215 Comments
User's avatar
Patrick Lovell's avatar

These last two pieces that you've written since going solo are the best stuff you've written in years. Well worth the price of admission and my personal broadcast to anyone that would listen to subscribe as fast as humanly possible. Oh, and Kellerher is Da Man!

J N's avatar

Matt. you have returned with a vengeance with this great article concerning buybacks in the form of looting! Kudos. I consider this article, great investigative journalism I was used to reading in Rolling Stone. It appears that Trump has executed the junkyard dog that was to watch over pandemic related funds distributions. I thought there was to be, language in this bill to prohibit TrumpCo. from looting us, again and again. What can stop this madman dictator? Thank you. Stay healthy and please continue turning the knife, only faster.

M A's avatar

I like your stuff typically but this is a really weakly written story from a factual or mechanical perspective and I'm a little disappointed as you've fallen into the trap of every other media outlets' click-bait style reporting. I was holding off on subscribing to get a sense of the type of work you'd be doing independently and this is pushing me against subscribing -- hopefully future stories won't do so. To be specific about my qualms It doesn't appear you've interviewed anyone involved in capital markets, corporate / securities law etc (ie people who do the economic analysis and are in the board rooms). Just as examples of factually incorrect items or weak arguments:

1. when you state that buybacks boost the stock price that's not really true mathematically (though you could argue the demand pressure of the company purchasing shares pushes up the value marginally but I wouldn't go into a boardroom advocating that as a basis for distributions). I can illustrate the math for you if you like but a buyback (or any other capital structure change) doesn't change the value of the enterprise or the stock price (there are some technical reasons this isn't totally true at the extremes but those are exceptions)

2. capital decisions (invest / return) typically don't flow the way you suggest they do ... ie the company wants to juice their stock price therefore they return instead of invest in R&D or something else ... more typically they allocate the capital to investments that return their cost of capital, once there are no other investment opportunities that are attractive they then return anything left to shareholders to be good stewards of capital. In fact companies who don't return capital often end up being wasteful with that capital (corporate planes, executive perks fancy offices, etc). You should also remember that capital isn't a one way street -- if I return capital today because I don't have a good project to invest in doesn't mean i can't go to the capital markets and raise that capital again (follow on offerings) to invest ... in fact if I show a history of responsibility it's typically easier.

3. an underlying assumption in your article is that corporations should have been prepared to sustain a shock that essentially amounts to all their revenue going to zero (while still needing to maintain all their costs) -- why would anyone assume a shock like that is possible? Certainly none of the small businesses or restaurants in the country did! This is a very unusual situation and that shouldn't be forgotten ... there are certainly cases where companies push things too far and therefore have no cushion for normal risks but this is not that type of situation.

To argue buybacks are somehow inherently problematic because they reduce your cushion for the unexpected you would need to argue that any other use of capital (wages, r&d, capex dividends) is problematic for the same reason (as they all reduce cash available to sustain disruption).

Moreover a corporation does not exist to accumulate cash in its coffers - it's a productive engine that exists to return capital to stakeholders. Your argument that these returns to shareholders are somehow flowing to the richest also shows a lack of depth on the topic. If you dig into ultimate attribution of the majority of (domestic) capital in the capital markets it will trace back to large public employee pension funds (teachers, firefighters, public employees) and individual retirement funds so in many cases typical middle class people (at least as the majority) ... even big pools of actively managed capital such as private equity or hedge funds are fiduciaries investing capital on behalf of these large pension funds so it's a bit erroneous as an argument.

I typically tell people to think about large companies as you would think about your own assets. Imagine you own a rental property that you rent out to a tenant. Arguing that returning corporate profits to their shareholders is wrong is like arguing you shouldn't be able to use your rental income to buy groceries ... does that make any sense? If it doesn't for your rental property why should it for your 401k?!

UserFriendlyyy's avatar

Oh yeah, it's all the little people who gain from the stock market....

The share of stocks owned by the bottom half of all Americans was less than one percent at the end of September 2019. In comparison, the top 10% of the household wealth distribution held 88.1% of all stocks and mutual fund shares at that time.

And with buybacks rich people get to cash out via capital gains and duck paying taxes at their much higher personal rate.

Open source currency's avatar

Bingo. Dividends on stock options are not "qualified." So the executive insider would likely be taxed at 37%-instead of at 18 or 20 as a capitalist gainer...

M A's avatar

The dividends actually are typically qualified -- that's not the reason it's more tax efficient to buy back -- the reason is if I'm currently working and just investing for retirement I don't really want that dividend because I'll get taxed today on it. I'd rather the company use it to grow -- if it doesn't have a good place to invest it and wants to distribute it doing a buyback allows them to increase my ownership (I own 1/90th post buyback vs 1/100th pre buyback) so I do get the value of that distribution but in a form that doesn't trigger a tax now for me. Most investors in their accumulation phase of life "turn on" the "reinvest dividend" setting which means I get some dividends, I then take those and reinvest them so similarly my ownership goes up (from 1/100th = 1% to 1.1/100th = 1.1% which is the same thing as if the company takes the cash and buys stock (1/100th = 1% to 1/90th = 1.1%) except in the dividend I have to pay some tax on that whereas in the buyback I don't. Its more efficient for the people who don't want the money back now and lets investors "select their option" also remember these are all "open market purchases" that we're talking about so it's just buying from the regular sales flow.

