I can't agree with that, given that Matt has repeatedly pointed out the difference between actual police states and the freedoms of an open society that we still have available in the US.
Matt's warning about a perilous trend. That's different than actually having arrived in the pit.
I never thought that, and the old Indian and cowboys told you so. It was their land, but we came over and took it , but they were bad for fighting for what was theirs. As a kid it told me we are not who we say we are.
In the “meta” sense it shows the true dangers of “tribalism”(a synonym for diversity). If the Indians (early on) could have set their differences aside and recognized the existential threat Europeans posed to them they could have easily eliminated their small nascent communities. At least for awhile. King Phillip made a valiant effort but failed.
Tribalism is not a synonym for diversity. Not in any thesaurus or dictionary. Most people have a suspicious idea of "tribalism," that it might not be good. And you seem to want to somehow drag diversity into it?
If anything, diversity is an antonym of tribalism.
I always remembered reading that a pope in the 15 century gave all those headed off to claim new land a thumbs up, and a sense of entitlement to the land of the infidels, and killing them off was indeed an option, and I'm sure what you're saying is true.
15th century? "...headed off to claim a *new land*, and a sense of entitlement to the land of infidels and killing them"? You got a little more reading to do. Better go read up on a "crusade" that happened from the middle of the 7th century to the 14th. Look up the geographical location of Al-Andalus and the Umayyad Caliphate and how it came to be. Read past the historical re-writes of how living in dhimmitude was cool beans(someone forgot to give some Frenchman named Chuck Martel the news that it was great). "New lands" only when they decided to embark on kicking the invaders asses all the way back to where they came from and plundered on the way back home(went Viking) because that shit cost$$$ and they were broke. You see when pushing back on and evening things up with your centuries long oppressors and you do this in silly outfits, swing cords to chop and crush up close and personal........well you tend to be brutal hard SOB's. Not putting a smiley face on it but look at it from the proper perspective not through the prism of today. This wasn't just some random "hey lets go kill these a-holes and take their shit cuz we're greedy and have nothing else better to do because Christianity".
The latter crusades we're questionable but the early ones had a purpose. Unfortunately chasing these oppressors back to where they came from the, Christian Crusaders discovered new resources of worth and good ol' human nature(conquest) took over.
I think I see Madjack's point. So-called diversity ISN'T diversity of ideas/thinking reasonably. It's the opposite, fractionating people into superficial tribal categories, i.e. white=oppressors, blacks=victims, questioning trans ideology's enforced demands=transphobia, etc. And so it goes.
I think you could argue there's two completely different word senses of 'tribalism' now. One is political tribalism (diversity being ONLY ONE of the many totem poles of a particular tribe, say, "protect the borders" would a the right-wing totem pole) and the other is actual tribal behaviors in real human contexts (like, tribes in Africa, etc.).
You make a good point about indigenous American tribes though.
Would that have worked out better for them? Both Persia and China were centralized empires and they didn’t fare any better against the guns and cannons of industrialized Europe. The Chinese empire had some outdated respect for the land due to their old Shamanistic beliefs and didn’t want to mine coal for industrialization. Same thing happened to the native Americans. Only when China had arms production on par with the Western countries did they start winning wars.
And who did 'The Natives' take the land from? Other natives...
American Pioneers in the 19th century who actually lived life without servants respected American Indians and their ways, our 'beloved' government decided to remove them much like their efforts on the middle class these days.
Well, not familiar with who was here first. I guess you didn't watch those cowboy and Indian movies I watched on TV where the message was this is our land not your's even though you were here first. You cannot excuse what we did to the indigenous people of the America's. Sorry, nor the permission given by the church, which was not restricted to the Americas. Trail of tears, lets see you justify that.
Conquest has been a human condition since the first caveman stepped outside his cave, looked across a valley seen another clan and said I want their stuff. Asian descendants that built grass rafts set out from their mainland and went island hopping would occasionally bump into others that did the same and wanted each others stuff. Humans did it as a matter of survival and advancement for living conditions. Not excusing what we did to each other as humans but as another commenter pointed out(Danimal28) the Indians weren't exactly living together in peace and harmony either. Some tribes had their own versions of conquest, genocide, slavery, robbing each others food stores, warring over hunting grounds, kidnapping females to breed. I'm not impugning Native Americans just pointing out an uncomfortable truth of human nature that even Indians were prone too.
You seem to be very focused on the church/ christianity. If that what floats your boat, fine, but don't let it skew the truth of history.
Trail of Tears? Justify what? Allowing the Indians that were paid to relocate force their 800 black slaves (some of the Cherokee/Creek elites among them owned) to have to go with them or the misfortune that befell the actual members of the tribe on the way?
I watched them; I will never excuse what we did to indigenous people, but that is the way of the world - and governments(not the People) are responsible for all of it. Just like when they locked you down through the use of force a mere three years ago.
You're agreeing that they arrived across an 18,000 year time span. So either they were the slowest walkers in history, or there were multiple waves of people coming across.
The United States is neither a democracy nor is it a democratic republic, but an oligarchy featuring unlimited political bribery for those who can afford pricey lawyers.
I had a lot of respect for Reich from his doc on income inequality until someone pointed out that he was the Sec Labor under Clinton during the NAFTA negotiations. That man is a quisling in that he bears a signifcant responsibility for the hollowing out of the USA's industrial base.
The situation described in Hillbilly Elegy rests (in a large part) on his shoulders. Both Reich and Arnand Ammawhazizname are such posers. Empty suits crying out empty platitudes, thinking their 'La Resistance'. Ugh
And the plethora of removed comments? WTF?
NOW I understand why SS contribs are moving to Locals.
I thought J. D. Vance's point in Hillbilly Elegy is that the crucial responsibility for the situation he described was on the people who lived there and just refused to change the self-destructive component of their life ways. Including his homefolks.
And Robert Reich did not negotiate NAFTA as Secretary of Labor under Clinton. The agreement was negotiated in the Bush I administration, and signed by President George H. W. Bush as an international agreement. The only thing that Bush ally (on the down-low, of course, although it's become much more obvious over the years) Bill Clinton did was to forcefully endorse its ratification by the Congress, the final authority on certifying treaties, and sign it into law after Congress had passed it.
Clinton was able to successfully articulate to his fellow democratic faithful, in coded speech and phony backwoods bluster refined by Yale Law, what the republicans had discovered a few decades previous. Money got you elected, and even more money kept you in office.
Reich is loyal to Team Blue, despite having most of his personal suggestions ignored and disrespected in the Clinton years. He was only appointed Labor Secretary as window dressing. No one who counted paid attention to his recommendations.
That's what the fake narrative framing of Team Blue and Team Red encourages. Ironclad team loyalty and partisanship. There's no third position, in the absence of ranked choice voting. Team Blue is terrified that they would be doomed if ranked choice voting got out of hand. And orthodox CNN/MSNBC American liberals are okay with that, because they buy into the neoliberal narrative that continues to insinuate that a 3rd Position could only be Fascist. The GOP establishment doesn't want ranked choice voting, either, because their leaders suspect that Team Red would be doomed.
If Substack wanted to shoot its value proposition in the ass, introducing mass censorship so as not to offend the delicate sensitivities of The People Who Matter is the way to do it, right there.
Consider Robert Reich's presence a test. Principally a test for him, not for those of us who have adopted it as a base for preserving freedom of speech and reasoned dissent.
If I want to read another of Bobby reich’s articles on how it’s horrible that we don’t do exactly what he says, I have about five dozen outlets that will deliver the exact same low rent lefty punditry. Maybe if he ever had an original thought he wouldn’t be so offensive. It it’s the same formula all the time “how dare we let billionaires live when people are dying every day!?”
The comments (including mine) were mostly innocuous. Example: he claimed there was book banning, my comment was "can you named the banned books"? It was deleted. In fact "Heather" turned off commenting on the whole post, the only time I've ever seen it on Substack.
All of the defenses of censorship I've seen are eloquent. Censors-in-waiting regard themselves as noble, and their messaging is rife with fawning self-elevation to heroism.
Censorship only “works”when there is only one game in town. In the US media ecosystem this is long gone, no matter how hard the Ds, neo-cons, Deep Staters, and corporate wokesters may try.
Except places like here, where (1) people think, and reward it in others; or (2) as in your case, they use structural and rhetorical tactics to game the system, while thinking they are convincing anyone.
Where's the "thinking" in regurgitating a widely-circulated, century-old platitude? And given how much time Democrats spent calling Trump a fascist during his term, I would love to know which Americans OP thinks aren't aware that "it can happen here".
I'm pretty sure it's a large amount of Americans on both the left and the right who think authoritarianism could never happen here. To a large degree, it's believing their side won't be the one that does it.
Fully agree with your take. I get VERY tired of shopworn tropes like that above which seem to be designed to simply get likes. And why "kids"?! It is so gauche! No real contribution to the discourse, just social media-esque attempts for "likes" (love?). And unfortunately it works. I have noticed that a lot of Matt Taibbi's Substack commenters post things like "You go, Matt!" "We got your back!" "Give 'em hell, Matt!", etc. I for one would prefer more substantive comments. After all, aren't those rah-rah sentiments most efficiently captured by clicking the thumbs up icon? No need to type out a cliche!! Now watch how my post will be vilified by the same people who purport to hate similar vilification of dissenting voices in the mainstream media!!
What is the problem with complimenting a writer on their work - or in the case of Matt Taibbi - for their bravery in reporting on the shit-show that is our current government ? Let me be the first to apologize to you on behalf of everyone on this Substack who has wasted your precious time saying what they wanted to say - and not giving a shit if their comments offend the sensibilities of those who thought they were here to weigh in on a Ph.D. dissertation defense.
I'm writing about this as well, with the added bonus of how the paid-off press like the LA Times will literally submit their questions beforehand -- and the president has a little notecard telling him who to call on.
It really tells you everything you need to know about the state of the media these days. Play along and you get rewarded. Dare speak out, and you're unemployed. (Tucker will be fine, but how many reporters will duck their heads back down because they wouldn't be fine?)
I didn't vote for trump in 2016, always a registered democrat, although not loyal. Bad enough I saw the democrat's growing authoritarian stance during the Trump years, but the media and so called left fell into line, like little soldiers. Asses.
And David Dayen was Tucker-lite. He wrote about the Great Financial Crime Spree and he now caved to the establishment. During the GFCS years, he uncovered many crimes the government/financial coup were doing. Now, he replaces an article favored to Tucker with one opposing Tucker? That shit is horrible! What a coward!
...."unimportant" part of a "parenthetical." Oh you sound so smart, now who is M. sim's and what is his excellent point? Four degrees with bad comprehension and 2 in science. What an accomplishment for someone with no comprehension. Now if you could take a minute out of your day and rephrase your nasty ass comment maybe I'll condescend to answer.
The Times denied giving Biden the questions. Does that mean the White House gave the questions to the Times? He clearly had the questions so it has to be one or the other...oh wait, one of the three letter agencies tapping in perhaps?
I saw that! The questions are obviously present, and if the Times didn't give them to the White House in advance, the only other possibility is that the White House gave THE TIMES the question in advance..........which is even worse.
For plausible deniability, it may have gone like this: White House tells certain reporters what specific aspects of certain specific topics the president would be addressing in questions today. Those reporters then submit the questions.
Just like the tabletop exercise on the "Russian Disinfo" that was rehearsed the month before the Post released the story on Hunter's laptop, these agencies (WH, intelligence) will always attempt to keep some veneer of deniability, which then their lapdogs in the MSM will highlight to say that assertions of their collusion/collaboration are not proven (and thus are lies).
Biden got tripped up by a couple of children today because that's the first time he's faced questions that weren't pre-planted in ages. Literal toddlers tripped him up more than the WH press corp has. If that doesn't tell you all you need to know about our current media, I don't know what will.
The question was pretty hard (what was the last place you visited or something like that). He was in Ireland a week ago, but he was stumped. Another child stepped in to help him out. This is where we are today.
yep. its one giant global cartel. there isnt anything that hasn't been monopolized. we live in a world of illusion that appears to have choice, but not too many of any real consequence.
Tucker is rare in that he has his own genuine talent and following meaning he doesn’t need a Fox or CNN brand to survive. Like a Megyn Kelly, he will be able to find a very prosperous new path. But that’s him, not most media people. And so his firing had a real sweeping effect to send a message to the rest.
Actually, this manipulation of the press in briefings started with Regan. If a reporter asked him an uncomfortable question, he didn't get a seat at the next press conference. And now no one asks the President or whatshername anything they don't want to answer or they're brushed off or attacked for even approaching a subject.
