102 Comments
User's avatar
Debbie Lerman's avatar

“Old school digital censorship”? It has been one long continuous trend of ever increasing clamp-downs on free speech. Trump, Musk and any other false heroes have been engaged in exactly the same speech-curtailing activities as every other member of the techno-fascist oligarchy. Covid was the apotheosis of the global censorship and propaganda efforts — demonstrating very clearly that it is not partisan or political: it is about raw power and control.

There are no good guys in this battle: just the population/serfs vs our would-be feudal overlords.

Running Burning Man's avatar

"Trump, Musk and any other false heroes have been engaged in exactly the same speech-curtailing activities as every other member of the techno-fascist oligarchy. "

Give us some examples, Debbie. I think you are just looking for clicks.

Epaminondas's avatar

Musk's purchase of X singlehandedly broke the illusion of consensus manufactured by the tech platforms to suppress dissent and revealed the censorship apparatus at work during COVID. I'm not sure why he's getting thrown in the hopper with Trump. And X is far from perfect, but it's still much better than Meta and Google.

JDK's avatar

Thanks Matt. Important perspective. You say, "...the awesome information-squashing gadgets available..." I am praying that, in this age of broad independent platform availability, truth finds its way to the pubic. X has helped to this point, but I don't think we can put our trust in Musk. You are certainly doing your part; I'm off to purchase Siegel's "The Information State." I also highly recommend Iain Davis' new book, "The Technocratic Dark State." NOT available on Amazon, a good sign that it hits the mark.

Helo Pilot's avatar

“X has helped truth find its way to the public”? Good grief. X has become a major conduit for false information (especially right-wing propaganda) under Musk. X is now the epicenter for election misinformation and conspiracy theories. Researchers have found false or misleading election claims made by Musk have accumulated billions of views. Research has also shown a significant increase in hate speech and inauthentic (bot-like) activity on the platform since Musk took over. Additionally, Musk has made structural changes to X’s algorithm in order to favor his own content, as the platform’s most followed user, as well as that of other far-right accounts.

Running Burning Man's avatar

"Research has also shown a significant increase in hate speech and inauthentic (bot-like) activity on the platform since Musk took over. "

Another unsupported and unsupportable premise from a left wing loser. Go back to Bluesky

Running Burning Man's avatar

BS response. Just leftwing publications saying waaa waaa waaa.

Plos - You are just butt hurt that X doesn't censor shit you think is "hate".

Montclair State - again, just a bitch session that something some lefties call "hate" is allowed in public and you are butt hurt by it.

Berkley - Duh, Berkley - snitching as usual that thibnkgs it does not like, othe3r people say. Here's one: “To solve society’s most pressing challenges, such as climate change, poverty and access to health care, we need cooperation, and so it’s important to build information environments that foster pro-social interaction and cooperation,” Hickey said. “It’s important to keep research like this alive and to continue monitoring social media platforms for antisocial behavior.”

Arxiv - more bitfching by lefties who think anything they do not like is hate speech and should be suppressed.

You are simply an unhappy Prog idiot who is butt hurt by Elon Musk's existence.

Back to Bluesky with you!

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 3Edited
Comment deleted
Rfhirsch's avatar

"(especially right-wing propaganda) " should be "(especially left-wing propaganda) ".

Most of the fake posts are from left wing sources, a lot probably from Russia.

Helo Pilot's avatar

Um, no, most of the posts on X containing false information are from right wing sources. Whether it is fake accounts or real accounts spewing misinformation, researchers have found such accounts portray themselves as American patriots or are run by real conservatives that pushing topics like anti-vaccine sentiments, immigration concerns and pro-Kremlin narratives on the Russia-Ukraine war.

https://edmo.eu/publications/how-elon-musks-powerful-disinformation-machine-works/

Rfhirsch's avatar

So right-wing sources hate President Trump and love Barack Obama and J. Autopen Biden????? Those are the main fake posts on X.

Also "pro-Kremlin narratives" are left wing. Putin obviously hates President Trump for his support for Ukraine, unlike Biden who let Russia invade Ukraine!

Gary Edwards's avatar

They see the winds are changing. Tech guys are like wall street, they are leading indicators.

John J’onzz's avatar

Glad you're covering this Matt. Order your copies of The Information State now, folks, before Renee DiResta is successful — yes, it's her, and she's actually doing this — in convincing publisher Henry Holt to "correct the manuscript."

Mr. Siegel's been on the RCI pod, Doug Lain's pod, and others, and he continues to be one of the most fascinating writers and thinkers on this still-important subject. It's clear that what Mr. Taibbi has been documenting here, and what Mr. Siegel has written about in his book never actually stopped; it's the information state, but newly concealed. Zuckerberg and those guys are going to favor, or disfavor, whoever they think is in their best interest from day to day.