There's this insinuation above that the little guy can't own stock. Why not? Go buy some if they want it. Frankly I think companies should grant stock to employees more to get them invested in the benefits. This should really be combined with a more robust financial education system because the worry is people don't really understand what they're buying and that creates a ripe environment for fraud and people to be taken advantage of. I think the solution is better education, better DETAILED reporting on the topic etc.

DC Reade's avatar

"There's this insinuation above that the little guy can't own stock. Why not? Go buy some if they want it."

Oh, yeah. The "let them eat cake" rejoinder.

The main reason that "the little guy can't own stock" is that they don't have the money to buy any. The allied reason is that it's the small investors in the market who typically get taken, no matter how "robust their financial education." The middle income people just beneath the 20% top earner level that is arguably the main class stratification in this society who possess "robust financial educations" in the school of hard knocks know this, or they're just plain cynical and they intuit that reality (a justified cynicism, in this case.) Notwithstanding the small number of poster child exceptions, that is the governing reality. So they stay out of the market.

The main reason that this is the case is Money, vs. the lack of it. High-income people who play the stock market can ride out the recessions- and even buy during the plunges. Very often they buy from the people in the market who are closer to the margins, who are the ones who find themselves needing to sell those assets simply to remain afloat. You know, consider your statement about "Its more efficient for the people who don't want the money back now"...those would be the set of all investors who already have enough of a margin to simply roll it over, while reaping the tax advantage you spoke of by doing so. You don't appear to have noticed, but an increasing number of Americans are learning that the only people capable of increasing their net worth- and, crucially, holding on to it securely- are those who already have a lot of material wealth to begin with, and moreover that attributes like intelligence, perspicacity, thrift, and foresight are secondary considerations at most. To say nothing of ethics. And most of those Americans are inclined to view that as a serious problem. For what it's worth, I don't think that lowering middle-class income taxes by another few percentage points is going to distract the rest of them from eventually figuring out that this is the case, and that their personal tax burden is not actually to blame for their inability to achieve financial stability and security.

As for the "little guys" who do have a stake in the stock market, most of them are invested in mutual funds or exchange-traded funds, which some cynics would say are the means by which the wealthy dispense (or functionally impose) perpetual dependency on Wall Street (and its shifting fortunes) to everyone from the beneficiaries of State government public employee pension plans to the holders of 401k accounts and IRAs. So what used to be a simple matter of a savings account or employer-funded pension plan is now wedded to return on investment, which incurs the risk that the investment can shrink as well as grow. Although it is worth pointing out that if those small players in the market use financial advisers, the advisers make money no matter what.

Also, how much direct influence do mutual fund or ETF investors have on the decisions made in individual corporation boardrooms? None. They're "passive investors." Although it is worth noting that there are now ETFs, like PKW, that specialize in playing the angle of stock buybacks. (I'd be wary.)

You wanted more detailed reporting on the topic; there it is.

Open source currency's avatar

"The dividends actually are typically qualified"

That is not true. Employee stock dividends are NOT qualified. Do you understand the difference between "are" and "are not"?

Jonathan Park's avatar

Is your argument that buybacks don’t increase price per share because the overall value of the co decreases in proportion to the assets expended on the buyback, thereby negating the per gains? And if it buybacks really do result in a constructive wash, what function do they serve?

You describe their function essentially as that of dividends - a mechanism for returning excess earnings to stock holders, which would otherwise be wasted on private jets & baby tigers & stripper parties & other ostentatious corporate fetishes.

I think the point your missing is that most of us aren’t burdened with the decision to either pay ourselves huge, lump sums of money or ball out on a new company yacht. We as individuals are forced to save for unexpected exigencies, and if one arises & we aren’t prepared, Big Bro doesn’t dump heaping bags of taxpayer dollars on our front door to help us make rent. So it doesn’t seem fair that big airline executives & the like get to pad their pockets with would-be rainy day reserve money, & then thrust the burden on the taxpayers, who are already subsidizing their massive gains with huge tax breaks, to bail them out when they don’t budget properly. If my grandma bought a new pearl necklace every time she had a little extra cash, you think the gov or the banks would bail her out if she got sick & couldn’t afford to pay her medical bills? No. Granny would die. If Delta blows its reserves on private jets & astronomical dividends, it shouldn’t expect the taxpayers to sweep in & save it’s ass. It should die just like my granny would, especially since she’s contributed a much larger share of her total earnings to the greater good than has Delta. If anything, we should recognize that the economy can replace a Delta (and should if Delta isn’t economically viable) but it can’t replace my granny, so we shouldn’t be spending billions of dollars bailing out industries who have a proven track record of reckless frivolousness. We should allocate tax dollars to help people who need it, rather than sustaining a catch-all corporate safety net for egregiously wasteful & socially irresponsible profiteers. Don’t you agree with Matt’s general assessment of the health of the proverbial economic forest, if not the exact genus of the trees he’s identified?