I don't remember where I saw it (it might have been right here, honestly) but somebody mentioned how the press complains that without being inside the velvet rope, they can't do their jobs -- but they don't realize they were never supposed to be inside the rope in the first place.
I'm just disgusted that the media/journalists don't do their jobs any more. Perhaps they never did, but there were just enough rogue journalists to actually dig in and find the truth so we were lulled into thinking we had a watchdog press of sorts. Now the ones in the mainstream are just lackeys for their controllers, and nothing original comes out of any of them. Do they know they have controllers? Do they bristle at being told what they can and cannot write about? It doesn't seem like it.
You mean the time I pointed out that you published a wildly inaccurate statistic in huge banner font in one of your articles, and in response you closed your comments to non-paid readers?
It's amazing to me how "trolling" and "saying things I don't like" seem to be interchangeable concepts to dimwits like you.
Tucker didn't get fired for speaking out, he got fired for 1. telling lies that cost his company $$$, and 2. allowing his staffing to be run in a discriminatory, abusive way. Rupert Murdoch is not exactly a bastion of woke leftism... when that dude wants his top earner gone, you know the guy REALLY fucked up.
LOL the good thing about trolls is that you know exactly what they're going to say. I love how the woman suing Tucker for a hostile work environment never even met him.
Tucker was actually the guy who went on TV and said Powell was full of BS. The media made fun of FOX for losing viewers to NewsMax. You can still read the articles today.
But now since it's politically convenient to rewrite history, that's what you do.
Fox is going to lose far more $$$ in the wake of firing Tucker than it did in the Dominion settlement. His positions on Ukraine and vaccines are what sealed his fate. The powers that be insisted he be muzzled before the next election cycle fully kicked in. There will be no major mainstream media platform for RFK, Jr’s presidential bid now.
You don’t have a clue what you’re talking about. In fact, Tucker was not a top earner because all of the left wing boycotts of his show scared off major advertisers over the last few years. Try again.
He's actually complimenting you. By accusing you of trolling, he's implying that you're smart enough to know better, but are deliberately posting bullshit. The alternative is that you are being genuine and actually believe what you write.
Have to disagree on point 1. Carlson was not a large part of the 20 examples Dominion cited in the actual coverage. I think it was one for him. In fact, Carlson made it very clear, on the air, that he asked Sidney Powell to come on his show and show the evidence that the election was stolen. She declined, and he pointed this out. It was almost heresy to do this on Fox News at the time.
What lies are you talking about? Name the most recent ones that got him fired...
Abby Grossmans lawyers confirmed that she has never met Tucker Carlson as he does his shows from a separate location in a different state. Maybe Tucker went to the Matt Lauer, Chris Cuomo, Don Lemon school of charm and how to promote a hostile work environment.
Rupert Murdoch and his sons are avowed leftists. Murdoch only tolerated Ailes because he made them money in a niche market. Shock; leftists like money too. Who knew!
I suppose the irony of suggesting a "silence function" in the comment section of an article about the perils of preemptive restriction of speech is lost on you.
If by "silence function" you're recommending an "ignore" capability, you should realize that all you're doing is giving an edge to the people whose comments you refuse to read, who are still able to reply to anything you post for the wider audience to read. It's sort of like putting a paper bag over your head and imagining that you're invisible.
If I find another comment writer's post(s) to be worthless, I know how to use a scroll mouse. I don't feel any requirement to block everything they say forevermore.
Even more, it needs better system for submerging worthless ones like ...
An ignore flag would be perfect. And no, It's not censorship if each individual reader has to make the decision for themselves that a certain common terrorism not worth listening to.
Regarding AOC: if the establishment is good at nothing else, it is very good at determining who can be co-opted, who can be bought off, who is to be neutralized, whom to safely ignore.
How quickly she was co-opted, and now is just another culture warrior, and establishment sycophant. Man, that was quick. SMH. Wealthy elites love easy "turns" like this one.
I doubt she was ever who she claimed to be. That Netflix "documentary" was all scripted. Most likely she is a plant. At least that is what I believe now. A newcomer doesn't win against an establishment unless they want you to.
As a former constituent who followed her from before her first election, I have wondered what her "community organizer" tenure actually consisted of, for nearly a decade out of college. Did she go to the same school as Obama? Was it in Langley VA?
Remember how people pointed out that she responded to a casting call, but all the 'fact checkers' said that was fake because the organization that put on the event does these types of things all the time looking for new talent.........
Y'know, I never considered that. But...I remember seeing her do a livestream before the primaries, and...its hard to put my finger on it...but...there seemed to be a sort-of un-natural buzz in the room, from the commenters, etc...the whole thing seemed just a little too good to be true....And the fact that I was even alerted to that stream in the first place speaks volumes, since I typically don't even follow local political primaries in states/districts far away from me. That it was put in front of me at all to begin with is a little bit suss.
she never was. she’s an actor who responded to an ad, looking for someone to play the part she played well, at first. throwing her own words back at her...”and so, when you elect a politician, and then they let you down, it feels like rejection. it feels like heartbreak. it feels like betrayal.”
I wish I could link to an article I read in 2008 about Obama's nice digs on Lake Shore Drive overlooking Lake Michigan when he was sent to Chicago as a community organizer. After a hard day of speaking about asbestos in black neighborhoods, he would retire to a nice apartment. Maybe it was Paul Street's book or on Black Agenda Report or Adolph Reed, JR. Of course, the church ladies were doing most of the organizing and baking.
She was a socialist. Of course she was going to take the money and screw the little guy. Name a socialist country that doesn't, and if you say Denmark I will scream.
Part of me wonders if AOC fell into the trap of being more concerned about selling a brand/image than pushing for actual change. Because once you are more concerned about brand or image, it's a lot easier to co-opt you and get you to toe the line.
Shant Mesrobian has pointed out that when AOC first came on the scene, she branded herself as an anti-establishment radical but quickly realized that doing so left her with no future in the Democratic party. So she pivoted to staking out the most radical edge of party advocacy, routinely advocating for the censorship and deplatforming of Party critics and enemies and hoping that the difference in these two radical postures would go unnoticed. It's been a remarkably successful strategy considering how it's provided her so much approval and popularity within the liberal-left base, allowing her to have a future in the Party while continuing to maintain a differentiated political brand premised upon a more youthful, activist, radical mode of politics.
Ironically, her 2018 campaign touted the need for elected officials to exercise "courage". And now she's a subservient little mouse, unable even to buck the remainder of "The Squad" rescinding their Ukraine plea for negotiations.
Yet advocating for censorship is antithetical to a true liberal or progressive who fights for freedom; so AOC will criticize book banning but not deplatforming of conservatives. Politicians do this hypocritical game which is so obvious but that’s part of the job I suppose. She tries to be the moral one but politics and moral integrity just don’t mix
All it takes is a little power and even those who pretended to thumb their nose at the boss are fast to jump in the passenger seat when it’s offered. It’s easy to turn into the Establishment.
And the classic picture of her in that stupid dress and in background, the wait-staff masked while none of the celebrities are. The message was crystal clear -- "we are somebody and you are nobody and don't forget it."
My point is what the hell is a supposed "for the People" Representative doing attending a MET GALA, where tickets cost FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS???? And up against the ticket cost you have her stupid "tax the rich" outfit. She is beyond ludicrous.
I can't even blame the establishment for her. She is really just a shallow individual who won a primary campaign (what was the vote turnout for her to win). So now the generous government world of Democratic rule is her oyster. She really is just an internet influencer, whatever that is. "Evita," the Broadway musical, meets Tanya (Patty Hearst) meets Social Media. Pretty sure Her AOCeminence is unschooled in those first two references.
Seems to me most politicians, that is the vast majority, can be bought off in time. I also think there should be more accountability for those so called lefties, even those speaking out now in light of Tucker's firing. They too, should be held accountable since they showed no objectivity during Trump's time in office. They were in almost total complicity with the democrats, the mainstream media in that regard and they are equally culpable in making this country more authoritarian. They were literally feeding into what many of them are complaining about now.
As bad as what AOC had to say is, I'm not giving her any credit for what happened to Tucker.
On the other hand, it wouldn't surprise me if it was the GOP establishment types who wanted him gone, because how dare Tucker question what the hell we are doing in Ukraine when he could talk about, for example, abortion.
I'm still amazed he got away with it this long. He was on mainstream television spouting anti-war rhetoric that would have given McGovern a hard-on. He slammed the military industrial complex again and again and again. It was beautiful. Especially when we started sending our TANKS to Ukraine. And he meant it, too.
I'm a bit mixed about my assessment of Tucker, but Jesus did he ever get the war stuff right.
Yeah the real power in the republicant party is by doing the lefts dirty work, and maintaining status quo and their fucking miserable little jobs. I have been a conservative since the debacle that was Vietnam, and renounced my membership in the gop in about 1977.
Saw a clip of R. Weingarten testifying before Congress yesterday. Is that an American flag crossed with a Ukrainian flag pin she was wearing? Hilarious.
yeah, Paul Ryan and his ilk happy to give him to boot. They will follow I up with 4 hour segments on Bud Lite and Disney and hope that makes up for it with the audience.
"Ex-government employee interviewing current government employee about how the current government should crack down on 'wrongthink' while the ex-government employee nods along'" -- totally not fascism at all.
Trump saying "you are fake news" -- THAT is fascism!
Trump sending his mob of thugs to overrun the capitol is a lot closer to fascistic than anything Dems have done. But you'll note that I never called Trump a fascist.
What you're describing simply isn't fascism. That said, I would love it if you and all your right-wing turd buddies would keep saying that, since it makes clear to the rest of the population what mush-brained lemmings you people are.
Dude you're still in your 2021 talking points. We know the Metro PD was in the crowd. We know the feds were in the crowd. Nobody was surprised by anything, it was a set-up from the start, and that's why the video remains locked away.
Well it was Mussolini who invented the system and the word --and who basically said it is what he says it is!
It’s symbol was a group of sticks bundled together and wrapped tightly as one. One stick is easily breakable. The bundle is impossible to break. The theory is everyone working together --going in the same direction, by force if necessary, makes the state strong. Dissent and difference of opinion make it weak.
So actually, the government working with business to wipe out unpopular speech is indeed textbook fascism.
Nothing is ever "fascism" and nothing is ever "socialism" when you can constantly move the goal posts/change definitions to suit a narrative. Fascism? Well that's me(by the lefts definition and labeling), Mussolini and Hitler and Socialism is something in Amsterdam.
"Everything in the State, nothing outside the State, nothing against the State."
That is the quintessential definition of fascism, as stated by ol' Benito himself. It's a totalitarian worldview... it's not just about *some* control, it's about absolute, *unescapable* control.
If you can escape fascism by just turning off the TV, that's not fascism.
Right! Now maybe you can explain employing intellectual gymnastics and pretzel logic just how the hell you guys label people like me a fascist when I share no philosophical beliefs with your kissing cousin Benito and his buddy to the north you guys tie yourselves up in knots trying to hang around the rights neck. LMAO! You know when I'm not out in my white hood burning crosses, lynching, oppressing women with my girthy patriarchy and chasing atheists around with my Bible quoting scripture! LMAO! Such d-heads with your BS, f'ing old and beat.
Fascism is when you turn on the TV and the political philosophical opposition of a news network that has been this political oppositions object of removing from a market place entirely has someone removed for no logical, reasonable, rational explanation.
None of you freedom loving leftists have been calling for that right? That's the difference between me and you. I am all for the left having a platform and spewing their BS. I don't want them removed I want them all to be seen for what they are as an example of what not to be. Problem is you run from debate or lie your asses off as a tactic because by any means necessary and the ends justify the means. Yell liar or fascist or racist or copy n paste articles you do not read or comprehend yourselves as some sort of argument or refutation.
The best part about making baseless accusations on the anonymous internet is that you never have to feel like a shithead when it turns out you're wrong.
I'm not sure they ever really were about freedom. Matt says liberals "didn't want to ban things" but cites The American President, the climax of which has the president, glorying in his own power, promising to go door to door confiscating people's guns. Hard to be pro-freedom and anti-ban when you want to ban and seize lots of things and effectively delete 10% of the Bill of Rights. They're up to at least 20% now but they were never at 0.
Another great piece. My whole life (in my 50s) I've never liked the puritanical pearl clutching of the religious GOP but I also caught the scent very early for the totalitarian leanings of Democrats.
