261 Comments
User's avatar
Unset's avatar

"The bulk of America’s oil-producing regions were located in the South, which presented a considerable problem for the Union, which was heavily invested in the nascent new business empire led by Rockefeller."

Huh? At the time of the Civil War Western Pennsylvania was the only significant oil-producing region in the US. And even that only started in 1859. Sloppy language at best!

Running Burning Man's avatar

That apparently was Krutakov, the hero of Matt Taibbi's Substack piece here.

Seems like Hero of Russia™ Krutakov has had his brain infected by the Soviets back in the day and now by, well, who knows. This is a conclusion looking for evidence. Really an embarrassing error. A good editor would have spiked that - and perhaps with that other folly in this tale as well.

Speaking of editors, whatever happened to Emily Kopp? Not that she has editorial talent, but just asking ...

Ken Kunda's avatar

Lost me when he stated that average driving for a month is 1000 km and average consumption is 10 liters per kilometer .

Art's avatar

I noticed that too, but suspect it was a language translation error. He probably meant 10 km per liter is a bit over 23.5 mpg, which makes sense.

Libertarian Prepper's avatar

13,500 miles a year is what the average American drives, give or take. So it's even more than he estimated, but maybe he's using data from other countries.

Ken Kunda's avatar

I thought he was referring to Russia.

novalvesprings's avatar

So, our current war with Iran has to do with oil. Saudi Arabia has oil, nobody is trying to take theirs. israel pounding the shit out of Iran is because they want their oil? The exporting of terrorism by tribal fundamentalists has nothing to do with it? The only thing that oil has to do with this conflict is that it is being used to fund a bunch of fucking fucks terrorists. All credit to Lewis Black for the term, “Fucking fucks”, his term for the 9/11 terrorists.

Taras's avatar

When Krutatov referred to the Russian invasion of Ukraine as a “Special Military Operation”, I began to wonder. And when he justified the invasion, comparing it to the Cuban Missile Crisis …

Does Krutatov live in Putin’s Russia?

N.B.: Trying to mollify Putin (probably a mistake), the Ukrainians voted not to seek NATO membership. Putin responded by seizing Crimea and invading Eastern Ukraine. Of course it’s ridiculous to claim that the distant prospect of NATO membership is the equivalent of fully deployed nuclear weapons (which, by the way, Ukraine voluntarily gave up 30 years ago).

edwardc_sf's avatar

Um, you have it backwards. Ask Dr. Google: "ukrainian constitution nato" (w/o quotes) and her AI will tell you this:

"In February 2019, Ukraine amended its constitution to formally commit to securing full membership in NATO and the European Union. This legislation mandates that the President, Parliament, and government ensure this strategic course, designating the president as the guarantor of Euro-Atlantic integration."

Taras's avatar

Putin annexed Crimea (and began invading Eastern Ukraine) in 2014, not 2019.

So what you’re saying is, Ukraine finally, reluctantly changed its constitution to apply for NATO membership after Russia had been occupying Crimea for _five years_.

Tanya Owen's avatar

Again, It is my understanding NATO is exclusively defense. I am wrong?

Taras's avatar

Exactly. Putin doesn’t want neighboring countries to join because invading a NATO member is riskier and more complicated.

Mark Blair's avatar

Yes -- you are wrong. No NATO nation was attacked by remnant Yugoslavia.

NATO involved themselves in internal conflict of a non-member nation in order to pry Kosovo from Yugoslavia. They even updated their mission statement, which had stated they were a defensive alliance, to do so.

Little Humpbacked Horse's avatar

Specifically, NATO presense in Sevastopol.

Encouraging Maidan did not advance US interests.

Jane's avatar
Apr 2Edited

No it didn't. But Hillary and Obama thought it would. Apparently T and his advisors like Rubio think this latest adventure somehow advances US interests. The US seems to have remarkably shortsighted politicians.

Taras's avatar

Building democracy and human rights in Ukraine complicated Putin’s plans for reconstituting/reconquering the USSR. Obedient satellite Ukraine would have been a platform for the next invasion (probably the Baltics) — just as obedient satellite Belarus served as a platform for the Russian blitzkrieg on Ukraine.

What “NATO presence in Sevastopol”? Not sure what you mean to refer to.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Putin believes Ukraine IS Russia.

Taras's avatar

Or rather, that’s what Putin says now.