M A's avatar

Yes you're pretty much right on why they don't juice the price -- I do the math in another response. I don't disagree with your point that they shouldn't be bailed out for nothing by the tax payer -- ultimately the people who benefitted from the buybacks are the shareholders the govt can definitely take their pound of flesh out for bailing out and they did in the financial crisis in a lot of cases (in fact the government profited on a number of the deals). The way this is done is by diluting the shareholders. As I said my real issue is that you're all clearly smart readers and so if you were informed with the actual facts you'd be better positioned to have a view on the issue. I don't think this article does that unfortunately and the MSM does a poor job as well so I was hoping a highly capable author like Matt T would fill that gap and just present the facts in a more accurate way so people can decide with full information. To be fair there's a lot of stuff you'd need to have a lot of experience in to fully understand so not an easy task

Jonathan Park's avatar

It's a complicated constellation of issues to be sure but I think Matt excels at explaining it to readers like myself who don't have as much experience with or understanding of the financial sector as you do. I'd never heard the term buybacks before reading this article so it was eye-opening for me, even setting aside the possibility that some of the precise mechanisms of buybacks are less cut and dry than the article lets on. I appreciate your informed insights and I wonder if you agree with Matt's ultimate conclusion that we should put the brakes on buybacks? They feel shady to me and seem to pose an unjustifiable risk to the overall health of businesses and to economic stability writ large. Do you think the benefits they afford investors outweigh the risks? And do you agree that companies should maintain enough cushion to weather sudden storms, just as individuals are expected to do? In sum, how do the specific flaws you perceive in the article change your perception of its general conclusion?

Never Panic's avatar

In a LOT of cases, the buybacks do artificially inflate share prices. It's a little bit Ponzi, if you ask me. Seeing the share price climbing attracts new investors. Momentum guys ride it up a little, then dump.

M A's avatar

Thanks for the kind comment. I don't agree we should put breaks on it because the rationale is if we did the companies would have more money on their balance sheet but how do the shareholders get compensated for investing? Remember that shareholder could be you. I'd also point out while there are of course flaws in our system we have a really amazing one where we all can participate. If you're saying the buybacks are "shady" as in someone is profiting in an illicit way I disagree with you but if that's what you really believe why wouldn't you just go buy a shares in public companies that do buybacks (which is really most of the good reputable ones with real underlying businesses)? If it's really a boon for the shareholders then you're missing a great opportunity to be a profiteer! I'd say its just a return of capital like any other return of capital. The reason it's even a thing (versus dividends) is two fold: 1) there's a big stigma against cutting a dividend for whatever reason so companies like to just put them at very low safe levels they can always support and never pull back; they then use buybacks typically for the excess over that (so you have a good year or you don't have any attractive targets to acquire or no good R&D projects you can just give the profits back to shareholders) and 2) it's better for your shareholder from a tax perspective so say you don't need the cash if you get a dividend you're forced to pay the tax and then reinvest which is inefficient I on the other hand am retired and want the cash -- it's more efficient to just have enough buyback activity that I can sell a little bit for income (and pay the tax) and you just get your ownership "accreted" buy the buybacks (so if you owned 1% before you probably own 1.5% after the share retirement). Make sense? You could get into a debate of whether that makes any sense as a tax policy but changing it would require a whole gutting of the system and would just be different not necessarily better.

DudeInCoverage's avatar

I’d argue that in an era of low interest rates, share buybacks can be accretive to EPS and represent a change in capital structure that can increase valuation. So if the company trades on a P/E multiple, assuming your multiple is constant (no reason for that to change unless you’re levering up way too much), your share price will go up. Exec comp is also tied to metrics such as EPS growth and DPS growth, which are boosted by the financial engineering of share buybacks. Way easier to do this rather than do the hard work of developing new products / entering adjacent markets.

That being said, I think public investors, including activist investors can be too short-sighted and stifle innovation in public companies because they are too focused on the short-term and destroy long-term value - Elliott isn’t holding their position for 5 years, they just want the bump from the cost-cuts and get out a year or two later. It’s not a coincidence that the greatest value creation in the market over the past decade comes from founder-led and controlled tech companies who don’t care as much about their stock price gyrations every quarter.

HAD's avatar

Every analyst call ever..."Hey, this is XYZ, filling in for ABC, at NYC Capital. Congrats on the great quarter guys [very little emotion]. I see gross margins are up 10 bps. So can you give me some 'color' on how you are going to use all that new cash flow from this quarter? M&A or buybacks?"

M A's avatar

This is an informed response!

M A's avatar

That said this is financial mumbo jumbo..and part of the fallacy of PEs vs say EBITDA multiples ... I'd argue if you're doing your math right on the PE basis you should use a PE ex cash which shouldn't change then just add the cash per share to your valuation but now we're nerding out

J N's avatar

Tried to make sense of rental property example. Here is my interpretation. And not that Boeing will receive any epidemic related funding, I would be upset if they receive funding, knowing that they recently participated in stock buyback(s), thereby having non-shareholders subsiding wealth distribution to shareholders.

Boeing doing business as Boeing Defense Space and Security, St. Louis, provides for the extension of the contract for an additional five years, and increases the contract ceiling by $6,534,283,787. Work will be performed in St. Louis, Missouri, and is expected to be complete by Feb. 28, 2025. (One of many DoD contracts).

