in the process built a large audience of right wing fans.
If you have read his books he is equally harsh on the things the RIGHT has done regarding censorship and if you read his recent book Hate INC he interviews Noam Chomsky at the end and Chomsky clearly shows how the RIGHT is the far bigger threat to Censorship.
Think you missed something there: I agreed that Mr Taibbi has pointed out how most recently the Left, led by the DP, has been the greater threat to freedom of speech THESE LAST FEW YEARS. At no point did I attempt to exonerate the Right, which of course over different periods in years gone by has also been in favour of censorship in various areas of public life and threatened freedom of speech in the US. But we are talking about the very recent past .. and NOW! And what has been happening in the US, most especially this past year, is outrageous. I think it notable that Mr Taibbi, himself a man of the Left - but a man with principles and probity - has found it necessary to speak out. Likewise that other decent people "on the Left" - like Brett Weinstein and Glenn Greenwald (to pick out the first names which come to mind) - have been so disgusted by the actions of the broad Left that they too have felt the need to speak out. Most noteworthy too has been the manner in which these people from the Left have been smeared and vilified and instantly branded as "right wing" and "Trump-supporting", not only by the far left but also by many DP supporters.
As for your statement about Chomsky showing "how the Right is a far bigger threat to Censorship", I am afraid this is nonsense; or perhaps merely wishful thinking! (Incidentally, I presume you mean threat to freedom of speech; if the left or right were a "threat" to censorship that would be a good thing :-) ) The drive to censorship has nothing to do with "left" or right persuasion: the Soviet Union, the Japanese Empire, Communist China, Cuba, Nazi Germany, Venzuela, Franco's Spain, North Korea etc. etc. prove the fallacy of that assumption. The simple fact is that as soon as any political movement becomes ideological it attracts adherents who convince themselves that they are right about everything; and that anyone who disagrees with them is wrong and needs to be silenced. It is the mentality of the religious fundamentalist. Reason is thrown to the winds and political repression with varying degrees of violence follows. Arch thugs like Lenin, Hitler, Stalin and Mao are the finest examples of this trend of course. Incidentally, as pointed out in an earlier Taibbi post, I wouldn't put too much store by Chomsky in the area of censorship. A single example of his limited intellect & power of judgment is that for years he was a huge fan of Hugo Chávez: a man who once decreed that all TV stations broadcast his interminable speeches daily. I understand that between 15% and 20% of the total population of Venzuela has now left the wreck of a country Chávez and his followers bequeathed to them.
Again, a discussion completely derailed by people using "simplified" terminology.
In this case, "the right". When Piketty uses it, he means the evil, shadowy forces of power and wealth, funding grifters to indoctrinate ignorant rubes into believing things that are beneficial to their continued hold on that power and wealth.
When most of us use "the right", we mean ordinary citizens who feel they do not need to be highly educated to know they bear no racial animus, or to determine the biological sex of 98% of their fellow citizens* and who agree with the principle that the most productive should get the greater reward. Also, the people who view the fact that "bonds of family may interfere with loyalty to the state" (or "the cause") as a feature, not a bug.
Pretty small definitional overlap there, for the purposes of discussion or persuasion.
*-to be expressed, suppressed or satisfied howeverthefuck they want, no homophobe here, though that term (homophobe) is yet another that's been ginned-up as a tool for discussion avoidance.
RTF - Who are you talking about? Biden appointed Tim Wu and Lina Khan and they know more about what these companies are doing to censor than you and they are absolutely on the left.
Who to Trump, the right wing lunatic, put in power that did anything about these platforms? Name her? you cant. Sorry your claim is laughable
LOL you think Biden or democrats want Big Tech to not censor their opposition? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA You must still be waiting for that $2000 cheque or the $15 minimum wage or the medicare for all too....
CNN - I see that Biden actually hired the most well respected critics of big tech into his administration. Trump hired a bunch of industry hacks.
I have no idea what Wu and Khan will accomplish, they are going to be fighting the larges donors to politicians in DC.
Elizabeth Warren was appointed by Obama to fight the banks and they crushed her and got her thrown out. The banks got Katie porter thrown off of the finance committee after she chewed up their CEO's in public.
All i know is Democrats put heavy hitters out there to fight for consumers against these powerful entities. Republicans hire lobbyists like Mik Mulvaney and Ajit Pai to push the interests of big corporations over consumers.
No, the Democrats did not give enough support to people like Warren when she founded the consumer protection agency and they may not give Wu and Khan the support they need. But i do know that the MORE people we vote into office that think like Warren and Sanders and Porter and many others the more Support the Dems can give these people in fighting big business.
Let me know when the GOP start fighting big business because under Trump and Bush they did NOTHING to help consumers and far more than corrupt leaders like Pelosi and Schumer to help business. And Pelosi and Schumer are total corporate shills.
At least i know the battle and who we are fighting. You don't.
Anyone who imagines there is currently a single amerikan pol of true leftish bent in either the house of reps or the senate is a moronic pawn of amerikan indoctrination.
Calling the dims leftish is the equivalent of describing Robespierre as a monarchist.
I hold that big tech is overtly pushing the edicts of amerikan media that were oncemuch less obvious though they were practised.
I reckon this goes back to what Jays says alludes to in the Taibbi interview, that apart from shitty education, amerikans are frequently denied access to primary sources, that particular second-hand commentaries on historical events are permitted but access to the untainted, uninterpreted view of historical events us outright verboten.
Deb - It is 2021 not 1794 and the US is not a monarchy it is a representative democracy so a Robespierreian leader is not likely to appear in either the Republican or Democratic party, nor is one needed. In the 200yr history of this country th Rich and Powerful have many times purchased the government to subvert capitalism in favor of oligarchy. OUr system is set up to address such things if and only if American votes can UNITE to fight back.
Media and politicians that focus little on policy and strongly on why HATING the other side is all that matters (these people and media are on the left and right) are serving the overlords that want Oligarchy.
There have always been political leaders that are truly fighting for everyday Americans. But with out compromise they will never gain power.
Please name one Republican member of congress or the Senate that is FIGHTING for the economic well being of the POOR and MIDDLE CLASS and what policy they are fighting for to help the poor and middle class economically?
If you can't, and you can't then it will be clear where the few elected leaders are that are fighting for the economic well being of the poor and middle class and I can assure you that YOU PERSONALLY HATE them because of their identity politics. Right? If so, you are being played by the media. You know that right?
The irony (and there's so much of it!) is that many/most of such people don't even know who Robespierre was or that they're following in his footsteps to the point of unwittingly making of him their de facto "patron saint."
Todd - The Right is pushing censorship just as much as the left.
The FACT that you can't name any people that Trump brought in much less policy he got passed to reduce censorship proves you are INGORANCE on the issue.
Tim Wu and Lina Khan are more qualified to fight censorship than anyone Trump brought in and that is why Trump accomplished NOTHING to reduce it. Trump supports censorship just not against him, and you are the same. RIGH?
Tell me what Tim Wu and Lina Khan are doing to prevent said censorship.
Because I most recently heard of the White House providing "suggestions" to the tech platforms as to who might be good candidates for suppression. Maybe they weren't part of that, but I also didn't hear any outrage from them.
The Biden admin seems pretty clearly to be using those tech platforms to circumvent the First Amendment. Which is as clever as it is evil.
I really enjoy the way that wrongly informed ill-educated - through no fault of their own I must add, critics of my posts, always prove my point of view with their uninformed, always irrational replies, full of name calling ad hominems but light on logic.
However I am sure that their time would be more wisely spent educating themselves by searching out the primary sources of events which they have thus far only learned about via Tucker Carlson's or Rachel Maddow's paid deceits.
RTJ - Give me a break. The RIGHT turned a blind eye while Bush and Cheney lied through their teeth to get us into a war.
Both sides turn a blind eye when the other-side is censured.
And you are one of them. People of PRINCIPLE on censorship would see that the RIGHT is as guilty as the LEFT. You don't appear to be one of those people
I'm a single, no kids, pretty low-income, working class peasant. Lately i've been sort of toting things up over the last decade or two, and realizing that the Republicans, from W thru Trump, have actually been better for me financially than the Dems.
I didn't say "the economy". I said better for me as a low income person.
What's "the economy"? GDP? The Dow? Gains in GDP or the market all go to those at the top of the scale, increasing inequality.
You know what helps low-income people? Doubling the standard deduction, like Trump did in '17.
At the beginning of the pandemic, it was "quiet rooms", "i like to fire people", "low income people don't pay taxes" asset stripper Mitt Romney whose idea it was to get cash out to people ASAP. And Steve Mnuchin, who got it out fast. Nancy didn't want to do it. It was the Repubs who wanted the topoff to unemployment. Was also Mittens who wanted to give essential workers a $20/hr top off.
Last August when the $600 / wk topoff ended, Repubs tried to make various deals with Pelosi, who turned them all down. They wanted to pass a skinny bill, that would have at least given people a $300 / wk topoff. This deeply stupid woman (and the Senate) rejected it because they couldn't get the full what of the bill that they wanted. And tried to gaslight the desperate unemployed that nothing was better than $300. But at least Donald Trump got us $1800 from FEMA. Sure, the Dems extended the unemployment and added a $300 topoff in January when Joe got elected. Was too late for me and a lot of other people, mine expired in early Dec.
Those D House Reps that lost their seats last November? They were the centrists begging Pelosi to pass a skinny bill for their desperate constituents.
FOR. WHOM.? You average in all the millions and billions hoovered up by fund managers, CEOs, Big Tech, MIC, Walmart and Amazon, you may well have a statistical case. Buy the guy SAID "From my point of view as a sub-middle class individual citizen, it looks like".
Are you dismissing his lived experience?? Denying his truth? You are literally ERASING HIM!! REEEE!! Violence!!
First, you are the one introducing the concept of "shock". There is none in
my comment.
Second, the most hilarious arrogance in the world cannot compare to the act
of telling someone that you do not know, and will never meet, what they do or do not know, based upon a brief statement. About anything. You can tell me what you *assume, but please don't bother assuming to tell me what I know.
*Fairly annoying ? ;-D That observation, Sir, demonstrates more patience and milk of human kindness for whackery than Mother Teresa herself ever knew ! ;-D
I do, however, support the right of any fool to spew their logorrhea under the rights accorded them under the First Amendment. People such as myself (at least for now)
Pesce - Non sense. Low wages are causing Americans to live in utter poverty. And that has been happening for 40yrs now.
The US has had censorship issues since the beginning of the Republic. Censorship is ALWAYS a problem. But if you think Censorship of the RIGHT is the biggest problem while 70% of Americans are living pay check to pay check because of POLICY people like Obama and Trump pushed on America then you are clearly being manipulated by the media into IGNORING our biggest problems.
Yes, I think freedom is more primary to American life than wages rising. And FREEDOM is entirely integral to allowing Americans to succeed. You say censorship like it's nothing. Which just shows how blind people are. Without dissent there is no democracy.
You do not believe that the ability to freely speak and associate and begin endeavors with government restraint is a driver of innovation and the economy?
As someone from the Republican Right, my fear is that the Establishment Democrats and their allies in the media and big tech will misinterpret my side's arguments. You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for, then say that any effort to correct these arguments are lies and must be censored.
I think Paul Jay's arguments are nonsense; but he should be allowed to present them. My fear is that Jay will be allowed to present his arguments; but someone who argues that Trump's statements were not incitement to riot will be blocked. The ONLY version of this story that we will be allowed to hear is the one that wants to paint Trump and his allies as dangerous threats that must be silenced.
This will be great for the security state. How best to insure that their budgets are increased and the amount of resources allocated to them are increased: by making Americans feel that they are under threat. What better threat then to have 70 million of us declared a danger to America.
"You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for..."
Don't feel special. First of all, the Dems don't even know what they stand for. And they (and the GOP, to be fair) seem to think that folks like me, and Independent Bernie economic progressive, somehow want to defund the police and abolish ICE instead of just wanting some healthcare for all, affordable housing and a living wage.
You mean we think that people in your camp believe what many of them very openly declare that they believe?
Next thing you know we'll be telling you that your complete refusal to do anything less than give such people your full support constitutes tacit approval for their radicalism!
People in my camp? Yes, there is some overlap between some economic progressives, the defund / abolish crew, and the wokies. And absolutely between the wokies and the establishment Dems. Ever heard Bernie express support for abolish / defund? I haven't. Never heard him wade into the CRT cesspool either.
Bernie regularly engages in identity politics which is basically CRT. He even called Orange Man a xenophobe and said he wouldn't have shutdown travel from China. He said: "I wouldn't have closed the air traveling with China if I was a president. Trump is racist xenophobic."
Bernie also supports the AOC/Cori Bush squad who regularly exploit identity politics / defund the police nonsense while giving themselves more police funding. So claiming he doesn't wade into CRT is false.
One of the best things against Bernie Sanders is that he used to complain about illegal immigration being "right wing proposals". Until 2016. We all know what changed in 2016 when Orange Man announced his run. Bernie used to hate illegal immigration, called it a “right wing proposal” “using a dollar or two wages to drive down wages of Americans”. And then he did a flip calling Orange Man a racist and xenophobic etc and became open border advocate. Just listen to his own words in this VOX interview and tell me how what he used to say was any different from Orange Man and how he's now done a full 180:
Bernie Sanders attacked the socialist Liberty Union Party in 1981 for accommodating the 351 Jamaican immigrants in his state's apple orchards: "With the Vermont unemployment rate one of the highest in the nation, I could never support importing foreign workers when our own people are out of work." ... "It sounds like she wants to bring slavery back to Vermont." said Sanders, who was collecting unemployment insurance at the time. For socialist Sanders, then 33, the situation supported his contention that businesses were yet again selling out U.S. residents in favor of cheap labor.
Even in 2007, he said:
“If poverty is increasing and if wages are going down, I don’t know why we need millions of people to be coming into this country as guest workers who will work for lower wages than American workers and drive wages down even lower than they are right now,” Sanders said. ” … On one hand, you have large multinationals trying to shut down plants in America, move to China, and on the other hand, you have the service industry bringing in low-wage workers from abroad. The result is the same: Middle class gets shrunken, and wages go down.”
"I think as you've heard today, sanctions against employers who employ illegal immigrants is virtually nonexistent. Our border is very porous," Sanders said during a press conference at the time. “And I think at a time when the middle class is shrinking, the last thing we need is to bring over in a period of years, millions of people into this country who are prepared to lower wages for American workers." "I think from a moral responsibility, we've got to work with the rest of the industrialized world to address the problems of international poverty," he said in a 2015 interview. "But you don't do that by making people in this country even poorer." In both cases, Sanders defended his vote by suggesting that the guest worker provisions in the bill were “akin to slavery,” a notable shift from how Sanders talked about immigrant labor before his presidential bids.
Again in 2013:
"I'll tell you look what my concern is the provisions dealing with the guest worker programs. Real unemployment in America counting those people have given up looking for work and are working part-time when they want to work full-time in order is close to 14 percent. It's higher for young people it is higher for people of color. You have in this bill guest worker programs that will bring in hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers. You know on television you hear these guys talk about all PhDs are coming into this country....hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers to work in kitchens waiters waitresses lifeguards ski resort workers. Is it really true that we can't find American workers to do those jobs? Frankly I don't believe it.
Given the magnitude of the problem it doesn't go anywhere near far enough so the nation we have got to ask ourselves do we really need when you go to ghettos in this country when you go to inner cities you have thirty forty percent unemployment do we really need hundreds of thousands of workers entry-level workers from around the country coming in competing against these kids? I think not."
Even the leftist washington post admits: "For years, Bernie Sanders warned that increased immigration would lower the wages of U.S. workers. Now he barely mentions it.":
But when Trump ran in 2015, he switched and became radical open border. He says "Illegal immigrants are "entitled" to the same government benefits as citizens":
This flip flopping and pie in the sky promises are quite natural for Bernie Sanders. Mr $15 an hour Bernie Sanders refused to pay his staff $15 because his campaign couldn't afford to. He has been a Vermont senator for 30+ years! The min wage in Vermont is still $10.
Bernie's hotel demands from his “Senator Comfort Memo”: King-size beds and 60-degree rooms. He flies on private jets and has a memo detailing minimum requirements of the private jet. He used to complain about millionaires and billionaires. Until 2 years ago when he became a millionaire. Then only the billionaires were the problem for him. You can verify this by going through his twitter history. The "millionaires and billionaires" change to "billionaires" only. He released his tax returns couple years ago. For someone complaining so much about poor people suffering, he barely paid anything in charity from his multi millions. For someone who's so anti-pharma, Bernie still gladly took $1.3 million from Pharma. Orange Man got $2.5 million and Biden took $8.5 million:
Bernie, "mr. anti-big-pharma" took $1,301,155 from Big Pharma in 2020. He was also the number 1 recipient in the senate for pharma manufacturing in 2020 by getting $416,066, Ossoff, Jon was second with $302,137, Elizabeth Warren got $291,168. Thom Tillis was 4th got $270,270 and Mitch McConnell was 5th at $265,980:
Why would pharma manufacturing give the most money to Bernie and other democrats and more than Mitch and Lindsey Graham? Kindness of their heart?
Bernie endorsed Biden after getting fucked in his ass twice by the DNC. He couldn't grow up a spine to call out Biden's and his son's obvious corruption, instead he called him a good friend and respectable man. You think such a spineless man could stand up to foreign nations?
Unlike Bernie who rolled over at the very first sight, Orange Man at least put up a fight and won the nomination. Imagine Bernie rolling over like that to foreign nations. He got "cheated" out twice from the nomination and he rolled over without a fight - maybe because this was the plan all along for Democrats to use him to get the left to vote for Biden. Then he refused to look at the "cheating" allegations from Orange Man. He called Biden his friend and respectable man. Didn't even have the balls of calling out his obvious selling out to China and his son using his office for profit. Now he's going on CNN making excuses on why they couldn't get $15 minimum wage, why $2000 has still not gone out, why $1400 is more than enough instead of the $2000 they promised, why medicare for all is now too hard to achieve. And his supporters thought Bernie would care about them LMFAO. When his supporters couldn't wake up to how big of a pathetic cuck Bernie was when he gave up his mic to the 2 BLM activists at his own rally, how he did a full 180 flip on illegal immigration when Orange Man ran, then nothing will wake them up.
I am surprised it took this long for people to see through AOC and Bernie. Bernie was always in on it with the establishment dems from the beginning. I was mostly politically uneducated till 2015 but even then I was able to see through Bernie sanders fraud when he did a complete 180 flip on his stance on illegal immigration. Bernie is there to tell you nice things to get votes for Democrats. He was never there to win. Bernie tells people pie in the sky dreams to siphon votes to the Democrats. That's it.
"there is some overlap between some economic progressives, the defund / abolish crew, and the wokies. And absolutely between the wokies and the establishment Dems"
I would argue that the Establishment Dems have gone all in on Wokeness because it's a convenient deflection from actual economic issues. "Watch that squirrel!"
Perhaps not. But they "know," "stand for" and agree on this much: get Trump, before any others, whatever the costs to the law, principle, our electoral rules or democratic heritage (such as it is), just "get Trump"--lie, cheat, and steal to do it.
"Don't feel 'special'"?!?
The point is rather that Sanders proved unable to effectively counter the misrepresentation of his positions. That's a fatal failing in _ANY_ open, democratic electoral system because it's a given that one's opponents--especially if one is honest--shall defame and misrepresent you.
