45 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

This guy is like Hitler; Hitler never to my knowledge shot or gassed any Jews or gypsies, he just wrote the orders. Or general that orders war crimes be carried out. The actions of the protesters in the protests that he organized were criminal; he’s the head of a criminal conspiracy; does not RICO statutes apply?

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

Show me the orders this "Hitler" issued and we can talk. Show me the criminal charges laid by the attorney general and we can talk more. What's that, you can't. Then this man is a victim of the Speech Police and needs to be released. I'm a Zionist and I think this arrest is ridiculous.

Expand full comment
Pacificus's avatar

Shane, as a green card holder, Khalil is a guest, and is subject to administrative removal if he is in any way implicated in the lawless "protest" at Columbia. Not about "free speech."

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Aaaaand Godwin's law has entered the chat.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Ah the stupid have entered the fray!! Riddle me this, Dog Milk: who is this guy’s targets? Is it not Jews? Who were Hitler’s targets? Jews, IIRCC. Hitler wasn’t Fuhrer when he started out; he started out as an ex-corporal in the German army, IIRCC, so the analogy is exactly correct. Godwin’s law can be invoked when an inaccurate or inappropriate analogy to the leader of the 3rd Reich is made.

YOU LOSE, Sucker.

Expand full comment
Carlos's avatar

Actually, Roger - you just expose your ignorance and stupidity with every word you write. There are justifiable targets, and warranted hate. Zionist actions and philosophies are two great examples. They aren't hated ENOUGH - but that time is coming, as people wake up.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Ah, another Jew hater shows his face. Go to Gaza and become a human shield for Hamas.

Expand full comment
JennyStokes's avatar

Tell me something where do the majority of Israelis come from? Most of them are not Semitic.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

That’s why I called him a Jew hater, and my guess is that only a minority of the Muslims railings against Israel and the Jews are Semites.

Expand full comment
Savi_heretic33's avatar

Yeah! Go!

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Too many lines to figure out what you are replying to

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

"Zionists aren't hated enough."

Roger is wrong but you're wrong AND a hate-mongering jerk.

Expand full comment
Carlos's avatar

I’m not wrong - or even hate mongering. I’m direct and blunt. I don’t put polite words on the totalitarian genocide that Zionists have been pursuing since 1947

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Totalitarian is a strange word to use for a parliamentary representative democracy that includes Jews, Arabs, Christians, and others, Carlos.

Expand full comment
TeeJae's avatar

You say that like the "Jews, Arabs, Christians, and others" enjoy equal rights and treatment under Israel's zionist leadership. Now that's funny.

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

Also, Arabs in Israel are far more equal under Israeli leadership than Jews are under Arab leadership--oh, wait. Arabs kicked out all their Jews from all their countries back in the Forties and Fifties.

That doesn't mean Arabs, Christians, and others are treated EXACTLY the same as Jews by Israel. It is, after all, a Jewish state. But it's a lot closer than the opposite setup would be. And it's hardly unique to Israel. White Christian males are treated better by the U.S. government than non-white non-Christians males or, worse, females. Most societies have a ruling-class cultural streak that is unfortunate but, with luck, gets fairer year after year.

Expand full comment
Carlos's avatar

It's not just the leadership of Zionists that are the problem., though that is the biggest problem. The TALMUD is a Satanic document, promoting hate and atrocities.

Jews have been kicked out of 129 countries for great reasons. They made up 80% of the Bolsheviks - and killed 70-100 million Christians. They influenced Chairman Mao with Marxism - which caused 75 million more dead.

As stated, you can't hate the ideology or actions enough. You're defending them is delusional denial.

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

It's not "Israel's Zionist" leadership. It's simply "Israel's leadership." Zionism is the belief that Jews can move back to their indigenous home in Canaan--which the world calls Palestine--if they choose and re-establish their Jewish state if they can. They did both those things back in 1948, so Zionist mission complete.

Or are you one of those who believe Israel should pack up and leave because it has no right to be there?

Expand full comment
TeeJae's avatar

Israel's leadership primarily consists of zionists. And zionism is not as innocent as you're portraying:

"A Century of Settler Colonialism in Palestine: Zionism’s Entangled Project"

https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/Truth/CallLegacyColonialism/CSO/Al-Haq-Annex-1.pdf

"From Yahweh to Zion: Jealous God, Chosen People, Promised Land...Clash of Civilizations"

https://www.amazon.com/Yahweh-Zion-Jealous-Promised-Civilizations/dp/0996143041?

"Zionism is a fundamental/extremist religion (aka Psychopathy) rooted in an adherence to Yahweh's dictates from the Tanakh (Hebrew Bible)"

https://www.unz.com/article/israels-biblical-psychopathy/

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

🙄🙄 I can’t believe you have the balls to say that!!! Compared to being hostages after being kidnapped, assaulted, beaten, tortured, and/or raped, you are trying to strain gnats. There are actually Arab members of the Knesset.