Never Panic's avatar

Yeah, after a rocky start, I thought he may be picking up a tiny bit of momentum before the rental property blurb. At that point, it was clear I had just wasted my time. lol

Open source currency's avatar

Yeah, instead of buying back back their own stock they could have spent a few bucks ironing out the new autopilot glitches and printing the manual in different languages. Claw back the buybacks!!!

Michael DAmbrosio's avatar

Why don’t they just give out dividends instead?

Don Bell's avatar

Spoken like a true capitalist. It's all about the money boys!

NevadaTom's avatar

Hey, M A, what company are you CEO of?

Joseph Fleischman's avatar

Mr. Taibbi didn't say that stock buybacks alone raise stock prices but that the retiring of those stocks purchased raises the prices. He said that the corps have purchased their own stocks, retired them, and their stock prices rose. It's akin to what happens when the fed purchases T bills on the open market -- it makes them scarcer, so their prices rise. Here, a corporation uses its corporate $ to purchase their stocks, then retire them, so that individuals, like board members, who hold said corporate stocks get wealthier. So that's one problem. The other is that the company could have used those corporate funds to further Research and Development, pay their workers better, or keep the $ for a rainy day. But no need, as the federal government will save them when that day comes, which it always does.

Joseph in Missoula

Michael Goldenberg's avatar

What a load of horse manure. But no doubt it convinces all the MBAs you hang with.

M A's avatar

I think this was the best response I've gotten -- truly enlightening

Never Panic's avatar

Yeah, that's not a good analogy.

James vee's avatar

Wrong analogy. It would be like taking the rent money and never doing any repairs or up keep to the apartment until no one will pay to live there.

M A's avatar

What company or business doesn't do upkeep that makes no sense - the underlying argument is they should have had a bigger cash buffer for the unexpected. I'm not sure that has anything to do with buybacks. It may say that boards and management overly discounted the frequency of crises

Open source currency's avatar

"What company or business doesn't do upkeep that makes no sense" Did you even understand the article? A mob bust-out outfit, that kind of company. A company that is too big to fail, and wants to cash in an implied bailout. That kind. A company that leverages its reputation to sell inferior product at a premium. GE come to mind? Why do upkeep if your bonus options just got unlocked? How was the upkeep on the 737 max? Survivorship bias, indeed...

Submarcos's avatar

Jeebus what a steaming pile...

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 13, 2020
Comment deleted
M A's avatar

I personally think the removal of the stupid incentive to keep capital outside the US (trapped cash) combined with the horrible flaws in our supply chain (ie its all in china) that this COVID outbreak has cause will prompt a return of manufacturing. That's an opinion -- we shall see if I'm right. Hopefully you can agree that a law that taxes a multi-national's earnings outside the US at 0% if you leave it outside but applies the tax if you bring it back (as the old law did) only incentivizes corporations to not bring it back here. The new law now taxes foreign earnings regardless of whether you do or don't "bring them back" meaning the decision is no longer skewed against the US which is much better. Second I don't know where I implied there's some 3d chess game going on. I really don't care about buybacks - I think they're fine but if the majority of people decide they're bad go for it at and ban it I don't think it does anything to ban it. If I was a corp and you ban buybacks I'd just shrug and distribute via dividends -- I'd view it as a silly law that doesn't do much of anything. My point is that this article attributes a lot to a very mundane topic in my opinion. I don't think having buybacks or not having them does anything. I actually think if you apply occam's razor my explanation is the simpler of the two (i.e., I'm saying they're just a distribution mechanism like dividends that are slightly tax advantaged because dividends are taxed to all the shareholders now whereas buybacks are taxed to only those who want the proceeds now and the rest later, whereas the various counter arguments that buybacks are some nefarious tool to manipulate things and are jumping around to find all sorts what-aboutisms to counter my assertion based on experience that they're not that complicated). Again I really don't care about buybacks -- ban them they don't matter my only objection is I think the article did a weak job of presenting the facts not what conclusion he or anyone else here wants to come to. At least I'm being consistent.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 13, 2020
Comment deleted
M A's avatar

I agree there are multiple conversations going on here. I'm trying to stick to my original point which is that a distribution is a distribution whether its a dividend or a buyback and that i just don't really think buybacks in and of themselves really do anything overly positive or negative they just get money to the owners. There's a corporate policy question which is: if I give this money back can I get new money if I need to grow or do cover a cost or hit a speed bump? Frankly that question applies to any other use of capital too -- if I spend it on R&D will it be good R&D? If I spend on a new plant will it be a good investment? If I acquire another company will I pay too much, etc. Those are all ways you could use the capital and would lead to the same disastrous outcome if you make what turns out to be a wrong choice at the wrong time. Ultimately those questions are about prudence, judgement and luck and there's no rule or formula that will give you a fool proof answer. There's also the whole public policy issue which I wasn't really dealing with before with my original post but I keep getting dragged into. I think if your point is that Matt was saying "hey with the benefit of hindsight these guys stripped the company of resources leaving it barren and unable to cope and that seems dumb" then yes that's a valid point and I agree its part of his article and one that I didn't object to. My point is he attributed it all to buybacks which I believe is just a mechanism by which the bad decision was implemented -- the problem was the decision not the mechanism as there are other mechanisms that could have been used if this one was not available. Second there's no discussion of a way to apply breaks so that companies don't over do it (frankly because I'm not sure there is one because you only know you've over done it if the proverbial sh*t hits the fan ... I truly doubt any of these companies made these decisions knowing it would wreck the companies and the reputations of the management teams). I sort of get lost in the second part of your response but I think what you're positing is that "individual self benefit may often lead to collective disaster" ... yup I agree someone else here referenced the tragedy of the commons as an example from classic game theory. I definitely agree there's an element of that in our economy and any smart solutions to put boundaries around things so as to direct the natural desires of individuals to benefit themselves in a way that creates positive outcomes collectively (or at the very least avoids negative collective outcomes) I am supportive of. What I'm not supportive of is actions or laws that require you to suspend belief that individuals will act in a narcissistic selfish way (at least on average across large numbers) because I don't believe that will happen. Just to go back to my original point banning buybacks does nothing to help any of these bigger issues and is irrelevant either way -- that's the weakness of Matt's article (in my opinion).