Political correctness was a start of it, the race baiting of Sharpton's Tawana Brawley era in NYC, Jessie Jackson and on and on. Manipulating people for ever increasing power and intrusion into day to day lives by the ever growing government. The obsession with disarming the public...it all spelled tyranny for years. Here we are now, my worst nightmares realized.
Look at the fanatical obsession with the smoking ban, another left mob driven cult expression. The issue was distorted in the extreme so the mob could join in othering a target that they knew was not going to be defended. The pattern repeated and escalated. Everything is always sold as the "greater good" when it means mob rule under a violent and oppressive government that will stop at nothing if you resist.
It's always been clear that conformity and compliance were something fundamental in the "liberal" orthodoxy. I've never known a Democrat in my life that had any respect for individual freedom and liberty.
The disgraceful false racism agenda is probably their most shameful exploit, causing utterly needless division using baseless fear driven nonsense. The censorship is a close second and equally disturbing, however without total information control they cannot ensure the falsehoods will propagate. With an open dialogue, their entire platform, their entire premise, baseless, will disintegrate instantly.
The fact that all of their motions are clearly mapped in Mao's Red Book, and all the Frankfurt School and other historical writings and that people can't even see it is probably the most distressing. They have so decimated education that people are woefully ignorant participants in something they don't even understand.
Excellent comment! An old friend of mine said years ago that the government outlawing smoking with ever encroaching laws was the first step in control of more aspects in private life. At the time I thought she was overreacting but now see the wisdom and foresight in her observation.
From what I can see, the government picks the issues to amplify (Trump indicted for paying off a prostitute), or gives minimal lip service to others (invasion at the border, fentanyl crisis) and in the case of Carlson, punishes those who bring up topics left ignored by them.
On many fronts, I'm a Classic Liberal, but I've never once felt those ideals represented by Democrats. The idea that the government of my lifetime would ever effectively create and deliver on major programs like universal healthcare is just ludicrous. I'm not opposed in concept to a nation as wealthy as ours providing social services like healthcare or subsidized education, it's our _actual_ government that leaves me where I would never support it.
You last sentence hits the nail on the head. Our healthcare system, in and of itself, is fine. The payment bureaucracy and associated politics is the nightmare.
I'm close to health services via my family and many relatives and friends. The current system is badly eroding due to incompetent regulation and the market consolidation in care providers. Add in DEI viral infection in accreditation bodies and physicians are running, retiring early and leaving the industry.
It is in a bad state and it will take time to be more visible to average people but right now it's crumbling and crumbling fast. In rural America it is almost impossible to find basic General Practitioners or OBGYNs, in more concentrated urban areas it is becoming impossible to get a simple appointment. I live rurally now and to get in to see a GP, you only find 30yr olds that have just ended residency accepting new patients and appointments are months out in booking and frequently canceled.
The heavy handed regulation, price fixing and other measures that were put in since the Obama administration have created an anti-competitive environment that was constructed to favor massive consolidation under just a few behemoth health provider networks. It's a bad scene.
About which Biden said "they have their guns, and we have the F-15s". We're all waiting to see what form Schumer's "sensible F-15 regulation" will take.
The Iraq war was the political event that most shaped my childhood. I learned to take anything the government says with a healthy grain of salt, and never trust those who would seek to censor or silence opposition viewpoints. Last year I took a First Amendment class in law school. Probably fifty or so students in the class. I figured there would be at least one other principled civil-libertarian in the class. I mean, after all, we read all the major free speech cases: Pentagon Papers, Times v Sullivan, the Flag-burning and draft-card-burning cases, obscenity doctrine, Skokie march, Wesborough Baptist Church, etc. Somebody had to come around to the obvious position that censorship does not work and it is foolish to trust the government with the power to decide which opinions are on and off limits. I’m 30 now, so I’m was a few years older than most of the other students. Nevertheless, it was pretty depressing to be literally the only student who fit into the old-school ACLU mold. I got the sense that myself and my professor were probably the only two people in the room who had even heard of Ira Glasser. I believe there are very few millennials, let alone gen Z, who value freedom of thought. They believe corporations and the government have a responsibility to protect us from wrong-think and, the most laughable phrase in vogue today, “harmful speech”. It’s bleak, man. I don’t see how this leads to anything besides ever-increasing polarization. I don’t see how this ends well.
When the speech police censor viewpoints they don't like, it's "holding people accountable". When they censor viewpoints they agree with, it's fascism. I have argued vehemently in effort to convince young people that the transgressive ideas they support (ie boycott divestment and sanctions, radical ideas about police and prisons, etc) may one day become to target of cancelation. The response is usually along the lines of, "Well then we will deal with the fascists when that happens".
I'm old enough to remember when police would go out into the streets and bash gay people. My parents are old enough to remember when police unleashed dogs on peaceful black protestors during the civil rights movement.
Now they think they'll be on the right side of "democracy" forever?
I don’t think you were attracted to liberalism per se then, you were attracted to the libertarian aspects of pre-2000s liberalism. Modern liberals are authoritarians, because there is nothing about either liberalism or conservatism that mandates whether they be authoritarian or libertarian, it varies by era. But don’t make the mistake of associating liberalism with tolerance or free speech -- those may be liberal values in some eras, but they are always libertarian values. Because “liberal” and “conservative” change their meaning over time, no one should establish a permanent identification as one or the other. In particular, you have to see if “your side” is using authoritarian means to achieve their goals -- if they are, they are probably the bad guys.
Basically, but modern liberals have substituted something different for “liberalism” than classical liberals or even liberals of the ‘60s and ‘70s understood as liberalism. It is another example of the nominative fallacy, mistaking the label for the thing, without realizing that the underlying thing identified by the label has changed.
The whole right, middle, left paradigm is a crock. You're either for ordered liberty or for some form of tyranny.
I love all of the malleable labels, definitions, stereotypes and caricatures people can come up with on the left. I seriously don't know how the hell you can keep up with it all.
Plato had it right. You can have Oligarchy, Tyranny, or Democracy. I assure you though that there also is indeed a Left and a Right. The basic tenets of Leftism: the common good is more important than individual property rights. Natural resources should be used for public benefit, not private gain. All people should be provided with medical care and housing. Monopolies should be nationalized, turned over to the workers, or broken up. Banking should be a public utility, not a privately managed interest-taking sector. All peoples of the world share a common humanity, war is just the elites sending the working class to die so the elites get richer and get more sphere of influence control. Workers of the world unite. THAT is Leftism, which is very very distinct from centrism or being on the Right.
The left/right paradign describes centers of power. You can be philosophically opposed to one side or the other, but still support them for some reason or another.
Libertarians and Conservatives just happen to overlap in a majority of views and policy positions, and tend to vote almost exclusively Republican. Go figure.
"Because 'liberal' and 'conservative' change their meaning over time, no one should establish a permanent identification as one or the other."
Yes, agreed. Just as with "Democrat" and Republican" (in the US).
But "Left" and "Right" have essentially fixed meanings, and for that reason, I think it would be beneficial to beef up our understanding and use of them.
I don’t think so -- “left” and “right” are relative to the then-current status quo, so modern leftists for example are focused on race over class, in contrast to the leftists of the ‘30s and 40s. What is “progressive” in one era becomes conservative in the next, like how rock ‘n roll was once seen as edgy and progressive but is now considered staid and reactionary. Or, to put it another way, Woodrow Wilson and AOC are both progressives relative to the society of their time, but would hate each other and don’t have much in common viewpoint- or policy-wise. “Libertarianism” and “authoritarianism” however are not relative to the the current status quo, as libertarians in every era prioritize small government, free speech, due process and other civil rights etc. and authoritarians do the opposite.
Modern progressives love nominative fallacies, where people get attached to the label of a thing without realizing that the thing it identifies has changed. This is why many “old lefties” continue to support “progressivism” even though modern progressivism is antithetical to many of the things they believed in -- anti war, pro free speech, deeply suspicious of government, etc. In my view, no one should identify as permanently “progressive” or “conservative” under the assumption that those things are immutable, because they aren’t. The liberals of the ‘60s were largely libertarian progressives, modern liberals are authoritarian progressives, and it is important to keep that distinctions in mind rathe than simply reflexively identify as “progressive” or “conservative”, as those descriptors by themselves don’t capture all the relevant dimensions. As Orwell said, the real division is not between conservatives and revolutionaries, but between libertarians and authoritarians.
As a historical record, I agree with that. Thank you. I also see that "Authoritarian" and "Libertarian" are persistent impulses, what ever they are called, in contrast to shifting labels and label-to-label-associations.
But what is a great need today regarding political language? Allowing important words to constantly change meaning at the whim of thought leaders is just one type of potential poison to society. It is well-recognized that the pace of change is certainly driving us crazy today, turning us into a tower of Babel. But there's no reason to assume it is even necessary...
"'left' and 'right' are relative to the then-current status quo"
That's a fair conclusion from their origins in the French Revolution. But curiously, that era also produced what persists today in the French national motto -- Liberté, égalité, fraternité -- where the first two terms neatly reflect persistent fundamental Rightist and Leftist values over the centuries since: Freedom and Equality. So it's important that they persisted here *combined* in a national statement, even as they are assumed to be opposed in Western political ideologies.
I'd tweak the second to what I think is a more widely palatable concept, Fairness, and then you've got two essential, complementary components of societal needs: (individual) freedom and (social) fairness. The third component is one that has been disparaged in recent years, and now with woke politics supposed to be completely dispensed with: Brotherhood, or sense of community, where societies are permitted to define and support themselves in contrast to other societies. It presupposes no necessary hostility, despite what globalists promote.
I think the libertarian/authoritarian distinction frequently gets subsumed into or conflated with “progressivism” or “conservatism” because the progressive or conservative movement in any snapshot of time may seek to achieve their ends through libertarian or authoritarian means, and people living in that time assume that “progressivism” or “conservatism” always support those means. But in a broader historical perspective this is not true. Governments on both the left and the right can be either authoritarian or libertarian, and extreme political movements on both sides tend to converge on the authoritarian end (e.g., Stalin and Hitler both united at the authoritarian end though one is on the left and one on the right). I think it is important to disentangle the two axes to make sure you are not reflexively identifying with a tribe because it is nominally “progressive” or “conservative” if they are using authoritarian means (assuming you disapprove of authoritarian means) to achieve their progressive or conservative goals.
... who work for perpetual shapeshifters barreling toward their their own secret goals. "Change is [always] good!" "Change is inevitable! [even when humans make the change]"
I just texted a couple friends yesterday when I saw that AOC interview and said "I am ashamed I once thought AOC was our political future." Seriously, the Democrats are going to force me to vote Trump in the next election. We've really sunk so far.
What has happened to the anti-war left, and the left in general, is mind blowing to me every single day. The two things that basically attracted me to the political "left" as it were; basically in a nutshell three things in the 1980s: it was still the place where the anti-war movement had traction, especially as it pertained to our actions in Central America and other places. It was definitely, 100% for free speech and free expression (I was a punk rock fan and especially found the Minutemen and other totally anti-war and anti-establishment bands transcendent). Finally, it opposed apartheid in South Africa and we longed for racial harmony in America, AKA the Martin Luther King Jr. variety.
These are all gone from the left now. The last professional conference I attended there was a "BIPOC Affinity Room" that white people were not allowed to enter, and the elites and liberal professional class scream at the residents of the most poverty stricken counties in America in Kentucky, which are mostly white, that they have "white privilege." The left is, in some ways, even more warmongering than the hated neocons of the 1990s and 2000s. But what really blows my mind is how much they want to literally censor everything.
I've never been more politically homeless in my life.
Smith - in the words of Noam Chomsky, the Democratic party is the only hope this country has to remain a democracy. The GOP are fascist.
So I can understand your concern that like 90% of Democratic leaders are corporate tools. They are. But 100% of GOP leaders are corporate tools as are most of their voters. Big difference.
If you want a home, fight for power in the Dem party. If not you are just naval gazing
Lifelong conservative here that unfortunately has had to vote R a few times in my life. 100% of Dems have been and always were corporate tools while railing against corporations as 99% of Republicans have always been corporate tools too. LMAO, fight for power in the Democrat Party? You guys already have the power. With the exception of a few red state legislatures you guys have the culture, institutions of higher learning, Hollywood, the media, FBI, DOJ and cancel culture is a whole owned subsidiary of you. As I commented elsewhere here and will pass along to S Smith. The whole right, middle, left paradigm is BS. You are either for ordered liberty or for some form of tyranny. There is no being kinda sorta for both. Taibbi has literally been documenting and reporting on this very thing. Maybe you should actually read his articles.