Tucker Carlson’s interview of Putin was mostly softball questions; but there was one exception: If it’s so obvious Ukraine is really a runaway province of Russia, Tucker asked, why did it take Putin 20 years to get around to making that argument?

Mark Blair's avatar

It is very similar to the Cuban Missile Crisis.

We'd never allow Mexico to enter a Chinese millitary alliance. We'd take that as a major threat.

Taras's avatar

See the Wikipedia article on “Ukraine-NATO relations” (which I discuss in more detail above).

To keep Putin happy, the Ukrainians had agreed not to seek NATO membership but, in 2014, Putin invaded Crimea and Eastern Ukraine anyway.

In other words, Putin didn’t attack because Ukraine applied to (someday) join NATO. Ukraine applied to join NATO because Putin attacked.

Of course, what makes the comparison to the Cuban Missile Crisis even more absurd is that Ukraine originally had nuclear weapons but voluntarily handed them over 30 years ago — to Russia!

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: Apparently, she's on a long lunch hour with Judge Crater.

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: This is what happens when you believe what you read on Wikipedia, or just mentally sleep-walk / regurgitate AI slop ("Black Nazis" Google):

"The bulk of America’s oil-producing regions were located in the South,"

Patently absurd. Sublimely stupid. A riot of radical rubbish.

Taras's avatar

Suddenly hit me: This whole interview is an April Fools joke — Matt, you really got us!

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: If so, how humiliating,. I'm going home to Mother.

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: No, actually, the statement is factually correct. Once both sides realized what was happening, in 1863, President Abrahambone Lincoln Nebraska issued his famous “Oil Emancipation Proctologist Enunciation” edict.

This put the American Civil War on hold for a decade so that both sides could pump the oil needed to fight with weapons yet to be invented (and also, to bail out Matt’s statement that “The bulk of America’s oil-producing regions were located in the South…”).

They resumed fighting in 1873. The North was now armed with “Sherman tanks,” presciently named after a Northern general not yet famous (actually, unknown to anyone other than the West Point plebes Eisenhower and Patton).

Little Known Fact: Winner of 163 Purple Hearts was the original “Hellfire Hegseth,” who made his business to fight for both the North and the South and the East and the West. His post-Gettysburg campaign in Greenland created a diplomatic crisis in Denmark, a country that had yet to acquire the country now coveted by the Iranians.

DaveL's avatar

Yes, what he said…

Carlos Marighella's avatar

I'm from Pennsylvania, so I also took issue with that. I was once in Oil City.

Carlos Marighella's avatar

I was there back in 1994 to interview for a reporting job with the Derrick, which I just found out is going to be shut down soon.

Carlos Marighella's avatar

Good thing they didn't hire me.

Magdalene's avatar

His baseline acceptance of the notion of "fossil fuel" is what has me looking askance 😁

omnist's avatar

Are you under the impression that we're making more oil

Magdalene's avatar

No. You can answer all your own questions by using search engines in a persistent manner to find highly suppressed scientific work.

omnist's avatar

I don't have any questions except about how your diseased mind works.

Pacificus's avatar

"Sloppy language"? This clown Kutakov has no business saying anything about the causes of the American Civil War, about which he clearly knows nothing.

Unset's avatar

Probably so. I was trying to give maximum benefit of the doubt. Perhaps he meant "suspected potential oil-producing regions." But even that is highly suspect.

Gene Frenkle's avatar

Did we give up when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor??

Mark Blair's avatar

Yea, the oil industry was brand new at the time. He probably projected backwards, assuming that the oil dominant regions remained the same.

James P's avatar

Rockefeller didn't even enter the oil business until 1863 when he and a partner established a small refinery.

DaveL's avatar

Yes, that is incorrect. At the time of the Civil War, it was in eastern Ohio and western Pennsylvania; he got his US geography mixed.

Otherwise, an accurate appraisal, particularly about how culture and life-style is intimately connected to oil (and gas).

James P's avatar

The Spindletop discovery in Texas wasn't until 1901! Hardly a driver of the Civil War 🙄

RN retired's avatar

Absolutely and England was building Iron Clad warships for the Confederacy to break the Union port blockades so the cotton from the South could continue to flow to England and France and English coal was what the Confederacy desperately needed

Richard Imbro's avatar

Where does one purchase this book? And is there an English-language edition?

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

My dear, you have your carbon chains mixed up. Kerosene and paraffin and lighter oil were vital to the British industrialization machine. The Americas have light oil. We add heavy oil to produce products above Kerosene.

