111 Comments
User's avatar
William Dean Thurmond's avatar

This rule was first proposed by Zsa Zsa Gabor, except instead of writing she applied it to marriage.

Dan Hunt's avatar

LOL certainly doesn't do this justice. LMAO is lame. As is ROFL . My response: a full throated gut laugh for about 3 minutes. Thanks for brightening my day.

Dan Hunt's avatar

Thanks. It takes one to know one. Have a blessed day.

Ken Braun's avatar

Marriages are like cats. Anyone can end up with two. But at 3 or more, and more so with each addition, it's reasonable until proven otherwise to assume a defect in sanity.

Lee G's avatar

Damn, beat me to it. Kudos....

Kelly Green's avatar

Don't you have to pick someone who was married five times, not NINE? The fail here is that she never gave up.

Graham Stull's avatar

Reminds me of a thing I used to say to colleagues who came to me for writing help, usually pressing a hopelessly confused first draft under my nose.

“Forget what’s on the page,” I would tell them. “Tell me, in your own words, what it is you want to say.”

If they could, I would say, “That’s it! Write down exactly what you just said.”

If they couldn’t, it meant they didn’t have anything to say in the first place.

J. Lincoln's avatar

I need to apply this rule to my comments...

Don's avatar

I finally read this. As as one who has written through my long life for the sole purpose of writing rather than publishing or gaining fame, I've come to believe writing is an attempt to capture in 100% precision, the thought in my mind. Sometimes it happens and it's like finding true love for the first time. I guess that makes my writing more like Don Quixote searching for the next windmill.

Bob's avatar

Same for me... still tilting...

Die Daily's avatar

I tried to compose a brilliant comment but after 5 tries I gave up

Robert Urbaschek's avatar

Was this the first thing you came up with then? 😉

Starry Gordon's avatar

I have a completely different approach to revision: I never revise, at least not if it's fiction or opinion. Here's how I learned that: long, long ago, I wanted to write something really good for an obscure literary publication. So I wrote the thing, and then I started to rewrite it. Scribble scribble scribble. After some days of this, a "friend" came to visit and looked at my drafts. After contemplating them, he picked up the first draft and said, "This is much better than the others." "That's just what every writer wants to hear," I said, "I already washed up as a writer." "No," he replied, "your first draft is pretentious crap, but it has vitality. Your other drafts are pretentious crap, but now, no vitality." From this I learned not to rewrite. However, for those who can't resist the temptation, I suggestion the following method: 1. Write your first draft, as quickly as possible, but don't sweat it. Just write it. 2. Set the first draft aside. 3. Write the second draft, from memory if possible, but if you must pick and snip, pick and snip. 4. Now take the second draft and throw it out. 5. Recover the first draft, correct the spelling errors and solecisms (or don't), and present it as your finished work. You're done.

Sara Fox's avatar

I have feeling this is EXACTLY how I should be working - "revisions" just mean flailing about in the weeds. It's why I've always worked best under deadline - but who wants to live that way? I stopped writing because I couldn't sustain the way I was living. Thank you!

Die Daily's avatar

Yes, I recently dug out an old short story I wrote long ago and proceeded to edit it into something horrible. It was a complete waste of several hours.

WAHomeowners's avatar

Thank you, Matt!

I have decided that I want to write my first book. I have saved all the letters from my British pen pal since we were randomly put together in a Teen Magazine application. I think it would be great to expose how a random selection created a lifelong close friendship from two people who live halfway round the world from each other.

cathy's avatar

I can not write until I am clear about who I am writing for. The problem is that most of my desired audience has passed away, making feedback a bitch

Celayne Jones's avatar

Have you considered a Ouija board? 😉

Starry Gordon's avatar

Yes, I frequently talk to ghosts. Could almost as easily write them letters. They give plenty of feedback, if you listen for it.

Nicole Langlois's avatar

Please always call this the "Sisyphus 5 Rule"! A funny, snappy little snippet and an excellent rule. I'm sharing it to my editorial networks.

Melanie Notkin's avatar

Matt! I’m a writer and 100% love and appreciate that you are sharing your tips! Knowing even YOU struggle sometimes is helpful. 🙏

Robert Racansky's avatar

I remember seeing "Sisyphus 5" before they were popular.

judith's avatar

Hahah it takes me at least three hours lately to write a three Pp email. Some of that of course is adding commas

Fred Belanger's avatar

Commas...always the bugaboo of writers, really.

Atavistic Residuum's avatar

That "natural pause" rule will always get in the way

Craig's avatar

Huh. So THAT's what that nasty smell is...