Trump, one of the most savagely defamed political figures in U.S. history, still won two presidential election and should, today, be in office, except for the blatant electoral fraud that is finally becoming apparent even to many of his former detractors.
Clearly, whether one likes or agrees with Trump the man or the office-holder is beside the point. If he gets the most votes in a fair, open contest under the rules as all parties understood them---not under a criminal conspiracy to thwart his election through ballot fraud--then one is obliged to respect that electoral outcome---or be exposed as an enemy of democratic processes per se.
Sanders' supporters certainly feel "special": specially disgruntled, specially entitled, specially hurt that their candidate, in two efforts (the 2016 and 2020 primaries), in failed to defeat what were thought by many (and, in the first case, thought _especially_ by his own partisans) to be two of the worst candidates for the office of president of the United States in the history of the nation, Hillary Clinton in the first case and Joe Biden in the second.
LOL! Here's "special" for you:
(quote)
... "on July 25, during which he gave Clinton his full support. Some of his supporters attempted to protest Clinton's nomination and booed when Sanders called for party unity. He responded, "Our job is to do two things: to defeat Donald Trump and to elect Hillary Clinton … It is easy to boo, but it is harder to look your kids in the face if we are living under a Trump presidency." ... (Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernie_Sanders#Primary_loss_and_endorsement_of_Hillary_Clinton)
(end quote)
(quote)
" (CNN) Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders on Monday endorsed former Vice President Joe Biden for president, pledging to help him defeat President Donald Trump in the general election as the two agreed to launch a series of task forces to work jointly on policy matters.
" 'We need you in the White House. I will do all that I can to see that that happens, Joe,' Sanders said to Biden during a livestream broadcast by Biden's campaign on his website and on social media.
"The endorsement of Biden by his leading Democratic rival marks a key moment for Democrats as the party seeks to unify and turn its focus toward a November match-up with President Donald Trump.
"Sanders' quick endorsement of Biden in mid-April, just five days after he suspended his campaign, was a stark contrast to the 2016 Democratic race, when Sanders continued to battle Hillary Clinton into June and waited until July to endorse her.
"This time, the former vice president and the Vermont senator sought to immediately address the distrust some of Sanders' supporters have for Biden after a primary campaign in which the two repeatedly clashed on issues like foreign policy and health care.
" 'I think that your endorsement means a great deal,' Biden said. 'It means a great deal to me. I think people are going to be surprised that we are apart on some issues but we're awfully close on a whole bunch of others.'"...
(end quote)
We now have the living proof (which only the most obtuse required) of Biden's incompetence: noticed how Afghanistan took Biden only 8 months to lose to the Taliban? 20 years and a Trillion (est. ) U.S. $ spent: down the spout. Never mind, we have a "nice guy" once more in the White House. That Biden was a fucking fool and a push-over wasn't for a moment lost on them. Nor did the teeming North-bound Central and South Americans eager to take their places as the newest illegal immigrants to the U.S.. massed at the Mexican border, fail to notice.
First of all, I think you need to relax. You're way overthinking my comment, which was me cracking a joke. And was not intended as a bid for being the winner in the victim Olympics. With a serious undertone, and aimed at the Dems, not Trump supporters.
The point being that the Dems have no business whatsoever dissing any voters. If for no other reason, the simple one is that they need the votes. For those of us who supported Bernie, they expected and felt entitled to our votes. For Trump supporters, they need those votes in swing districts. And trashing the voters is absolutely not the way to get them. Considering they lost centrist House seats in swing districts, you'd think they would have learned a lesson. I'm not rating their odds, either in the midterms or in '24.
I always love it (sarc.) when in a forum such as this a reader tells me I "need to relax" or that I'm "overthinking" his or her point.
You were (merely) cracking a joke? Try labeling them for your reader's benefit.
I "overthought" your point?
I thought I'd understood it rather clearly. Your words in answer to this, from "Hugh Fifth of Five", (which you directly cited),
(quote)
Hugh 5th of 5
Aug 11
"As someone from the Republican Right, my fear is that the Establishment Democrats and their allies in the media and big tech will misinterpret my side's arguments. You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for, then say that any effort to correct these arguments are lies and must be censored." ...
(end quote)
were, hardly surprisingly, also, in so many words, "relax". That seems to be your boiler-plate retort--(when you have nothing better?)
I misread, "overthought", these, your words,
"Don't feel special"
?
I gather that was to say, in effect, "Take a number, pal."--or, in other words, "Yes, you and millions of others". You don't so much dispute Hugh Fifth of Five as advise him not to take it so hard; apparently because you think that the hordes of company ought to give him some sort of comfort.
And, there, you "underthink" _my_ point: Hugh's candidate (and mine) _won_ the fucking White House--and lost that to a criminal conspiracy which was mounted against him to thwart his deserved re-election.
None of _that_ happened to any candidate _you_ supported, as far as I can tell. In this light, then, I think that there's nothing about your comments, from which you now sheepishly run with the claim that you were "joking", which you can (honestly) show I actually misread or misconstrued.
No, the trouble here is that I got exactly what you meant the _first_ time. And it was cheap and undeserved--toward Hugh Fifth of Five and everyone else like him, myself included.
"Dissing" voters is poor practice? Coming from you, that's another "joke".
Know it or not, you "dissed" Hugh. And that's not just my "overthinking" it.
"noticed how Afghanistan took Biden only 8 months to lose to the Taliban?"
The US has been losing to the Taliban for 20 years. This one ain't on Biden; he wanted us to get out when he was still VP. Barack rolled over for the generals, as always (Trump did too).
Riddle me this; why is it important for the US to occupy Afghanistan? What justifies the expenditure of money and American lives (to say nothing of Afghan lives; they will be expended whether or not we are there) over the course of two decades?
I think it's on Biden. Not on getting out (which i'm in full agreement with), but for quite obviously doing it without a workable plan. Seems to me that it was more important to be symbolic about it (ie getting out by Sept 11), then by having a realistic and workable plan to execute. Which would have included getting the Afghans who helped us all of these years out first, and for planing for the inevitablity of the Taliban moving in quickly to fill the gaps.
Both Greenwald and Turley, both civil liberties lawyers, said that Trump's speech was legal; he didn't actually tell them to go storm the Capitol, and may have been pretty surprised when they did. As were they. When I read the key passages, i thought that, yes, he was inciting something, but apparently he had good legal advice. Of course, his job leading a rally is to get everybody revved up; whether that's '"incitement" is in the eye of the beholder.
Other than the speech not inciting violence (It's like saying "While Fighting the Virus, We Must Fight for Our Rights." or "We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic" - these don't mean fighting as in violence).
Plus speeches like Maxine Watters' "Maxine Waters encourages supporters to harass Trump administration officials" or during the Chauvin trial "Waters calls for protesters to 'get more confrontational' if no guilty verdict is reached in Derek Chauvin trial" are a lot more "incitement".
And why were the anti-kavanaugh protestors who stormed the capitol and senate chambers all encouraged by Democrats - Pelosi, AOC etc treated differently as compared to the Trump supporters:
Anyone remember when Rand Paul was swarmed by people demanding he say Breonna Taylor’s name after he wrote the Justice for Breonna Taylor Act?
Or the riots last year encouraged and bailed out by Kamala?
Other than all this, the bigger fact which no one seems to mention is that Trump's speech could not have caused the capitol riot because the capitol was stormed before Trump was even done speaking 40 minutes away from the capitol.
I watched it all go down live. Trump was speaking till 1:11PM and on stage till 1:15PM. Capitol was breached at 12:40PM according to WaPo (anti trump source). It is nearly 1.5mi from the Ellipse to the Capitol, which is at least 40-45 min walk with crowd-related delays, that would put the first people from Trump’s speech at Capitol Hill no earlier than 1:56pm – a full hour and sixteen minutes after troublemakers arrived.
And while the Washington Post clumsily attempts to blame President Trump for the violence...their own article admits the first wave of protesters arrived at the Capitol about 12:40pm.
Anyone who claimed his speech was inciting anything at the Capitol is hiding the truth that the Capitol was breached 45 minutes before Trump's speech ended and 40 minute walk away.
Even Twitter performed all sorts of mental gymnastics to claim Trump incited violence even though they couldn't pin point a single place where he did.
Trump could not have been *that surprised that his mob went down there, the man *literally told the mob "You need to fight like hell ..." and later, "I'll be right there with you." Then the consistent coward, (pleading "Bone Spurs" ? ;-D ) turned tail and went back to the White house to watch the whole thing on TV.
Quickly then, the GOQ goes into the childish defense mode right up there with the classic of childish defense mode: "The dog ate my homework", and busts out with:
"y'all didn't *really see what was being clearly broadcast all over the world. It didn't happen, y'all. You were just havin' an acid flash back."
Know what ? The arguably best version of the movie "Gaslight", the Charles Boyer/Ingrid Bergman version, came out in 1944. The youngsters in elite colleges today *are given school credit for sitting around watching "The Honeymooners". Maybe we need to improve their taste in classic movies.
Judging from many entries on this queue, apparently some commenters on the Right have either never *seen "Gaslight", and are thus *themselves victims of the propaganda technique simply repeating what they have heard, and what they want
to believe; or they are busting their humps in a conscious effort to "Gaslight" others.
Attempting to convince the viewing world that they did not *SEE what was being clearly broadcast is just a lame stab out of some class called "Gaslighting 101".
If anybody *does hope to convince others that they didn't see what they *saw, put a little love behind the lies. Put some effort into it ! Get *good at what you are attempting to accomplish. So far, even Goebbels is embarrassed.
Without question, Jackie was a *master, and a great nostalgic kick from my childhood. He, Art Carney, and Audrey Meadows had perfect comic timing.
The show was great, but the show was *entertainment. Entertainment more than has a place in the human experience, but NOT when one is paying Harvard tuition for watching it, and receiving Harvard Credits that are "equal" to Harvard Credits, in, say quantum physics.
This practice also seriously dumbs-down U.S. Students relative to students from the rest of the globe. Watching B&W TV is what college students used to do while they were *skipping the serious classes that either they, or their parents were paying for.
The problem is when he saw what was happening - he reportedly enjoyed it immensely - if it was not what he at least hoped would happen - he could well have called for it to stop immediately ....
Oh, give me a break - "Stop the Steal! - so how to do that, at that time, in that place - keep the electoral votes from being certified - this is not rocket science ....
If you think "Stop the Steal!" somehow means inciting violence, then you must think "We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic" must be inciting a war....
That day, Ted Cruz was proposing a 10 day delay in certifying the electoral votes so an audit could be performed in those 10 days. Seems like such basic things are rocket science for you?
It's such a snooze, this whole who's worse: Trump or Sanders; McConnel or Pelosi; Stalin or Hitler. Don't y'all get bored with the lack of new information uncovered in these arguments? Or is not about accumulating information and just about scoring points like in a public school debating society or cricket match?
The whole thing puts me *heavily in mind of Plato's "Cave Allegory" contained in his work "The Republic." Plato describes society as being in the bottom of a cave, seated chained in a circle with their backs facing the center of the cave. In that center is a large fire. Between that fire and the chained society are unseen, and unnamed beings who use forms to project shadows on the wall past the society. Chained as society is, with their backs to the center, all they see their entire lives are the shadows being cast upon the wall in front of them. So, society competes (being human) on the progression of the shadows, betting on which (of a limited number) of the shadows will be coming up next. For their entire lives .... they bicker about shadows being produced by the controllers in the center. But Society thinks that the shadows are all there *IS in life, and they therefore make no attempt to seek for truth *beyond the "Shadow World", or the "Shadow Game". The shadow world is Plato's stand-in for the world of 3-D reality. The rest of the allegory goes on to illustrate what it means to finally break away, beyond that limitation.
Sometimes this queue (which is actually the most intellectual comment queue I have come across, because I am quite social media "shy" [averse]), reminds me for all the world of Plato's "Shadow Game". Plato wrote that 2,400 years ago. Society has not changed one scintilla since. Better technology, different clothes, but still stuck playing by the rules of the "Shadow Game". Breaking those chains, and escaping the Shadow World is the goal Plato proposed for his students. Even Plato understands that very few will succeed.
The Republican Right is a very small group if you exclude all the blow hards that claim to be conservative, but are actually just self serving assholes.
Most Americans belong to the authoritarian party. They call themselves Left or Right, but it only takes me about 2 questions to identify which opposition they want censored and locked in cages.
As a lifelong leftist -- whatever that is supposed to mean any more (people who are willing to work should be able to earn a living wage?) I am sympathetic to this viewpoint.
“Jay similarly believed Trump’s speech was perhaps designed to incite a destabilizing moment during which acting Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller could declare martial law. The fear …..”.
Jay “believed” a speech was “perhaps designed…. ? Perhaps, perhaps not? Perhaps Jay’s a twit, perhaps he isn’t! 50/50.
Are we supposed to take him seriously? If so, to what end? Perhaps we will never know …..; perhaps.
I take him seriously. He's done a tons of great stuff.
Do you know the piece? I've listened to it twice. Once when it was new and the other time a couple of weeks ago. Jay's interpretation of Trump's behavior is worth considering. Who knows what any of Trump's actual intentions are? (Assuming there's enough coherence to his intentions to talk about meaningfully about them.) I think Jay's idea fits as well as any other.
I'm actually anti-conspiracy theory on the merits. It's too easy to make one up. My wife is really into them, though. But she also believes in homeopathy and Reiki. I think it's a brain chemistry thing.
This is the first I’ve heard of him. Personally I don’t find Trump’s intentions to be any more or less coherent/incoherent than BO, GW or any other politician’s intentions; they all want to get reelected.
Of course, what could have some bearing on that is I don’t have an out of control hatred for any of them. Might it be you and your ilk hold Trump to a different standard?
Perhaps it wasn’t intentional, perhaps it was, but it’s interesting you didn’t address the suggestion you hold Trump to a different standard from say BO and other Presidents.
As for question about your ilk, I defer to the accurate assessment provided by ruralbob.
I didn’t name anyone, but a noticeable portion of people who post here sure give the appearance of being driven by an out of control hatred for Trump. Without knowing anything about Tom, other than his statement about Trump’s coherence, perhaps it is easy to conclude Tom falls into that category.
As for having said hatred, that’s cool, it’s cool as long as one acknowledges it. It’s those who possess it yet try to pass themselves off as reasoned thinkers of the day, who induce out of control laughter, as opposed to out of control hate.
Personally I consider the past several presidents to be revolting trash, but their significance to my daily life is nil, thus perhaps they are not worth the time and trouble to hate.
Doesn't matter: He should be free to speak his mind and report what he wants to, even on a so-called "private platform" that makes a killing on selling people's information publicly by data mining every keystroke, photo, linked friend, private message, etc.
It'll never happen before the end of it all though, so don't hold your breath.
I agree with you on that. The problem is that we seem to be willing to give the luxury of free speech to our opponents but our opponents don't want to give us the same luxury. And this luxury is supposed to be a fundamental liberty.
I agree completely. I would never propose squelching his, or anyone’s voice, even though I personally may see nothing worth noting from his/their efforts. Perhaps ….. ⛳️
What Jay doesn't mention is that the fear he was victim to, and that much of Washington was victim to that week, the fear of a military coup, CAUSED Jan. 6.
The people responsible for the decision to not have the National Guard deployed, the Sgts at Arms of both the House and Senate (and Miller himself, incidentially) testified before congress that the reason they did not deploy the National Guard was to avoid the optics that Trump would attempt a military coup. And no National Guard meant the Capitol Police were overrun. TDS FTW, once again!
Fake fear, no less. They'd talked themselves into a tizzy over nothing and reaped the whirlwind.
Besides which, they deserved every iota of the election fraud thing. 4 years of bullshit collusion claims, one good turn deserves another. This election fraud thing is going to last a lot longer than 4 years, though. All the Jan 6 whining in the world won't make the doubt go away - the more it is censored and the debate is put off, the more the doubt grows.
At first I thought Russiagate was just desserts for birtherism, as turnabout is fair play, but the emergence of blatantly illegal intelligence community and law enforcement activity changed that.
I still can't believe they just all freaking wiped or dumped their phones and got away with that. There's so much, but that just gets me. Professionals who know exactly what they are doing colluding to destroy evidence and getting away with it scot free.
This is a version of how Weimar went south. More and more extralegal stuff "temporarily" in use just to stabilize things, from a certain party's vantage point. Then people later took that as a precedent to do more extralegal stuff until that was all that was left.
Standard military ops ! Raid the village, poison the water well with dead animals.
Correct you are. This will last a LONG time, and that is partly why it was undertaken to begin with. This is too well planned, and too long range even to be blamed on Trump, personally.
Now wouldn't that be simple. But no, I don't know what happened in the election. That's humility and integrity right there. The thing that the media and apparently you don't have. What I do have is lots of schadenfreude.
You see, the only thing that would defuse this thing would be a pants down audit of the whole process. The one thing that won't be done. So it's going to keep festering - past the midterms, past 2024. The media and you can say it's a lie all you want - it just feeds into the impression of dishonesty created by the unwillingness to audit. This is politics 101, folks. The silencing of Trump fits right in with this.
Just enjoying the spectacle of people hoist on their own petard. A real Pyrrhic victory, 2020 was.
"to avoid the optics that Trump would attempt a military coup."
Really ? And while worrying about "saving face" countless people *could literally have been dying inside ? THAT sounds like a weak-kneed "the dog ate my homework" level cop-out than *any kind of "tight combat readiness strategy". This clearly did *not result as the result of a "comedy of errors" - it was planned. Poorly planned, granted, but no "accident" nonetheless.
It's a futile attempt to avoid the illegitimacy of the current government. Futile, I say, because sniping at one or the other candidates isn't going to settle the legitimacy question. With the Democrats putting their fingers in their ears and saying "HR 1, HR 1" and the Republicans in their usual supine position, don't expect a solution anytime soon. An actual statesman would be nice right about now.
Absolutely correct, yes. Sniping at the individual candidates is like walking up to a cauldron of boiling water, and trying to push all of the *bubbles down.
Perhaps I’m wrong, after all, it’s bound to happen eventually 🍺, but maybe you think you get muddled answers because your question are a bit muddled. That is if they resemble this particular post.
Am I correct in concluding you are of the opinion the government bureaucrats, the Biden administration and Big Phrama, who claim all is well with the vaccines, are accurately telling the facts?
That, of course, would imply, perhaps, you conclude anyone who disagrees with the afore mentioned cabal, errr I mean concerned benefactors, are little more than narrow-minded conspiracy theorist?
"...I see the vaccine working..." Really? You SEE it working? Personally?
You invoke--saying you subscribe to--Occam's razor. Very well. I suppose you're also familiar, then, with the phrase "Post hoc. ergo propter hoc" to describe the logical fallacy in which you're wallowing here.
I hear people assure me with no less confidence than yours that they "See Jesus working." What do you say to such people?
Superstitions come in all kinds of colors and flavors.
Consider: might not the marked fall off in infections, hospitalizations and deaths due to this virus not be just as plausibly accounted for by the simple fact that it has already killed millions around the world?--those, by chance, (never mind their demographic profile) ipso facto, "most vulnerable"?
What, if anything, do you do with this? I? It gives me pause.
Maybe it ought to give you pause. There's another latin phrase, this one taught early in medical school: "Primum non nocere." it means that, where one lacks genuine understanding based on empirically-based knowledge, not hopes or guess-work, one refrains rather than leaps ahead.