M A's avatar

Also I personally believe that when presented with two scenarios of explanations: 1) nefarious scheming evil mastermind(s) who has somehow made a rube-goldberg-like sequence of events happen in order to profiteer; or 2) stupidity, laziness and general shortsightedness. I typically opt for #2 as the more likely explanation. No one is as smart as #1 would require

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 13, 2020
Comment deleted
M A's avatar

Dude (or dudette?) read my other posts -- you're right currently corporations have one duty (to their shareholders) I say elsewhere I think a more expansive duty set is required. It also exists already in other countries (e.g. Germany if I'm not mistaken). There the board has a duty to the various constituencies including employees, community etc. So the question is not only "what is best for my shareholders" but rather "what is best for my constituents broadly." I personally like the construct. You argue that the foundation of my belief is self interest -- I don't really have a very strong self interest tied to buybacks frankly limiting them and other distributions would probably be better for my own self interest. I'm partial to software engineers -- the ability to think algorithmically is a huge asset.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 10, 2020
Comment deleted
M A's avatar

This entire response makes no sense -- I have multiple decades of experience advising companies and boards on mergers and acquisitions and capital markets so your "they hoard cash to buy companies" statement is simplistic. I can finance a deal many ways beyond cash (e.g. I can just issue shares of the acquirer as consideration for the target I can go out and do a follow on offering of equity to get cash if they want a cash deal, I can raise debt in the debt markets -- I don't need cash on my balance sheet. Your argument that the business and shareholders are not the same is obvious. Stewardship of capital means I am the shareholder (ie owner) I hire the management (through my ability to vote for the board of directors) and if they're wasting money buying corporate jets to feel special I'm going to vote the board out and replace them with a board that fires that team. If they blow the capital on crappy R&D projects that never generate a return same thing. You're going to say the individual shareholder doesn't have power to do this which is true -- BUT there is an entire industry of activist hedge funds that make a career out of chasing down companies that are not shareholder friendly and don't act in the interest of shareholders so that's been handled. Anyway on the share price math ... If I have an enterprise that is worth $1,000 and it has $500 of debt and $300 of cash the equity (shares) is worth 1000-500+300 = 800. If there are 20 shares then each share is worth $800/20 = $40.00 .... If I take all that 300 and buy back shares then I retire 300/40.00 = 7.5 so now I have 20-7.5 = 12.5 shares. Following? So what's the equity worth after doing this? The "enterprise" is still worth 1000 because it's still the same company so it's 1000-500+0 = 500 of equity. The new stock price is 500/12.5 = $40.00 ... if you're wondering why the equity changed value just think about a house worth 1000 with 500 mortgage -- you've got 500 of equity ... If I leave $300 i the table when I sell it to you you'd have the 500 equity + 300 = 800. The reason you could argue price moves a bit is because the trading day to day depends on the supply and demand of shares to a degree but it really should be anchored to what people think the company is worth not supply demand. Anyway my underlying point is I have no real issue with arguing against buybacks if that's someone's opinion but I'd prefer that the factual basis be at least informed because otherwise the whole rest of the argument falls apart.

Open source currency's avatar

Do you have any clue as to the spectacular irony of your trying to support a logical argument with "I have multiple decades of experience advising [on high finance]...? Hilarious. And it's a math problem, to boot. Let me give you a little unpaid advice: your ad hominem revealing that 'your job depends on your believing it' is unlikely to score you any points from readers of this article- quite the opposite. Your assumption that the buyer of the insider's shares is tracking every dollar of "true underlying valuation"- and not some sucker-a-minute (or shill)- is right out of textbook Econ 101. 'Assume you have a can opener!'

M A's avatar

Because I'm a cynic I'll give you credit for pointing that out and a tip of the hat. Though actually barring buybacks would be great for me as I do M&A so it would probably be good for business. My point is i'm not talking my book I just understand the mechanics which is a statement of fact. My job doesn't depend at all on buybacks but as a shareholder (i like many own diversified stocks) think its good policy. If you or anyone else wants to argue its bad policy that's totally fine and I'm willing to listen but as a starting point you should get the facts right.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 10, 2020
Comment deleted
M A's avatar

Anyway you're right market valuation is a bit of a squishy concept but you can't argue a business that generates profits has no value (though a business that generates no profits is a different question to your point about the .com bubble). To use my example of a house with $300 in it and $500 mortgage ... is that worth -200??? You're confusing the rationality of the value with whether it exists as a concept. Doesn't matter, whatever the enterprise is worth the math always comes out the same -- buybacks shouldn't alter value (as long as you're not in the "extreme" ... so if I leverage the business to 99% and they have zero wiggle room the value should be lower as someone else said due to going concern value ... ie I'm probably going to go bust at that level .. what about 90%? 80%? 50%? 10%? there's some point where it doesn't pose undue risk)

M A's avatar

What? I have a business that throws of cash flow and it's worth -200? Goodwill? Are you an accountant? What if that business throws off 300 a year post tax / interest? is it worth -200? Sorry I don't want to be dismissive but that makes no sense.