Moreover, factories in the industial portions of Great Britain could stay open 24 hours per day now, because of vast artifical light, e.g., exploiting the southern states, their mines (fuel can be made from coal), and their slaves.

We had Kerosene, coal and cotton. Vital commodities industrialization.

Unset's avatar

I think you meant to respond to a different comment, mine was not about these things

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Kerosene can be made from coal. What did the South have? I think this process was developed in 1946?

Eli C's avatar

Civil war started in 1861. Standard oil’s precursor started in 1863. Kerosene was introduce in the 1860s. When you get small obvious facts wrong it call into question entire narratives

ShirtlessCaptainKirk's avatar

Krutakov broke rule #1 of historical revisionism: “Never go full-1619 Project.”

Samuel's avatar

I saw that, too

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Prior to the 1850s development of kerosene, people used whale blubber as oil for lamps.

Much of this is recorded in the children's books by Laura Ingalls Wilder. When they ran out of kerosene during the long winter, their parents used animal fat and paraffin to create a button lamp until the train came through the snow in spring. I am going off memory now, but I am sure you can google it.

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Actually Kerosene was developed in the 1850s.

Eli C's avatar

Haven’t read the book but the first oil well in the south was in Texas in 1866. It was only discovered in Pennsylvania in late 1850’s so if the claim is made that the civil war was related to oil, this is foolish

Carlos Marighella's avatar

I'm from Pennsylvania, and I was in Oil City once, so I had a problem with that too.

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: No, actually, the statement is factually correct. Once both sides realized what was happening, in 1863, President Abrahambone Lincoln Nebraska issued his famous “Oil Emancipation Proctologist Enunciation” edict.

This put the American Civil War on hold for a decade so that both sides could pump the oil needed to fight with weapons yet to be invented (and also, to bail out Matt’s statement that “The bulk of America’s oil-producing regions were located in the South…”).

They resumed fighting in 1873. The North was now armed with “Sherman tanks,” presciently named after a Northern general not yet famous (actually, unknown to anyone other than the West Point plebes Eisenhower and Patton).

Little Known Fact: Winner of 163 Purple Hearts was the original “Hellfire Hegseth,” who made his business to fight for both the North and the South and the East and the West. His post-Gettysburg campaign in Greenland created a diplomatic crisis in Denmark, a country that had yet to acquire the country now coveted by the Iranians.

Glitterpuppy's avatar

Finally, a true history lesson. Bravo!

Don Reed's avatar

04/02/26: Thank you. Look up Will Cuppy (real name), American humorist. When I finished the above, I realized that W.C. is still with us (!).

RN retired's avatar

Right it was coal which England supplied along with Iron Clad ships for the Confederacy to use breaking the Unions blockade of Southern Ports

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Alabama, Kentucky and Tennessee had coal too.

I am arguing that the object of the British supplying the Confederacy was not just to have control over those southern states if the Confederacy won, but Britain would control the Union too and the USA would be right back to 1775, a vassel of the British and the City of London.

The Civil War was a proxy war with the British using Americans as fodder (sound familiar?), but no one talks about that, and to some extent the French against the British too, in the War of 1812, only on American soil.

Some have argued Iran and Palestine are still vassels of the City of London (financially/MI6), and that what the USA and Israel are currently involved in is a proxy war to disrupt City of London financially and supply chain control.

I am not saying I believe that, but it has been classically the London MO since the 1600s.

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Wrong carbon chain. You what you want to focus on Kerosene. Coal can make Kerosene (1849). Which states have coal, cotton, and Kerosene? What fueled the British industrialization? Coal, cotton, Kerosene, and slavery. Who supplied the Confederacy to fight the Union?

Eli C's avatar

I believe his claim involved Rockefeller. He was only involved in oil. Pennsylvania and West Virginia were union states and PA was the main source of coal at the time. Specifically anthracite from Eastern PA

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Right, see my reply to RN retired, and it was NOT the English. It was the City of London financial machine and the British Empire. As far as I am concerned, the English and Celtic people are separate from the financial-ists. The English and Celts were fodder for the wars and factories.

Perhaps even an extension of the Roman Empire form of control?

Just ideas floating around in my head from reading English fiction, and frankly not nearly enough for my satisfaction. 😉

Jen Wadewitz's avatar

Wrong carbon chain.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Probably a hundred readers will point this out but 10 liters per kilometer is 0.2 miles per gallon.