All the two political parties are is the Harlem Globetrotters vs the Washington Generals. Good cop, bad cop. Corporations need more regulatory power to stifle innovation and upstarts....vote(fund) Dem one cycle. Need corporate tax breaks vote(fund) Rep the next cycle. The GOP and Dems are fascist economically and use communist tactics in the streets(antifa/BLM).
Chomsky is a political idiot and should have stuck to his field of expertise, linguistics.
Jeff - No, the Democrats don't have all of the power. Hollywood has been screaming for things like Universal Health Care, Less Corporate Power, Higher Taxes for the rich for decades and law makers in the GOP and DEM party ignore them as well as the majority of voters that want these policies.
You say 99% of GOP have been corporate tools. The majority of GOP voters want to ban assault rifles. Can you name the 1% of GOP leaders that would vote the way GOP voters want on this issue. The majority of GOP voters want the government to fund health care. Can you name the 1% of GOP law makers that are willing to vote for government funded health care? 100% of GOP law makers vowed that they don't believe in climate change. Do 100% of GOP voters think it is fake?
Who are you kidding?
GOP law makers are 100% controlled by big business. They have ZERO % that are not controlled by big business.
As the former president of College Republicans in college it is very telling to hear that you have been a life long conservative. You need to wake up and smell the coffee... Yes most Dem law makers are terrible. But there is a huge difference between MOST and ALL.
Who am I kidding? I don't know what parallel universe you are living in or echo chamber you reside specifically but nothing, zero, nada of the shit you claim GOP voters want is true. I suppose you'd sight some obscure polls as proof. You're intellectually dishonest and do not debate in good faith. The GOP which is made up of the establishment has kept and preserved Obama Care after campaigning endlessly on repealing it. The GOP voters want to ban assault rifles(facepalm), I can't even entertain that obvious bogus claim. Yep, GOP lawmakers are controlled by big business as is the entirety of the Democrat Party. I mean how intellectually dishonest can you possibly get? Your side has been pimping the BS narrative as the party of the little guy, unions, the working man. Taibbi has done yeoman work in pointing this out to his own ideological brethren. He's now saying shit we've been pointing out for years. Big business/corporations and government work hand in hand while both parties point the fingers at each other.
I'm sure you were the president of College Republicans(eyeroll). Sounds about right as there isn't much difference between the Checked Pant Country Club Republicans and Limousine Liberals/Progressives.
My family was Goldwater conservatives even before he put out Conscience Of A Conservative(or Buckley's God and Man At Yale) of which I still have my Grandfathers hardcover first edition. My mother helped organize a fund raiser in Reno , Nv for Reagans 80' presidential run where I listened to the adults talk to Paul Laxalt and heard him explain how the Bushes were a huge problem/obstacle. Too bad Reagan feared he needed Bush to win. I'm sure you already knew that Laxalt was who Reagan wanted as VP and not that limp dick GOPestablishment Bush being a president of the College Republicans and all.
The Tea Party is an example of organizing. The Justice Democrats are an example of organizing.
If you can't get your ideas adopted by either the Dem or GOP party you are just navel gazing. Parties change quite a bit over time. Southern Democrats in 2023 are very different than they were in 1973. Trump Republicans are very different than Bush Republicans.
If you want your ideas adopted you have to organize and get them pushed through an effective political organizing group.
The Tea party is now the Trump party. All they ever really stood for was bringing down the old school Bush GOP. And at that they have succeeded. And they did it pretty quick.
Ideas are just naval gazing if they are not aligned with political power.... LBJ did not sign the Civil Rights bill because he was a true believer in MLK. He did it because MLK organized and brought VOTES to the table. and that is what LBJ wanted more than civil rights for people of color.
Why do you imagine that me, an apostate in the party now, as I viciously opposed lockdowns and vaccine mandates, in addition to opposing the madness of sending billions to Ukraine, and a huge free speech advocate, would even be accepted in the D party now? For these views, over the last 3 years I have been called a fascist and worse. I have been threatened with violence toward myself and my family for opposing the ludicrous mask mandate here as well. I hate the Rethuglicans, but sorry, man, the Dems hate my views as well.
It's very bad that there is uniform silencing of all those who vary from the Establishment narrative.
It's even worse that those granted the megaphone by our betters are so dull and stupid. When's the last time you watched a CNN or MSNBC and said "Wow, I never thought about that, I need to evaluate my underlying assumptions and thought process."
"When's the last time you watched a CNN or MSNBC..."
If you cut off your question right there, I could honestly say "on 9/11." Ditto with Fox News. And I highly doubt I will ever watch any of them (or any other TV news show) again.
Yes, they did. But I specifically remember a reporter commenting on Bldg 7 looking like "controlled demolition." I've looked at the way back machine on the video coverage of 9/11 and can't find it.
Uniform silencing? What do you think is happening right here, on this Substack? Silence? Joe Rogan gets 100,000,000 views a month, while CNN and MSNBC both hover at or below 1,000,000. Your "dull and stupid" comment is spot on, but that's probably why *nobody watches those networks*.
I have never watched any TV news, ever. Except in airports. That makes 60 years worth.
In Nov 2017 I decided to boycott the New York Times, and shortly afterward extended that to all non-independent media. I trust only those who are reader-supported, like the newspapers used to be.
We were dumbfounded that uoung people rolled over and just accepted being locked down and not being able to go to graduation, play sports, see live music, go to bars, etc. Our generation NEVER would have accepted that!! We were, in our late 50's, few of the rebellious folks that went to the grocery store, were out the first night of restaurants re-opening, and out anywhere that it was "allowed" during the lockdowns. But the narrative "you'll kill granny" worked on the youth! Why should we be surprised? Today's youth believe they only have 12 years left, thanks to AOC and others!
One of our few voices was Tucker. It appears even our only one conservative network rolled over. Thank God there are still courageous voices like yours, Matt.
"Yes, but can you imagine how pissed off they're going to be when they finally wake up?"
Chris Hedges was in Yugoslavia. Many people could not believe anything was going to change. That is, until they got put in vans and taken away to camps.
The real test of whether someone is truly anti-authoritarian and pro free-speech is whether they still believe either of those things when they are in charge.
"What we have instead is an increasingly pissed-off population that needs to look about eighty results down in every Google search to find its point of view represented. Who thinks that situation is going to hold? "
Who thinks that is going to hold? That's easy. Google, Facebook and their enablers in the administration think it is going to hold as long as they control access to opinions.
That's more due to search engine optimization than anything.
I'm increasingly becoming convinced that the internet is an overwhelming force for bad in the world... you almost couldn't conceive of a more effective tool for shifting power to the establishment and away from individuals.
USG "watch-out" lists aren't helping, though. As for the internet being a force for bad--I tend to agree, but I don't think those people who we all think control those platforms and data can really control them. They've evolved to function beyond their creators' purview. Those systems are all semi-autonomous and feedback-driven, so who knows what kind of shit will hit the fan in the future.
Remember, kids, authoritarianism is something that ever always only happens in other countries!
We're going full shithole!
we are full shithole.
I can't agree with that, given that Matt has repeatedly pointed out the difference between actual police states and the freedoms of an open society that we still have available in the US.
Matt's warning about a perilous trend. That's different than actually having arrived in the pit.
I just got done reading the Wired article about the deployment of Hikvision facial surveillance technology in the PRC. https://www.wired.com/story/surveillance-china-security-camera-giant-ipvm/
Now THAT is what actual totalitarian control is.
The American company that exposed Hikvision: https://ipvm.com/
“Matt's warning about a perilous trend. That's different than actually having arrived in the pit. “
Time is what keeps everything from happening at once
See: how to boil a live frog
Going, going, gone...?
Osiris was right. You never go Full Retard.
I never thought that, and the old Indian and cowboys told you so. It was their land, but we came over and took it , but they were bad for fighting for what was theirs. As a kid it told me we are not who we say we are.
In the “meta” sense it shows the true dangers of “tribalism”(a synonym for diversity). If the Indians (early on) could have set their differences aside and recognized the existential threat Europeans posed to them they could have easily eliminated their small nascent communities. At least for awhile. King Phillip made a valiant effort but failed.
Tribalism is not a synonym for diversity. Not in any thesaurus or dictionary. Most people have a suspicious idea of "tribalism," that it might not be good. And you seem to want to somehow drag diversity into it?
If anything, diversity is an antonym of tribalism.
Tribalism is a synonym for diversity.
I always remembered reading that a pope in the 15 century gave all those headed off to claim new land a thumbs up, and a sense of entitlement to the land of the infidels, and killing them off was indeed an option, and I'm sure what you're saying is true.
Might have something to do with the old Testament where God literally tells the Isaelites to kill tribe after tribe after tribe.
15th century? "...headed off to claim a *new land*, and a sense of entitlement to the land of infidels and killing them"? You got a little more reading to do. Better go read up on a "crusade" that happened from the middle of the 7th century to the 14th. Look up the geographical location of Al-Andalus and the Umayyad Caliphate and how it came to be. Read past the historical re-writes of how living in dhimmitude was cool beans(someone forgot to give some Frenchman named Chuck Martel the news that it was great). "New lands" only when they decided to embark on kicking the invaders asses all the way back to where they came from and plundered on the way back home(went Viking) because that shit cost$$$ and they were broke. You see when pushing back on and evening things up with your centuries long oppressors and you do this in silly outfits, swing cords to chop and crush up close and personal........well you tend to be brutal hard SOB's. Not putting a smiley face on it but look at it from the proper perspective not through the prism of today. This wasn't just some random "hey lets go kill these a-holes and take their shit cuz we're greedy and have nothing else better to do because Christianity".
The latter crusades we're questionable but the early ones had a purpose. Unfortunately chasing these oppressors back to where they came from the, Christian Crusaders discovered new resources of worth and good ol' human nature(conquest) took over.
I think I see Madjack's point. So-called diversity ISN'T diversity of ideas/thinking reasonably. It's the opposite, fractionating people into superficial tribal categories, i.e. white=oppressors, blacks=victims, questioning trans ideology's enforced demands=transphobia, etc. And so it goes.
I think you could argue there's two completely different word senses of 'tribalism' now. One is political tribalism (diversity being ONLY ONE of the many totem poles of a particular tribe, say, "protect the borders" would a the right-wing totem pole) and the other is actual tribal behaviors in real human contexts (like, tribes in Africa, etc.).
You make a good point about indigenous American tribes though.
I believe "antonym" is the word you're searching for, rather than "synonym."
Would that have worked out better for them? Both Persia and China were centralized empires and they didn’t fare any better against the guns and cannons of industrialized Europe. The Chinese empire had some outdated respect for the land due to their old Shamanistic beliefs and didn’t want to mine coal for industrialization. Same thing happened to the native Americans. Only when China had arms production on par with the Western countries did they start winning wars.
Thanks for a chuckle -- reminded me of some of the, um... pragmatists in Chayefsky's "Network"!
And who did 'The Natives' take the land from? Other natives...
American Pioneers in the 19th century who actually lived life without servants respected American Indians and their ways, our 'beloved' government decided to remove them much like their efforts on the middle class these days.
That's a bad rewrite of history.
Well, not familiar with who was here first. I guess you didn't watch those cowboy and Indian movies I watched on TV where the message was this is our land not your's even though you were here first. You cannot excuse what we did to the indigenous people of the America's. Sorry, nor the permission given by the church, which was not restricted to the Americas. Trail of tears, lets see you justify that.
Conquest has been a human condition since the first caveman stepped outside his cave, looked across a valley seen another clan and said I want their stuff. Asian descendants that built grass rafts set out from their mainland and went island hopping would occasionally bump into others that did the same and wanted each others stuff. Humans did it as a matter of survival and advancement for living conditions. Not excusing what we did to each other as humans but as another commenter pointed out(Danimal28) the Indians weren't exactly living together in peace and harmony either. Some tribes had their own versions of conquest, genocide, slavery, robbing each others food stores, warring over hunting grounds, kidnapping females to breed. I'm not impugning Native Americans just pointing out an uncomfortable truth of human nature that even Indians were prone too.
You seem to be very focused on the church/ christianity. If that what floats your boat, fine, but don't let it skew the truth of history.
Trail of Tears? Justify what? Allowing the Indians that were paid to relocate force their 800 black slaves (some of the Cherokee/Creek elites among them owned) to have to go with them or the misfortune that befell the actual members of the tribe on the way?
I watched them; I will never excuse what we did to indigenous people, but that is the way of the world - and governments(not the People) are responsible for all of it. Just like when they locked you down through the use of force a mere three years ago.
You're agreeing that they arrived across an 18,000 year time span. So either they were the slowest walkers in history, or there were multiple waves of people coming across.