Thom's avatar

Re: Matt Taibbi

Matt, thank you so much! This is one of the most timely and informative pieces of writing I have ever encountered, and it will require much more than one reading.

Good luck on your newly enhanced independence and association. Of course, it is good to know that you will continue to contribute to Rolling Stone.

By the way, I have attempted to subscribe online using a valid prepaid VISA "Gift" debit card. This method of payment was refused with no explanation, or suggestion of a secure alternative. Please advise at your convenience.

As Usual,

Thom

Newcavendish's avatar

On the whole, this is an excellent article (putting aside the temptation to quibble). One point that it overlooks: buybacks are an alternative to dividends. Buybacks favor management and short-term investors for all the reasons recited. But their benefits of higher stock prices are ephemeral and essentially irrelevant for long-term stockholders. They, however, actually benefit from money in their pockets when dividends are paid, and this is the most transparent and measurable way of returning capital that the company can't use to stockholders, if that's the real (as opposed to BS) reason for a given company's buybacks. Moreover, dividends are typically set at predictable levels (often to attract long-term stockholders), which, on the one hand, is beneficial to pension funds and other institutions and, on the other, creates fixed expectations for management's performance. Dividends are, and have traditionally been, the best and most transparent way to share the actual, sustainable returns on investments in corporations which, at the end of the day, is the only legitimate reason for investing in them.

Lara W's avatar

Excellent piece. Curious if you follow Ben Hunt and his crew at Epsilon Theory. He's also a wellspring of righteous indignation on all things finance.

Owner of Zero Shares ;-)'s avatar

I am also a little disappointed by this article, as somebody who usually loves Matt's reporting. Clearly, stock buybacks are just another way of returning capital that, for various reasons, has simply become more fashionable than dividends. Companies could have been stripped the same amount of capital through massive dividend payments, which would be reprehensible to the same degree. Apparently that is just "not done" because people love their stable dividend payments, which seems more like a cultural quirk than anything else.

The underlying issues remain though. If you are bailed out, your equity should be wiped out. If you can take the gains, you should also take the losses. If you don't like that, maybe build up a cushion.

One step further would be to argue about the concept of limited liability itself, which helps with much of the "socialisation of the losses". There are great reasons in favour of it of course, but maybe that is something that could actually benefit of review in the age of the MegaCorp?

bruce.n's avatar

There's nothing wrong with stock buybacks - except when they're poorly executed.

The problem is not stock buybacks, it is with crony capitalism. The airlines, for example, were irresponsible in using funds to buy stocks, but also in many other ways.

The solution is not to bail the airlines (or any other company) out. What happened to the "creative destructive" of true capitalism? Let them go bankrupt and you'll see that the companies that follow them are suddenly more prudent in their allocation of funds.

Open source currency's avatar

"There's nothing wrong with stock buybacks - except when they're poorly executed."

And there is nothing wrong with assault rifles. "Poorly executed" from whose perspecive? If they enrich the insider executives, that sounds well-executed.

bruce.n's avatar

When I say there's nothing inherently wrong with it, I'm simply claiming it can be valid use of the company's funds under certain circumstances. If you're running a business and you see shares of that business floating around for below their value, it might be a prudent decision to buy some of these shares (depends on alternative uses for money, of course).

You cannot solve executive irresponsibility and lack of future-focus by forbidding buybacks, because then those managers will simply spend the money on dividends (and maybe even bigger bonuses for themselves). Stock buybacks are simply not the right point in the system to stop this. Irresponsible executives will keep being irresponsible. It's akin to blocking a downstream creek when the problem is a dam breaking down much further upstream.

Open source currency's avatar

"When I say there's nothing inherently wrong with it, I'm simply claiming it can be valid use of the company's funds under certain circumstances. "

And if there is a gang of hungry vicious thieves outside my house, and the police and National Guard all have coronavirus, I would like to have an assault rifle- for "valid use".

Do you think a company, like an airline, that bought back billions in stock recently, instead of putting away cash for a rainy 3 months, should get a taxpayer bailout or be allowed to get bankruptcy protection (or neither)?

bruce.n's avatar

As mentioned in my original post above, I don't think the airlines should be bailed out. The bankruptcy process would work fine.

chillidogg's avatar

"You cannot solve executive (greed) by forbidding buybacks". Lolz. Never heard a more honest endorsement for co-op owned businesses and the elimination of the current hierarchical corporate executive structure. No, you can't eliminate greed, and since capitalism doesn't even try to mitigate it, it's time for something else.