Buck Turgidson's avatar

Another howler of an error. He means 10 liters per 100km. Liters per 100km is the standard measure of fuel consumption outside of the U.S.

DaveL's avatar

Needs better editing. Did Matt’s staff leave?

DaveL's avatar

Is that what those big dually trucks get?

James Schwartz's avatar

Have to love when someone from another country attempts to rewrite the history of the U.S. when it was clear from Lincoln’s own writings why the civil war happened. Matt going to what he loves most and it’s Russia. The worst is he actually believes what that guy was saying. Getting to the point of just dropping Racket News. Matt, you made a choice and you chose wrong. I’d pivot back is you could but you allowed your new editor to publicly slander Walter as you stood by her. You really screwed the pooch on that one. Attempting to promote some Russian hack as a some US history authoritarian is a joke.

Substack Reader's avatar

I read your comment and I started to ask what the heck you were talking about. Thinking I should first RTFM (anyone else old enough to remember that?), I went to Grok. Holy cow! There is a lot more to this story than I realized.

James Schwartz's avatar

I don’t know what Grok told you as I’ve never used it but I follow Walter on Substack and he posted what she was claiming about his movie. Walter is an American treasure an should be revered more then to have some half twit try and damage his career. I also subscribe to his county highway newspaper which is a joy

Substack Reader's avatar

Grok told me that (which I'd not heard before) and a good summary of the timeline of everything. I was oblivious to pretty much all of it other than what was disclosed here at the time of the ATW breakup.

James Schwartz's avatar

I’m surprised that it had it. Like I said I don’t use any of them.

omnist's avatar

Than. Half wit.

omnist's avatar

"That's not true, a politician said otherwise" is a very American and very stupid argument

Glitterpuppy's avatar

This whole thing seems to be unraveling. Very disappointing…….. I truly admire Matt and admired Walter. Hope this mess can be salvaged.

Richard Harris's avatar

It’s fascinating how often people like Krutakov with a good handle on social reality and a sophisticated understanding of political economy are ignored in favor of simple-mindedness and wish casting from our “leaders”: Vietnam is like the Alamo (LBJ); we’ll bring democracy to Libya (BHO & HRC); we’ll liberate Iraq (GWB); we’ll take Ukraine to victory over Putin (JRB ).And it’s even more fascinating how many highly credentialed pundits and journalists traffic in the same simple-minded “analyses.” Thanks Matt, for introducing a little depth to the national conversation.

Running Burning Man's avatar

"Knutson"

You mean "Krutakov,"?

Richard Harris's avatar

Thx. Corrected it. Curse autocorrect!

Asa Plinch's avatar

"There are parts of the book that will cause an American reader to raise an eyebrow, like the assertion that the American Civil War “wasn’t fought over human rights or a struggle over slavery . . . ."

That war (which wasn't a "civil war" but was simply named such by the victors) was about preserving the union --not about eliminating slavery. Lincoln said so himself, repeatedly. He didn't give a damn about the slaves (and said that repeatedly as well). The author of this piece would do well to learn his history.

Pacificus's avatar

False. The immediate cause of the Civil War was the South Carolinians' attack on Fort Sumter in Charleston harbor. Lincoln used that attack to launch the war as an act of national self-defense, much the way a border skirmish on the Texas-Mexico border had been used as an excuse to start the Mexican War in 1846. But the underlying cause (without which, there would have been no showdown at Ft Sumter) was over slavery, and in particular, its extension into the western territories, to which Lincoln was utterly opposed. It was Lincoln's uncompromising opposition to any further addition of slave states into the Union that had prompted the South (starting with South Carolina) to secede. In short, the Civil War began as a war over slavery disguised as a war to save the Union. After the Emancipation Proclamation in Sept 1862, it officially became a war both to save the Union and to end slavery. Any questions?

Show me the quotes where Lincoln said he "didn't give a damn about the slaves" and I will explain how you have mis-contextualized/misconstrued his words.

omnist's avatar

Do you not know that the North still had slaves after the civil war or do you know that and just choose not to think about it

Pacificus's avatar

I know more about before, during, and after the Civil War than you ever thought about knowing. Clown.

omnist's avatar

Yeah it sounds like it. You don't sound like an ignorant imbecile at all. Not at all, not even a little bit.

If you want help, start by reading my comment and trying to respond to it. You can start now.