As long as our leader doesn’t wear goofy hats or Captain Crunch uniforms at official events it can’t happen here!
never confuse the country and the government. 2 very different things.
Well we’re a democracy. Just kidding.
The United States is neither a democracy nor is it a democratic republic, but an oligarchy featuring unlimited political bribery for those who can afford pricey lawyers.
Preach.
Notice that the establishment's phrase is "our democracy," not "a" or "the." Tells you all you need to know.
duh- mocker- see!
I’m agreeing more and more with Andrew Willow’s take on democracy.
Educate me, please. The Google wasn't helpful.
For example, try this one on for size. See Comments Section.
https://open.substack.com/pub/read/p/the-active-voice-robert-reich?r=p3vha&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
I had a lot of respect for Reich from his doc on income inequality until someone pointed out that he was the Sec Labor under Clinton during the NAFTA negotiations. That man is a quisling in that he bears a signifcant responsibility for the hollowing out of the USA's industrial base.
The situation described in Hillbilly Elegy rests (in a large part) on his shoulders. Both Reich and Arnand Ammawhazizname are such posers. Empty suits crying out empty platitudes, thinking their 'La Resistance'. Ugh
And the plethora of removed comments? WTF?
NOW I understand why SS contribs are moving to Locals.
If I could electronically zap everybody who quotes Robert Reich, I could say that I lived a life of true happiness.
I like Robert Reich's ideas, some of the time. He's really wrong on Internet free speech, though.
He was a small socialist bent thinker posing as an intellectual
I thought J. D. Vance's point in Hillbilly Elegy is that the crucial responsibility for the situation he described was on the people who lived there and just refused to change the self-destructive component of their life ways. Including his homefolks.
And Robert Reich did not negotiate NAFTA as Secretary of Labor under Clinton. The agreement was negotiated in the Bush I administration, and signed by President George H. W. Bush as an international agreement. The only thing that Bush ally (on the down-low, of course, although it's become much more obvious over the years) Bill Clinton did was to forcefully endorse its ratification by the Congress, the final authority on certifying treaties, and sign it into law after Congress had passed it.
Clinton was able to successfully articulate to his fellow democratic faithful, in coded speech and phony backwoods bluster refined by Yale Law, what the republicans had discovered a few decades previous. Money got you elected, and even more money kept you in office.
Reich is loyal to Team Blue, despite having most of his personal suggestions ignored and disrespected in the Clinton years. He was only appointed Labor Secretary as window dressing. No one who counted paid attention to his recommendations.
That's what the fake narrative framing of Team Blue and Team Red encourages. Ironclad team loyalty and partisanship. There's no third position, in the absence of ranked choice voting. Team Blue is terrified that they would be doomed if ranked choice voting got out of hand. And orthodox CNN/MSNBC American liberals are okay with that, because they buy into the neoliberal narrative that continues to insinuate that a 3rd Position could only be Fascist. The GOP establishment doesn't want ranked choice voting, either, because their leaders suspect that Team Red would be doomed.
Hence, America's got BOTH kindsa politics...
If Substack wanted to shoot its value proposition in the ass, introducing mass censorship so as not to offend the delicate sensitivities of The People Who Matter is the way to do it, right there.
Consider Robert Reich's presence a test. Principally a test for him, not for those of us who have adopted it as a base for preserving freedom of speech and reasoned dissent.
If I want to read another of Bobby reich’s articles on how it’s horrible that we don’t do exactly what he says, I have about five dozen outlets that will deliver the exact same low rent lefty punditry. Maybe if he ever had an original thought he wouldn’t be so offensive. It it’s the same formula all the time “how dare we let billionaires live when people are dying every day!?”
Reich is a charlatan of the first order. A government shill distorting young minds with lies.
He's an insult to little people everywhere.
O to have copped a look at the comments section before Substack stepped in!
Must have been an epic response to a puff piece so gushing that it made a high school mash note look like a model of restraint and measured praise.
I saw some of the early comments. They were unanimously anti-Reich. Hilariously so.
They seemed no more harsh than some seen here, but .......
The comments (including mine) were mostly innocuous. Example: he claimed there was book banning, my comment was "can you named the banned books"? It was deleted. In fact "Heather" turned off commenting on the whole post, the only time I've ever seen it on Substack.
Would love to have supper with Obamas and Clintons, if I could get a word in edgewise....... on second thought.......
a lawyer who tells you he's an economist. What could he possibly get wrong? Other than everything
Wow! I've never seen so many comments removed in a comment section!
I read that. I threw up. Robert Reich should be in prison for treason.
Somebody probably pointed out what a useless douchebag Robert Reich is - and a bunch of people took exception to that statement of fact.
Makes me wonder.
Has there ever been an eloquent defense of censorship? I’m talking a truly beautiful piece of writing or speaking.
Eloquence in the defense of censorship could only be beautiful as satire.
Beautifully said.
A certain pithy partisan could write it. Now *that* would be beautiful.
All of the defenses of censorship I've seen are eloquent. Censors-in-waiting regard themselves as noble, and their messaging is rife with fawning self-elevation to heroism.
Censorship only “works”when there is only one game in town. In the US media ecosystem this is long gone, no matter how hard the Ds, neo-cons, Deep Staters, and corporate wokesters may try.
Remember kids, pithy comments with no actual point or content always rise to the top.
Except places like here, where (1) people think, and reward it in others; or (2) as in your case, they use structural and rhetorical tactics to game the system, while thinking they are convincing anyone.
Huh?
Where's the "thinking" in regurgitating a widely-circulated, century-old platitude? And given how much time Democrats spent calling Trump a fascist during his term, I would love to know which Americans OP thinks aren't aware that "it can happen here".
It's just feel-good pablum.
I'm pretty sure it's a large amount of Americans on both the left and the right who think authoritarianism could never happen here. To a large degree, it's believing their side won't be the one that does it.
Which is naive.
You are right about the always regurgitating (I like that!) M. Finster, who I suspect really *is* a Russian Western-media-plant.
But M. Anti-Hip is right about the substacks.
You wouldn't know pithy if it kicked you in the ass.
How pithy.
Fully agree with your take. I get VERY tired of shopworn tropes like that above which seem to be designed to simply get likes. And why "kids"?! It is so gauche! No real contribution to the discourse, just social media-esque attempts for "likes" (love?). And unfortunately it works. I have noticed that a lot of Matt Taibbi's Substack commenters post things like "You go, Matt!" "We got your back!" "Give 'em hell, Matt!", etc. I for one would prefer more substantive comments. After all, aren't those rah-rah sentiments most efficiently captured by clicking the thumbs up icon? No need to type out a cliche!! Now watch how my post will be vilified by the same people who purport to hate similar vilification of dissenting voices in the mainstream media!!
What is the problem with complimenting a writer on their work - or in the case of Matt Taibbi - for their bravery in reporting on the shit-show that is our current government ? Let me be the first to apologize to you on behalf of everyone on this Substack who has wasted your precious time saying what they wanted to say - and not giving a shit if their comments offend the sensibilities of those who thought they were here to weigh in on a Ph.D. dissertation defense.
I normally sort by "New First", just thought I'd try something new today. Variety is the spice of life!
"Remember kids, pithy comments with no actual point or content always rise to the top."
Upvotes have never been a priority for me. In fact, I find downvotes more illuminating.
Diawhy! Keep posting like it's your job!
You rock dude!
Pot, Kettle, Black.
?
It's a shortened version of "the pot calling the kettle black", in other words, he is engaging in the same thing he is accusing others of.
Opinions are like assholes.
The mrówki tell me that the censorship is more pervasive than in Communist Poland, as more famously did Andrzej Łobczewski.
I'm writing about this as well, with the added bonus of how the paid-off press like the LA Times will literally submit their questions beforehand -- and the president has a little notecard telling him who to call on.
It really tells you everything you need to know about the state of the media these days. Play along and you get rewarded. Dare speak out, and you're unemployed. (Tucker will be fine, but how many reporters will duck their heads back down because they wouldn't be fine?)
Edit: Article is out https://simulationcommander.substack.com/p/tucker-unleashed
Really not a question of Tucker being fine, or not fine, but what it says is, we're not.
Greenwald on Rumble this past week really explained what was going on very well.
Right. My point was that they aren't really after Tucker, but every Tucker-lite out there who will be cowed into submission.
I didn't vote for trump in 2016, always a registered democrat, although not loyal. Bad enough I saw the democrat's growing authoritarian stance during the Trump years, but the media and so called left fell into line, like little soldiers. Asses.
I'd say they were/are after both. Tucker was more than pulling his weight. I was certainly expecting his firing.
This.
And David Dayen was Tucker-lite. He wrote about the Great Financial Crime Spree and he now caved to the establishment. During the GFCS years, he uncovered many crimes the government/financial coup were doing. Now, he replaces an article favored to Tucker with one opposing Tucker? That shit is horrible! What a coward!
Greenwald's report on Monday was first rate. The best explanation of what could be happening.
GG is always on point, and has been on fire about this from the start.
It's too bad he's on locals now :(
I think it's worth it to see what he has to say.
System Update is free on Rumble.
Locals is fine, it's the information that's important, not the platform.
M. Fran, you water down M. sim's excellent point by picking out the *unimportant* part of a *parenthetical*.
Your comprehension is as bad as your choice of political party.
...."unimportant" part of a "parenthetical." Oh you sound so smart, now who is M. sim's and what is his excellent point? Four degrees with bad comprehension and 2 in science. What an accomplishment for someone with no comprehension. Now if you could take a minute out of your day and rephrase your nasty ass comment maybe I'll condescend to answer.
Nicely credentialed you are.
"...maybe I'll condescend to answer."
You just did, and thanks!
The Times denied giving Biden the questions. Does that mean the White House gave the questions to the Times? He clearly had the questions so it has to be one or the other...oh wait, one of the three letter agencies tapping in perhaps?
There's a very easy explanation for all this.
The Times lied. As they do about pretty much everything.
I saw that! The questions are obviously present, and if the Times didn't give them to the White House in advance, the only other possibility is that the White House gave THE TIMES the question in advance..........which is even worse.
For plausible deniability, it may have gone like this: White House tells certain reporters what specific aspects of certain specific topics the president would be addressing in questions today. Those reporters then submit the questions.
Just like the tabletop exercise on the "Russian Disinfo" that was rehearsed the month before the Post released the story on Hunter's laptop, these agencies (WH, intelligence) will always attempt to keep some veneer of deniability, which then their lapdogs in the MSM will highlight to say that assertions of their collusion/collaboration are not proven (and thus are lies).
Exactly how it is done.
🛎
Biden got tripped up by a couple of children today because that's the first time he's faced questions that weren't pre-planted in ages. Literal toddlers tripped him up more than the WH press corp has. If that doesn't tell you all you need to know about our current media, I don't know what will.
The question was pretty hard (what was the last place you visited or something like that). He was in Ireland a week ago, but he was stumped. Another child stepped in to help him out. This is where we are today.
Please give a reference?
https://nypost.com/2023/04/27/biden-cant-recall-visit-to-ireland-he-took-two-weeks-ago/
We used to speak of “regulatory capture”. Our whole country is captured. These are the times that try mens souls.
yep. its one giant global cartel. there isnt anything that hasn't been monopolized. we live in a world of illusion that appears to have choice, but not too many of any real consequence.
Tucker is rare in that he has his own genuine talent and following meaning he doesn’t need a Fox or CNN brand to survive. Like a Megyn Kelly, he will be able to find a very prosperous new path. But that’s him, not most media people. And so his firing had a real sweeping effect to send a message to the rest.
Actually, this manipulation of the press in briefings started with Regan. If a reporter asked him an uncomfortable question, he didn't get a seat at the next press conference. And now no one asks the President or whatshername anything they don't want to answer or they're brushed off or attacked for even approaching a subject.
I don't remember where I saw it (it might have been right here, honestly) but somebody mentioned how the press complains that without being inside the velvet rope, they can't do their jobs -- but they don't realize they were never supposed to be inside the rope in the first place.
I'm just disgusted that the media/journalists don't do their jobs any more. Perhaps they never did, but there were just enough rogue journalists to actually dig in and find the truth so we were lulled into thinking we had a watchdog press of sorts. Now the ones in the mainstream are just lackeys for their controllers, and nothing original comes out of any of them. Do they know they have controllers? Do they bristle at being told what they can and cannot write about? It doesn't seem like it.
So you're just here to shill your own substack? Cool.
This place needs a better system for surfacing top comments.
LOL everybody can see you trolling, dude.