Mark Kennedy's avatar

The encouraging news, from your point of view, is that the lack of conceptual clarity at the root of an inability to express oneself clearly in print announces itself only to thinkers astute enough to receive this message. They're the ones who sense something is wrong--the necessary preliminary to possibly realizing, sooner or later, just what it is. Those who know intellectual clarity only by hearsay remain blithely unaware of how incoherent and unreadable their writing is (you don't have to look far for examples).

Way Back Joe's avatar

UUHH...

Intellectual stuff doesn't sell these days. The little money that you will get isn't worth the work. Worst is that you will get ring fenced with the rest of the wink wink intelligentsia and then you will discover that boredom and bullshit can make you wish for terrible things.

I will consider myself a writer when a stranger walks up to me and says that I am.

Mark Kennedy's avatar

(?) Your 'reply' addresses nothing in my post. However...

a) Even a cursory perusal of the offerings of the world's finest publishers (Knopf, Oxford, etc.) confirms that the market for "intellectual stuff" remains as strong as it ever was. Furthermore, if you check the backlists of these same publishers, as well as the secondary market for used books on sites like ABE, you'll find that heavy-duty intellectual books not only hold their value but increase it. A copy of Israel's Radical Enlightenment or Husserl's Logical Investigations, for example, will now set you back several hundred dollars.

b) Whether what you choose to market qualifies as intellectual or non-intellectual, if you're unclear in your mind just what you're trying to say, your writing is bound to reflect your confusion. Making this point is the sole reason the phrase 'intellectual clarity' made it into my post, which doesn't concern itself even slightly with what sells and contains no recommendation as to what level of intellection writers should aim for. The necessary precondition to becoming a writer, I should have thought, is being able to understand what one reads, words and their meanings being indispensable tools of the writer's trade, yes? This stranger's opinion anyway.

Way Back Joe's avatar

Mark Kennedy

I generalized of course and I did not mean to criticize your post. We could have a conversation sometime regarding the current western culture of materialism the great lubricant of all means of motion and activity including becoming a successful writer and making a living at it. As well as what writing will or will not be acceptable by the current publishing houses who now are political and cultural censors.

I am up in years, retired comfortably and I write when I feel like it about anything which my mind/emotion/intuition feels a need to engage the keyboard as a means to express a personal and lately pissed off opinions. A far greater amount of anger is now part of my comments posts and writings than in the past, especially in the last 2 to 3 years.

I fully agree with you on this quote: The necessary precondition to becoming a writer, I should have thought is being able understand what one reads, words and their meanings being indispensable tools of the writers trade.. ..

WBJ

Mark Kennedy's avatar

Thanks, WBJ, for your gracious reply. We're fellow travelers, "retired comfortably." Funny... making money was never my priority (I submit as evidence the fact that I devoted six university years to acquiring a philosophy M.A.). Yet we're part of a generation where, if you followed the rules and your parents' advice and invested in a house, you probably now collect more in dividends from the company that heats that house than you pay them to heat it. Things worked out for us to the extent that we're now able, quite easily, to help our children buy houses too, something that might otherwise be impossible for them. What's gone wrong for them and their era? Here's one of the more entertaining takes on the matter (once you get past the turgid introduction to Blyth himself):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGuaoARJYU0

I fear there's still a slight misunderstanding between us. I have no objection to anybody criticizing any post of mine. What I wanted to alert you to was the irrelevance of your observations to anything in the post to which you were ostensibly replying, a reflex response for which you can blame my philosophy background (I specialized in logic and epistemology and still find instances of logical irrelevance jarring--sorry). As for anger and disappointment at the state of the world, I think the state of the world warrants such response. When I was young, 2023 was a science fictional date, and I had much higher hopes for the future that 2023 would deliver if I ever made it that far, as I suspect you did.

Good luck with the writing, if that's one of your retirement projects. I wrote a novel after I retired, just to see if I could do it, and did manage to finish and get it printed. The process was interesting, almost a collaboration between the person who goes to bed thinking he's done good work, and the one who gets up in the morning realizing what needs to be fixed. ;-)

Scuba Cat's avatar

I feel like I'm always a contrarian on these. This may be mostly true, but some concepts are worth struggling with. I think if you're trying to write something truly new, talking about something in a way people don't usually talk about it, it's hard. I've struggled with things and ended up tabling them, but I save them in a separate file in case I ever figure it out.

Mark Kennedy's avatar

That isn't contrary to what was said. To the extent that your struggle to eliminate the conceptual confusion succeeds, the writing problems will become solvable as well. Failing conceptual clarity the writing is a lost cause, evidence of your thought's opacity to itself.

Brook Hines's avatar

in way, we all write the same essay over and over again.

Roman S Shapoval's avatar

Why vomit drafts are necessary- it allows us to spew satan all over the page, so by the 26th draft we feel like an angel has come down to write our final draft for us!