DaveL's avatar

You are correct.

Thucydides's avatar

10 liters per kilometer driven? That is roughly 2 1/2 gallons per mile. Really?

Baltimoracle's avatar

That's actually worse than what my boat gets -- w/ twin 8.1 l engines

Buck Turgidson's avatar

"The bulk of America’s oil-producing regions were located in the South, which presented a considerable problem for the Union, which was heavily invested in the nascent new business empire led by Rockefeller. " I don't understand this comment. Spindletop was only in 1901. Until then virtually all oil production was in Pennsylvania with a small amount in adjacent states and literally zero in the Confederate states.

DaveL's avatar

He screwed up.

John Schwager's avatar

Where can one find a copy of the book in English?

Carlos Marighella's avatar

I just asked that myself.

Don Reed's avatar

In which language?

Carlos Marighella's avatar

I want one in English. The only edition I found online is in Russian.

John's avatar

"with an average consumption of 10 liters per kilometer." I'm not a metric native but that seems very wrong.

Lekimball's avatar

Well, interesting article. Not sure the guy is completely accurate. I HAVE come to see Trump's geopolitical agenda in a much bigger way than I first did. It IS about energy and about stopping China and Russia from strategically controlling it. Trump is consistent that this is all America First (which I and he think will ultimately benefit the world--we don't want China or Russia's to run the world--at least we have more democratic ideas). Iran needed to be dealt with and it seems even other Arab countries see that more than Europe does. I heard someone say last night something I hadn't thought of: Europe has migrated in so many Muslims they are afraid of what they will do within their own countries if they get involved. Probably truth there.

As for the civil war, yes it was partly economic but it was not ALL economic. Every day he stood on the senate floor my cousin ancestor, John Adams railed about the evils of slavery--he owned none and paid everyone who worked for him, including black people all his life -- and the constitution was written with abolishing it in mind, clearly. To say it was not part of the equation does America a disservice.

James Roberts's avatar

Hmm why would Europe need to shelter so many Muslims 🤔 maybe because the US and Israel have corrupted, overthrown, and destroyed many of their original counties. Iran needed to be dealt with? How delusional are you?

Lekimball's avatar

YOU are delusional. Europe is sorry they ruined their sovereignty. It's a mess there.

James Roberts's avatar

Oh the sovereignty that you refuse to grant Iran huh? Guess it's only good for the goose no the gander. Go drink some bleach you warmonger.

Glitterpuppy's avatar

Why do you launch off into a pissing contest? And I was beginning to enjoy some of your points……. But, you gotta go off on some mission.

DaveL's avatar

Iran with ICBM’s and a medieval religion maybe?

Lekimball's avatar

The US and Israel have not corrupted, overthrown their original countries, though I am sure it has been framed and can be perceived that way. What caused all this is England messing around in it on top of a centuries long Hatfield and McCoys feud between Muslims and Jews in that part of the world, where they both tell a good story. Read BOTH of the stories, not just this propaganda against Israel that you are all lapping up. I don't understand taking a side in this. Israel has a tiny spot over there but that's not ok with them, that particular spot matters to them both, and the Muslims want them OUT. And Israel defending herself is now "genocide" when Hamas behavior isn't? "Zionists" do not go all over the world, especially here, into Mosques and kill Muslims or Americans. They have a nightmare in Europe now.

James Roberts's avatar

You can be ignorant of history all you like. Doesn't change the fact that Israel is the aggressor and committed multiple acts of "terrorism" that mainstream media won't call out. Propaganda is Israels main tool and they have controlled the narrative for decades. The US and Israel are actively committing war crimes. Full stop.

Lekimball's avatar

You are ignorant of history, not me. Israel is NOT the aggressor. You can argue they over-reacted (though the US would do exactly that until the terrorists were wiped out if they were hanging in Mexico). If Israel commits "genocide," so did Hamas. And no thinking person should have a dog in that fight. You just lap up with leftist propaganda bullshit.

Little Humpbacked Horse's avatar

My greatgrandfather rode with Sherman in the 2nd volunteer Indiana cavalry. (He was 16, my father and his mother were both the youngest of very large families.) His issue, along with so many German refugees from the repression of 1849, was Free Soil. The Jeffersonian ideal of a yeomanry of small landholders is inconsistent with protoindustrial plantation economy dependent on slave labor. That was the Republican goal, not abolition per se.