And I've been commenting on Taibbi articles long before I had a Substack.......
Ignore Dwhy, CDR. He's still sour about the time he got absolutely bodied in my comments section.
LOL
You mean the time I pointed out that you published a wildly inaccurate statistic in huge banner font in one of your articles, and in response you closed your comments to non-paid readers?
Talk about living in a dream world.
It's amazing to me how "trolling" and "saying things I don't like" seem to be interchangeable concepts to dimwits like you.
Tucker didn't get fired for speaking out, he got fired for 1. telling lies that cost his company $$$, and 2. allowing his staffing to be run in a discriminatory, abusive way. Rupert Murdoch is not exactly a bastion of woke leftism... when that dude wants his top earner gone, you know the guy REALLY fucked up.
LOL the good thing about trolls is that you know exactly what they're going to say. I love how the woman suing Tucker for a hostile work environment never even met him.
Tucker was actually the guy who went on TV and said Powell was full of BS. The media made fun of FOX for losing viewers to NewsMax. You can still read the articles today.
But now since it's politically convenient to rewrite history, that's what you do.
Fox is going to lose far more $$$ in the wake of firing Tucker than it did in the Dominion settlement. His positions on Ukraine and vaccines are what sealed his fate. The powers that be insisted he be muzzled before the next election cycle fully kicked in. There will be no major mainstream media platform for RFK, Jr’s presidential bid now.
You don’t have a clue what you’re talking about. In fact, Tucker was not a top earner because all of the left wing boycotts of his show scared off major advertisers over the last few years. Try again.
Sources?
He's actually complimenting you. By accusing you of trolling, he's implying that you're smart enough to know better, but are deliberately posting bullshit. The alternative is that you are being genuine and actually believe what you write.
Have to disagree on point 1. Carlson was not a large part of the 20 examples Dominion cited in the actual coverage. I think it was one for him. In fact, Carlson made it very clear, on the air, that he asked Sidney Powell to come on his show and show the evidence that the election was stolen. She declined, and he pointed this out. It was almost heresy to do this on Fox News at the time.
Yeah and then they paid off a complicit part of a stolen election, a pretty large part, by offering them a billion dollars. You're a funny girl, dwhy
What lies are you talking about? Name the most recent ones that got him fired...
Abby Grossmans lawyers confirmed that she has never met Tucker Carlson as he does his shows from a separate location in a different state. Maybe Tucker went to the Matt Lauer, Chris Cuomo, Don Lemon school of charm and how to promote a hostile work environment.
Rupert Murdoch and his sons are avowed leftists. Murdoch only tolerated Ailes because he made them money in a niche market. Shock; leftists like money too. Who knew!
And yet, no rebuttal, unless you consider early grade school stylee as the best you can do. Why are you here, ma'am?
Substack so desperately needs a silence function. This has always been true. But they did get rid of the #1 troll, so I thank them daily for that.
I suppose the irony of suggesting a "silence function" in the comment section of an article about the perils of preemptive restriction of speech is lost on you.
If by "silence function" you're recommending an "ignore" capability, you should realize that all you're doing is giving an edge to the people whose comments you refuse to read, who are still able to reply to anything you post for the wider audience to read. It's sort of like putting a paper bag over your head and imagining that you're invisible.
If I find another comment writer's post(s) to be worthless, I know how to use a scroll mouse. I don't feel any requirement to block everything they say forevermore.
You clearly missed the Gene Frenkel phase...
You know you can just... not... read it... right?
Dwhy is obviously some kind of agent provocateur, and most likely paid to be here.
You waste space and air.
You’re just full of smart ass comments aren’t you? Talk about adding nothing to the discussion
NOTHING wrong with pointing us to other writers who can expand the conversation..
Is that your way of prompting me to write a "smart ass comment"?
I know. I keep seeing yours.
In top comments? I find that hard to believe.
Even more, it needs better system for submerging worthless ones like ...
An ignore flag would be perfect. And no, It's not censorship if each individual reader has to make the decision for themselves that a certain common terrorism not worth listening to.
Well said, Commander.
Regarding AOC: if the establishment is good at nothing else, it is very good at determining who can be co-opted, who can be bought off, who is to be neutralized, whom to safely ignore.
How quickly she was co-opted, and now is just another culture warrior, and establishment sycophant. Man, that was quick. SMH. Wealthy elites love easy "turns" like this one.
I doubt she was ever who she claimed to be. That Netflix "documentary" was all scripted. Most likely she is a plant. At least that is what I believe now. A newcomer doesn't win against an establishment unless they want you to.
As a former constituent who followed her from before her first election, I have wondered what her "community organizer" tenure actually consisted of, for nearly a decade out of college. Did she go to the same school as Obama? Was it in Langley VA?
After Obama and AOC, "community organizer" may as well be a code-word for "deep-state shill"
She organized her bar patrons, b/c, like, everyone will listen to a hot bartender even one spouting lefty claptrap.
Remember how people pointed out that she responded to a casting call, but all the 'fact checkers' said that was fake because the organization that put on the event does these types of things all the time looking for new talent.........
That's a casting call.
Oh, I must have missed that. But, yes, I think she is a plant to bring around the youth vote.
Look up her handlers. That's all you need to know.
Y'know, I never considered that. But...I remember seeing her do a livestream before the primaries, and...its hard to put my finger on it...but...there seemed to be a sort-of un-natural buzz in the room, from the commenters, etc...the whole thing seemed just a little too good to be true....And the fact that I was even alerted to that stream in the first place speaks volumes, since I typically don't even follow local political primaries in states/districts far away from me. That it was put in front of me at all to begin with is a little bit suss.
she never was. she’s an actor who responded to an ad, looking for someone to play the part she played well, at first. throwing her own words back at her...”and so, when you elect a politician, and then they let you down, it feels like rejection. it feels like heartbreak. it feels like betrayal.”
LOL remember when she was complaining about not being able to find an apartment?
And then the issue went away when she "miraculously" ended up with some sweet digs?
I wish I could link to an article I read in 2008 about Obama's nice digs on Lake Shore Drive overlooking Lake Michigan when he was sent to Chicago as a community organizer. After a hard day of speaking about asbestos in black neighborhoods, he would retire to a nice apartment. Maybe it was Paul Street's book or on Black Agenda Report or Adolph Reed, JR. Of course, the church ladies were doing most of the organizing and baking.
She was a socialist. Of course she was going to take the money and screw the little guy. Name a socialist country that doesn't, and if you say Denmark I will scream.
It’s really disappointing cause back in 2018 I has high hopes for her
Part of me wonders if AOC fell into the trap of being more concerned about selling a brand/image than pushing for actual change. Because once you are more concerned about brand or image, it's a lot easier to co-opt you and get you to toe the line.
Shant Mesrobian has pointed out that when AOC first came on the scene, she branded herself as an anti-establishment radical but quickly realized that doing so left her with no future in the Democratic party. So she pivoted to staking out the most radical edge of party advocacy, routinely advocating for the censorship and deplatforming of Party critics and enemies and hoping that the difference in these two radical postures would go unnoticed. It's been a remarkably successful strategy considering how it's provided her so much approval and popularity within the liberal-left base, allowing her to have a future in the Party while continuing to maintain a differentiated political brand premised upon a more youthful, activist, radical mode of politics.
Ironically, her 2018 campaign touted the need for elected officials to exercise "courage". And now she's a subservient little mouse, unable even to buck the remainder of "The Squad" rescinding their Ukraine plea for negotiations.
Nancy took her into the woodshed very early in her career, and AOC has been an obedient soldier ever since.
Yet advocating for censorship is antithetical to a true liberal or progressive who fights for freedom; so AOC will criticize book banning but not deplatforming of conservatives. Politicians do this hypocritical game which is so obvious but that’s part of the job I suppose. She tries to be the moral one but politics and moral integrity just don’t mix
Does anyone remember so far back in time when AOC protested outside Pelosi's office?
Fancy dress for the ball (gala) is now the price for admission?
Seems she was an easy pushover.
Just took a soft fascist breeze.
All it takes is a little power and even those who pretended to thumb their nose at the boss are fast to jump in the passenger seat when it’s offered. It’s easy to turn into the Establishment.
Yes, just remember to wear a "tax the rich" gown at the Met. And forget all those things like.....oh.....protesting Mama Bear's office.
And the classic picture of her in that stupid dress and in background, the wait-staff masked while none of the celebrities are. The message was crystal clear -- "we are somebody and you are nobody and don't forget it."
My point is what the hell is a supposed "for the People" Representative doing attending a MET GALA, where tickets cost FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS???? And up against the ticket cost you have her stupid "tax the rich" outfit. She is beyond ludicrous.
AOC spends lots of time on her ‘packaging’, her look....
She is also not exactly an "inner-city kid" - she spent most of her childhood in an affluent small town in Westchester.
Unset, I was very surprised that Matt did not know that.
I can't even blame the establishment for her. She is really just a shallow individual who won a primary campaign (what was the vote turnout for her to win). So now the generous government world of Democratic rule is her oyster. She really is just an internet influencer, whatever that is. "Evita," the Broadway musical, meets Tanya (Patty Hearst) meets Social Media. Pretty sure Her AOCeminence is unschooled in those first two references.
"She is really is just an internet influencer, whatever that is."
Not a bad summary.
If they can’t “co-opt” you you are in read danger. See Trump, Donald.
Seems to me most politicians, that is the vast majority, can be bought off in time. I also think there should be more accountability for those so called lefties, even those speaking out now in light of Tucker's firing. They too, should be held accountable since they showed no objectivity during Trump's time in office. They were in almost total complicity with the democrats, the mainstream media in that regard and they are equally culpable in making this country more authoritarian. They were literally feeding into what many of them are complaining about now.
Given how precarious jobs are these days, I would think it doesn’t take much to co-opt someone.
Substitute Ruling classes for establishment and BINGO!
We'll argue semantics later.
After Tuckers firing, she went on to brag “de-platforming works”.
And then she calls others fascists.
God, I miss old school liberals who were all about freedom.
As bad as what AOC had to say is, I'm not giving her any credit for what happened to Tucker.
On the other hand, it wouldn't surprise me if it was the GOP establishment types who wanted him gone, because how dare Tucker question what the hell we are doing in Ukraine when he could talk about, for example, abortion.
Yeah, I can't help but think Paul Ryan had something to do with this...
Yup - it’s about Ukraine & the 💰💰💰of the military industrial complex
I'm still amazed he got away with it this long. He was on mainstream television spouting anti-war rhetoric that would have given McGovern a hard-on. He slammed the military industrial complex again and again and again. It was beautiful. Especially when we started sending our TANKS to Ukraine. And he meant it, too.
I'm a bit mixed about my assessment of Tucker, but Jesus did he ever get the war stuff right.
This heterodox thinking is exactly why I watched him regularly. Then, I turn off FOX.
Totally agree. More likely Cocaine Mitch vs AOC
AOC, lying piece of shit that she is, is all in on a full scale war with Ukraine now. She's such a tool.
Glenn greenwald pretty much said that : in nutshell he dissented from mainstream republicans
Yeah the real power in the republicant party is by doing the lefts dirty work, and maintaining status quo and their fucking miserable little jobs. I have been a conservative since the debacle that was Vietnam, and renounced my membership in the gop in about 1977.
Saw a clip of R. Weingarten testifying before Congress yesterday. Is that an American flag crossed with a Ukrainian flag pin she was wearing? Hilarious.
She's beyond stooge.
yeah, Paul Ryan and his ilk happy to give him to boot. They will follow I up with 4 hour segments on Bud Lite and Disney and hope that makes up for it with the audience.
There is an old saying: "scratch a liberal, reveal a fascist".
An older one is "Scratch a Liberal, find a Tory."
When you strip away the feel-good rhetoric, Liberals are only about Free Markets and the sanctity of private property rights.
Not even private property rights. WA State (bluer than blue) just passed SSB 5077 that will eviscerate property rights.
Yeah, that's not fascism. Go read a book.
"Ex-government employee interviewing current government employee about how the current government should crack down on 'wrongthink' while the ex-government employee nods along'" -- totally not fascism at all.
Trump saying "you are fake news" -- THAT is fascism!
Trump sending his mob of thugs to overrun the capitol is a lot closer to fascistic than anything Dems have done. But you'll note that I never called Trump a fascist.
What you're describing simply isn't fascism. That said, I would love it if you and all your right-wing turd buddies would keep saying that, since it makes clear to the rest of the population what mush-brained lemmings you people are.