Jan Ravensbergen's avatar

Opening line of book review that was ‘cancelled’ was:

“EVERY SO OFTEN a political book arrives that reshapes how we understand the ground beneath our feet…”

Here is link to full text, courtesy of Wayback Machine

https://web.archive.org/web/20260324181826/https://thebaffler.com/latest/digital-leviathan-greenwald

(More detailed comment below in this comments stream)

John J’onzz's avatar

I read the archived review. It's good, and isn't without criticisms. It's beyond bewildering that the Baffler felt like it needed to be fully removed.

Ayn's avatar

The Baffler review removal is ... baffling, to say the least. Tell us more.

Jan Ravensbergen's avatar

Lots of info on X — you can hook into the stream via author’s Twitter account [ @Jacob_Siegler ] assuming you have an account there. Coverage from other outlets including Substack coming, I would presume…

Meanwhile:

https://web.archive.org/web/20260324181826/https://thebaffler.com/latest/digital-leviathan-greenwald

Bob's avatar

Who could have seen this coming?? The entire "the left is worse than the right when it comes to censorship and power" really need to get back to calling balls and strikes. The full on shift to Trump in 2024 should have them all apologizing for helping to get him elected. The credibility of everyone involved in that clown show continues to disappear the further into Trump 2.0 we go.

Running Burning Man's avatar

You are butthurt that your fellow citizens disagree.

Bob's avatar

That makes no sense. Cool comment, though.

Tim Hurlocker's avatar

I like Brendan Carr's ham-handed threats against the propaganda monopolists; they are entirely consistent with free speech.

clockworkcatcher's avatar

Big Tech is reverting to its old ways in less than two years? When did it actually change?

"If both parties use the tools, the first things to vanish will be criticism of the tools. We’re headed that way." We're here, homie, and we've been here for a while. These tools are only criticized by the party that is currently out of power. Once that party is in power, the criticism stops.

What a naive article.

TeeJae's avatar

Rather than naive, I see it more as pointing out to those who think their side is infallible, that their side ALSO does it.

Bob Knutson's avatar

All power leans towards censorship. Nothing new here. Trump may be marginally better as he fights the censorship in the public sphere rather than just gaslighting freedom and stealing it with government, but all government hates being criticized no matter the source or the truth.

James Schwartz's avatar

If you use social media then you’re subjected to the whims of those private companies owned by oligarchs. Haven’t used any in over a decade and couldn’t care less if they all went by the way of the dodo. I’m not missing any news of the day and not getting it within the second it happens is more than fine with me.

Sabrina LaBow's avatar

They are all full of it. They will use censorship when it is convenient for them. No moral compass. No real convictions other than to make more money.

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Have you heard of Doomberg?

They are market analysts and they ran an experiment when the Iran war kicked off.

They had a new iPad with only X. They trained the algorithm to only provide content from a pro-Iranian perspective.

By Sunday, they could no longer see content from Iran, or only on a limited basis.

Surprise, surprise, surprise…it was like a switch was flipped and they were cut off from content except pro-American.

The next war they decided they are doing a factory resent and training the algorithm again.

Censorship is alive and well in the good ol’ USA.

Running Burning Man's avatar

This article is light on evidence but very heavy on conspiracy.

Mark Marshall's avatar

Come on. Free speech is in a much better place under Trump than under Biden.

No Use For a Band/Name's avatar

The phrase "re-arranging deck chairs on the Titanic" comes to mind

Hassan Al-Mosawi's avatar

أحسنت النشر والقول – سلام غزة و القدس عليكم - العزة والنصر حليف محورالمقاومة وحلفاءها والذلة والعار لمحور الشر وجماعة أبستين (امريكا و بريطانيا وفرنسا وتركيا وقطر والامارات و دول الناتو والصهيونية و أسرائيل) وحلفاءه

Robt.B's avatar

Google's translation:

"Well done, publish and say - Gaza and Jerusalem peace be upon you - pride and victory, an ally of the axis of resistance and its allies, humiliation and shame for the axis of evil and the Epstein group (America, Britain, France, Turkey, Qatar, the UAE, NATO countries, Zionism and Israel) and its allies."

A bit off-topic, but hell yes to "humiliation and shame" for Operation Epstein Fury being carried out by the Zionest Axis, as accurately listed by this commentor.

(I'm an atheist, but hey, Inshallah baby!)

Running Burning Man's avatar

Take a hike, Caliphate Ahole.

HariSeldon's avatar

The translation from Google Translate: Well published and said – peace in Gaza and Jerusalem upon you – pride and victory is the ally of the axis of resistance and its allies, humiliation and shame for the axis of evil and the Epstein group (America, Britain, France, Turkey, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, NATO countries, Zionism and Israel) and its allies. ... I'm not sure if Hassan is for free speech or just spouting off.

HariSeldon's avatar

I didn't realize Robt B had already done this. Nevermind.