Lekimball's avatar

John Adams words which he was know to repeat constantly, but slavery mattered to nobody, just money? If he equivocated at ALL it was to get the south on board the constitution. They knew the south would not join if the constitution prohibited slavery. Ridiculous to think it was only one issue. Why can't it be more than one?

"I have, through my whole life, held the practice of slavery in such abhorrence, that I have never owned a negro or any other slave, though I have lived for many years in times, when the practice was not disgraceful, when the best men in my vicinity thought it not inconsistent with their character, and when it has cost me thousands of dollars for the labor and subsistence of free men, which I might have saved by the purchase of negroes at times when they were very cheap."

John Adams

Lekimball's avatar

Oh bologna. I did not say that wasn't part or even the main goal, I said it was economic certainly; what I SAID if you read it is that our forefathers did care about slavery, and not just John Adams. It MATTERED, too. Adams was the most outspoken, but they easily could have reinforced slavery and discrimination in the constitution and they did not. It was worded in a way to get the south to go along with the intention of getting rid of it. If you read Adams' history, you'd know that. So don't tell me there was only one goal. That's just not true. And it wasn't just an excuse. It mattered. I get sick of people saying there were NO moral or ethical goals in the civil war. There were a lot of issues.

Little Humpbacked Horse's avatar

I'm sorry. I wasn't questioning your point. I was adding another perspective.

I said NOTHING about the "main goal." I was telling the story of the enormous midwestern German contingent that contributed to the Union victory.

Please do try to read a little more closely.

Lekimball's avatar

Oh, I'm sorry. It sounded like you were saying there was only ONE goal and it was economic.

Lekimball's avatar

But actually you DID claim the Republican's main goal" was economic, that was the R epublican goal, not abolition "per se."

It sounds like that is the main and/or only goal, the way that is worded.

Glitterpuppy's avatar

Bologna? I always thought it was called Baloney. Learn something new everyday

Lekimball's avatar

Pronounced by many baloney. Spelled bologna, originally anyway.

michael Griffin's avatar

I read the piece and come away with scratching my head about a lot of loose ends

Obviously, the Civil War assertion is ridiculous. This sounds to me like someone formed a thesis and then went out looking for facts to support them rather than the other way around

The other part that had me wondering was the reference to Dmitry Simes and the shutdown of Russian TV. Depending on what source you look at, Simes is either a KGB agent who deeply infiltrated the Reagan administration and the republican party in general or visionary. I am still not sure just what "As for cutting off access to Russian television, I can only say that this is how it always happens when you lose in direct information confrontation" refers to.

So, to me it was kind of a circuitous chat with no real conclusion. Anyone else get that impression ?

omnist's avatar

How did you not understand any of that? It couldn't be more clear.

michael Griffin's avatar

Well, explain to me what he meant? Was arresting Dmitry good or bad ? That certainly was not clear

Treeamigo's avatar

10 liters of gasoline per Kilometer?

Maybe a Soviet tank gets an MPG of a 1/4 mile per gallon, but otherwise the math is way off

Liz LaSorte's avatar

One of the laws of the universe is that energy is everything and everything is energy. So, it will always be connected to $$ and hey, who doesn’t buy energy stocks?

Since human nature is self-serving, instinctually, it will always influence government to serve the man, not the “higher good,” so it would make sense to get rid of government since it will become corrupt. The bigger the government the more corrupt it will become.

But, since human nature is self-serving, how do we live in a civilized society without some form of government?

If the solution is to truly limit government, wasn’t that the idea of our original constitution, the Articles of the Confederation?

Maybe we got it right the first time around (first instincts), and after the revolutionary war exposed its problems, it just needed to be amended to address those problems that are basically moot today.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

If the decision is to get rid of government there will be a need to allocate work and the products of work. At great sacrifice I offer myself for the role. I promise to be fair in all decisions. I will, however, require a guarded compound to insulate my decisionmaking from any who might take exception. I'll also need a nice plane.

Glitterpuppy's avatar

I will offer my services as your Viceroy….

Running Burning Man's avatar

Liz, outstanding comment. Question: Why do you subscribe to the same Substacks as me? Are you surveilling me or are we just great minds in sync?

🤣🤣

Liz LaSorte's avatar

🙏 - inquiring minds gotta know...what exactly?

laura's avatar

Most intriguing remark: "Where is 'Rain Man'? Where is 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest'? Only lines and comics." Would like to hear more about that.