M A's avatar

isn't a coop just equity owned by the employees? i think that's great but it's the same thing. who manages it? you have the same issues it's just the employees holding the bag if there's corrupt management rather than 3rd party shareholders. the only way to combat corrupt crony capitalism is transparency, information, educated equity holders, etc. ultimately the owners have to be equipped to monitor the board and board needs to be equipped to monitor the management.

M A's avatar

Lets not get to the gun debate -- I'm sure we'd land on opposite ends as well. There's nothing wrong with hammers unless they are used to crack your skull open. Statement of fact.

Open source currency's avatar

But I'm reminded of the arguments supporting the MBS and CDO squared ponzi scams. According to the smartest guys at MIT in finance, there was nothing wrong with splitting mortgages into a milllion tranches in the name of liquidity. In perfect world theory, it "works". In practice, they are selling bits of the Brooklyn Bridge over and over.

M A's avatar

I don’t think there is anything inherently wrong with splitting them up into tranches. Again it’s a matter of degree and frankly your oft cited tragedy of commons is most relevant to securitization. There’s a limited quantity of “credit worthiness” in the system. You can split up the risks to offer some diversification and get closer to that capacity but the problem with how that system was designed was that there were no breaks. Everyone socialized the risks and individualized the benefits and the result was it dragged us all down. It’s not lost in me that that last statement is exactly what you’re citing as the problem with the current system and I think I agree with that though I’m not sure that buybacks are the culprit to that artifact. I honestly don’t know what is or how to fix that piece. All the suggestions I’ve ever heard to date to fix it I think don’t really address that problem and frankly dampen the good features of the system. I suppose if it were easy someone would have done it already.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 12, 2020
Comment deleted
Open source currency's avatar

Without the assault rifle, outnumbered armies would have no defense. This may be good or bad, historically, but what you probably mean is 'assault rifles in the hands of civilians exist solely to murder people'. Which is my point.

Jon Warren Lentz's avatar

Thieves on Both Sides of the Aisles.

Nate F's avatar

I don't think it's fair to lay the shareholder value theory at the feet of Milton Friedman. His point was that companies should eschew "social" spending and focus on making as much PROFIT as possible, so long as they didn't run foul of social norms or the law and were not engaged in deception or fraud. That's a pretty reasonable position. I'm 100% certain that Friedman would NOT have agreed with the notion that juicing the stock price is good, desirable, or even a smart idea. In his article in the NYT and other talks he gave on the subject, it was clear he was talking about focusing on competition and making as much money as possible through competition, and that he was not talking about things like massive lobbying or attempts to monopolize a market through legislation. He was NOT a fan of getting the government involved in the free market.

Earl North (non de plume)'s avatar

I am a fan... however. I started and ran a company that ultimately went public. We consistently generated more in earnings than we could put to work sensibly in our business. My choices were to sit on this capital, pay large dividends or repurchase shares. As our stock typically traded at 6-7X earnings (low but not atypical for a capital intensive business), it was frequently more attractive to shareholders to repurchase stock than to pay dividends. Over a decade we repurchased several billions of dollars in stock. We never borrowed money to do it, we rigorously sized the amount of risk we would take to our ongoing capital, we never fired anyone (in fact we created several thousand jobs), and we sailed through the financial crisis without even a momentary blip in our business, despite carrying billions in investments (AA+ government securities).

I struggle to see any wrong in this action. We were a good citizen, but always worked under the premise that our capital belonged to our owners (shareholders). What we did was to buy stock from those who wanted to sell, leaving our remaining shareholders with a larger share of the future profits of the business. No different than one partner buying out another in a professional practice. I can point to at least two dozen competitors who behaved similarly. No mass layoffs, no government bailouts, no executives selling right after a buyback. In fact, very few of our executives were ever willing to sell their shares, until the business was ultimately acquired.

Kevin Dunn's avatar

Another great piece by MT. Just subscribed today and encouraging all my social media connections to do the same.

James Andrews's avatar

A stock buyback is essentially the same thing as a dividend.

Mark "Machine" Graham's avatar

If it were ... it would be called a dividend. A buy back alters the amount of shares. Dividends don't. Major difference

James Andrews's avatar

Both are a return of capital to shareholders. The company can always retire treasury shares and issue new shares to replace the ones they repurchased. Focusing on the mechanics of compensating capital is silly.

Mark "Machine" Graham's avatar

The dividend is received, consistently, no matter the value of the share (provided the dividend is not cut/increased/eliminated for the duration of ownership of the share. Until you decide to sell the share. The buy back will increase the value of the stock, probably. But it is a manipulation of the stock price at best and the shareholder will only realize significant proceeds if they sell, at the higher price. If they continue to hold, the stock goes back to being valued on the many other factors of the company and the market (stock price can continue higher, but can drop to prior levels and further), but the effects of the buy back quickly fade. My main point is that there is a distinct difference between the two. And the argument that a lot of people make that companies should be using profits/stimulus/grants/loans to build a stronger company through more traditional proven company strengthening avenues like core competencies, financial solvency, employee retention, etc. and not stock price manipulations ... not silly ideas, at all.

James Andrews's avatar

It is a return of capital to shareholders. With a dividend all shareholders receive capital, with a stock buyback only the shareholders who want capital receive it. As long as there are incentives in the tax code that tax dividends differently than capital gains, there will be stock buybacks. Nobody complains about dividends... why are stock buybacks drawing the ire of people?