Where Covid vaccines are concerned, the health-care profession forgot its creeds and leapt.
No kudos to YouTube for responding to queries only when they come from a high-profile journalist. That's a sign of their corruption and the corruption of our elected officials for allowing them to become so powerful.
Here is the algorithm. Is the information put out by our friends? Yes...It's OK regardless of content. No....even though it is exactly what our friends claim it must be banned. And by friends we mean people or groups that when we lobby they gives us what we want, or we sure did enjoy the cocktail party the other night. Wasn't it fun disparaging all those deplorables. Fuck Google and YouTube. There are alternatives. Brave and Odysee.
Don't be a racist bigot. The systemically oppressed Obamas were just hosting a small sophisticated unmasked party of over 500 celebrities at their systemically oppressed $15 million mansion along the beach which is supposed to be under water because of all the climate change and rising sea water.
John Kerry, US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate Change, who owns beach front property (rising sea levels????), flew in his private jet (CO2 emissions????) to attend systemically oppressed Obama's birthday party at his $15 million beach front property (rising sea levels????).
Marie Antoinette was actually responding to an artificially imposed bread quota put in place by the French government to raise prices. If you got to the braisserie too late and the day’s quota of bread was already sold, you had to buy cake instead.
2 --DNC oligarchs (Biden, Pelosi, Schumer) are even WORSE (censorship, they concocted Russia-gate hoax, torture of Julian Assange, Daniel Hale’s persecution for Obama’s drone crimes, $16B Haiti-corruption under Hillary/Obama – Biden-family corruption pales in comparison)
The ONLY solution – vote THIRD party – now and forever. ALWAYS vote – but VOTE for a Third (or fourth, fifth..) party – at ALL levels, especially at LOCAL levels (vote OUT each and every incumbent).
“If you always vote for the lesser of two evils, you will always have evil, and you will always have less.” [Ralph Nader].
Only ACTION: Sustained organized mass civil disobedience - not distractions like DNC-controlled hollering and tweeting....
I wonder about the wisdom of the whole content moderation thing. Terrorist beheadings and kiddie porn, sure. Block 'em. No problem. But I'm not sure Youtube is actually changing minds for the better by silencing political views it disapproves of, especially if they're widely held. Doesn't matter if they're right or wrong, true or not. The very fact of these large, powerful, well resourced institutions presuming to decide on "truth" and what we're allowed to hear, consider, think about or believe just amplifies the rampant distrust and conspiracy mongering. It convinces nobody. It just produces backlash.
It's highly cynical, actually. The logic is that if they stupids don't see the things that Youtube's masters don't like, they'll forget about that stuff.
And no, it doesn't work, at least the way they want it to. It further radicalizes people.
I’m glad someone mentioned “terrorist beheadings”. Imagine for a minute that YouTube allowed that and, to generate some revenue, put ads up between victims. Disgusting, right? Now, go to YouTube and search “AC-130 gunship”. You’ll be treated to gun camera footage of human beings being slaughtered like fish in a barrel. It’s mesmerizing until you remember it’s not some video game. While being declared “enemies” of the USA, making them “fair game”, the victims are still someone’s son, father, or husband. And YouTube throws up ads. YouTube’s supposed “standards” are disgusting.
Bu,bu,but - they're the "bad guys", right? and I am sure AI has no problem with killing the "bad guys" - after all it deals with the data fed to it ....
I think it's less a wisdom an more a natural logic. The internet monopolies are trying to defend their business. In a simplistic model they are trying to balance two goals. One we can understand as the PR goal of being allowed to maintain their legally tenuous monopoly privileges, the loss of which has a $ value they can estimate. The other is ad revenue minus operating cost.
The PR part could be pretty complicated but so far these firms seem to be simply following the preferences of lamestream news media. Youtube in particular has explicitly stated that's how they do it.
So it doesn't make any sense as an editorial policy serving a social good and any coherent of "wisdom" you may discern, if any, has to be an emergent property.
Yes, so far both the Lamestream and the New Secular Moralists (of all stripes, including MT/TK) have made hay by pointing at these patterns and declaring validation or shenanigans resp. but this could easily change.
Honestly, I know it is popular with the social media set to toss around insurrection, coup, and rebellion. But, nothing of the sort was planned, organized or acted upon. Milley is a delicate flower - and partisan. Those how opposed Trump - and many of the top brass did - came up with all kinds of loose talk claiming a coup was in process. Trump felt the election was stolen; and then felt he could capitalize on this when the facts did not fully back him up.
But in their defense, the Trump campaign filed dozens of cases and not one, not one, was heard on the merits. All were tossed out for standing, lack of claim, and other procedural matters. What is a shame is we know there was some election ‘irregularities’ and we know there is little cooperation to get to the bottom of these. This legitimizes Trump’s claims - as does Facebook when is censors Trump or election discussion.
I have lived through an insurrection. Insurrectionists bring guns, tanks, and rocket launchers. They are organized and generally funded. Our insurrectionists were a bad version of Animal House. Rowdy, loud, and lost.
Milley and the silly social media set need to stop pretending the Republic almost fell and face facts. This was a temper tantrum.
The best description for January 6th was a "riot."
The Florida Recount, Brooks Brothers Riot, and SCOTUS decision in 2000 smells a more like a coup to me. Had the unfortunate characteristic of being successful too.
Copy pasting an old comment. This is not specific to you, it's just relevant to your question.
Democrats spent over 40 million and 3 years chasing some russian collusion, then inventing russian bounty hoaxes but somehow any audit or signature matching is not allowed in 2020. Pathetic hypocrisy.
Democrats being against voter id clearly tells me they enjoy cheating. It's like opposing ID for buying cigarettes or booze and then claiming no underage kid ever bought a cigarette or booze. Monmouth University released a poll on early voting and voter ID. The poll found the majority of Americans support voter ID, and more minorities support voter ID than white people. Question 31 on page 7: 84% of minorities. & 77% of white people support voter ID. Yet Democrats keep claiming voter id is somehow racist:
I can present hundreds of examples but I don't think it's worth it because nobody's mind will change. I like how everyone agrees Bernie got cheated out twice, DNC using the IOWA "app" to cheat again and somehow the general election was perfectly cool. I will give a few examples for the audience here:
I am sure these types of vote counts where a candidate make vertical jumps in multiple states after vote counting has stopped and at 4am when Republican observers have been sent home is totally cool:
I am sure the 6000 votes which was exposed to have been switched from Trump to Biden in Antrim County and similarly in GA - all mistakes in one direction - was totally cool:
The typical excuses I hear when I point out how Biden won as "the most popular president with 12 million more votes than Obama" and yet couldn't get 10 people at his rallies is "Because Biden voters believe in science and didn't want to go out during a pandemic" to which I reply with "Then why did his YouTube videos and live streams also not get any views and got ratioed to the point where YouTube has to actively remove dislikes?
130 Thousand dislikes were removed in a 24hr period! And this is for the most popular US President of all time!
Another response is "Trump's personality cost him the election" to which I reply with "Trump has a in party approval of 95% - highest EVER" and Republicans gained tons of house seats and even state house and senate seats. So somehow people were voting for republicans but not for Trump despite him having 95% approval? It's the opposite - people voted for Republican house and senate BECAUSE Trump asked them too. It's been shown time and time again that the constituents like Trump, they hate the establishment RINOs. Hence the 95% approval in his party.
Usually first-time mail voters ~3X more likely to spoil ballot. In GA 2016 whopping 6.4% failed, 2020 just 0.2%. In PA, rate 0.03% in 2020 vs ~1% in 2016. Nevada from 1.60% in 2016 to ~0.75% this year. N.C. rate ~2.7% in 2016 to 0.8%. Totally cool.
Biden somehow gets 12 million more votes but only in VERY select few cities - enough to push him over in the entire state. And somehow ends up losing house seats, state house, senate seats. And Trump - who's the first Republican to make major gains in blacks and hispanics, his party makes major gains everywhere from house seats to state senate races loses.
Bellwether Counties Went Overwhelmingly for Trump in 2020. All but one of the 19 bellwethers picked President Donald Trump by a margin of some 16 points on average. They all accurately picked the president since 1980. Before the elections, here's NYTimes claiming:
> "The 10 Bellwether Counties That Show How Trump Is in Serious Trouble. Each one is in a battleground state. Votes from people there will matter a lot — and offer Joe Biden several paths to victory. Conversely, Mr. Trump would likely need to win at least eight of those 10 states for a second term. A look at these bellwethers — all either tossups or leaning toward Mr. Biden — makes clear that Mr. Trump is in serious trouble." NYTimes was claiming Biden will easily win thw bell weathers too.
Once the elections were over and all but one bell weather county that had chosen every presidential winner since 1980 went for President Trump in 2020, suddenly "bellwether counties are not a good way of indicating". HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAAHAA whatever doesn't fit the narrative suddenly becomes unreliable.
I am sure those perfectly coordinated stopping of counting in the 6 states on election night was totally cool.
I am sure the GA "pipe burst" which was widely claimed as the reason for stopping counting at 10:30PM in Fulton and used to send observers home - and then for the black chick and her daughter to pull out a box with ballots and re-scan the same ballots 4 times all on video was all just totally cool. And guess what - that pipe burst story also turned out to be completely false - in fact it didn't even happen that day - it happened the day prior and has nothing to stop counting as exposed by the the FOIA requests:
> Fulton County Elections head Richard Barron said Wednesday that the pipe dumped a lot of water, soaking the carpeting and hampering work. “It looked really like there was rain coming out of the ceiling and the entire carpeting was just covered in water,” he said. “There was no way to go in there and perform work.”
In the hearings, the state officials claimed it was a toilet leak which happened at 6am and was fixed by 8am - not at night.
All so well coordinated. Yet these people can't keep their story straight.
I am sure covering up the voting counts with boards in Detroit is totally cool.
I am sure Democrats and RINO republicans absolutely refusing to do a REAL SIGNATURE MATCH audit before certifying must be because everything was cool.
CA Governor recall petition had a signature unmatched of 20%. But for the general election, it's somehow less than 1% everywhere. Totally cool.
I am sure judge dismissing cases claiming Republicans being blocked and put over 20 feet away from counting was totally okay because they were still in same building is totally cool.
42,000 people in Nevada voted more than once, 1,500 dead, 19,000 didn't live in Nevada, 8,000 voted from a non-existent address, 15,000 registered to a commercial address and 4,000 non-citizens.
Please explain why at least 10315 dead voters, 8718 died before they voted, 66,247 underage, 2560 felons, 5300 voting in multiple states, 15700 out of state voters, 40279 voting in wrong county etc in Georgia alone.
I am sure the 3000 signed affidavits under penalty of perjury were all lying. If they were all lying, then why have none of the affidavit signers been prosecuted for lying (the DOJ is clearly very pro prosecuting Trump supporters).
Florida fixed their shit and ran one of the smoothest elections despite having more population than NY and twice the population of GA. Florida was able to finish their election counting within 2 hours of poll closures. GA and NY and other states with less population took weeks....
The best is this 2016 BBC article "Vote rigging: How to spot the tell-tale signs". The 2020 US election passes every sign from this article. But it's totally cool. Nothing to see here, move along:
In key swing states this year, mail-in ballot rejections plummeted from 2016 rates. Rates are below historical average and significantly less than most recent presidential election - despite having massive mail in voting:
All this doesn't even cover the unconstitutional voting law changes and mass mail-in voting using out dated voter rolls without voter ID. Or the censorship aspect.
The unconstitutional voting law changes alone should have changed the elections.
Using factcheck as your source is like using cnn as a source for russiagate nonsense. Same factcheck site which claimed lab leak was a conspiracy theory and got me banned from social media.
Antirim County was not a conspiracy theory. Even left leaning sources admitted that 6000 votes were switched from trump to Biden. Somehow all mistakes went in Biden’s favour and these are only the ones which we know about.
Please tell me how before the elections, nytimes and Washington post claimed all bell weather counties favored Biden but after elections, trump won 19 of the 20 bell weather counties and the same media claims bell weather counties don’t mean anything??? Please explain this to me.
Btw I am not talking about the Sidney Powell and Lin Wood nonsense. Those people did more damage by chasing every red herring instead of going for the real issues.
The actual LEFT doesn't want censorship, because they understand that it applies to different political dissidents over time. The Democratic party, which isn't LEFT, wants it because its a convenient way to shut down their political opponents (i.e. people who love Trump) at the moment.
I think it's dishonest to say that the Trump movement is not dangerous, but censorship is strategically the wrong move, as it has the exact opposite effect it intends to, and it gives them a gift to feel persecuted (i.e. Marjorie Taylor Greene wearing a mask that says "censored" on it)
Perhaps it’s because trump supporters are rightfully upset with institutions that have failed them. But are only presented with a demagogue like tromp because he was the only one (in rhetoric at least) that talked openly about institutions failing. Bernie Sanders has a similar message but has actual policy ideas that most people who voted for Trump would actually appreciate and benefit from. Thus the schism in American politics. The Democratic Party does everything it can to make Bernie sanders and his surrogates fail. We are only presented with a terrible version of the Democratic Party. You might disagree with this. But this is my assessment.
One of the best things against Bernie Sanders is that he used to complain about illegal immigration being "right wing proposals". Until 2016. We all know what changed in 2016 when Orange Man announced his run. Bernie used to hate illegal immigration, called it a “right wing proposal” “using a dollar or two wages to drive down wages of Americans”. And then he did a flip calling Orange Man a racist and xenophobic etc and became open border advocate. Just listen to his own words in this VOX interview and tell me how what he used to say was any different from Orange Man and how he's now done a full 180:
Bernie Sanders attacked the socialist Liberty Union Party in 1981 for accommodating the 351 Jamaican immigrants in his state's apple orchards: "With the Vermont unemployment rate one of the highest in the nation, I could never support importing foreign workers when our own people are out of work." ... "It sounds like she wants to bring slavery back to Vermont." said Sanders, who was collecting unemployment insurance at the time. For socialist Sanders, then 33, the situation supported his contention that businesses were yet again selling out U.S. residents in favor of cheap labor.
Even in 2007, he said:
“If poverty is increasing and if wages are going down, I don’t know why we need millions of people to be coming into this country as guest workers who will work for lower wages than American workers and drive wages down even lower than they are right now,” Sanders said. ” … On one hand, you have large multinationals trying to shut down plants in America, move to China, and on the other hand, you have the service industry bringing in low-wage workers from abroad. The result is the same: Middle class gets shrunken, and wages go down.”
"I think as you've heard today, sanctions against employers who employ illegal immigrants is virtually nonexistent. Our border is very porous," Sanders said during a press conference at the time. “And I think at a time when the middle class is shrinking, the last thing we need is to bring over in a period of years, millions of people into this country who are prepared to lower wages for American workers." "I think from a moral responsibility, we've got to work with the rest of the industrialized world to address the problems of international poverty," he said in a 2015 interview. "But you don't do that by making people in this country even poorer." In both cases, Sanders defended his vote by suggesting that the guest worker provisions in the bill were “akin to slavery,” a notable shift from how Sanders talked about immigrant labor before his presidential bids.
Again in 2013:
"I'll tell you look what my concern is the provisions dealing with the guest worker programs. Real unemployment in America counting those people have given up looking for work and are working part-time when they want to work full-time in order is close to 14 percent. It's higher for young people it is higher for people of color. You have in this bill guest worker programs that will bring in hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers. You know on television you hear these guys talk about all PhDs are coming into this country....hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers to work in kitchens waiters waitresses lifeguards ski resort workers. Is it really true that we can't find American workers to do those jobs? Frankly I don't believe it.
Given the magnitude of the problem it doesn't go anywhere near far enough so the nation we have got to ask ourselves do we really need when you go to ghettos in this country when you go to inner cities you have thirty forty percent unemployment do we really need hundreds of thousands of workers entry-level workers from around the country coming in competing against these kids? I think not."
Even the leftist washington post admits: "For years, Bernie Sanders warned that increased immigration would lower the wages of U.S. workers. Now he barely mentions it.":
But when Trump ran in 2015, he switched and became radical open border. He says "Illegal immigrants are "entitled" to the same government benefits as citizens":
This flip flopping and pie in the sky promises are quite natural for Bernie Sanders. Mr $15 an hour Bernie Sanders refused to pay his staff $15 because his campaign couldn't afford to. He has been a Vermont senator for 30+ years! The min wage in Vermont is still $10.
Bernie's hotel demands from his “Senator Comfort Memo”: King-size beds and 60-degree rooms. He flies on private jets and has a memo detailing minimum requirements of the private jet. He used to complain about millionaires and billionaires. Until 2 years ago when he became a millionaire. Then only the billionaires were the problem for him. You can verify this by going through his twitter history. The "millionaires and billionaires" change to "billionaires" only. He released his tax returns couple years ago. For someone complaining so much about poor people suffering, he barely paid anything in charity from his multi millions. For someone who's so anti-pharma, Bernie still gladly took $1.3 million from Pharma. Orange Man got $2.5 million and Biden took $8.5 million:
Bernie, "mr. anti-big-pharma" took $1,301,155 from Big Pharma in 2020. He was also the number 1 recipient in the senate for pharma manufacturing in 2020 by getting $416,066, Ossoff, Jon was second with $302,137, Elizabeth Warren got $291,168. Thom Tillis was 4th got $270,270 and Mitch McConnell was 5th at $265,980:
Why would pharma manufacturing give the most money to Bernie and other democrats and more than Mitch and Lindsey Graham? Kindness of their heart?
Bernie regularly engages in identity politics which is basically CRT. He even called Orange Man a xenophobe and said he wouldn't have shutdown travel from China. He said: "I wouldn't have closed the air traveling with China if I was a president. Trump is racist xenophobic."
Bernie also supports the AOC/Cori Bush squad who regularly exploit identity politics / defund the police nonsense while giving themselves more police funding. So claiming he doesn't wade into CRT is false.
Bernie endorsed Biden after getting fucked in his ass twice by the DNC. He couldn't grow up a spine to call out Biden's and his son's obvious corruption, instead he called him a good friend and respectable man. You think such a spineless man could stand up to foreign nations?
Unlike Bernie who rolled over at the very first sight, Orange Man at least put up a fight and won the nomination. Imagine Bernie rolling over like that to foreign nations. He got "cheated" out twice from the nomination and he rolled over without a fight - maybe because this was the plan all along for Democrats to use him to get the left to vote for Biden. Then he refused to look at the "cheating" allegations from Orange Man. Everyone agrees Bernie got cheated out twice, DNC using the IOWA "app" to cheat again and somehow the general election was perfectly okay.
He called Biden his friend and respectable man. Didn't even have the balls of calling out his obvious selling out to China and his son using his office for profit. Now he's going on CNN making excuses on why they couldn't get $15 minimum wage, why $2000 has still not gone out, why $1400 is more than enough instead of the $2000 they promised, why medicare for all is now too hard to achieve. And his supporters thought Bernie would care about them LMFAO. When his supporters couldn't wake up to how big of a pathetic cuck Bernie was when he gave up his mic to the 2 BLM activists at his own rally, how he did a full 180 flip on illegal immigration when Orange Man ran, then nothing will wake them up.