Dude you're still in your 2021 talking points. We know the Metro PD was in the crowd. We know the feds were in the crowd. Nobody was surprised by anything, it was a set-up from the start, and that's why the video remains locked away.
https://www.scribd.com/document/631445713/MPD-Report
Notice they have a complete schedule of events and coordinated attire so they can spot one another at a glance.
Well it was Mussolini who invented the system and the word --and who basically said it is what he says it is!
It’s symbol was a group of sticks bundled together and wrapped tightly as one. One stick is easily breakable. The bundle is impossible to break. The theory is everyone working together --going in the same direction, by force if necessary, makes the state strong. Dissent and difference of opinion make it weak.
So actually, the government working with business to wipe out unpopular speech is indeed textbook fascism.
What an incredibly stupid remark. Wow.
Nothing is ever "fascism" and nothing is ever "socialism" when you can constantly move the goal posts/change definitions to suit a narrative. Fascism? Well that's me(by the lefts definition and labeling), Mussolini and Hitler and Socialism is something in Amsterdam.
"Everything in the State, nothing outside the State, nothing against the State."
That is the quintessential definition of fascism, as stated by ol' Benito himself. It's a totalitarian worldview... it's not just about *some* control, it's about absolute, *unescapable* control.
If you can escape fascism by just turning off the TV, that's not fascism.
Right! Now maybe you can explain employing intellectual gymnastics and pretzel logic just how the hell you guys label people like me a fascist when I share no philosophical beliefs with your kissing cousin Benito and his buddy to the north you guys tie yourselves up in knots trying to hang around the rights neck. LMAO! You know when I'm not out in my white hood burning crosses, lynching, oppressing women with my girthy patriarchy and chasing atheists around with my Bible quoting scripture! LMAO! Such d-heads with your BS, f'ing old and beat.
Fascism is when you turn on the TV and the political philosophical opposition of a news network that has been this political oppositions object of removing from a market place entirely has someone removed for no logical, reasonable, rational explanation.
None of you freedom loving leftists have been calling for that right? That's the difference between me and you. I am all for the left having a platform and spewing their BS. I don't want them removed I want them all to be seen for what they are as an example of what not to be. Problem is you run from debate or lie your asses off as a tactic because by any means necessary and the ends justify the means. Yell liar or fascist or racist or copy n paste articles you do not read or comprehend yourselves as some sort of argument or refutation.
Yep. You should look up Wikipedia's "fascism" entry on the Wayback Machine.
When you do, you’ll discover that what we have is textbook. Government and “private” orgs collude to control the rabble.
The left cognitive dissonance to their own fascism is amazing to behold. There are no mirrors in their parallel universe.
Yeah, that's not fascism.
beep boop
The best part about making baseless accusations on the anonymous internet is that you never have to feel like a shithead when it turns out you're wrong.
I'm not sure they ever really were about freedom. Matt says liberals "didn't want to ban things" but cites The American President, the climax of which has the president, glorying in his own power, promising to go door to door confiscating people's guns. Hard to be pro-freedom and anti-ban when you want to ban and seize lots of things and effectively delete 10% of the Bill of Rights. They're up to at least 20% now but they were never at 0.
I miss the old-school liberals who understood the definition of irony.
I’m still here. But I still have dial up....so.
Another great piece. My whole life (in my 50s) I've never liked the puritanical pearl clutching of the religious GOP but I also caught the scent very early for the totalitarian leanings of Democrats.
Political correctness was a start of it, the race baiting of Sharpton's Tawana Brawley era in NYC, Jessie Jackson and on and on. Manipulating people for ever increasing power and intrusion into day to day lives by the ever growing government. The obsession with disarming the public...it all spelled tyranny for years. Here we are now, my worst nightmares realized.
Look at the fanatical obsession with the smoking ban, another left mob driven cult expression. The issue was distorted in the extreme so the mob could join in othering a target that they knew was not going to be defended. The pattern repeated and escalated. Everything is always sold as the "greater good" when it means mob rule under a violent and oppressive government that will stop at nothing if you resist.
It's always been clear that conformity and compliance were something fundamental in the "liberal" orthodoxy. I've never known a Democrat in my life that had any respect for individual freedom and liberty.
The disgraceful false racism agenda is probably their most shameful exploit, causing utterly needless division using baseless fear driven nonsense. The censorship is a close second and equally disturbing, however without total information control they cannot ensure the falsehoods will propagate. With an open dialogue, their entire platform, their entire premise, baseless, will disintegrate instantly.
The fact that all of their motions are clearly mapped in Mao's Red Book, and all the Frankfurt School and other historical writings and that people can't even see it is probably the most distressing. They have so decimated education that people are woefully ignorant participants in something they don't even understand.
Keep going.
Excellent comment! An old friend of mine said years ago that the government outlawing smoking with ever encroaching laws was the first step in control of more aspects in private life. At the time I thought she was overreacting but now see the wisdom and foresight in her observation.
From what I can see, the government picks the issues to amplify (Trump indicted for paying off a prostitute), or gives minimal lip service to others (invasion at the border, fentanyl crisis) and in the case of Carlson, punishes those who bring up topics left ignored by them.
It's a slow walk to train people to accept the control.
I've always agreed it resembles Maoism. Nothing about it resembles the Old Left that I once knew, and loved, the Orwellian variety.
On many fronts, I'm a Classic Liberal, but I've never once felt those ideals represented by Democrats. The idea that the government of my lifetime would ever effectively create and deliver on major programs like universal healthcare is just ludicrous. I'm not opposed in concept to a nation as wealthy as ours providing social services like healthcare or subsidized education, it's our _actual_ government that leaves me where I would never support it.
You last sentence hits the nail on the head. Our healthcare system, in and of itself, is fine. The payment bureaucracy and associated politics is the nightmare.
I'm close to health services via my family and many relatives and friends. The current system is badly eroding due to incompetent regulation and the market consolidation in care providers. Add in DEI viral infection in accreditation bodies and physicians are running, retiring early and leaving the industry.
It is in a bad state and it will take time to be more visible to average people but right now it's crumbling and crumbling fast. In rural America it is almost impossible to find basic General Practitioners or OBGYNs, in more concentrated urban areas it is becoming impossible to get a simple appointment. I live rurally now and to get in to see a GP, you only find 30yr olds that have just ended residency accepting new patients and appointments are months out in booking and frequently canceled.
The heavy handed regulation, price fixing and other measures that were put in since the Obama administration have created an anti-competitive environment that was constructed to favor massive consolidation under just a few behemoth health provider networks. It's a bad scene.
Yes, and how did that Maoism work out for China?
Basically like woke authoritarianism is working out for America: turning it into a fucking dystopia
Smoking as an act of resistance has actually crossed my mind in more irrational moments
Mao's Red Book says "political power grows out of the barrel of a gun." How GOP can you get?
About which Biden said "they have their guns, and we have the F-15s". We're all waiting to see what form Schumer's "sensible F-15 regulation" will take.
The Iraq war was the political event that most shaped my childhood. I learned to take anything the government says with a healthy grain of salt, and never trust those who would seek to censor or silence opposition viewpoints. Last year I took a First Amendment class in law school. Probably fifty or so students in the class. I figured there would be at least one other principled civil-libertarian in the class. I mean, after all, we read all the major free speech cases: Pentagon Papers, Times v Sullivan, the Flag-burning and draft-card-burning cases, obscenity doctrine, Skokie march, Wesborough Baptist Church, etc. Somebody had to come around to the obvious position that censorship does not work and it is foolish to trust the government with the power to decide which opinions are on and off limits. I’m 30 now, so I’m was a few years older than most of the other students. Nevertheless, it was pretty depressing to be literally the only student who fit into the old-school ACLU mold. I got the sense that myself and my professor were probably the only two people in the room who had even heard of Ira Glasser. I believe there are very few millennials, let alone gen Z, who value freedom of thought. They believe corporations and the government have a responsibility to protect us from wrong-think and, the most laughable phrase in vogue today, “harmful speech”. It’s bleak, man. I don’t see how this leads to anything besides ever-increasing polarization. I don’t see how this ends well.
When the speech police censor viewpoints they don't like, it's "holding people accountable". When they censor viewpoints they agree with, it's fascism. I have argued vehemently in effort to convince young people that the transgressive ideas they support (ie boycott divestment and sanctions, radical ideas about police and prisons, etc) may one day become to target of cancelation. The response is usually along the lines of, "Well then we will deal with the fascists when that happens".
Isn't it weird?
I'm old enough to remember when police would go out into the streets and bash gay people. My parents are old enough to remember when police unleashed dogs on peaceful black protestors during the civil rights movement.
Now they think they'll be on the right side of "democracy" forever?
I don’t think you were attracted to liberalism per se then, you were attracted to the libertarian aspects of pre-2000s liberalism. Modern liberals are authoritarians, because there is nothing about either liberalism or conservatism that mandates whether they be authoritarian or libertarian, it varies by era. But don’t make the mistake of associating liberalism with tolerance or free speech -- those may be liberal values in some eras, but they are always libertarian values. Because “liberal” and “conservative” change their meaning over time, no one should establish a permanent identification as one or the other. In particular, you have to see if “your side” is using authoritarian means to achieve their goals -- if they are, they are probably the bad guys.
Always best to minimize labels and discuss individual topics
Absolutely! Sick of the labels and the isms...let’s go issue by issue.
Libertarians are basically Classical Liberals. They're one and the same.
Basically, but modern liberals have substituted something different for “liberalism” than classical liberals or even liberals of the ‘60s and ‘70s understood as liberalism. It is another example of the nominative fallacy, mistaking the label for the thing, without realizing that the underlying thing identified by the label has changed.
Not true. Libertarians are the right-wing sect of Classical Liberals.
The whole right, middle, left paradigm is a crock. You're either for ordered liberty or for some form of tyranny.
I love all of the malleable labels, definitions, stereotypes and caricatures people can come up with on the left. I seriously don't know how the hell you can keep up with it all.
Plato had it right. You can have Oligarchy, Tyranny, or Democracy. I assure you though that there also is indeed a Left and a Right. The basic tenets of Leftism: the common good is more important than individual property rights. Natural resources should be used for public benefit, not private gain. All people should be provided with medical care and housing. Monopolies should be nationalized, turned over to the workers, or broken up. Banking should be a public utility, not a privately managed interest-taking sector. All peoples of the world share a common humanity, war is just the elites sending the working class to die so the elites get richer and get more sphere of influence control. Workers of the world unite. THAT is Leftism, which is very very distinct from centrism or being on the Right.
The left/right paradign describes centers of power. You can be philosophically opposed to one side or the other, but still support them for some reason or another.
Libertarians and Conservatives just happen to overlap in a majority of views and policy positions, and tend to vote almost exclusively Republican. Go figure.
"Because 'liberal' and 'conservative' change their meaning over time, no one should establish a permanent identification as one or the other."
Yes, agreed. Just as with "Democrat" and Republican" (in the US).
But "Left" and "Right" have essentially fixed meanings, and for that reason, I think it would be beneficial to beef up our understanding and use of them.
I don’t think so -- “left” and “right” are relative to the then-current status quo, so modern leftists for example are focused on race over class, in contrast to the leftists of the ‘30s and 40s. What is “progressive” in one era becomes conservative in the next, like how rock ‘n roll was once seen as edgy and progressive but is now considered staid and reactionary. Or, to put it another way, Woodrow Wilson and AOC are both progressives relative to the society of their time, but would hate each other and don’t have much in common viewpoint- or policy-wise. “Libertarianism” and “authoritarianism” however are not relative to the the current status quo, as libertarians in every era prioritize small government, free speech, due process and other civil rights etc. and authoritarians do the opposite.
Modern progressives love nominative fallacies, where people get attached to the label of a thing without realizing that the thing it identifies has changed. This is why many “old lefties” continue to support “progressivism” even though modern progressivism is antithetical to many of the things they believed in -- anti war, pro free speech, deeply suspicious of government, etc. In my view, no one should identify as permanently “progressive” or “conservative” under the assumption that those things are immutable, because they aren’t. The liberals of the ‘60s were largely libertarian progressives, modern liberals are authoritarian progressives, and it is important to keep that distinctions in mind rathe than simply reflexively identify as “progressive” or “conservative”, as those descriptors by themselves don’t capture all the relevant dimensions. As Orwell said, the real division is not between conservatives and revolutionaries, but between libertarians and authoritarians.
As a historical record, I agree with that. Thank you. I also see that "Authoritarian" and "Libertarian" are persistent impulses, what ever they are called, in contrast to shifting labels and label-to-label-associations.