Expand full comment
Matt L.'s avatar

The Hebrew hate seems a bit strong in you, Carlos. Come on over to the light?

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

If the "totalitarian genocide that Zionists have been pursuing since 1947" is anything other than your brain fever, Carlos, why has the Palestinian population there quintupled since then? And why did Israel remove every single Jew, every IDF soldier, even every Jewish coffin, from Gaza twenty years ago, hand over the keys, and said, "Here you go, Gaza's all yours, have fun governing."

Israelis would be world-class genociders if they were remotely interested. They aren't. Even when handed the golden opportunity to genocide Gaza--the October Massacre--they could have loaded bombers with thermobaric weapons, dropped them north south, and bulldozed the ashes of 2 millions Gazans into the Med to ensure every Hamasnik was dead topo. Instead, Israel slogged house to house for more than a year to minimize the deaths of noncombatants.

Expand full comment
Carlos's avatar

You are literally the silliest online, propagandized troll I've ever wasted time responding to. And that's saying a lot.

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

Wow, I always wanted to be the best in the world at something. Delighted to know it's getting under your skin.

As for troll, who here posts under his real name and who here posts under a trolling pseudonym? The troll is you, bud.

Expand full comment
TeeJae's avatar

What about those who say Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pol-Pot, etc, etc should be hated? Are they hate-mongering jerks, too?

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

You put Zionists in the same camp with Hitler, Stalin, and Mao? Talk about hate-mongering jerkitude.

Expand full comment
TeeJae's avatar

Nice deflection.

Expand full comment
Carlos's avatar

Stalin and Mao took their lead from Khazarian Jewish lunatics who set them on the path to killing over 100 million people. Of course, you don't know that, Shane, because you're delusionally in denial.

Expand full comment
Shane Gericke's avatar

Step away from the magic mushrooms, Carlos, they're poisoning whatever brain cells you have left.

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Well golly gee Dr. Kimber, two people from different centuries and different parts of the world seem to have one thing in common and presto! They're the same man! If I have bad teeth, does that make me George Washington?

Mahmoud Khalil is an obnoxiously self-righteous college student. There are actually a lot of such students in the US. If you can't see the difference between that and 20th century German Satan, I don't think I can help you.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

I don’t believe that he is a student anymore, from the comments in this string. He is organizing and leading illegal protests that are damaging private property (Colombia University is a private university) and interfering with other students property rights (they or their parents contracted with the university for more than a pretty penny for a semester’s worth of education, including classroom instruction ). He is leading what could be argued is a criminal conspiracy, and if so, can be prosecuted under RICO even if he has not himself committed any individual crime ( but I am not a lawyer)

I am old enough to have participated in the anti Vietnam war protests at my college. They were carefully planned to be legal, and while I participated in protest activities, I didn’t miss a day of class or lab & took my exams and wrote my papers, & not a class or lab was canceled and no college property was damaged. That was free speech exercised. Someone should educate themselves.

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Very well Doctor, I'll go educate myself. And while I do, I'll not behave like the political equivalent of a man who reacts to seeing a garter snake at his feet as if he's just been bitten by a king cobra.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Analogy doesn’t = identity/identical, go and look it up. He and you seem to be Jew haters, along with Carlos.

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Godwin's law, semantic hair splitting, and now an obvious straw man. Keep going, I've almost got bingo.

Expand full comment
David Pawley's avatar

Ipse dixit Dog Milk.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Go to it, Jew hater.

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Good morning Dr. Kimber. I've been reflecting on our exchange yesterday. While I find your political views inconsistent and your way of expressing them off-putting, I responded by behaving like a smart ass. And so I've circled back to sincerely and publicly offer my apologies for treating you that way. Cheers.

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Thank you sir. I appreciate your apology.

Expand full comment
Dog Milk's avatar

Name calling, thank you. But it's in the wrong square. Rats.

Expand full comment
Matt L.'s avatar

Oh dear, another ‘Hitler’ comment. Roger, let me break it to you: the Long Twentieth Century is now dead. Or as Tiabbi said this past summer - “Motherf*cker I’m an American. That shit does not work on me” … anymore

Expand full comment
Roger Kimber, MD's avatar

Ok, I’ll leave Hitler out, & substitute our friend Carlos. He’s the ringleader who is responsible for stirring up the crowds who are interfering with other students ability to get the full value out of the time they spend & the money their parents spent. That is a tort, even without the damage to university property that has been reported in the media.

I appreciate Matt’s attempt to be even handed & stand up for free speech, coming from his true journalist background, but I disagree, & I do so having participated in the 1960s &70s anti war protests— see my comment elsewhere here.

Expand full comment
Savi_heretic33's avatar

Yeah just like Hitler! That's why he's supporting jews and kicking out Nazi sympathizers. You are dumber than dirt.

Expand full comment
ErrorError