I am surprised it took this long for people to see through AOC and Bernie. Bernie was always in on it with the establishment dems from the beginning. I was mostly politically uneducated till 2015 but even then I was able to see through Bernie sanders fraud when he did a complete 180 flip on his stance on illegal immigration. Bernie is there to tell you nice things to get votes for Democrats. He was never there to win. Bernie tells people pie in the sky dreams to siphon votes to the Democrats. That's it.
Trump and his supporters are in fact fiscally liberal and socially conservative. So you're actually half-correct. On fiscal matters, they really are left-wing.
By making these big tech companies common carriers.
SCOTUS Justice Clarence Thomas opined couple months ago discussing big tech censorship quite extensively. The case was regarding whether Trump was allowed to block people on Twitter and it being a 1st amendment violation. While the case was declared moot as Trump left office, Justice Clarence Thomas took the opportunity to discuss censorship. How politicians aren't allowed to block users on big tech but big tech is able to block and ban politicians and government employees and how this creates a weird power dynamic.
> "But whatever may be said of other industries, there is clear historical precedent for regulating transportation and communications networks in a similar manner as traditional common carriers. Candeub 398–405. Telegraphs, for example, because they “resemble[d] railroad companies and other common carriers,” were “bound to serve all customers alike, without discrimination." ... "Internet platforms of course have their own First Amendment interests, but regulations that might affect speech are valid if they would have been permissible at the time of the founding. See United States v. Stevens, 559 U. S. 460, 468 (2010). The long history in this country and in England of restricting the exclusion right of common carriers and places of public accommodation may save similar regulations today from triggering heightened scrutiny—especially where a restriction would not prohibit the company from speaking or force the company to endorse the speech." ... "The similarities between some digital platforms and common carriers or places of public accommodation may give legislators strong arguments for similarly regulating digital platforms. [I]t stands to reason that if Congress may demand that telephone companies operate as common carriers, it can ask the same of ”digital platforms." ... "For example, although a “private entity is not ordinarily constrained by the First Amendment,” Halleck, 587 U. S., at ___, ___ (slip op., at 6, 9), it is if the government coerces or induces it to take action the government itself would not be permitted to do, such as censor expression of a lawful viewpoint. Ibid. Consider government threats. “People do not lightly disregard public officers’ thinly veiled threats to institute criminal proceedings against them if they do not come around.” Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U. S. 58, 68 (1963). The government cannot accomplish through threats of adverse government action what the Constitution prohibits it from doing directly. See ibid.; Blum v. Yaretsky, 457 U. S. 991, 1004–1005 (1982). Under this doctrine, plaintiffs might have colorable claims against a digital plat- form if it took adverse action against them in response to government threats. The Second Circuit feared that then-President Trump cut off speech by using the features that Twitter made available to him. But if the aim is to ensure that speech is not smothered, then the more glaring concern must perforce be the dominant digital platforms themselves."
> "As Twitter made clear, the right to cut off speech lies most powerfully in the hands of private digital platforms. The extent to which that power matters for purposes of the First Amendment and the extent to which that power could lawfully be modified raise interesting and important questions. This petition, unfortunately, affords us no opportunity to confront them."
The last 2 points are important as Justice Thomas is basically saying "give us a case which brings up these two questions and then we will have a deep look."
One can even cite Amazon's recent censorship of SCOTUS Justice Clarence Thomas's own documentary as well as Eli Steele’s documentary as examples:
to Twitter, which after all is headquartered in CA. Under Pruneyard, the owner of a public shopping mall could not exclude students engaged in political activities. An argument could be made that social media sites, like shopping centers in 1979, are places "to which the public is invited [and] can provide an essential and invaluable forum for exercising [speech and petition] rights." So, the infringement of free speech by social media would seem to be unconstitutional (at least in CA)."
Thomas compares Twitter to common carriers:
Thomas suggested that the case could fall under two other doctrines. The first was the doctrine of common carriers, in which private entities in the transportation and communication sectors are tightly tied to “public concerns.” Governments had, for example, required telegraph companies to serve all customers. Second, governments might restrict a company’s right to exclude individuals from public accommodations.
In exploring these analogies, Thomas noted that companies were not typically treated as speakers for “information that they merely distribute.” He focused on the manner in which digital platforms “have dominant market share” in a business that “may have substantial barriers to entry.” This gives such companies as Facebook and Google “enormous control over speech.”
Acknowledging alternate modes of communicating, Thomas likened such alternatives to having to swim over a river rather than take a bridge, or having to hike, rather than travel by car, over the Oregon Trail. Arguing that such analogies supported the 2nd Circuit’s “intuition” that Trump’s Twitter was a public forum, he noted that nothing in the record “evaluates Twitter’s market power” and no one had identified any current regulation “that restricts Twitter from removing an account that would otherwise be a ‘government-controlled space.’” Moreover, courts had split as to “whether federal accommodations laws apply to anything other than ‘physical’ locations.”
Thomas pointed out in his concurring opinion in Biden v. Knight that, like Twitter, Facebook, and Google, trains and communication networks are privately owned yet the law obligates them to serve everyone. Justice Thomas went on to note that Congress has granted social media platforms immunity from certain types of lawsuits but that it “has not imposed corresponding responsibilities, like nondiscrimination.”
I'd really like to know...that was the first time I've ever watched that clip of Trump and other Republicans....how the hell is that inciting violence? What does "peaceful and patriotic" mean to you? I'd never approve of what happened, but is this inciting violence? Honestly, when you have a sitting Congresswoman telling anybody who will listen to confront conservatives while they're at dinner, how is this WORSE? You may not agree that the election was stolen and I'm sure there's a strong debate to be had, but inciting violence? When? Did he say "Storm the Capitol!!!!!!"..? Did he say "Take back the White House by force with all of your one guns!!!!" Seriously, how could anybody misinterpret "peacefully and patriotically?"
When you say, and I do get your point, that you never approved of what happened, from what I remember seeing was, as they “stormed” the Capitol, they did so in a mannerly fashion, staying within the ropes.
The entire issue shows what a bunch of panty waste populate this country, especially in the media and government. It’s a tool to keep the lemmings in line; after all, each step brings them closer to the precipice.
That leaves me with a question, where do I get a link that I can post, to what I remember? The reason that’s what I remember could stem from my lack of concern related to the event.
I wasn’t freaking out when the union members took over the Wisconsin capitol in Madison a few years ago, were you? That said, other than the children with cameras and microphones in the media screaming rape, and scum like AOC thinking the entire event was an attempt to rape her; who cares? As a matter of fact, the entire thing reminds me of some B movie from years ago where the psycho-chick is in a daze, mumbling about how they are all after her, lusting for her; a perfect picture of the squid..
Why is this a big deal? Because it is yet another attempt by the immature scum in DC trying to eliminate what they perceive to be the Trump Threat; aka, a threat to their power.
(Coming soon will be video of people storming the Capitol as they waved Russian flags, chanting “Trump/Putin 2024”!)
And let’s not ignore the Useful Idiots who bend over backwards to accommodate the DC elite. It is yet another attempt by the immature scum in DC trying to eliminate what they perceive to be the Trump Threat; aka, a threat to their addiction to power.
I sadly close by saying I have several family member who are part of that game.
Trump's speech did not constitute legal incitement, which is why he hasn't been indicted for that crime. I strongly doubt that he had advance knowledge of the plans to invade the Capitol or that he conspired with any of the rioters to do so.
What Trump did do, in my humble opinion, is wage a campaign of lies about the election in order to bring public pressure from GOP voters to bear on GOP Senators and Congressmen to vote to reject Biden electors under the Electoral Count Act of 1887, 3 U.S.C. sec. 3, and throw the election into the House of Representatives. Does that constitute a coup attempt? It clearly would if he was conspiring with the rioters to use force to compel Congress to act. But absent such conspiracy to use force, it's unlikely that he broke the laws against insurrection and seditious conspiracy. To be sure, Trump violated the foundational norm of democracy, respecting the results of an election, and if he succeeded, historians would probably call that a successful coup, but the water is muddy, which is why Attorney General Garland won't go there.
Much like Stacy Abrams and Hilary Clinton respected those norms?
Give me a fucking break. There are massive questions about that election in at least a third of voters' minds. And if Trump did think there were shenanigans in the vote, he, as someone sworn to defend the constitution, which voting rights are a strong portion thereof, is duty-bound to bring that to the attention of congress.
Norms are what we do, but they should be thrown in the wastebasket of eternity when they are being used to screw over parts of the country. Remember, it was a norm to beat your wife at one point.
Hi there Doug. Just following up to see if you had any thoughts on Conservative Contrarian's question about Hillary Clinton's or Al Gore's claims of election fraud.
Cognitive dissonance can be painful, eh? I wouldn't think too much about that question either, if I were you.
May I take your comment as agreement with my assessment that Trump deliberately lied about election fraud? You point, I take it, is that his lies were no big deal because Mrs. Clinton and Gore also lied about election fraud.
The bigger Democratic lie in my opinion was the claim that Trump was a Russian intelligence asset, a traitor, who stole the 2016 election in a conspiracy with Putin. The Democrats pushed that lie, which originated in a fabrication financed by Hillary Clinton, for three years, trying to force Trump from office. That was outrageous, in my personal opinion. The Democrats' pushing of that lie was one of the reasons I voted for Trump in the last election.
What do I do now? I can't vote for the Democrats, who have never apologized for the Russia hoax, and whose economic polices are disastrous. I can't vote for Trump, who is still insisting that the election was fraudulent and who tried to overturn the election via his campaign of lies. I'm back to where I was in 2016, when I didn't cast a vote for president.
What are your sources that cause you to conclude there was no election fraud? After all, we can only agree Trump lied about it if we have all facts in front of us, correct?
Both Greenwald and Turley, who should know, have said that Trump's speech wasn't LEGALLY incitement. I'll take their word for it. My take was that it was certainly inciting something, but carefully hedged to stay within the law. Apparently he speaks more carefully than it appears, and had decent lawyers.
Maybe you notice that up above I wrote, "Trump's speech did not constitute legal incitement." Of course, that's just the start, not the end, of the inquiry.
When I noticed this starting to happen more, I was initially hopeful that it would spur people to using decentralized platforms for social media and content. This has only barely happened, though. Right now all I actually expect people to do is to bifurcate into two spheres of centralized social media and content platforms.
Good lord, Paul Jay is such a mini-me fascist. Just parse this statement to see how his mind REALLY works: "I’m not in favor of the algorithms at all. Period. So let’s start with that. The whole idea of censorship through algorithm is BS." Oh, so you're saying if content was monitored and censored by humans (who support MY position) it's okay. Which is why Paul Jay reveals himself to be a closet fascist, because the correct answer is the 'whole idea of censorship is BS.' No sympathy for this dude.
Who the fuck made Google, Youtube, Twitter and FaceBook of all things the arbiter of truth and the ministry of what is and what is not to be discussed regarding elections, candidates, why the weather if foul this week or anything else?
Answer:
They did.
That they even say they "allow" discussions about this or that tells you everything you need to know. They're self-appointed Goebbels.
When you sit and think about the fact that the federal government, (or more specifically,) persons who were either elected or appointed politically are tugging their sleeves and requesting more censorship and nudging discourse in a particular direction, you have what amounts to the government chilling the 1st amendment through private business.
I may remind you all at this time that it's fucking illegal.
I guess we just add it to the pile of other illegal shit they do all day, every day, and the war crimes, pollution, failure to serve their constituencies and refusing to honor their crummy oaths and be done with it.
I'm not really sure what solution or solutions you're suggesting here. High government regulation of tech companies? Breaking them up to neutralize their monopolies? Designating them as common carriers? Maybe even nationalizing them? Not only are all those left-wing solutions, but they will also enable the government more control of tech companies. Which means that whichever party is in power will be in a position to weaponize them against the other party. So how is that better than the current situation?
Paul Jay is not a voice Google et al really want to censor in the first place. His views are milquetoast "left" just the kind of stuff they love. Obviously the algorithm picked it up and was adjusted to accept him. He opposed Force the Vote for example definitely not progressive, if there is such a thing in the US.
The correct answer is to stop using these obviously corrupt social media networks. Sure it'll suck at first, but you will be a much better person for it.
"Our Community Guidelines apply equally to everyone, regardless of whether they’re a small news channel or a larger media outlet."
Can we take a moment to reflect on what a load of insulting, gaslighting feces that statement is?
The video of that late night host calling Ivanka Trump "cunt" is still allowed. Or Stephen Colbert calling Trump Putin's Cock Holster. Or the thousands of videos of the russian collusion nonsense. Or the russian bounty nonsense.
Or the claim that the GA election law does anything like what they say it does. I saw one MSM story that was honest. One.
The people against "misinformation" are the biggest source of misinformation.
They're just mad that people are believing the wrong set of lies.
The word is used to cast FUD on something but it's really just a passive-aggressive way to insult whoever said or wrote the thing.
Complete and utter bullshit
Now ponder the ratio pf Alphabet, Google and Youtube staff that believe it.
Some of the brightest minds and smartest people go to work for companies like Facebook, YouTube, Google etc which spend every minute of their existence to figure out how to place an ad in front of our eyes for 1 more second.
That's how you know that some of the dumbest smart people end up controlling your speech too.
Same thing on Wall St. Did you read Antonio García Martínez book? There were times I got angry at his descriptions of FB and then I calmed myself with the fact that it is a confession. Very interesting book, especially the afterword to the 2nd edition.
Bright minds and smart people tend to get credit for their god-given gifts rather than the consequences of how they use them. https://thebaffler.com/salvos/outsmarted-perlstein
I remember when someone programmed a bot to observe internet comments and respond like a “human” based on what it read/absorbed and with 36 hours it turned into a racist troll! It makes sense that an algorithm programmed by Alphabet/YouTube types would reflect their political nitwittery in it’s decisions.
It was Microsoft’s Tay bot:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-microsoft-twitter-bot-idUSKCN0WQ2LA
Because it’s very easy to troll these stupid AI
Yeah, that was deliberate fuckery. It was scientific only if you substitute "lulz" for "data".
I don't mind being lied to but I hate my limited intelligence being insulted.
Dennis Prager calls bs on that one.
STX... You realize Dennis Prager is as much a grifter as the Evangelicals pushing Trump down the throat of their followers. RIght? Prager U = Trum U aka Grifter U
That's irrelevant. Everyone's a grifter on both sides. What we are talking about here is that Prager U routinely gets censored for milquetoast stuff while corporate media gets to lie about everything.
Dennis Prager is a mild mannered Jewish conservative who is about as much of a grifter as Mister Rogers or Ned Flanders.
None sense. The platform with his name on it funded by a billionaire pushing one thing and one thing only, lower taxes to the rich. The way they do it is to focus conservative voters on identity politics rather than economic policy.
The people on his platform are Grifters. They get paid by the click to push none sense meant to distract conservative voters away from the policy that Lobbyists are getting passed that has for 40yrs shifted GDP from the middle class and poor to the WEALTHY. (Trumps tax cut is the perfect example. Bailing out Banks is another one and the recent stimulus sending mostly going to large companies is another one, min wage, health care etc...)
His platform is to focus you on Woke Professors at Ivy League schools and Tranny's so you ignore how you are getting screwed by the Rich.
Feel free to call bs on this one yourself. It would mean more to me. Honestly.
Censorship, blacklisting and persecution of dissenters is the biggest issue we face right now. It literally strikes at the foundations of our Democracy. It's shocking that the LEFT is willing to turn a blind eye to this out of disdain for Trump Supporters and any journalist capable of nuance. I think this extended to people like Alex Jones, who should not have been deplatformed for political beliefs, despite being fairly annoying.
My friend the LEFT - allowing for the modification of the definition of LEFT that Scott called out - is not just willing to turn a blind eye. They're the ones who are demanding that censorship, blacklisting, and persecution.
Indeed. Just one recent example: the entire DP leadership - as well as "thoughtful" hangers on like the Atlantic etc - all cheered on the complete, thorough & total elimination of Parler from the internet. There is no doubt that these last few years the Left, led by the DP, as Mr Taibbi has pointed out, is the greatest threat to freedom of speech.
ART- Matt has done an outstanding job of pointing out how the left is reducing freedom of speech. And in the process built a large audience of right wing fans.
If you have read his books he is equally harsh on the things the RIGHT has done regarding censorship and if you read his recent book Hate INC he interviews Noam Chomsky at the end and Chomsky clearly shows how the RIGHT is the far bigger threat to Censorship.
So what are you talking about
Think you missed something there: I agreed that Mr Taibbi has pointed out how most recently the Left, led by the DP, has been the greater threat to freedom of speech THESE LAST FEW YEARS. At no point did I attempt to exonerate the Right, which of course over different periods in years gone by has also been in favour of censorship in various areas of public life and threatened freedom of speech in the US. But we are talking about the very recent past .. and NOW! And what has been happening in the US, most especially this past year, is outrageous. I think it notable that Mr Taibbi, himself a man of the Left - but a man with principles and probity - has found it necessary to speak out. Likewise that other decent people "on the Left" - like Brett Weinstein and Glenn Greenwald (to pick out the first names which come to mind) - have been so disgusted by the actions of the broad Left that they too have felt the need to speak out. Most noteworthy too has been the manner in which these people from the Left have been smeared and vilified and instantly branded as "right wing" and "Trump-supporting", not only by the far left but also by many DP supporters.
As for your statement about Chomsky showing "how the Right is a far bigger threat to Censorship", I am afraid this is nonsense; or perhaps merely wishful thinking! (Incidentally, I presume you mean threat to freedom of speech; if the left or right were a "threat" to censorship that would be a good thing :-) ) The drive to censorship has nothing to do with "left" or right persuasion: the Soviet Union, the Japanese Empire, Communist China, Cuba, Nazi Germany, Venzuela, Franco's Spain, North Korea etc. etc. prove the fallacy of that assumption. The simple fact is that as soon as any political movement becomes ideological it attracts adherents who convince themselves that they are right about everything; and that anyone who disagrees with them is wrong and needs to be silenced. It is the mentality of the religious fundamentalist. Reason is thrown to the winds and political repression with varying degrees of violence follows. Arch thugs like Lenin, Hitler, Stalin and Mao are the finest examples of this trend of course. Incidentally, as pointed out in an earlier Taibbi post, I wouldn't put too much store by Chomsky in the area of censorship. A single example of his limited intellect & power of judgment is that for years he was a huge fan of Hugo Chávez: a man who once decreed that all TV stations broadcast his interminable speeches daily. I understand that between 15% and 20% of the total population of Venzuela has now left the wreck of a country Chávez and his followers bequeathed to them.
Again, a discussion completely derailed by people using "simplified" terminology.
In this case, "the right". When Piketty uses it, he means the evil, shadowy forces of power and wealth, funding grifters to indoctrinate ignorant rubes into believing things that are beneficial to their continued hold on that power and wealth.
When most of us use "the right", we mean ordinary citizens who feel they do not need to be highly educated to know they bear no racial animus, or to determine the biological sex of 98% of their fellow citizens* and who agree with the principle that the most productive should get the greater reward. Also, the people who view the fact that "bonds of family may interfere with loyalty to the state" (or "the cause") as a feature, not a bug.
Pretty small definitional overlap there, for the purposes of discussion or persuasion.
*-to be expressed, suppressed or satisfied howeverthefuck they want, no homophobe here, though that term (homophobe) is yet another that's been ginned-up as a tool for discussion avoidance.
RTF - Who are you talking about? Biden appointed Tim Wu and Lina Khan and they know more about what these companies are doing to censor than you and they are absolutely on the left.