Open source currency's avatar

Dividends draw plenty of ire also. This article focuses on buybacks. And it isn't "only the shareholders who want capital...". It's only the shareholders who sell their shares. From a very "macro-" perspective the result may be similar (can't ignore the tax code effects, however- someone has to pay if others don't). But there is a huge difference in who gets fat in the fat years.

James Andrews's avatar

If you don't want the capital, then don't sell your shares. Some tech companies sit on a mountain of cash for a reason...some investors do not want dividends and it can actually drive share price down. We have an economic system that is structured to loot the public treasury every decade and leaves out large swathes of the country, and world for that matter. I just don't get the focus on share buybacks. It is like shouting and stomping your feet about dirty forks on the Titanic. If you want proof how inconsequential this issue is... why would political leaders pay any attention to share buybacks if they were really a structural problem. Matt is generally better at focusing on core issue.

True Rock's avatar

Stock buybacks are the same as stock dividends.

I hope Taibbi hasn't gone to the dark side and is going to start writing click-bait articles.

There is no necessary relationship between dividends and/or stock buy backs and

1. executives being paid too much

2. firing employees as away to reduce OpEx

3. focusing on maximizing stockholder value

When someone suggests that dividends are not the same as a stock buy back, what they are actually not explaining is that there is not necessarily a relationship between the value of a business and the total market value of its stock - which is a completely different issue unrelated to stock buy backs. These individuals do not have a basic understanding of accounting and specifically retained earnings on a balance sheet.

Vivek S.'s avatar

dark side? His Rolling Stone articles were great. You only like writers when you agree with their viewpoint?

Edward Jones's avatar

The article is very helpful. The discussion generated is excellent and is just as important as the article. I think that is an important role for journalism. One of the core arguments from the investment community is that management exhausts the supply of projects that generate positive returns. I have managed factories for 45 years and can tell you that no US factory ever exhausted its ability to generate new positive returns. Toyota is a great example they make millions of mini-investments that strengthen them long term while the Big Three automakers do not. These mini investments have little NPV but high returns and result in a company with more cash to invest. As a result the big three all leave the small sedan market and Toyota is investing in the Corolla in the US. Another example is the US coal fired electric generation business. They produce coal ash. There is a market for coal ash, it can be used a concrete additive. It has to be processed when it is produced. This requires an investment. The utilities do not make the investment they just pile the ash on site next to a river waiting to be cleaned up by the public later. The investment has positive cash flow but will have a lower NPV than the plant itself so it does not get done. We now import coal ash from China for our concrete plants creating a circle of stupid nonsense.

M A's avatar

At the risk of getting dragged back into this debate after some further consideration I will give Matt many cudos for generating an insightful discussion with his article (my qualms on technical inaccuracies / over simplifications notwithstanding). On reflection I think it's also worth noting there are differences in the types of buyback -- there are two broad types 1) is a debt fueled one time "leveraged recapitalization" which is often favored by activists who want a "quick buck" and are often resisted by more conservative management teams and 2) is ongoing normal course "flow buybacks" which in my mind are very similar to dividends but more flexible to turn on and off as the company needs money for other purposes. I personally as a rule disfavor the first as I think a sudden leveraging like that is a pretty risky proposition and is basically a "public market leveraged buyout" and really doesn't generate any value per se (hence my point that buybacks don't really juice the price). There's also a valid argument that the "short termists" are extracting resources and running off in this type of "financial engineering". The irony here is theres are not 10b-5 buybacks they're "tender offers" (I'm not a lawyer but my understanding is they're governed under a different provision) so arguably this SEC rule should be less problematic as it allows more ordinary course "flow buybacks" like I outline in 2. As I've mentioned in other posts I see a lot of validity in an argument line that boils down to "you're taking too much risk at the expense of the public (ie you might need to get bailed out", your long term shareholders, and your employees who have built careers here all accruing to the advantage of short-term activists." I think the real issue boils down to an issue of scale/prudence vs a choice of mechanism to effect distributions and how you even define "excessive or imprudent risk." The reality is that question is often answered on the basis of "comparables" and "precedents", which in simple terms means you take a look at what others are doing and do something not too far off from that. To "Open source currency's" commentary elsewhere this does in some ways lead to a "tragedy of commons" as for every 9 cases that people don't push the envelope there's always 1 that does (made up numbers) and the effect there is if it goes well the "precedents" drift up o the risk curve this systemically means you'll have market participants (management, investors, etc) convince themselves whatever envelope they're pushing isn't too risky because it's not that much more aggressive than the last situation (which worked out) ... that keeps going until a bubble pops. Now how do you solve this? I truly have no idea!

Grant Manheim's avatar

Yes, MA is correct. Its a bad piece by a good writer. Worse, as MA is too polite to say, Tabi demonstrates he is - as so many many journalists are - a financial illiterate.......

As Tabi is a financial illiterate its not surprising he doesn't acknowledge, probably doesn't know, that share buy backs, aka capital reductions, are the usual way capital is returned to owners of the some 30 million SMEs.

U2GT's avatar

Grant, you're 100% right. Lot of finance ignorance from commenters. MA is 100% right also. Thank you!