But what is a great need today regarding political language? Allowing important words to constantly change meaning at the whim of thought leaders is just one type of potential poison to society. It is well-recognized that the pace of change is certainly driving us crazy today, turning us into a tower of Babel. But there's no reason to assume it is even necessary...
"'left' and 'right' are relative to the then-current status quo"
That's a fair conclusion from their origins in the French Revolution. But curiously, that era also produced what persists today in the French national motto -- Liberté, égalité, fraternité -- where the first two terms neatly reflect persistent fundamental Rightist and Leftist values over the centuries since: Freedom and Equality. So it's important that they persisted here *combined* in a national statement, even as they are assumed to be opposed in Western political ideologies.
I'd tweak the second to what I think is a more widely palatable concept, Fairness, and then you've got two essential, complementary components of societal needs: (individual) freedom and (social) fairness. The third component is one that has been disparaged in recent years, and now with woke politics supposed to be completely dispensed with: Brotherhood, or sense of community, where societies are permitted to define and support themselves in contrast to other societies. It presupposes no necessary hostility, despite what globalists promote.
I think the libertarian/authoritarian distinction frequently gets subsumed into or conflated with “progressivism” or “conservatism” because the progressive or conservative movement in any snapshot of time may seek to achieve their ends through libertarian or authoritarian means, and people living in that time assume that “progressivism” or “conservatism” always support those means. But in a broader historical perspective this is not true. Governments on both the left and the right can be either authoritarian or libertarian, and extreme political movements on both sides tend to converge on the authoritarian end (e.g., Stalin and Hitler both united at the authoritarian end though one is on the left and one on the right). I think it is important to disentangle the two axes to make sure you are not reflexively identifying with a tribe because it is nominally “progressive” or “conservative” if they are using authoritarian means (assuming you disapprove of authoritarian means) to achieve their progressive or conservative goals.
' "Left" and "Right" have essentially fixed meanings,'
Tell that to the media.
... who work for perpetual shapeshifters barreling toward their their own secret goals. "Change is [always] good!" "Change is inevitable! [even when humans make the change]"
Coco I appreciate this reflection.
I just texted a couple friends yesterday when I saw that AOC interview and said "I am ashamed I once thought AOC was our political future." Seriously, the Democrats are going to force me to vote Trump in the next election. We've really sunk so far.
The lady doth protest too much, methinks
What has happened to the anti-war left, and the left in general, is mind blowing to me every single day. The two things that basically attracted me to the political "left" as it were; basically in a nutshell three things in the 1980s: it was still the place where the anti-war movement had traction, especially as it pertained to our actions in Central America and other places. It was definitely, 100% for free speech and free expression (I was a punk rock fan and especially found the Minutemen and other totally anti-war and anti-establishment bands transcendent). Finally, it opposed apartheid in South Africa and we longed for racial harmony in America, AKA the Martin Luther King Jr. variety.
These are all gone from the left now. The last professional conference I attended there was a "BIPOC Affinity Room" that white people were not allowed to enter, and the elites and liberal professional class scream at the residents of the most poverty stricken counties in America in Kentucky, which are mostly white, that they have "white privilege." The left is, in some ways, even more warmongering than the hated neocons of the 1990s and 2000s. But what really blows my mind is how much they want to literally censor everything.
I've never been more politically homeless in my life.
Smith - in the words of Noam Chomsky, the Democratic party is the only hope this country has to remain a democracy. The GOP are fascist.
So I can understand your concern that like 90% of Democratic leaders are corporate tools. They are. But 100% of GOP leaders are corporate tools as are most of their voters. Big difference.
If you want a home, fight for power in the Dem party. If not you are just naval gazing
Lifelong conservative here that unfortunately has had to vote R a few times in my life. 100% of Dems have been and always were corporate tools while railing against corporations as 99% of Republicans have always been corporate tools too. LMAO, fight for power in the Democrat Party? You guys already have the power. With the exception of a few red state legislatures you guys have the culture, institutions of higher learning, Hollywood, the media, FBI, DOJ and cancel culture is a whole owned subsidiary of you. As I commented elsewhere here and will pass along to S Smith. The whole right, middle, left paradigm is BS. You are either for ordered liberty or for some form of tyranny. There is no being kinda sorta for both. Taibbi has literally been documenting and reporting on this very thing. Maybe you should actually read his articles.
All the two political parties are is the Harlem Globetrotters vs the Washington Generals. Good cop, bad cop. Corporations need more regulatory power to stifle innovation and upstarts....vote(fund) Dem one cycle. Need corporate tax breaks vote(fund) Rep the next cycle. The GOP and Dems are fascist economically and use communist tactics in the streets(antifa/BLM).
Chomsky is a political idiot and should have stuck to his field of expertise, linguistics.
Jeff - No, the Democrats don't have all of the power. Hollywood has been screaming for things like Universal Health Care, Less Corporate Power, Higher Taxes for the rich for decades and law makers in the GOP and DEM party ignore them as well as the majority of voters that want these policies.
You say 99% of GOP have been corporate tools. The majority of GOP voters want to ban assault rifles. Can you name the 1% of GOP leaders that would vote the way GOP voters want on this issue. The majority of GOP voters want the government to fund health care. Can you name the 1% of GOP law makers that are willing to vote for government funded health care? 100% of GOP law makers vowed that they don't believe in climate change. Do 100% of GOP voters think it is fake?
Who are you kidding?
GOP law makers are 100% controlled by big business. They have ZERO % that are not controlled by big business.
As the former president of College Republicans in college it is very telling to hear that you have been a life long conservative. You need to wake up and smell the coffee... Yes most Dem law makers are terrible. But there is a huge difference between MOST and ALL.
Assault rifles have been illegal for civillian use for a very long time.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_weapon
"Assault weapon" is just a scare term used to motivate people who answer poll questions.
Who am I kidding? I don't know what parallel universe you are living in or echo chamber you reside specifically but nothing, zero, nada of the shit you claim GOP voters want is true. I suppose you'd sight some obscure polls as proof. You're intellectually dishonest and do not debate in good faith. The GOP which is made up of the establishment has kept and preserved Obama Care after campaigning endlessly on repealing it. The GOP voters want to ban assault rifles(facepalm), I can't even entertain that obvious bogus claim. Yep, GOP lawmakers are controlled by big business as is the entirety of the Democrat Party. I mean how intellectually dishonest can you possibly get? Your side has been pimping the BS narrative as the party of the little guy, unions, the working man. Taibbi has done yeoman work in pointing this out to his own ideological brethren. He's now saying shit we've been pointing out for years. Big business/corporations and government work hand in hand while both parties point the fingers at each other.
I'm sure you were the president of College Republicans(eyeroll). Sounds about right as there isn't much difference between the Checked Pant Country Club Republicans and Limousine Liberals/Progressives.
My family was Goldwater conservatives even before he put out Conscience Of A Conservative(or Buckley's God and Man At Yale) of which I still have my Grandfathers hardcover first edition. My mother helped organize a fund raiser in Reno , Nv for Reagans 80' presidential run where I listened to the adults talk to Paul Laxalt and heard him explain how the Bushes were a huge problem/obstacle. Too bad Reagan feared he needed Bush to win. I'm sure you already knew that Laxalt was who Reagan wanted as VP and not that limp dick GOPestablishment Bush being a president of the College Republicans and all.
No way, man, I'm done with the Democrats forever.
The Tea Party is an example of organizing. The Justice Democrats are an example of organizing.
If you can't get your ideas adopted by either the Dem or GOP party you are just navel gazing. Parties change quite a bit over time. Southern Democrats in 2023 are very different than they were in 1973. Trump Republicans are very different than Bush Republicans.
If you want your ideas adopted you have to organize and get them pushed through an effective political organizing group.
The Tea party is now the Trump party. All they ever really stood for was bringing down the old school Bush GOP. And at that they have succeeded. And they did it pretty quick.
Ideas are just naval gazing if they are not aligned with political power.... LBJ did not sign the Civil Rights bill because he was a true believer in MLK. He did it because MLK organized and brought VOTES to the table. and that is what LBJ wanted more than civil rights for people of color.
Why do you imagine that me, an apostate in the party now, as I viciously opposed lockdowns and vaccine mandates, in addition to opposing the madness of sending billions to Ukraine, and a huge free speech advocate, would even be accepted in the D party now? For these views, over the last 3 years I have been called a fascist and worse. I have been threatened with violence toward myself and my family for opposing the ludicrous mask mandate here as well. I hate the Rethuglicans, but sorry, man, the Dems hate my views as well.
The Justice Democrats are an example of sheepherding
In the words of Burt Reynolds "Do the letters F O mean anything to you?"
Please mention some of those "leaders" in that 10% category?
Sanders, Warren, Porter, Khana, i can go on
My god she is simply awful. That is all.
Just gross.
The "tax the rich" gown wearer at the Met Gala. That was when I knew she had jumped the shark and could not see she was now just a meme.
It's very bad that there is uniform silencing of all those who vary from the Establishment narrative.
It's even worse that those granted the megaphone by our betters are so dull and stupid. When's the last time you watched a CNN or MSNBC and said "Wow, I never thought about that, I need to evaluate my underlying assumptions and thought process."
"When's the last time you watched a CNN or MSNBC..."
If you cut off your question right there, I could honestly say "on 9/11." Ditto with Fox News. And I highly doubt I will ever watch any of them (or any other TV news show) again.
Which reporter on 9/11 watched Bldg 7 go down and said "looks exactly like controlled demolition"? I can't find that even in the way back machine.
Ron Insana, CNBC.
Has he been Tucker'd yet? Or was that just a misstep and he corrected himself?
All of them looked like controlled demolition
Yes, they did. But I specifically remember a reporter commenting on Bldg 7 looking like "controlled demolition." I've looked at the way back machine on the video coverage of 9/11 and can't find it.
Probably not remembering it correctly.
https://www.metabunk.org/threads/debunked-ae911t-cnbc-anchor-ron-insana-claims-building-7-a-controlled-implosion.10929/
Holy cow!!! I knew I was remembering things correctly. Dan Rather:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aeHUe3AdoQM
Given your screen name I understand why you do not watch network news. True TV news died after the final "One on the Town" aired.
My toxic relationship with Floyd Robertson also soured me towards the business.
Uniform silencing? What do you think is happening right here, on this Substack? Silence? Joe Rogan gets 100,000,000 views a month, while CNN and MSNBC both hover at or below 1,000,000. Your "dull and stupid" comment is spot on, but that's probably why *nobody watches those networks*.
Jesus christ.
I have never watched any TV news, ever. Except in airports. That makes 60 years worth.
In Nov 2017 I decided to boycott the New York Times, and shortly afterward extended that to all non-independent media. I trust only those who are reader-supported, like the newspapers used to be.
“Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth.” -Marcus Aurelius
Luckily, civilization has moved on since the Roman Empire.
If your definition of "fact" defines "facts" out of existence, you should probably get a better definition.
Exactly. Every human is mediated from reality.
We were dumbfounded that uoung people rolled over and just accepted being locked down and not being able to go to graduation, play sports, see live music, go to bars, etc. Our generation NEVER would have accepted that!! We were, in our late 50's, few of the rebellious folks that went to the grocery store, were out the first night of restaurants re-opening, and out anywhere that it was "allowed" during the lockdowns. But the narrative "you'll kill granny" worked on the youth! Why should we be surprised? Today's youth believe they only have 12 years left, thanks to AOC and others!
One of our few voices was Tucker. It appears even our only one conservative network rolled over. Thank God there are still courageous voices like yours, Matt.
"Yes, but can you imagine how pissed off they're going to be when they finally wake up?"
Chris Hedges was in Yugoslavia. Many people could not believe anything was going to change. That is, until they got put in vans and taken away to camps.
The real test of whether someone is truly anti-authoritarian and pro free-speech is whether they still believe either of those things when they are in charge.
"What we have instead is an increasingly pissed-off population that needs to look about eighty results down in every Google search to find its point of view represented. Who thinks that situation is going to hold? "
Who thinks that is going to hold? That's easy. Google, Facebook and their enablers in the administration think it is going to hold as long as they control access to opinions.
SE are almost useless now.
That's more due to search engine optimization than anything.
I'm increasingly becoming convinced that the internet is an overwhelming force for bad in the world... you almost couldn't conceive of a more effective tool for shifting power to the establishment and away from individuals.
USG "watch-out" lists aren't helping, though. As for the internet being a force for bad--I tend to agree, but I don't think those people who we all think control those platforms and data can really control them. They've evolved to function beyond their creators' purview. Those systems are all semi-autonomous and feedback-driven, so who knows what kind of shit will hit the fan in the future.