Who to Trump, the right wing lunatic, put in power that did anything about these platforms? Name her? you cant. Sorry your claim is laughable
LOL you think Biden or democrats want Big Tech to not censor their opposition? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA You must still be waiting for that $2000 cheque or the $15 minimum wage or the medicare for all too....
CNN - I see that Biden actually hired the most well respected critics of big tech into his administration. Trump hired a bunch of industry hacks.
I have no idea what Wu and Khan will accomplish, they are going to be fighting the larges donors to politicians in DC.
Elizabeth Warren was appointed by Obama to fight the banks and they crushed her and got her thrown out. The banks got Katie porter thrown off of the finance committee after she chewed up their CEO's in public.
All i know is Democrats put heavy hitters out there to fight for consumers against these powerful entities. Republicans hire lobbyists like Mik Mulvaney and Ajit Pai to push the interests of big corporations over consumers.
No, the Democrats did not give enough support to people like Warren when she founded the consumer protection agency and they may not give Wu and Khan the support they need. But i do know that the MORE people we vote into office that think like Warren and Sanders and Porter and many others the more Support the Dems can give these people in fighting big business.
Let me know when the GOP start fighting big business because under Trump and Bush they did NOTHING to help consumers and far more than corrupt leaders like Pelosi and Schumer to help business. And Pelosi and Schumer are total corporate shills.
At least i know the battle and who we are fighting. You don't.
Anyone who imagines there is currently a single amerikan pol of true leftish bent in either the house of reps or the senate is a moronic pawn of amerikan indoctrination.
Calling the dims leftish is the equivalent of describing Robespierre as a monarchist.
I hold that big tech is overtly pushing the edicts of amerikan media that were oncemuch less obvious though they were practised.
I reckon this goes back to what Jays says alludes to in the Taibbi interview, that apart from shitty education, amerikans are frequently denied access to primary sources, that particular second-hand commentaries on historical events are permitted but access to the untainted, uninterpreted view of historical events us outright verboten.
Deb - It is 2021 not 1794 and the US is not a monarchy it is a representative democracy so a Robespierreian leader is not likely to appear in either the Republican or Democratic party, nor is one needed. In the 200yr history of this country th Rich and Powerful have many times purchased the government to subvert capitalism in favor of oligarchy. OUr system is set up to address such things if and only if American votes can UNITE to fight back.
Media and politicians that focus little on policy and strongly on why HATING the other side is all that matters (these people and media are on the left and right) are serving the overlords that want Oligarchy.
There have always been political leaders that are truly fighting for everyday Americans. But with out compromise they will never gain power.
Please name one Republican member of congress or the Senate that is FIGHTING for the economic well being of the POOR and MIDDLE CLASS and what policy they are fighting for to help the poor and middle class economically?
If you can't, and you can't then it will be clear where the few elected leaders are that are fighting for the economic well being of the poor and middle class and I can assure you that YOU PERSONALLY HATE them because of their identity politics. Right? If so, you are being played by the media. You know that right?
What's an amerikan?
Readersaurus
2 min ago
The irony (and there's so much of it!) is that many/most of such people don't even know who Robespierre was or that they're following in his footsteps to the point of unwittingly making of him their de facto "patron saint."
What does your TDS-driven whataboutism have to do with his point that it is primarily the New Left that is driving the censorship?
Todd - The Right is pushing censorship just as much as the left.
The FACT that you can't name any people that Trump brought in much less policy he got passed to reduce censorship proves you are INGORANCE on the issue.
Tim Wu and Lina Khan are more qualified to fight censorship than anyone Trump brought in and that is why Trump accomplished NOTHING to reduce it. Trump supports censorship just not against him, and you are the same. RIGH?
Tell me what Tim Wu and Lina Khan are doing to prevent said censorship.
Because I most recently heard of the White House providing "suggestions" to the tech platforms as to who might be good candidates for suppression. Maybe they weren't part of that, but I also didn't hear any outrage from them.
The Biden admin seems pretty clearly to be using those tech platforms to circumvent the First Amendment. Which is as clever as it is evil.
Sorry, your claim is laughable.
See Scott above, as i mentioned.
https://www.thewrap.com/youtube-must-censor-misleading-election-videos-senate-democrats-say/
https://www.wsj.com/articles/facebooks-lab-leak-about-face-11622154198
e.pierce - You have been reduced to name calling. Very telling about your intellectual makeup wouldn't you agree?
I really enjoy the way that wrongly informed ill-educated - through no fault of their own I must add, critics of my posts, always prove my point of view with their uninformed, always irrational replies, full of name calling ad hominems but light on logic.
However I am sure that their time would be more wisely spent educating themselves by searching out the primary sources of events which they have thus far only learned about via Tucker Carlson's or Rachel Maddow's paid deceits.
That's right, like the "anti-fascists" they are.
RTJ - Give me a break. The RIGHT turned a blind eye while Bush and Cheney lied through their teeth to get us into a war.
Both sides turn a blind eye when the other-side is censured.
And you are one of them. People of PRINCIPLE on censorship would see that the RIGHT is as guilty as the LEFT. You don't appear to be one of those people
"The Left" isn't at fault here: it's THE RIGHT.
You know, the war-for-profit cunts you always thought were just in the Republitard party?
Nah, kid.
They're all over everything and the ack of leadership for actual working class and fair-minded people is galling.
I'm a single, no kids, pretty low-income, working class peasant. Lately i've been sort of toting things up over the last decade or two, and realizing that the Republicans, from W thru Trump, have actually been better for me financially than the Dems.
You seem to be in the minority. The economy performs better under Democrat presidents than under Republican ones.
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-economy-and-the-stock-market-tends-to-do-better-under-democrats-11611158787
I didn't say "the economy". I said better for me as a low income person.
What's "the economy"? GDP? The Dow? Gains in GDP or the market all go to those at the top of the scale, increasing inequality.
You know what helps low-income people? Doubling the standard deduction, like Trump did in '17.
At the beginning of the pandemic, it was "quiet rooms", "i like to fire people", "low income people don't pay taxes" asset stripper Mitt Romney whose idea it was to get cash out to people ASAP. And Steve Mnuchin, who got it out fast. Nancy didn't want to do it. It was the Repubs who wanted the topoff to unemployment. Was also Mittens who wanted to give essential workers a $20/hr top off.
Last August when the $600 / wk topoff ended, Repubs tried to make various deals with Pelosi, who turned them all down. They wanted to pass a skinny bill, that would have at least given people a $300 / wk topoff. This deeply stupid woman (and the Senate) rejected it because they couldn't get the full what of the bill that they wanted. And tried to gaslight the desperate unemployed that nothing was better than $300. But at least Donald Trump got us $1800 from FEMA. Sure, the Dems extended the unemployment and added a $300 topoff in January when Joe got elected. Was too late for me and a lot of other people, mine expired in early Dec.
Those D House Reps that lost their seats last November? They were the centrists begging Pelosi to pass a skinny bill for their desperate constituents.
FOR. WHOM.? You average in all the millions and billions hoovered up by fund managers, CEOs, Big Tech, MIC, Walmart and Amazon, you may well have a statistical case. Buy the guy SAID "From my point of view as a sub-middle class individual citizen, it looks like".
Are you dismissing his lived experience?? Denying his truth? You are literally ERASING HIM!! REEEE!! Violence!!
A measure that is simply a sum of spending is larger under the spending party than under the non-spending party?
How shocking!
If this shocks you, you do t understand the left.
@Sevender,
First, you are the one introducing the concept of "shock". There is none in
my comment.
Second, the most hilarious arrogance in the world cannot compare to the act
of telling someone that you do not know, and will never meet, what they do or do not know, based upon a brief statement. About anything. You can tell me what you *assume, but please don't bother assuming to tell me what I know.
@Steve Pesce
*Fairly annoying ? ;-D That observation, Sir, demonstrates more patience and milk of human kindness for whackery than Mother Teresa herself ever knew ! ;-D
I do, however, support the right of any fool to spew their logorrhea under the rights accorded them under the First Amendment. People such as myself (at least for now)
are always free to change the freakin' channel.
Pesce - Non sense. Low wages are causing Americans to live in utter poverty. And that has been happening for 40yrs now.
The US has had censorship issues since the beginning of the Republic. Censorship is ALWAYS a problem. But if you think Censorship of the RIGHT is the biggest problem while 70% of Americans are living pay check to pay check because of POLICY people like Obama and Trump pushed on America then you are clearly being manipulated by the media into IGNORING our biggest problems.
Yes, I think freedom is more primary to American life than wages rising. And FREEDOM is entirely integral to allowing Americans to succeed. You say censorship like it's nothing. Which just shows how blind people are. Without dissent there is no democracy.
"And FREEDOM is entirely integral to allowing Americans to succeed."
Has this ever been historically true? Which periods in American history are you basing this argument on?
You do not believe that the ability to freely speak and associate and begin endeavors with government restraint is a driver of innovation and the economy?
As someone from the Republican Right, my fear is that the Establishment Democrats and their allies in the media and big tech will misinterpret my side's arguments. You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for, then say that any effort to correct these arguments are lies and must be censored.
I think Paul Jay's arguments are nonsense; but he should be allowed to present them. My fear is that Jay will be allowed to present his arguments; but someone who argues that Trump's statements were not incitement to riot will be blocked. The ONLY version of this story that we will be allowed to hear is the one that wants to paint Trump and his allies as dangerous threats that must be silenced.
This will be great for the security state. How best to insure that their budgets are increased and the amount of resources allocated to them are increased: by making Americans feel that they are under threat. What better threat then to have 70 million of us declared a danger to America.
"You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for..."
Don't feel special. First of all, the Dems don't even know what they stand for. And they (and the GOP, to be fair) seem to think that folks like me, and Independent Bernie economic progressive, somehow want to defund the police and abolish ICE instead of just wanting some healthcare for all, affordable housing and a living wage.
You mean we think that people in your camp believe what many of them very openly declare that they believe?
Next thing you know we'll be telling you that your complete refusal to do anything less than give such people your full support constitutes tacit approval for their radicalism!
People in my camp? Yes, there is some overlap between some economic progressives, the defund / abolish crew, and the wokies. And absolutely between the wokies and the establishment Dems. Ever heard Bernie express support for abolish / defund? I haven't. Never heard him wade into the CRT cesspool either.
He was also mad against open borders, on behalf of "the working people of the country", which was one of his policy positions I very much agreed with.
Bernie regularly engages in identity politics which is basically CRT. He even called Orange Man a xenophobe and said he wouldn't have shutdown travel from China. He said: "I wouldn't have closed the air traveling with China if I was a president. Trump is racist xenophobic."
Bernie also supports the AOC/Cori Bush squad who regularly exploit identity politics / defund the police nonsense while giving themselves more police funding. So claiming he doesn't wade into CRT is false.
One of the best things against Bernie Sanders is that he used to complain about illegal immigration being "right wing proposals". Until 2016. We all know what changed in 2016 when Orange Man announced his run. Bernie used to hate illegal immigration, called it a “right wing proposal” “using a dollar or two wages to drive down wages of Americans”. And then he did a flip calling Orange Man a racist and xenophobic etc and became open border advocate. Just listen to his own words in this VOX interview and tell me how what he used to say was any different from Orange Man and how he's now done a full 180:
https://youtu.be/vf-k6qOfXz0
Bernie Sanders attacked the socialist Liberty Union Party in 1981 for accommodating the 351 Jamaican immigrants in his state's apple orchards: "With the Vermont unemployment rate one of the highest in the nation, I could never support importing foreign workers when our own people are out of work." ... "It sounds like she wants to bring slavery back to Vermont." said Sanders, who was collecting unemployment insurance at the time. For socialist Sanders, then 33, the situation supported his contention that businesses were yet again selling out U.S. residents in favor of cheap labor.
Even in 2007, he said:
“If poverty is increasing and if wages are going down, I don’t know why we need millions of people to be coming into this country as guest workers who will work for lower wages than American workers and drive wages down even lower than they are right now,” Sanders said. ” … On one hand, you have large multinationals trying to shut down plants in America, move to China, and on the other hand, you have the service industry bringing in low-wage workers from abroad. The result is the same: Middle class gets shrunken, and wages go down.”
"I think as you've heard today, sanctions against employers who employ illegal immigrants is virtually nonexistent. Our border is very porous," Sanders said during a press conference at the time. “And I think at a time when the middle class is shrinking, the last thing we need is to bring over in a period of years, millions of people into this country who are prepared to lower wages for American workers." "I think from a moral responsibility, we've got to work with the rest of the industrialized world to address the problems of international poverty," he said in a 2015 interview. "But you don't do that by making people in this country even poorer." In both cases, Sanders defended his vote by suggesting that the guest worker provisions in the bill were “akin to slavery,” a notable shift from how Sanders talked about immigrant labor before his presidential bids.
Again in 2013:
"I'll tell you look what my concern is the provisions dealing with the guest worker programs. Real unemployment in America counting those people have given up looking for work and are working part-time when they want to work full-time in order is close to 14 percent. It's higher for young people it is higher for people of color. You have in this bill guest worker programs that will bring in hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers. You know on television you hear these guys talk about all PhDs are coming into this country....hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers to work in kitchens waiters waitresses lifeguards ski resort workers. Is it really true that we can't find American workers to do those jobs? Frankly I don't believe it.
Given the magnitude of the problem it doesn't go anywhere near far enough so the nation we have got to ask ourselves do we really need when you go to ghettos in this country when you go to inner cities you have thirty forty percent unemployment do we really need hundreds of thousands of workers entry-level workers from around the country coming in competing against these kids? I think not."
Even the leftist washington post admits: "For years, Bernie Sanders warned that increased immigration would lower the wages of U.S. workers. Now he barely mentions it.":
https://archive.is/Ek7Xa
But when Trump ran in 2015, he switched and became radical open border. He says "Illegal immigrants are "entitled" to the same government benefits as citizens":
https://twitter.com/RNCResearch/status/1231347412356210688
During the DNC debates, all Democrats including Bernie raised their hands that Illegal Immigrants Should Get Health Care Coverage.
Here's more:
https://youtu.be/TtMqldNYloY
This video perfect describes how fake fact checkers keep making excuses for Democrats:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4SkGOCkhEs
This flip flopping and pie in the sky promises are quite natural for Bernie Sanders. Mr $15 an hour Bernie Sanders refused to pay his staff $15 because his campaign couldn't afford to. He has been a Vermont senator for 30+ years! The min wage in Vermont is still $10.
Bernie's hotel demands from his “Senator Comfort Memo”: King-size beds and 60-degree rooms. He flies on private jets and has a memo detailing minimum requirements of the private jet. He used to complain about millionaires and billionaires. Until 2 years ago when he became a millionaire. Then only the billionaires were the problem for him. You can verify this by going through his twitter history. The "millionaires and billionaires" change to "billionaires" only. He released his tax returns couple years ago. For someone complaining so much about poor people suffering, he barely paid anything in charity from his multi millions. For someone who's so anti-pharma, Bernie still gladly took $1.3 million from Pharma. Orange Man got $2.5 million and Biden took $8.5 million:
https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?cycle=2020&ind=h04
Bernie, "mr. anti-big-pharma" took $1,301,155 from Big Pharma in 2020. He was also the number 1 recipient in the senate for pharma manufacturing in 2020 by getting $416,066, Ossoff, Jon was second with $302,137, Elizabeth Warren got $291,168. Thom Tillis was 4th got $270,270 and Mitch McConnell was 5th at $265,980:
https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?ind=H4300&cycle=2020&recipdetail=S&Mem=Y&sortorder=U
Why would pharma manufacturing give the most money to Bernie and other democrats and more than Mitch and Lindsey Graham? Kindness of their heart?
Bernie endorsed Biden after getting fucked in his ass twice by the DNC. He couldn't grow up a spine to call out Biden's and his son's obvious corruption, instead he called him a good friend and respectable man. You think such a spineless man could stand up to foreign nations?
Unlike Bernie who rolled over at the very first sight, Orange Man at least put up a fight and won the nomination. Imagine Bernie rolling over like that to foreign nations. He got "cheated" out twice from the nomination and he rolled over without a fight - maybe because this was the plan all along for Democrats to use him to get the left to vote for Biden. Then he refused to look at the "cheating" allegations from Orange Man. He called Biden his friend and respectable man. Didn't even have the balls of calling out his obvious selling out to China and his son using his office for profit. Now he's going on CNN making excuses on why they couldn't get $15 minimum wage, why $2000 has still not gone out, why $1400 is more than enough instead of the $2000 they promised, why medicare for all is now too hard to achieve. And his supporters thought Bernie would care about them LMFAO. When his supporters couldn't wake up to how big of a pathetic cuck Bernie was when he gave up his mic to the 2 BLM activists at his own rally, how he did a full 180 flip on illegal immigration when Orange Man ran, then nothing will wake them up.
I am surprised it took this long for people to see through AOC and Bernie. Bernie was always in on it with the establishment dems from the beginning. I was mostly politically uneducated till 2015 but even then I was able to see through Bernie sanders fraud when he did a complete 180 flip on his stance on illegal immigration. Bernie is there to tell you nice things to get votes for Democrats. He was never there to win. Bernie tells people pie in the sky dreams to siphon votes to the Democrats. That's it.
"there is some overlap between some economic progressives, the defund / abolish crew, and the wokies. And absolutely between the wokies and the establishment Dems"
I would argue that the Establishment Dems have gone all in on Wokeness because it's a convenient deflection from actual economic issues. "Watch that squirrel!"
"Dems don't even know what they stand for..."
Perhaps not. But they "know," "stand for" and agree on this much: get Trump, before any others, whatever the costs to the law, principle, our electoral rules or democratic heritage (such as it is), just "get Trump"--lie, cheat, and steal to do it.
"Don't feel 'special'"?!?
The point is rather that Sanders proved unable to effectively counter the misrepresentation of his positions. That's a fatal failing in _ANY_ open, democratic electoral system because it's a given that one's opponents--especially if one is honest--shall defame and misrepresent you.
Trump, one of the most savagely defamed political figures in U.S. history, still won two presidential election and should, today, be in office, except for the blatant electoral fraud that is finally becoming apparent even to many of his former detractors.
Clearly, whether one likes or agrees with Trump the man or the office-holder is beside the point. If he gets the most votes in a fair, open contest under the rules as all parties understood them---not under a criminal conspiracy to thwart his election through ballot fraud--then one is obliged to respect that electoral outcome---or be exposed as an enemy of democratic processes per se.
Sanders' supporters certainly feel "special": specially disgruntled, specially entitled, specially hurt that their candidate, in two efforts (the 2016 and 2020 primaries), in failed to defeat what were thought by many (and, in the first case, thought _especially_ by his own partisans) to be two of the worst candidates for the office of president of the United States in the history of the nation, Hillary Clinton in the first case and Joe Biden in the second.
LOL! Here's "special" for you:
(quote)
... "on July 25, during which he gave Clinton his full support. Some of his supporters attempted to protest Clinton's nomination and booed when Sanders called for party unity. He responded, "Our job is to do two things: to defeat Donald Trump and to elect Hillary Clinton … It is easy to boo, but it is harder to look your kids in the face if we are living under a Trump presidency." ... (Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernie_Sanders#Primary_loss_and_endorsement_of_Hillary_Clinton)
(end quote)
(quote)
" (CNN) Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders on Monday endorsed former Vice President Joe Biden for president, pledging to help him defeat President Donald Trump in the general election as the two agreed to launch a series of task forces to work jointly on policy matters.
" 'We need you in the White House. I will do all that I can to see that that happens, Joe,' Sanders said to Biden during a livestream broadcast by Biden's campaign on his website and on social media.
"The endorsement of Biden by his leading Democratic rival marks a key moment for Democrats as the party seeks to unify and turn its focus toward a November match-up with President Donald Trump.
"Sanders' quick endorsement of Biden in mid-April, just five days after he suspended his campaign, was a stark contrast to the 2016 Democratic race, when Sanders continued to battle Hillary Clinton into June and waited until July to endorse her.
"This time, the former vice president and the Vermont senator sought to immediately address the distrust some of Sanders' supporters have for Biden after a primary campaign in which the two repeatedly clashed on issues like foreign policy and health care.
" 'I think that your endorsement means a great deal,' Biden said. 'It means a great deal to me. I think people are going to be surprised that we are apart on some issues but we're awfully close on a whole bunch of others.'"...
(end quote)
We now have the living proof (which only the most obtuse required) of Biden's incompetence: noticed how Afghanistan took Biden only 8 months to lose to the Taliban? 20 years and a Trillion (est. ) U.S. $ spent: down the spout. Never mind, we have a "nice guy" once more in the White House. That Biden was a fucking fool and a push-over wasn't for a moment lost on them. Nor did the teeming North-bound Central and South Americans eager to take their places as the newest illegal immigrants to the U.S.. massed at the Mexican border, fail to notice.
Yeah, baby! Ain't _that_ "special"?!?!
First of all, I think you need to relax. You're way overthinking my comment, which was me cracking a joke. And was not intended as a bid for being the winner in the victim Olympics. With a serious undertone, and aimed at the Dems, not Trump supporters.
The point being that the Dems have no business whatsoever dissing any voters. If for no other reason, the simple one is that they need the votes. For those of us who supported Bernie, they expected and felt entitled to our votes. For Trump supporters, they need those votes in swing districts. And trashing the voters is absolutely not the way to get them. Considering they lost centrist House seats in swing districts, you'd think they would have learned a lesson. I'm not rating their odds, either in the midterms or in '24.
I always love it (sarc.) when in a forum such as this a reader tells me I "need to relax" or that I'm "overthinking" his or her point.
You were (merely) cracking a joke? Try labeling them for your reader's benefit.
I "overthought" your point?
I thought I'd understood it rather clearly. Your words in answer to this, from "Hugh Fifth of Five", (which you directly cited),
(quote)
Hugh 5th of 5
Aug 11
"As someone from the Republican Right, my fear is that the Establishment Democrats and their allies in the media and big tech will misinterpret my side's arguments. You will get pols like Schumer and Pelosi making straw man arguments about what the GOP stands for, then say that any effort to correct these arguments are lies and must be censored." ...
(end quote)
were, hardly surprisingly, also, in so many words, "relax". That seems to be your boiler-plate retort--(when you have nothing better?)
I misread, "overthought", these, your words,
"Don't feel special"
?
I gather that was to say, in effect, "Take a number, pal."--or, in other words, "Yes, you and millions of others". You don't so much dispute Hugh Fifth of Five as advise him not to take it so hard; apparently because you think that the hordes of company ought to give him some sort of comfort.
And, there, you "underthink" _my_ point: Hugh's candidate (and mine) _won_ the fucking White House--and lost that to a criminal conspiracy which was mounted against him to thwart his deserved re-election.
None of _that_ happened to any candidate _you_ supported, as far as I can tell. In this light, then, I think that there's nothing about your comments, from which you now sheepishly run with the claim that you were "joking", which you can (honestly) show I actually misread or misconstrued.
No, the trouble here is that I got exactly what you meant the _first_ time. And it was cheap and undeserved--toward Hugh Fifth of Five and everyone else like him, myself included.
"Dissing" voters is poor practice? Coming from you, that's another "joke".
Know it or not, you "dissed" Hugh. And that's not just my "overthinking" it.
"noticed how Afghanistan took Biden only 8 months to lose to the Taliban?"
The US has been losing to the Taliban for 20 years. This one ain't on Biden; he wanted us to get out when he was still VP. Barack rolled over for the generals, as always (Trump did too).
Riddle me this; why is it important for the US to occupy Afghanistan? What justifies the expenditure of money and American lives (to say nothing of Afghan lives; they will be expended whether or not we are there) over the course of two decades?
I think it's on Biden. Not on getting out (which i'm in full agreement with), but for quite obviously doing it without a workable plan. Seems to me that it was more important to be symbolic about it (ie getting out by Sept 11), then by having a realistic and workable plan to execute. Which would have included getting the Afghans who helped us all of these years out first, and for planing for the inevitablity of the Taliban moving in quickly to fill the gaps.
Both Greenwald and Turley, both civil liberties lawyers, said that Trump's speech was legal; he didn't actually tell them to go storm the Capitol, and may have been pretty surprised when they did. As were they. When I read the key passages, i thought that, yes, he was inciting something, but apparently he had good legal advice. Of course, his job leading a rally is to get everybody revved up; whether that's '"incitement" is in the eye of the beholder.
Other than the speech not inciting violence (It's like saying "While Fighting the Virus, We Must Fight for Our Rights." or "We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic" - these don't mean fighting as in violence).
Plus speeches like Maxine Watters' "Maxine Waters encourages supporters to harass Trump administration officials" or during the Chauvin trial "Waters calls for protesters to 'get more confrontational' if no guilty verdict is reached in Derek Chauvin trial" are a lot more "incitement".
https://www.cnn.com/2018/06/25/politics/maxine-waters-trump-officials/index.html
https://www.cnn.com/2021/04/19/politics/maxine-waters-derek-chauvin-trial/index.html
And why were the anti-kavanaugh protestors who stormed the capitol and senate chambers all encouraged by Democrats - Pelosi, AOC etc treated differently as compared to the Trump supporters:
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=kavanaugh+protests+capitol&t=h_&iar=images&iax=images&ia=images
Anyone remember when Rand Paul was swarmed by people demanding he say Breonna Taylor’s name after he wrote the Justice for Breonna Taylor Act?
Or the riots last year encouraged and bailed out by Kamala?
Other than all this, the bigger fact which no one seems to mention is that Trump's speech could not have caused the capitol riot because the capitol was stormed before Trump was even done speaking 40 minutes away from the capitol.
I watched it all go down live. Trump was speaking till 1:11PM and on stage till 1:15PM. Capitol was breached at 12:40PM according to WaPo (anti trump source). It is nearly 1.5mi from the Ellipse to the Capitol, which is at least 40-45 min walk with crowd-related delays, that would put the first people from Trump’s speech at Capitol Hill no earlier than 1:56pm – a full hour and sixteen minutes after troublemakers arrived.
And while the Washington Post clumsily attempts to blame President Trump for the violence...their own article admits the first wave of protesters arrived at the Capitol about 12:40pm.
Anyone who claimed his speech was inciting anything at the Capitol is hiding the truth that the Capitol was breached 45 minutes before Trump's speech ended and 40 minute walk away.
Even Twitter performed all sorts of mental gymnastics to claim Trump incited violence even though they couldn't pin point a single place where he did.
Nice summary!
@Oregoncharles
Trump could not have been *that surprised that his mob went down there, the man *literally told the mob "You need to fight like hell ..." and later, "I'll be right there with you." Then the consistent coward, (pleading "Bone Spurs" ? ;-D ) turned tail and went back to the White house to watch the whole thing on TV.
Quickly then, the GOQ goes into the childish defense mode right up there with the classic of childish defense mode: "The dog ate my homework", and busts out with:
"y'all didn't *really see what was being clearly broadcast all over the world. It didn't happen, y'all. You were just havin' an acid flash back."
Know what ? The arguably best version of the movie "Gaslight", the Charles Boyer/Ingrid Bergman version, came out in 1944. The youngsters in elite colleges today *are given school credit for sitting around watching "The Honeymooners". Maybe we need to improve their taste in classic movies.
Judging from many entries on this queue, apparently some commenters on the Right have either never *seen "Gaslight", and are thus *themselves victims of the propaganda technique simply repeating what they have heard, and what they want
to believe; or they are busting their humps in a conscious effort to "Gaslight" others.
Attempting to convince the viewing world that they did not *SEE what was being clearly broadcast is just a lame stab out of some class called "Gaslighting 101".
If anybody *does hope to convince others that they didn't see what they *saw, put a little love behind the lies. Put some effort into it ! Get *good at what you are attempting to accomplish. So far, even Goebbels is embarrassed.
"While Fighting the Virus, We Must Fight for Our Rights."
"We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic"
“Fight for democracy - Hillary Clinton”
Are these all inciting violence Atma? You talking about gaslighting is the funniest shit.
@CNN
I had no doubt that it would go over your head, Slick. Need I remind you
that your comments to me are not welcomed ? I told so awhile ago.
Not knowing what "To the moon, Alice" means or "Hey Ralphie boy!!" has some cultural value at least.
Jackie Gleason was a pretty talented dude.
@HBI
Without question, Jackie was a *master, and a great nostalgic kick from my childhood. He, Art Carney, and Audrey Meadows had perfect comic timing.
The show was great, but the show was *entertainment. Entertainment more than has a place in the human experience, but NOT when one is paying Harvard tuition for watching it, and receiving Harvard Credits that are "equal" to Harvard Credits, in, say quantum physics.
This practice also seriously dumbs-down U.S. Students relative to students from the rest of the globe. Watching B&W TV is what college students used to do while they were *skipping the serious classes that either they, or their parents were paying for.
The problem is when he saw what was happening - he reportedly enjoyed it immensely - if it was not what he at least hoped would happen - he could well have called for it to stop immediately ....
Really? He put up a video which Twitter conveniently took down where he was literally telling people to go home.
It's like destroying the evidence and then claiming there's no evidence.
And how long after it all began did he do that - and what about folks who were with him said he was excited about what he was seeing on TV
By left's own standards:
"While Fighting the Virus, We Must Fight for Our Rights."
or
"We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic"
are all incitements of violence.
But standards don't apply to the "DNC left".
Trigger warning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QfwhI5N95y8
Oh, give me a break - "Stop the Steal! - so how to do that, at that time, in that place - keep the electoral votes from being certified - this is not rocket science ....
If you think "Stop the Steal!" somehow means inciting violence, then you must think "We Can't Stop Fighting for Our Democracy - The Atlantic" must be inciting a war....
That day, Ted Cruz was proposing a 10 day delay in certifying the electoral votes so an audit could be performed in those 10 days. Seems like such basic things are rocket science for you?
What's impressive is that people manage to interpret "Stop the Steal!" as "I want to overthrow the US government!"
It's such a snooze, this whole who's worse: Trump or Sanders; McConnel or Pelosi; Stalin or Hitler. Don't y'all get bored with the lack of new information uncovered in these arguments? Or is not about accumulating information and just about scoring points like in a public school debating society or cricket match?
@Tom Worster
The whole thing puts me *heavily in mind of Plato's "Cave Allegory" contained in his work "The Republic." Plato describes society as being in the bottom of a cave, seated chained in a circle with their backs facing the center of the cave. In that center is a large fire. Between that fire and the chained society are unseen, and unnamed beings who use forms to project shadows on the wall past the society. Chained as society is, with their backs to the center, all they see their entire lives are the shadows being cast upon the wall in front of them. So, society competes (being human) on the progression of the shadows, betting on which (of a limited number) of the shadows will be coming up next. For their entire lives .... they bicker about shadows being produced by the controllers in the center. But Society thinks that the shadows are all there *IS in life, and they therefore make no attempt to seek for truth *beyond the "Shadow World", or the "Shadow Game". The shadow world is Plato's stand-in for the world of 3-D reality. The rest of the allegory goes on to illustrate what it means to finally break away, beyond that limitation.
Sometimes this queue (which is actually the most intellectual comment queue I have come across, because I am quite social media "shy" [averse]), reminds me for all the world of Plato's "Shadow Game". Plato wrote that 2,400 years ago. Society has not changed one scintilla since. Better technology, different clothes, but still stuck playing by the rules of the "Shadow Game". Breaking those chains, and escaping the Shadow World is the goal Plato proposed for his students. Even Plato understands that very few will succeed.
You're being told to shut up.
It's a very ineffective strategy. Four boxes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RPZtX9rDzGY
The Republican Right is a very small group if you exclude all the blow hards that claim to be conservative, but are actually just self serving assholes.
Most Americans belong to the authoritarian party. They call themselves Left or Right, but it only takes me about 2 questions to identify which opposition they want censored and locked in cages.
As a lifelong leftist -- whatever that is supposed to mean any more (people who are willing to work should be able to earn a living wage?) I am sympathetic to this viewpoint.
Exactly what they are doing. Sickens me
This is pitiful:
“Jay similarly believed Trump’s speech was perhaps designed to incite a destabilizing moment during which acting Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller could declare martial law. The fear …..”.
Jay “believed” a speech was “perhaps designed…. ? Perhaps, perhaps not? Perhaps Jay’s a twit, perhaps he isn’t! 50/50.
Are we supposed to take him seriously? If so, to what end? Perhaps we will never know …..; perhaps.
Agreed. Total idiot but let him spew his nonsense
I take him seriously. He's done a tons of great stuff.
Do you know the piece? I've listened to it twice. Once when it was new and the other time a couple of weeks ago. Jay's interpretation of Trump's behavior is worth considering. Who knows what any of Trump's actual intentions are? (Assuming there's enough coherence to his intentions to talk about meaningfully about them.) I think Jay's idea fits as well as any other.
Nope. I dont
I love a good conspiracy theory and this one is unusually good.
I'm actually anti-conspiracy theory on the merits. It's too easy to make one up. My wife is really into them, though. But she also believes in homeopathy and Reiki. I think it's a brain chemistry thing.
This is the first I’ve heard of him. Personally I don’t find Trump’s intentions to be any more or less coherent/incoherent than BO, GW or any other politician’s intentions; they all want to get reelected.
Of course, what could have some bearing on that is I don’t have an out of control hatred for any of them. Might it be you and your ilk hold Trump to a different standard?
My ilk? Please elaborate.
People who say things like, "Assuming there's enough coherence to [Trump's] intentions to talk about meaningfully about them."
Perhaps it wasn’t intentional, perhaps it was, but it’s interesting you didn’t address the suggestion you hold Trump to a different standard from say BO and other Presidents.
As for question about your ilk, I defer to the accurate assessment provided by ruralbob.
I didn’t name anyone, but a noticeable portion of people who post here sure give the appearance of being driven by an out of control hatred for Trump. Without knowing anything about Tom, other than his statement about Trump’s coherence, perhaps it is easy to conclude Tom falls into that category.
As for having said hatred, that’s cool, it’s cool as long as one acknowledges it. It’s those who possess it yet try to pass themselves off as reasoned thinkers of the day, who induce out of control laughter, as opposed to out of control hate.
Personally I consider the past several presidents to be revolting trash, but their significance to my daily life is nil, thus perhaps they are not worth the time and trouble to hate.
Doesn't matter: He should be free to speak his mind and report what he wants to, even on a so-called "private platform" that makes a killing on selling people's information publicly by data mining every keystroke, photo, linked friend, private message, etc.
It'll never happen before the end of it all though, so don't hold your breath.
I agree with you on that. The problem is that we seem to be willing to give the luxury of free speech to our opponents but our opponents don't want to give us the same luxury. And this luxury is supposed to be a fundamental liberty.
I agree completely. I would never propose squelching his, or anyone’s voice, even though I personally may see nothing worth noting from his/their efforts. Perhaps ….. ⛳️
He's probably an asshat, but why was an asshat censored on every platform of note? That is the issue, not the quality of the content.
They misidentified him as a Trump supporter. They are buffoons
Perhaps Youtube was confused
They need to be dinged for everything until they are labeled a common carrier.
Never gonna happen as long as the current politicians have their seats.
What Jay doesn't mention is that the fear he was victim to, and that much of Washington was victim to that week, the fear of a military coup, CAUSED Jan. 6.
The people responsible for the decision to not have the National Guard deployed, the Sgts at Arms of both the House and Senate (and Miller himself, incidentially) testified before congress that the reason they did not deploy the National Guard was to avoid the optics that Trump would attempt a military coup. And no National Guard meant the Capitol Police were overrun. TDS FTW, once again!
Fake fear, no less. They'd talked themselves into a tizzy over nothing and reaped the whirlwind.
Besides which, they deserved every iota of the election fraud thing. 4 years of bullshit collusion claims, one good turn deserves another. This election fraud thing is going to last a lot longer than 4 years, though. All the Jan 6 whining in the world won't make the doubt go away - the more it is censored and the debate is put off, the more the doubt grows.
At first I thought Russiagate was just desserts for birtherism, as turnabout is fair play, but the emergence of blatantly illegal intelligence community and law enforcement activity changed that.
I still can't believe they just all freaking wiped or dumped their phones and got away with that. There's so much, but that just gets me. Professionals who know exactly what they are doing colluding to destroy evidence and getting away with it scot free.
@Substack Commenter 34
Fully agreed, and easily seen.
This is a version of how Weimar went south. More and more extralegal stuff "temporarily" in use just to stabilize things, from a certain party's vantage point. Then people later took that as a precedent to do more extralegal stuff until that was all that was left.
@HBI
Standard military ops ! Raid the village, poison the water well with dead animals.
Correct you are. This will last a LONG time, and that is partly why it was undertaken to begin with. This is too well planned, and too long range even to be blamed on Trump, personally.
So you freely admit that the "election fraud thing" is made up? And it's just petty retribution for Russiagate? Cool.
Now wouldn't that be simple. But no, I don't know what happened in the election. That's humility and integrity right there. The thing that the media and apparently you don't have. What I do have is lots of schadenfreude.
You see, the only thing that would defuse this thing would be a pants down audit of the whole process. The one thing that won't be done. So it's going to keep festering - past the midterms, past 2024. The media and you can say it's a lie all you want - it just feeds into the impression of dishonesty created by the unwillingness to audit. This is politics 101, folks. The silencing of Trump fits right in with this.
Just enjoying the spectacle of people hoist on their own petard. A real Pyrrhic victory, 2020 was.
@Substack Commenter 34
"to avoid the optics that Trump would attempt a military coup."
Really ? And while worrying about "saving face" countless people *could literally have been dying inside ? THAT sounds like a weak-kneed "the dog ate my homework" level cop-out than *any kind of "tight combat readiness strategy". This clearly did *not result as the result of a "comedy of errors" - it was planned. Poorly planned, granted, but no "accident" nonetheless.
@Substack Commenter 34
Well analyzed, aptly put ! Kudos
It's a futile attempt to avoid the illegitimacy of the current government. Futile, I say, because sniping at one or the other candidates isn't going to settle the legitimacy question. With the Democrats putting their fingers in their ears and saying "HR 1, HR 1" and the Republicans in their usual supine position, don't expect a solution anytime soon. An actual statesman would be nice right about now.
@HBI
Absolutely correct, yes. Sniping at the individual candidates is like walking up to a cauldron of boiling water, and trying to push all of the *bubbles down.
" ... clearly Trump is not going to be president ..." Don't bet on it ...
Perhaps I’m wrong, after all, it’s bound to happen eventually 🍺, but maybe you think you get muddled answers because your question are a bit muddled. That is if they resemble this particular post.
Am I correct in concluding you are of the opinion the government bureaucrats, the Biden administration and Big Phrama, who claim all is well with the vaccines, are accurately telling the facts?
That, of course, would imply, perhaps, you conclude anyone who disagrees with the afore mentioned cabal, errr I mean concerned benefactors, are little more than narrow-minded conspiracy theorist?
"...I see the vaccine working..." Really? You SEE it working? Personally?
You invoke--saying you subscribe to--Occam's razor. Very well. I suppose you're also familiar, then, with the phrase "Post hoc. ergo propter hoc" to describe the logical fallacy in which you're wallowing here.
I hear people assure me with no less confidence than yours that they "See Jesus working." What do you say to such people?
Superstitions come in all kinds of colors and flavors.
Consider: might not the marked fall off in infections, hospitalizations and deaths due to this virus not be just as plausibly accounted for by the simple fact that it has already killed millions around the world?--those, by chance, (never mind their demographic profile) ipso facto, "most vulnerable"?
What, if anything, do you do with this? I? It gives me pause.
Maybe it ought to give you pause. There's another latin phrase, this one taught early in medical school: "Primum non nocere." it means that, where one lacks genuine understanding based on empirically-based knowledge, not hopes or guess-work, one refrains rather than leaps ahead.
Where Covid vaccines are concerned, the health-care profession forgot its creeds and leapt.
Biden and Big Phrma, Trump and Big Phrma - what's the difference ...
Interesting, I was responding and for some reason my three paragraphs literally disappeared. I’ll try again:
No kudos to YouTube for responding to queries only when they come from a high-profile journalist. That's a sign of their corruption and the corruption of our elected officials for allowing them to become so powerful.
They only responded because this guy's viewpoint was aligned with YouTube's narrative.
That may have been why they acted in his favor, but it's not why they assigned a human being to look into it.
Here is the algorithm. Is the information put out by our friends? Yes...It's OK regardless of content. No....even though it is exactly what our friends claim it must be banned. And by friends we mean people or groups that when we lobby they gives us what we want, or we sure did enjoy the cocktail party the other night. Wasn't it fun disparaging all those deplorables. Fuck Google and YouTube. There are alternatives. Brave and Odysee.
"Let them eat cake." -some cunt at a swanky NYC cocktail party last week.
Some sophisticated and vaccinated cunts at a swanky party on the Vinyard last weekend.
Don't be a racist bigot. The systemically oppressed Obamas were just hosting a small sophisticated unmasked party of over 500 celebrities at their systemically oppressed $15 million mansion along the beach which is supposed to be under water because of all the climate change and rising sea water.
John Kerry, US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate Change, who owns beach front property (rising sea levels????), flew in his private jet (CO2 emissions????) to attend systemically oppressed Obama's birthday party at his $15 million beach front property (rising sea levels????).
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9869959/John-Legend-Chrissy-Teigen-Dwyane-Wade-arrive-Marthas-Vineyard-Obamas-birthday-bash.html
You just need to get sophisticated to be immune to covid.
Well, that's me told.
*hangs head*
Marie Antoinette was actually responding to an artificially imposed bread quota put in place by the French government to raise prices. If you got to the braisserie too late and the day’s quota of bread was already sold, you had to buy cake instead.
Your sentiment is spot on though!
Brioche. Not cake.
Why is "cunt" in every other comment you make? So disgusting!
I have it on very good authority that cunts are not disgusting.
Well put!!
1 Trump and GOP are truly HORRIBLE.
2 --DNC oligarchs (Biden, Pelosi, Schumer) are even WORSE (censorship, they concocted Russia-gate hoax, torture of Julian Assange, Daniel Hale’s persecution for Obama’s drone crimes, $16B Haiti-corruption under Hillary/Obama – Biden-family corruption pales in comparison)
The ONLY solution – vote THIRD party – now and forever. ALWAYS vote – but VOTE for a Third (or fourth, fifth..) party – at ALL levels, especially at LOCAL levels (vote OUT each and every incumbent).
“If you always vote for the lesser of two evils, you will always have evil, and you will always have less.” [Ralph Nader].
Only ACTION: Sustained organized mass civil disobedience - not distractions like DNC-controlled hollering and tweeting....
I've got a different idea.
What is it? Don't leave us in suspense ;-))
I wonder about the wisdom of the whole content moderation thing. Terrorist beheadings and kiddie porn, sure. Block 'em. No problem. But I'm not sure Youtube is actually changing minds for the better by silencing political views it disapproves of, especially if they're widely held. Doesn't matter if they're right or wrong, true or not. The very fact of these large, powerful, well resourced institutions presuming to decide on "truth" and what we're allowed to hear, consider, think about or believe just amplifies the rampant distrust and conspiracy mongering. It convinces nobody. It just produces backlash.
It's highly cynical, actually. The logic is that if they stupids don't see the things that Youtube's masters don't like, they'll forget about that stuff.
And no, it doesn't work, at least the way they want it to. It further radicalizes people.
Sure does. I get angrier every day.
Don't hold your breath ....
I’m glad someone mentioned “terrorist beheadings”. Imagine for a minute that YouTube allowed that and, to generate some revenue, put ads up between victims. Disgusting, right? Now, go to YouTube and search “AC-130 gunship”. You’ll be treated to gun camera footage of human beings being slaughtered like fish in a barrel. It’s mesmerizing until you remember it’s not some video game. While being declared “enemies” of the USA, making them “fair game”, the victims are still someone’s son, father, or husband. And YouTube throws up ads. YouTube’s supposed “standards” are disgusting.
Bu,bu,but - they're the "bad guys", right? and I am sure AI has no problem with killing the "bad guys" - after all it deals with the data fed to it ....
I think it's less a wisdom an more a natural logic. The internet monopolies are trying to defend their business. In a simplistic model they are trying to balance two goals. One we can understand as the PR goal of being allowed to maintain their legally tenuous monopoly privileges, the loss of which has a $ value they can estimate. The other is ad revenue minus operating cost.
The PR part could be pretty complicated but so far these firms seem to be simply following the preferences of lamestream news media. Youtube in particular has explicitly stated that's how they do it.
So it doesn't make any sense as an editorial policy serving a social good and any coherent of "wisdom" you may discern, if any, has to be an emergent property.
And those "emergent properties" are very valuable pieces of "real" estate ...
Yes, so far both the Lamestream and the New Secular Moralists (of all stripes, including MT/TK) have made hay by pointing at these patterns and declaring validation or shenanigans resp. but this could easily change.
Honestly, I know it is popular with the social media set to toss around insurrection, coup, and rebellion. But, nothing of the sort was planned, organized or acted upon. Milley is a delicate flower - and partisan. Those how opposed Trump - and many of the top brass did - came up with all kinds of loose talk claiming a coup was in process. Trump felt the election was stolen; and then felt he could capitalize on this when the facts did not fully back him up.
But in their defense, the Trump campaign filed dozens of cases and not one, not one, was heard on the merits. All were tossed out for standing, lack of claim, and other procedural matters. What is a shame is we know there was some election ‘irregularities’ and we know there is little cooperation to get to the bottom of these. This legitimizes Trump’s claims - as does Facebook when is censors Trump or election discussion.
I have lived through an insurrection. Insurrectionists bring guns, tanks, and rocket launchers. They are organized and generally funded. Our insurrectionists were a bad version of Animal House. Rowdy, loud, and lost.
Milley and the silly social media set need to stop pretending the Republic almost fell and face facts. This was a temper tantrum.
The best description for January 6th was a "riot."
The Florida Recount, Brooks Brothers Riot, and SCOTUS decision in 2000 smells a more like a coup to me. Had the unfortunate characteristic of being successful too.
It was so obvious we don't need that testimony. "There's not enough time to do a fair recount, so we have to quit with our guy ahead" Not enough time.
That said, if an NFL team has to whine about the referees, they actually just needed to play better so the refs didn't matter in the first place.
Milley enjoys yelling about "white rage" in front of congress.
His other generals like lying to the President about the troop numbers in Syria.
Others enjoy making up the russian bounty hoax to prevent pulling out of Afghanistan.
And we are supposed to believe whatever they are selling.
Copy pasting an old comment. This is not specific to you, it's just relevant to your question.
Democrats spent over 40 million and 3 years chasing some russian collusion, then inventing russian bounty hoaxes but somehow any audit or signature matching is not allowed in 2020. Pathetic hypocrisy.
Democrats being against voter id clearly tells me they enjoy cheating. It's like opposing ID for buying cigarettes or booze and then claiming no underage kid ever bought a cigarette or booze. Monmouth University released a poll on early voting and voter ID. The poll found the majority of Americans support voter ID, and more minorities support voter ID than white people. Question 31 on page 7: 84% of minorities. & 77% of white people support voter ID. Yet Democrats keep claiming voter id is somehow racist:
https://www.monmouth.edu/polling-institute/documents/monmouthpoll_us_062121.pdf/
I can present hundreds of examples but I don't think it's worth it because nobody's mind will change. I like how everyone agrees Bernie got cheated out twice, DNC using the IOWA "app" to cheat again and somehow the general election was perfectly cool. I will give a few examples for the audience here:
I am sure these types of vote counts where a candidate make vertical jumps in multiple states after vote counting has stopped and at 4am when Republican observers have been sent home is totally cool:
https://archive.vn/Lqji8/a840d17932a735d5648722b6907eec28b4ce75bb.webp
Wisconsin:
https://archive.vn/Lqji8/8992469bd89042e7d89485ebbd3a104a59f37be2.webp
I am sure the 6000 votes which was exposed to have been switched from Trump to Biden in Antrim County and similarly in GA - all mistakes in one direction - was totally cool:
https://www.westernjournal.com/michigan-recount-confirms-trump-won-county-went-biden/
The typical excuses I hear when I point out how Biden won as "the most popular president with 12 million more votes than Obama" and yet couldn't get 10 people at his rallies is "Because Biden voters believe in science and didn't want to go out during a pandemic" to which I reply with "Then why did his YouTube videos and live streams also not get any views and got ratioed to the point where YouTube has to actively remove dislikes?
White House Youtube Dislike Manipulation:
https://phzoe.com/2021/01/27/white-house-youtube-dislike-manipulation/
Someone built a tracker for the likes/dislikes on Biden's White House:
https://81m.org
https://rumble.com/vdcuql-130k-dislikes-removed-from-white-house-youtube-channel-in-24-hours.html
130 Thousand dislikes were removed in a 24hr period! And this is for the most popular US President of all time!
Another response is "Trump's personality cost him the election" to which I reply with "Trump has a in party approval of 95% - highest EVER" and Republicans gained tons of house seats and even state house and senate seats. So somehow people were voting for republicans but not for Trump despite him having 95% approval? It's the opposite - people voted for Republican house and senate BECAUSE Trump asked them too. It's been shown time and time again that the constituents like Trump, they hate the establishment RINOs. Hence the 95% approval in his party.
Usually first-time mail voters ~3X more likely to spoil ballot. In GA 2016 whopping 6.4% failed, 2020 just 0.2%. In PA, rate 0.03% in 2020 vs ~1% in 2016. Nevada from 1.60% in 2016 to ~0.75% this year. N.C. rate ~2.7% in 2016 to 0.8%. Totally cool.
Biden somehow gets 12 million more votes but only in VERY select few cities - enough to push him over in the entire state. And somehow ends up losing house seats, state house, senate seats. And Trump - who's the first Republican to make major gains in blacks and hispanics, his party makes major gains everywhere from house seats to state senate races loses.
Bellwether Counties Went Overwhelmingly for Trump in 2020. All but one of the 19 bellwethers picked President Donald Trump by a margin of some 16 points on average. They all accurately picked the president since 1980. Before the elections, here's NYTimes claiming:
> "The 10 Bellwether Counties That Show How Trump Is in Serious Trouble. Each one is in a battleground state. Votes from people there will matter a lot — and offer Joe Biden several paths to victory. Conversely, Mr. Trump would likely need to win at least eight of those 10 states for a second term. A look at these bellwethers — all either tossups or leaning toward Mr. Biden — makes clear that Mr. Trump is in serious trouble." NYTimes was claiming Biden will easily win thw bell weathers too.
https://archive.ph/Ezn1d
Once the elections were over and all but one bell weather county that had chosen every presidential winner since 1980 went for President Trump in 2020, suddenly "bellwether counties are not a good way of indicating". HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAAHAA whatever doesn't fit the narrative suddenly becomes unreliable.
I am sure those perfectly coordinated stopping of counting in the 6 states on election night was totally cool.
I am sure the GA "pipe burst" which was widely claimed as the reason for stopping counting at 10:30PM in Fulton and used to send observers home - and then for the black chick and her daughter to pull out a box with ballots and re-scan the same ballots 4 times all on video was all just totally cool. And guess what - that pipe burst story also turned out to be completely false - in fact it didn't even happen that day - it happened the day prior and has nothing to stop counting as exposed by the the FOIA requests:
https://archive.is/2Ara4
https://archive.is/5Liz7
https://archive.vn/m56Gv
https://archive.is/G7KOu
> Fulton County Elections head Richard Barron said Wednesday that the pipe dumped a lot of water, soaking the carpeting and hampering work. “It looked really like there was rain coming out of the ceiling and the entire carpeting was just covered in water,” he said. “There was no way to go in there and perform work.”
In the hearings, the state officials claimed it was a toilet leak which happened at 6am and was fixed by 8am - not at night.
All so well coordinated. Yet these people can't keep their story straight.
I am sure covering up the voting counts with boards in Detroit is totally cool.
I am sure Democrats and RINO republicans absolutely refusing to do a REAL SIGNATURE MATCH audit before certifying must be because everything was cool.
CA Governor recall petition had a signature unmatched of 20%. But for the general election, it's somehow less than 1% everywhere. Totally cool.
I am sure judge dismissing cases claiming Republicans being blocked and put over 20 feet away from counting was totally okay because they were still in same building is totally cool.
42,000 people in Nevada voted more than once, 1,500 dead, 19,000 didn't live in Nevada, 8,000 voted from a non-existent address, 15,000 registered to a commercial address and 4,000 non-citizens.
Please explain why at least 10315 dead voters, 8718 died before they voted, 66,247 underage, 2560 felons, 5300 voting in multiple states, 15700 out of state voters, 40279 voting in wrong county etc in Georgia alone.
I am sure the 3000 signed affidavits under penalty of perjury were all lying. If they were all lying, then why have none of the affidavit signers been prosecuted for lying (the DOJ is clearly very pro prosecuting Trump supporters).
Florida fixed their shit and ran one of the smoothest elections despite having more population than NY and twice the population of GA. Florida was able to finish their election counting within 2 hours of poll closures. GA and NY and other states with less population took weeks....
The best is this 2016 BBC article "Vote rigging: How to spot the tell-tale signs". The 2020 US election passes every sign from this article. But it's totally cool. Nothing to see here, move along:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-37243190
In key swing states this year, mail-in ballot rejections plummeted from 2016 rates. Rates are below historical average and significantly less than most recent presidential election - despite having massive mail in voting:
https://justthenews.com/politics-policy/elections/key-swing-states-year-mail-ballot-rejections-plummeted-2016-rates
Largest data breach in the history of America, Largest censorship of half the population's voice. Also most secure election ever! - CISA dot gov
> SolarWinds hack was 'largest and most sophisticated attack' ever: Microsoft president
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyber-solarwinds-microsoft-idUSKBN2AF03R
> What you need to know about the biggest hack of the US government in years
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/dec/15/orion-hack-solar-winds-explained-us-treasury-commerce-department
> The November 3rd election was the most secure in American history.
https://www.cisa.gov/news/2020/11/12/joint-statement-elections-infrastructure-government-coordinating-council-election
All this doesn't even cover the unconstitutional voting law changes and mass mail-in voting using out dated voter rolls without voter ID. Or the censorship aspect.
The unconstitutional voting law changes alone should have changed the elections.
Using factcheck as your source is like using cnn as a source for russiagate nonsense. Same factcheck site which claimed lab leak was a conspiracy theory and got me banned from social media.
Antirim County was not a conspiracy theory. Even left leaning sources admitted that 6000 votes were switched from trump to Biden. Somehow all mistakes went in Biden’s favour and these are only the ones which we know about.
Please tell me how before the elections, nytimes and Washington post claimed all bell weather counties favored Biden but after elections, trump won 19 of the 20 bell weather counties and the same media claims bell weather counties don’t mean anything??? Please explain this to me.
Btw I am not talking about the Sidney Powell and Lin Wood nonsense. Those people did more damage by chasing every red herring instead of going for the real issues.
http://wiseenergy.org/Energy/Election/2020_Election_Cases.htm
The LEFT and corporate media along with big tech are modern-day book burners. It’s sad - how does it get fixed Matt?
The actual LEFT doesn't want censorship, because they understand that it applies to different political dissidents over time. The Democratic party, which isn't LEFT, wants it because its a convenient way to shut down their political opponents (i.e. people who love Trump) at the moment.
I think it's dishonest to say that the Trump movement is not dangerous, but censorship is strategically the wrong move, as it has the exact opposite effect it intends to, and it gives them a gift to feel persecuted (i.e. Marjorie Taylor Greene wearing a mask that says "censored" on it)
No true leftist. Lmao.
Could you offer up an estimate of how many American citizens are on the "Left"?
As I often hear it described by the "No True Leftist" crowd, it can't be more than a few dozen.
The Democrats epitomize Left. Left is collectivism, of which identity politics is a subset, and intolerance is a defining trait.
The problem will not be solved as long as people keep carrying water for what is wrong.
Comments like these always engage in the No true Scotsman fallacy. By your logic, it would seem like Trump and his supporters are all LEFT wing?
Perhaps it’s because trump supporters are rightfully upset with institutions that have failed them. But are only presented with a demagogue like tromp because he was the only one (in rhetoric at least) that talked openly about institutions failing. Bernie Sanders has a similar message but has actual policy ideas that most people who voted for Trump would actually appreciate and benefit from. Thus the schism in American politics. The Democratic Party does everything it can to make Bernie sanders and his surrogates fail. We are only presented with a terrible version of the Democratic Party. You might disagree with this. But this is my assessment.
One of the best things against Bernie Sanders is that he used to complain about illegal immigration being "right wing proposals". Until 2016. We all know what changed in 2016 when Orange Man announced his run. Bernie used to hate illegal immigration, called it a “right wing proposal” “using a dollar or two wages to drive down wages of Americans”. And then he did a flip calling Orange Man a racist and xenophobic etc and became open border advocate. Just listen to his own words in this VOX interview and tell me how what he used to say was any different from Orange Man and how he's now done a full 180:
https://youtu.be/vf-k6qOfXz0
Bernie Sanders attacked the socialist Liberty Union Party in 1981 for accommodating the 351 Jamaican immigrants in his state's apple orchards: "With the Vermont unemployment rate one of the highest in the nation, I could never support importing foreign workers when our own people are out of work." ... "It sounds like she wants to bring slavery back to Vermont." said Sanders, who was collecting unemployment insurance at the time. For socialist Sanders, then 33, the situation supported his contention that businesses were yet again selling out U.S. residents in favor of cheap labor.
Even in 2007, he said:
“If poverty is increasing and if wages are going down, I don’t know why we need millions of people to be coming into this country as guest workers who will work for lower wages than American workers and drive wages down even lower than they are right now,” Sanders said. ” … On one hand, you have large multinationals trying to shut down plants in America, move to China, and on the other hand, you have the service industry bringing in low-wage workers from abroad. The result is the same: Middle class gets shrunken, and wages go down.”
"I think as you've heard today, sanctions against employers who employ illegal immigrants is virtually nonexistent. Our border is very porous," Sanders said during a press conference at the time. “And I think at a time when the middle class is shrinking, the last thing we need is to bring over in a period of years, millions of people into this country who are prepared to lower wages for American workers." "I think from a moral responsibility, we've got to work with the rest of the industrialized world to address the problems of international poverty," he said in a 2015 interview. "But you don't do that by making people in this country even poorer." In both cases, Sanders defended his vote by suggesting that the guest worker provisions in the bill were “akin to slavery,” a notable shift from how Sanders talked about immigrant labor before his presidential bids.
Again in 2013:
"I'll tell you look what my concern is the provisions dealing with the guest worker programs. Real unemployment in America counting those people have given up looking for work and are working part-time when they want to work full-time in order is close to 14 percent. It's higher for young people it is higher for people of color. You have in this bill guest worker programs that will bring in hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers. You know on television you hear these guys talk about all PhDs are coming into this country....hundreds of thousands of entry-level workers to work in kitchens waiters waitresses lifeguards ski resort workers. Is it really true that we can't find American workers to do those jobs? Frankly I don't believe it.
Given the magnitude of the problem it doesn't go anywhere near far enough so the nation we have got to ask ourselves do we really need when you go to ghettos in this country when you go to inner cities you have thirty forty percent unemployment do we really need hundreds of thousands of workers entry-level workers from around the country coming in competing against these kids? I think not."
Even the leftist washington post admits: "For years, Bernie Sanders warned that increased immigration would lower the wages of U.S. workers. Now he barely mentions it.":
https://archive.is/Ek7Xa
But when Trump ran in 2015, he switched and became radical open border. He says "Illegal immigrants are "entitled" to the same government benefits as citizens":
https://twitter.com/RNCResearch/status/1231347412356210688
During the DNC debates, all Democrats including Bernie raised their hands that Illegal Immigrants Should Get Health Care Coverage.
Here's more:
https://youtu.be/TtMqldNYloY
This video perfect describes how fake fact checkers keep making excuses for Democrats:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4SkGOCkhEs
This flip flopping and pie in the sky promises are quite natural for Bernie Sanders. Mr $15 an hour Bernie Sanders refused to pay his staff $15 because his campaign couldn't afford to. He has been a Vermont senator for 30+ years! The min wage in Vermont is still $10.
Bernie's hotel demands from his “Senator Comfort Memo”: King-size beds and 60-degree rooms. He flies on private jets and has a memo detailing minimum requirements of the private jet. He used to complain about millionaires and billionaires. Until 2 years ago when he became a millionaire. Then only the billionaires were the problem for him. You can verify this by going through his twitter history. The "millionaires and billionaires" change to "billionaires" only. He released his tax returns couple years ago. For someone complaining so much about poor people suffering, he barely paid anything in charity from his multi millions. For someone who's so anti-pharma, Bernie still gladly took $1.3 million from Pharma. Orange Man got $2.5 million and Biden took $8.5 million:
https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?cycle=2020&ind=h04
Bernie, "mr. anti-big-pharma" took $1,301,155 from Big Pharma in 2020. He was also the number 1 recipient in the senate for pharma manufacturing in 2020 by getting $416,066, Ossoff, Jon was second with $302,137, Elizabeth Warren got $291,168. Thom Tillis was 4th got $270,270 and Mitch McConnell was 5th at $265,980:
https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?ind=H4300&cycle=2020&recipdetail=S&Mem=Y&sortorder=U
Why would pharma manufacturing give the most money to Bernie and other democrats and more than Mitch and Lindsey Graham? Kindness of their heart?
Bernie regularly engages in identity politics which is basically CRT. He even called Orange Man a xenophobe and said he wouldn't have shutdown travel from China. He said: "I wouldn't have closed the air traveling with China if I was a president. Trump is racist xenophobic."
Bernie also supports the AOC/Cori Bush squad who regularly exploit identity politics / defund the police nonsense while giving themselves more police funding. So claiming he doesn't wade into CRT is false.
Bernie endorsed Biden after getting fucked in his ass twice by the DNC. He couldn't grow up a spine to call out Biden's and his son's obvious corruption, instead he called him a good friend and respectable man. You think such a spineless man could stand up to foreign nations?
Unlike Bernie who rolled over at the very first sight, Orange Man at least put up a fight and won the nomination. Imagine Bernie rolling over like that to foreign nations. He got "cheated" out twice from the nomination and he rolled over without a fight - maybe because this was the plan all along for Democrats to use him to get the left to vote for Biden. Then he refused to look at the "cheating" allegations from Orange Man. Everyone agrees Bernie got cheated out twice, DNC using the IOWA "app" to cheat again and somehow the general election was perfectly okay.
He called Biden his friend and respectable man. Didn't even have the balls of calling out his obvious selling out to China and his son using his office for profit. Now he's going on CNN making excuses on why they couldn't get $15 minimum wage, why $2000 has still not gone out, why $1400 is more than enough instead of the $2000 they promised, why medicare for all is now too hard to achieve. And his supporters thought Bernie would care about them LMFAO. When his supporters couldn't wake up to how big of a pathetic cuck Bernie was when he gave up his mic to the 2 BLM activists at his own rally, how he did a full 180 flip on illegal immigration when Orange Man ran, then nothing will wake them up.
I am surprised it took this long for people to see through AOC and Bernie. Bernie was always in on it with the establishment dems from the beginning. I was mostly politically uneducated till 2015 but even then I was able to see through Bernie sanders fraud when he did a complete 180 flip on his stance on illegal immigration. Bernie is there to tell you nice things to get votes for Democrats. He was never there to win. Bernie tells people pie in the sky dreams to siphon votes to the Democrats. That's it.
Trump and his supporters are in fact fiscally liberal and socially conservative. So you're actually half-correct. On fiscal matters, they really are left-wing.
They are left of past Republicans, but not nearly so Left as Democrats.
@Robert Nottoli
Primo Comment ! Very astute.
By making these big tech companies common carriers.
SCOTUS Justice Clarence Thomas opined couple months ago discussing big tech censorship quite extensively. The case was regarding whether Trump was allowed to block people on Twitter and it being a 1st amendment violation. While the case was declared moot as Trump left office, Justice Clarence Thomas took the opportunity to discuss censorship. How politicians aren't allowed to block users on big tech but big tech is able to block and ban politicians and government employees and how this creates a weird power dynamic.
I would highly recommend reading his opinion:
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/20-197_5ie6.pdf
Here's a few excerpts:
> "But whatever may be said of other industries, there is clear historical precedent for regulating transportation and communications networks in a similar manner as traditional common carriers. Candeub 398–405. Telegraphs, for example, because they “resemble[d] railroad companies and other common carriers,” were “bound to serve all customers alike, without discrimination." ... "Internet platforms of course have their own First Amendment interests, but regulations that might affect speech are valid if they would have been permissible at the time of the founding. See United States v. Stevens, 559 U. S. 460, 468 (2010). The long history in this country and in England of restricting the exclusion right of common carriers and places of public accommodation may save similar regulations today from triggering heightened scrutiny—especially where a restriction would not prohibit the company from speaking or force the company to endorse the speech." ... "The similarities between some digital platforms and common carriers or places of public accommodation may give legislators strong arguments for similarly regulating digital platforms. [I]t stands to reason that if Congress may demand that telephone companies operate as common carriers, it can ask the same of ”digital platforms." ... "For example, although a “private entity is not ordinarily constrained by the First Amendment,” Halleck, 587 U. S., at ___, ___ (slip op., at 6, 9), it is if the government coerces or induces it to take action the government itself would not be permitted to do, such as censor expression of a lawful viewpoint. Ibid. Consider government threats. “People do not lightly disregard public officers’ thinly veiled threats to institute criminal proceedings against them if they do not come around.” Bantam Books, Inc. v. Sullivan, 372 U. S. 58, 68 (1963). The government cannot accomplish through threats of adverse government action what the Constitution prohibits it from doing directly. See ibid.; Blum v. Yaretsky, 457 U. S. 991, 1004–1005 (1982). Under this doctrine, plaintiffs might have colorable claims against a digital plat- form if it took adverse action against them in response to government threats. The Second Circuit feared that then-President Trump cut off speech by using the features that Twitter made available to him. But if the aim is to ensure that speech is not smothered, then the more glaring concern must perforce be the dominant digital platforms themselves."
> "As Twitter made clear, the right to cut off speech lies most powerfully in the hands of private digital platforms. The extent to which that power matters for purposes of the First Amendment and the extent to which that power could lawfully be modified raise interesting and important questions. This petition, unfortunately, affords us no opportunity to confront them."
The last 2 points are important as Justice Thomas is basically saying "give us a case which brings up these two questions and then we will have a deep look."
One can even cite Amazon's recent censorship of SCOTUS Justice Clarence Thomas's own documentary as well as Eli Steele’s documentary as examples:
https://archive.is/aNv3B
I also suggest reading and consider the application of Robins v. Pruneyard Shopping Center (1979) 23 Cal.3d 899
https://law.justia.com/cases/california/supreme-court/3d/23/899.html
to Twitter, which after all is headquartered in CA. Under Pruneyard, the owner of a public shopping mall could not exclude students engaged in political activities. An argument could be made that social media sites, like shopping centers in 1979, are places "to which the public is invited [and] can provide an essential and invaluable forum for exercising [speech and petition] rights." So, the infringement of free speech by social media would seem to be unconstitutional (at least in CA)."
Thomas compares Twitter to common carriers:
Thomas suggested that the case could fall under two other doctrines. The first was the doctrine of common carriers, in which private entities in the transportation and communication sectors are tightly tied to “public concerns.” Governments had, for example, required telegraph companies to serve all customers. Second, governments might restrict a company’s right to exclude individuals from public accommodations.
In exploring these analogies, Thomas noted that companies were not typically treated as speakers for “information that they merely distribute.” He focused on the manner in which digital platforms “have dominant market share” in a business that “may have substantial barriers to entry.” This gives such companies as Facebook and Google “enormous control over speech.”
Acknowledging alternate modes of communicating, Thomas likened such alternatives to having to swim over a river rather than take a bridge, or having to hike, rather than travel by car, over the Oregon Trail. Arguing that such analogies supported the 2nd Circuit’s “intuition” that Trump’s Twitter was a public forum, he noted that nothing in the record “evaluates Twitter’s market power” and no one had identified any current regulation “that restricts Twitter from removing an account that would otherwise be a ‘government-controlled space.’” Moreover, courts had split as to “whether federal accommodations laws apply to anything other than ‘physical’ locations.”
Thomas pointed out in his concurring opinion in Biden v. Knight that, like Twitter, Facebook, and Google, trains and communication networks are privately owned yet the law obligates them to serve everyone. Justice Thomas went on to note that Congress has granted social media platforms immunity from certain types of lawsuits but that it “has not imposed corresponding responsibilities, like nondiscrimination.”
https://spectator.org/big-tech-lose-censorship-wars/
It doesn't/ It's all designed to bring about a cataclysmic and seemingly grassroots "change" we can all believe in.
You know, the hard part of their little coup.
I'd really like to know...that was the first time I've ever watched that clip of Trump and other Republicans....how the hell is that inciting violence? What does "peaceful and patriotic" mean to you? I'd never approve of what happened, but is this inciting violence? Honestly, when you have a sitting Congresswoman telling anybody who will listen to confront conservatives while they're at dinner, how is this WORSE? You may not agree that the election was stolen and I'm sure there's a strong debate to be had, but inciting violence? When? Did he say "Storm the Capitol!!!!!!"..? Did he say "Take back the White House by force with all of your one guns!!!!" Seriously, how could anybody misinterpret "peacefully and patriotically?"
When you say, and I do get your point, that you never approved of what happened, from what I remember seeing was, as they “stormed” the Capitol, they did so in a mannerly fashion, staying within the ropes.
The entire issue shows what a bunch of panty waste populate this country, especially in the media and government. It’s a tool to keep the lemmings in line; after all, each step brings them closer to the precipice.
There have been countless left-wing "protests" at the Capitol over the years that were more lawless than January 6, including several bombings.
"mannerly fashion" --Huh. That's not what I saw: https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/1926748740000/.
That leaves me with a question, where do I get a link that I can post, to what I remember? The reason that’s what I remember could stem from my lack of concern related to the event.
I wasn’t freaking out when the union members took over the Wisconsin capitol in Madison a few years ago, were you? That said, other than the children with cameras and microphones in the media screaming rape, and scum like AOC thinking the entire event was an attempt to rape her; who cares? As a matter of fact, the entire thing reminds me of some B movie from years ago where the psycho-chick is in a daze, mumbling about how they are all after her, lusting for her; a perfect picture of the squid..
Why is this a big deal? Because it is yet another attempt by the immature scum in DC trying to eliminate what they perceive to be the Trump Threat; aka, a threat to their power.
(Coming soon will be video of people storming the Capitol as they waved Russian flags, chanting “Trump/Putin 2024”!)
And let’s not ignore the Useful Idiots who bend over backwards to accommodate the DC elite. It is yet another attempt by the immature scum in DC trying to eliminate what they perceive to be the Trump Threat; aka, a threat to their addiction to power.
I sadly close by saying I have several family member who are part of that game.
Trump's speech did not constitute legal incitement, which is why he hasn't been indicted for that crime. I strongly doubt that he had advance knowledge of the plans to invade the Capitol or that he conspired with any of the rioters to do so.
What Trump did do, in my humble opinion, is wage a campaign of lies about the election in order to bring public pressure from GOP voters to bear on GOP Senators and Congressmen to vote to reject Biden electors under the Electoral Count Act of 1887, 3 U.S.C. sec. 3, and throw the election into the House of Representatives. Does that constitute a coup attempt? It clearly would if he was conspiring with the rioters to use force to compel Congress to act. But absent such conspiracy to use force, it's unlikely that he broke the laws against insurrection and seditious conspiracy. To be sure, Trump violated the foundational norm of democracy, respecting the results of an election, and if he succeeded, historians would probably call that a successful coup, but the water is muddy, which is why Attorney General Garland won't go there.
Much like Stacy Abrams and Hilary Clinton respected those norms?
Give me a fucking break. There are massive questions about that election in at least a third of voters' minds. And if Trump did think there were shenanigans in the vote, he, as someone sworn to defend the constitution, which voting rights are a strong portion thereof, is duty-bound to bring that to the attention of congress.
Norms are what we do, but they should be thrown in the wastebasket of eternity when they are being used to screw over parts of the country. Remember, it was a norm to beat your wife at one point.
If you are saying that Trump is as dishonest as Stacy Abrams and Hillary Clinton, I'd have to agree with you.
I am saying that throwing up claims to norms that are routinely broken by the other team is disingenuous horseshit.
But you knew that.
" To be sure, Trump violated the foundational norm of democracy, ..."
LOL! That's what Vlad Putin says about his opponents--before having them poisoned.
Is Hillary equally guilty for claiming Trump stole 2016? How about Gore related to 2000?
See my response to Jonathan above.
Hi there Doug. Just following up to see if you had any thoughts on Conservative Contrarian's question about Hillary Clinton's or Al Gore's claims of election fraud.
Cognitive dissonance can be painful, eh? I wouldn't think too much about that question either, if I were you.
May I take your comment as agreement with my assessment that Trump deliberately lied about election fraud? You point, I take it, is that his lies were no big deal because Mrs. Clinton and Gore also lied about election fraud.
The bigger Democratic lie in my opinion was the claim that Trump was a Russian intelligence asset, a traitor, who stole the 2016 election in a conspiracy with Putin. The Democrats pushed that lie, which originated in a fabrication financed by Hillary Clinton, for three years, trying to force Trump from office. That was outrageous, in my personal opinion. The Democrats' pushing of that lie was one of the reasons I voted for Trump in the last election.
What do I do now? I can't vote for the Democrats, who have never apologized for the Russia hoax, and whose economic polices are disastrous. I can't vote for Trump, who is still insisting that the election was fraudulent and who tried to overturn the election via his campaign of lies. I'm back to where I was in 2016, when I didn't cast a vote for president.
>>>May I take your comment as agreement with my assessment that Trump deliberately lied about election fraud?>>>
No, because I do not know that Trump lied about that.
>>>What do I do now?>>>
Sadly, the best answer I can offer is to enjoy the ride until it breaks down completely.
What are your sources that cause you to conclude there was no election fraud? After all, we can only agree Trump lied about it if we have all facts in front of us, correct?
Both Greenwald and Turley, who should know, have said that Trump's speech wasn't LEGALLY incitement. I'll take their word for it. My take was that it was certainly inciting something, but carefully hedged to stay within the law. Apparently he speaks more carefully than it appears, and had decent lawyers.
Maybe you notice that up above I wrote, "Trump's speech did not constitute legal incitement." Of course, that's just the start, not the end, of the inquiry.
When I noticed this starting to happen more, I was initially hopeful that it would spur people to using decentralized platforms for social media and content. This has only barely happened, though. Right now all I actually expect people to do is to bifurcate into two spheres of centralized social media and content platforms.
Well, when the alternative platforms are all smeared as white supremacist havens and deplatformed, what can you do?
Good lord, Paul Jay is such a mini-me fascist. Just parse this statement to see how his mind REALLY works: "I’m not in favor of the algorithms at all. Period. So let’s start with that. The whole idea of censorship through algorithm is BS." Oh, so you're saying if content was monitored and censored by humans (who support MY position) it's okay. Which is why Paul Jay reveals himself to be a closet fascist, because the correct answer is the 'whole idea of censorship is BS.' No sympathy for this dude.
"No sympathy for this dude." Hear, hear!
Rhetorical question:
Who the fuck made Google, Youtube, Twitter and FaceBook of all things the arbiter of truth and the ministry of what is and what is not to be discussed regarding elections, candidates, why the weather if foul this week or anything else?
Answer:
They did.
That they even say they "allow" discussions about this or that tells you everything you need to know. They're self-appointed Goebbels.
When you sit and think about the fact that the federal government, (or more specifically,) persons who were either elected or appointed politically are tugging their sleeves and requesting more censorship and nudging discourse in a particular direction, you have what amounts to the government chilling the 1st amendment through private business.
I may remind you all at this time that it's fucking illegal.
I guess we just add it to the pile of other illegal shit they do all day, every day, and the war crimes, pollution, failure to serve their constituencies and refusing to honor their crummy oaths and be done with it.
SSDD really.
I'm not really sure what solution or solutions you're suggesting here. High government regulation of tech companies? Breaking them up to neutralize their monopolies? Designating them as common carriers? Maybe even nationalizing them? Not only are all those left-wing solutions, but they will also enable the government more control of tech companies. Which means that whichever party is in power will be in a position to weaponize them against the other party. So how is that better than the current situation?
Paul Jay is not a voice Google et al really want to censor in the first place. His views are milquetoast "left" just the kind of stuff they love. Obviously the algorithm picked it up and was adjusted to accept him. He opposed Force the Vote for example definitely not progressive, if there is such a thing in the US.
The correct answer is to stop using these obviously corrupt social media networks. Sure it'll suck at first, but you will be a much better person for it.